$29.99
Paper House® Red Watercolor Hearts Double-Sided 12" x 12" Cardstock, 15 Sheets | Michaels®Michaels$12.47
Paper Punch, Heart Hole Punch, Heart Shaped Hole Puncher, Heart Paper Punches, Heart Craft Punches, Heart Punches for Paper Crafts, 3/8 inch Shape Punch, 5/8 Heart Punch, 1 inch Heart Shaped PuncherAmazon$1.20
pcsset Colorful Star Heart Dot Shaped Sticker Paper Multipurpose Decorative Sticker For DIY CraftSHEIN$7.00
Rainbow Paper Strips for Making Origami Hearts. Origami Lucky Heart Paper. 1 inch x 5.5 inch Paper Strips makes 1 inch Wide 3D Paper Hearts (Rainbow)Amazon$9.99
MyArTool Heart Paper Punch, 1 Inch Heart Punches for Paper Crafts, 25mm Heart Hole Punch for Making Scrapbook Pages, Memory Books, Card Making, Journals, Gift Tags, Homemade ConfettiAmazon$7.00
Red & Pinks Paper Strips for Making Origami Hearts. Origami Lucky Heart Paper. 1 inch x 5.5 inch Paper Strips makes 1 inch Wide 3D Paper Hearts (Red & Pinks)AmazonSAVE $1.00
$12.97$13.97
Paper Punch, Heart Hole Puncher, Circle Punch, Star Hole Punch, 1 inch Circle Hole Puncher, 1 inch Star Punch, 1 inch Heart Punch, Shape Hole Punch, 3 PCS Craft PunchAmazon$1.99
Glitter Heart Cardstock Paper by Recollections™ 12" x 12" in Red | Michaels®Michaels$81.99
Paper Bleeding Hearts-Gallery Wrapped CanvasBed Bath & Beyond$12.99
Heart On PaperAmazon$7.69
RIVCOIM Heart Doilies: Elegant Paper Doilies for Crafts and Valentines 4 inch - 100 Pcs of Paper Heart Doilies in Red, Pink, White, Blue (25 Each) - Perfect for Creative Decorations.Amazon$8.99
24Pcs Valentines Heart Paper Suncatcher for Kids, Stained Glass Effect Heart Paper Suncatchers Heart Shaped Tissue Paper Craft DIY Window Art, Classroom Art Craft, Valentine’s Day Party Game SuppliesAmazon$10.99
Heart Scrapbook Paper: 10 Neon Patterns X2, Decorative Craft Paper, Cardstock for Cardmaking, Valentine's Day, & Crafting Projects - Double Sided 8 x 8" DesignsAmazon$18.90
Paper Pieces - Assortment Hearts 18.90 DollarsEtsy$14.07
GOTHIC HEARTS Scrapbook Paper: Pink decorative paper collection with victorian Valentine's Day theme | Patterned paper supply with hearts and roses ... DIY projects, kids' crafts, collage, and moreAmazon$7.95
Heart Punch 1 inch Craft Lever Punch Valentine's Day Heart Punch Handmade Paper Punch Candy Color by Random(Candy Heart)Amazon$9.99
Foam Hearts for Crafts 6" Foam Shapes for Crafts Foam Paper for Crafts Heart Shaped Paper for Valentine Crafts Valentines Day Crafts Heart Cardstock Valentine Day Decoration Valentine Heart (24 Pcs)Amazon$9.99
360 Pieces Small Heart Cutouts Paper Heart Shapes 2" Assorted Color Heart Confetti Heart Die Cuts for Valentine's Day Craft Wedding Party Decor, Kid's Love and Peace School Craft Projects,12 ColorsAmazon$26.99
'Heart Crosshatched' Print on PaperWayfair$10.11
Heart Shape Kraft Paper Thank You Stickers 500 PiecesEtsy$2.00
pcs Hollow Out Heart Design Decorative Craft PaperSHEINSAVE $6.00
$17.99$23.99
PA Paper™ Accents 8.5" x 11" 100lb. Smooth Cardstock, 25 Sheets By Pa Paper Accents in Purple Hearts | Michaels®MichaelsSAVE $5.25
$15.74$20.99
PA Paper™ Accents Mini Dot 8.5" x 11" Cardstock, 25 Sheets By Pa Paper Accents in Prairie Hearts | Michaels®Michaels$9.99
Geyee 108 Pcs Heart Cutouts Paper Heart Bulletin Board Cutouts Assorted Color Heart Shaped Die Cut for Classroom Decor Teachers Kids DIY Craft School Bulletin Board Decorations (3.46 Inch)Amazon$8.99
72 Pcs Large Heart Cutouts Pink Paper Heart 6 Inch Heart Shape Card Paper Heart Die Cut Valentine’s Day Heart Decorations for Classroom Bulletin Board Decor Kids’ Love and Peace School Craft ProjectsAmazon$13.11
Red Love Hearts Wrapping Paper |Heart Shaped Yarn Balls | Valentine's Day Knitting New Baby AnniversaryEtsy$9.99
Stars Origami Paper Strips, Wartoon Heart Printing Heart Origami Stars Paper and Luminous Heart Paper Set, 1700 SheetsAmazonSAVE $1.01
$6.98$7.99
Ferraycle 108 Pcs Paper Hearts Stars Cut Outs Large Cutouts Hearts Star Shaped Paper Cutouts Double Sided Cardstock Decor for Kids Bulletin Board Craft Wall Classroom Decoration (Star Style)Amazon$10.00
Heart Of The Home ~ Paper/Mailed Punch Needle Embroidery Pattern From Notforgotten Farm™Etsy$4.00
