$9.99
Just Play Sesame Street Large Plush Elmo, MultiKohl'sSAVE $5.25
$9.74$14.99
Just Play Sesame Street Elmo Easter Plush Toy, MultiKohl's$9.99
Just Play Sesame Street Kohls Large Plush Cookie Monster, MultiKohl's$9.99
Just Play Sesame Street Large Plush Big Bird, MultiKohl's$24.99
Sesame Street Gabrielle Plush Toy - Multi-ColorMacy's$14.99
Sesame Street(R) Cuddly Corduroy Cookie Monster PlushBoscov's$14.99and up
Sesame Street(R) 13in. Cookie Monster Take Along PlushBoscov's & 1 more$14.99
Sesame Street(R) 12in. Big Bird Take Along PlushBoscov's$29.99and up
Sesame Street Dino Stomp Elmo 13-Inch Plush Stuffed Animal Sings and Dances - MultiMacy's & 1 more$24.99and up
Sesame Street Potty Time Elmo 12" Plush Stuffed Animal, Sounds and Phrases, Potty Training ToolMacy's & 1 more$18.99
Just Play Sesame Street Sing Along Plush Cookie Monster, MultiKohl's$15.99
Just Play Sesame Street Cookie Monster Large Holiday Plush Toy, MultiKohl's$24.99
Gund Sesame Street Official Big Bird Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy - MultiMacy's$19.99and up
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 10in. Oscar the Grouch PlushBoscov's & 1 more$24.99and up
Gund Sesame Street Snuffleupagus Plush - MultiMacy's & 1 more$32.99
Cookie Monster Soft Plush Sherpa Toddler Blanket Sesame StreetWayfair$20.00
Sesame Street Elmo PlushEtsy$4.99
Sesame Street Cookie MonsterCrocsSAVE $1.30
$11.69$12.99
Sesame Street 50th Anniversary Blind Box PlushBed Bath & BeyondSAVE $14.07
$32.83$46.90
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Eating Action SweatshirtBoxLunch$30.99
Sesame Street 14.5" Grover Character PlushOriental Trading Company$27.89
Sesame Street Ernie Character 13.5" PlushOriental Trading Company$26.99
Sesame Street Elmo 12-Inch Take Along PlushOriental Trading Company$24.99and up
Sesame Street Gonger 10 Inch Collectible Plush PinkOriental Trading Company & 1 more$19.99and up
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 11in. Elmo Plush Hand PuppetBoscov's & 1 more$8.95
Sesame Street Herry Monster, Monster Bean Bag, Plush, PlushEtsy$27.89
Sesame Street 9.5 Inch Doctor Elmo Collectible Plush RedOriental Trading Company$65.00
Sesame Street Toy, Kermit Frog, Collectible, Frog Gift, Mcdonalds Street, Hensen GiftEtsy$15.00
Sesame Street Stuffed Cookie Monster Or Ernie/Soft Plush Friends No NoiseEtsy$34.99
Sesame Street Big Bird and Mr. Snuffleupagus 4 Inch BFF Plush Set YellowOriental Trading Company$11.21
Sesame Street, Bert, Cookie Monster, Tyco, Yellow, 9", Plush, Soft, Toy, Figure, Vintage Stuffed Animal, ~ M-29-03Etsy$33.71
Sesame Street, Baby Big Bird, Muppets, Yellow, 11", Soft, Plush, Toy, Figure, Vintage Stuffed Animal, ~ 20-02-43Etsy$14.96
Sesame Street, Elmo, Muppet Show, Red Muppet, Puffalump Style, Swimming Suit, Stuffed Toy, 10", Vintage Plush, ~20-01-1039Etsy$5.14
The Sesame Street Players Present the Little Red Hen : Featuring Jim Henson's Sesame Street Muppets by Emily Perl KingsleyBetter World Books$12.50
Vintage Sesame Street Mini Bean Barkley The Dog 4" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy New 1990's Kellogg's Jim HensonEtsy$5.14
The Sesame Street Pet Show : Featuring Jim Henson's Sesame Street Muppets by Emily Perl KingsleyBetter World Books$220.00
Vintage Sesame Street Martian Plush Yip Yep Wa Alien Little 4"-7" With Stretched Legs VgcEtsy$19.99and up
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 14in. Bert PlushBoscov's & 1 more$27.00
3 Sesame Street Finger Puppets Vintage Big Bird, Oscar The Grouch & Cookie MonsterEtsy$10.00
Hasbro Sesame Street Elmo Cookie Monster Grover Abby Oscar You Pick KeychainMichaels$20.00
Vintage Sesame Street 1980S Cookie Montster Wearing Apron & Chef Hat Plush ToyEtsy$35.00
Playskool Sesame Street, Rockin' Numbers Ernie, Counting & Singing Teaching ToyEtsy$15.95
Small Sesame Street Elmo Stuffed Animal Plush ToyEtsy$17.99
Tonies Sesame Street Cookie Monster Audio Play FigurineTargetSAVE $5.00
$24.99$29.99
Playskool Sesame Street Peekaboo Cookie Monster Plush ToyBoscov's$183.00
PUMA Sesame Street x Leadcat 'Cookie Monster'Kicks Crew$33.71
Big Bird, Sesame Street, Knickerbocker, Firefighter, Red Suit, Number 1, Vintage Plush, Soft, 10", Figure, Stuffed Animal, ~20-33-1164Etsy$14.96
Tyco, Elmo, Sesame Street, Jim Henson, Bingo Puppy, Blue Jumpsuit, 14", Vintage Plush, Toy, Soft, Figure, Collectible, ~ 20-01-734Etsy$19.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 7in. Tango PlushBoscov's$34.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 12in. Bedtime Elmo PlushBoscov's$24.99
Talking Elmo Plush Doll - Tickle Me Sesame StreetEtsy$20.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 11in. Abby Cadabby PlushBoscov's$14.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 7in. Nylon Cookie Monster PlushBoscov's$20.00
Big Bird Tyco Plush 10" Sesame Street Vintage 1995Etsy$19.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 13in. Construction Worker Cookie MonsterBoscov's$14.99
Gund(R) Sesame Street(R) 13in. Grover Take Along Buddy PlushBoscov's$29.99
1996 Tyco Sesame Street Tickle Me Plush Toys - Elmo Cookie Monster ErnieEtsy$19.99
Vintage 1980S Sesame Street Toys - The Muppets Kermit Big Bird Miss Piggy ApplauseEtsy$27.00
Vintage Cookie Monster Plush Sesame Street Tyco Stuffed Animal 1998Etsy$11.99
Tyco Red Elmo Plush. Hard Plastic Eyes. 1995 Sesame StreetEtsy