- $118.99and upPaul O'Neill New York Yankees Autographed BaseballFanatics & 1 more
- SAVE $66.00$153.99$219.99Paul O'Neill New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Warrior" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $90.00$209.99$299.99Paul O'Neill & Tino Martinez New York Yankees Autographed BaseballFanatics
- $2.99Paul O'neill Reds 8x10 Photo Licensed, Vintage Mlb BaseballEtsy
- SAVE $57.00$132.99$189.99Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds Autographed 1990 World Series Logo BaseballFanatics
- $28.80Paul O'neill Signed Autographed 1986 Fleer Prospects Baseball Card Cincinnati Reds - Coa Matching HologramsEtsy
- $319.95Paul O'neill Jersey Retirement Maple Chrome BatEtsy
- $22.99Paul O'Neill Yankees 3 Card Collector Home Plate Plaque to Amazon!Amazon
- SAVE $54.00$125.99$179.99Paul O'Neill New York Yankees Autographed 2004 Upper Deck Classics #50 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated CardFanatics
- $124.99Autographed/Signed Paul O'Neill New York Grey Baseball Jersey JSA COAAmazon
- $0.992013 Topps Allen and Ginter #28 Paul O'Neill Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MTAmazon
- $1.802004 Donruss World Series Blue #52 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds MLB Baseball Card NM-MTAmazon
- $1.991998 Topps #322 Paul O'Neill NM-MT New York Yankees BaseballAmazon
- $28.99Yankees Paul O'Neill 2 Card Collector Plaque #2 w/ 8x10 Batting PhotoAmazon
- $3.991996 TOPPS CHROME #114 PAUL O'NEILL NMMT YANKEESAmazon