- $24.99Sesame Street Gabrielle Plush Toy - Multi-ColorMacy's
- $14.99Sesame Street(R) Cuddly Corduroy Cookie Monster PlushBoscov's
- $14.99and upSesame Street(R) 13in. Cookie Monster Take Along PlushBoscov's & 1 more
- $14.99Sesame Street(R) 12in. Big Bird Take Along PlushBoscov's
- $49.99Hasbro Sesame Street Plush Pal Elmo 8" 20cm Plush Toy With Durable Plastic EyesAmazon
- $24.99Gund Sesame Street Official Big Bird Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy - MultiMacy's
- $19.99and upGund(R) Sesame Street(R) 10in. Oscar the Grouch PlushBoscov's & 1 more
- $24.99and upGund Sesame Street Snuffleupagus Plush - MultiMacy's & 1 more
- $32.99Cookie Monster Soft Plush Sherpa Toddler Blanket Sesame StreetWayfair
- $6.89Sesame Street Friends Cookie Monster PlushTarget
- $49.99Sesame Street Elmo Slide PlushMacy's
- $4.99Sesame Street Cookie MonsterCrocs
- $6.89Sesame Street Friends Elmo PlushTarget
- $12.99Sesame Street 50th Anniversary Blind Box PlushBed Bath & Beyond
- $27.89Sesame Street Ernie Character 13.5" PlushOriental Trading Company
- SAVE $14.07$32.83$46.90Sesame Street Cookie Monster Eating Action SweatshirtBoxLunch
- $30.99Sesame Street 14.5" Grover Character PlushOriental Trading Company
- $24.99and upSesame Street Gonger 10 Inch Collectible Plush PinkOriental Trading Company & 1 more
- $19.99and upGund(R) Sesame Street(R) 11in. Elmo Plush Hand PuppetBoscov's & 1 more
- $26.99Sesame Street Elmo 12-Inch Take Along PlushOriental Trading Company
- $27.89Sesame Street 9.5 Inch Doctor Elmo Collectible Plush RedOriental Trading Company
- $34.99Sesame Street Big Bird and Mr. Snuffleupagus 4 Inch BFF Plush Set YellowOriental Trading Company
- $29.99and upSesame Street Dino Stomp Elmo 13-Inch Plush Stuffed Animal Sings and Dances - MultiMacy's & 1 more
- $24.99and upSesame Street Potty Time Elmo 12" Plush Stuffed Animal, Sounds and Phrases, Potty Training ToolMacy's & 1 more
- $5.14The Sesame Street Players Present the Little Red Hen : Featuring Jim Henson's Sesame Street Muppets by Emily Perl KingsleyBetter World Books
- $5.14The Sesame Street Pet Show : Featuring Jim Henson's Sesame Street Muppets by Emily Perl KingsleyBetter World Books
- $19.99and upGund(R) Sesame Street(R) 14in. Bert PlushBoscov's & 1 more
- $10.00Hasbro Sesame Street Elmo Cookie Monster Grover Abby Oscar You Pick KeychainMichaels
- $183.00PUMA Sesame Street x Leadcat 'Cookie Monster'Kicks Crew
- $19.99Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 7in. Tango PlushBoscov's
- $9.99Just Play Sesame Street Large Plush Elmo, MultiKohl's
- $34.99Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 12in. Bedtime Elmo PlushBoscov's
- $9.99Just Play Sesame Street Large Plush Big Bird, MultiKohl's