Paper Airplane Love Note With Heart Vinyl Laptop Sticker | Water Bottle Car DecalEtsy$9.99
Paper and Bag Clips,10Pcs Heart Shape Clamps Snacks Bag clips,Green - GreenBed Bath & Beyond$1.99
Dog & Heart Paper Clips by Celebrate It™ | Michaels®Michaels$25.59
UCEC Paper Punches for Crafting, 1 Inch Paper Puncher, 6 Pcs Hole Punch Shapes Cutters for Paper Craft Heart, Circle, Star, Butterfly, Maple Leaf, Flower Paper Punch Sets for DIY Projects ScrapbookAmazon$11.91
Neutral Hearts Scrapbook Paper 40 Pages 20 Sheets: Heart Pattern Paper: Double Sided for Scrapbooking, Card Making, Origami, DIY and MoreAmazonSAVE $1.00
$6.99$7.99
100pcs Mini Paper Clips, Cute Love Heart Paper Clips Stainless Steel Metal Paper Clips Small Bookmarks for Sorting Organizing Crafts Papers Kids Office School Home Use (Gold & Rose Gold)Amazon$12.99
Heart Punch Set, 3/8 Inch, 5/8 Inch, 1 Inch Heart Hole Punch Set for Scrapbooking, Heart Shaped Hole Punch for Paper Crafts, Weddings, Cardstock, Gift Wrapping, Greeting Cards and ScrapbooksAmazon$2.42
Heart Shaped Embossing Folders For Scrapbooking Album Decoration Paper Birthday Paper Card Making Cut DesignAmazon$12.99
Whaline Valentine Pattern Paper Heart Lip Stripe Scrapbook Specialty Paper Red Pink Double Sided Decorative Craft Paper for DIY Card Making Photo Album Journal Decor ,24 Sheets, 6 x 6 InchAmazonSAVE $8.00
$31.99$39.99
JAM Paper 2.5" Wired Glitter Hearts 2 Ribbon | Michaels®MichaelsSAVE $10.20
$40.79$50.99
JAM Paper 2.5" Wired Faux Linen Heart Glitter & Dots Ribbon | Michaels®MichaelsSAVE $1.00
$8.99$9.99
LOVEINUSA 3PCS Paper Punches for Craft, Paper Punch Heart Shapes Pink Paper Craft Puncher for Valentine's Day Scrapbooking Greeting Card DIY AlbumsAmazonSAVE $8.00
$31.99$39.99
JAM Paper 2.5" Wired Love Edged Heart Glitter Ribbon | Michaels®MichaelsSAVE $21.80
$87.19$108.99
JAM Paper 1.5" Wired Faux Linen Heart Ribbon | Michaels®Michaels$9.99
Baby Pink Hearts Scrapbook Paper: Valentines Day Heart Pattern Scrapbooking Paper Pad For Craft DIYAmazon$5.25
Embossed Paper Heart Cutouts For Scrapbook, Card Making |Valentine Die Cuts Making, Decoration, EmbellishmentsEtsy$6.00
Heart Shape Die Cuts Made From Cardstock Paper For Valentines Diy Card Making Weddings Well Wishes Kids Crafts BannersEtsy$0.79
Valentine's Day Heart Candy Cardstock Paper by Recollections™ 12" x 12" | Michaels®Michaels$36.71
Paper Mache Assorted Shape Small Boxes - Heart, Rectangle & Round Shape Small Papier Mache Boxes Gifts, Jewelry, Tooth Fairy Boxes, and DIY Crafts - Pack of 24 for Groups, Camps, Scouts, and VBSAmazon$3.75
Hearts Mug Sublimation Transfer, Printed Wrap For Mugs, Paper Ready To Press, Cricut Press Heat TransferEtsy$7.99
120 Pcs Valentine's Day Heart Cutouts Assorted Color Paper Hearts Crafts 4 Inch Heart Shape Die Cut with Glue Point Dots for School Classroom Bulletin Board Decor Wedding Anniversary Party SuppliesAmazon$22.99
Small Paper Heart - Wrapped Canvas PhotographWayfair$6.00
Paper Plane Love Letters On Pink Fabric By The Yard | Hearts Airplane Valentine Valentine's Day Made To OrderEtsy$9.99
48 Pc Glitter Paper Heart ShapesOriental Trading Company$6.99
Origami Paper 100 sheets Hearts & Flowers 6" (15 cm): Tuttle Origami Paper: High-Quality Double-Sided Origami Sheets Printed with 12 Different Patterns: Instructions for 6 Projects IncludedAmazon$8.99
LOVEINUSA 3PCS Blue Paper Punches for Craft, Paper Punch Heart Shapes Blue Paper Craft Puncher for Scrapbooking Greeting Card DIY AlbumsAmazon$2.79
Notebook Paper Heart Feltie, School Feltie Embellishment, Teacher FeltiesEtsy$5.00
Vintage Music Paper Heart, Upcycled Sheet Cut Out, Wedding Confetti, Party Decor, Die Cuts, Diy Valentine's, Heart PunchEtsy$4.50
Indy Bloom - Paper Hearts Faux Leather Valentine Designer Roll Pastel Heart Design Craft SheetsEtsy$12.99
Paw Print Scrapbook Paper: Paw on Heart Patterns Paper Pack, Variety of Colors, Double Sided 8 x 8" Sheets - 14 Unique Designs X2Amazon$8.99
72pcs 6x5.2 Inch Heart Paper Cutouts, 9 Colors Large Heart Shaped Cardstock Double-Sided Love Heart Cut Outs Valentine's Day Crafts for Kids Classroom Bulletin Board DecorationAmazon