- $52.49and upTyler Toffoli Calgary Flames Autographed Official Game PuckFanatics & 1 more
- $52.49and upTyler Toffoli Montreal Canadiens Autographed Official Game PuckFanatics & 1 more
- $199.99and upTyler Toffoli Calgary Flames Game-Used Goal Puck from February 6, 2023 vs. New York RangersNational Hockey League & 1 more
- SAVE $36.00$23.99$59.99Tyler Toffoli New Jersey Devils Autographed Official Game PuckFanatics
- $199.99and upTyler Toffoli New Jersey Devils Game-Used Goal Puck vs. New York Rangers on September 28, 2023Fanatics & 1 more
- $67.49and upTyler Toffoli Calgary Flames Autographed Official Game Puck with "C of Red" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- SAVE $54.00$35.99$89.99Tyler Toffoli New Jersey Devils Autographed Official Game Puck with "NJD Debut 10/12/23" InscriptionFanatics