- $1,999.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Game-Used Baseball from the 2023 MLB Season with Stats and Cy Young InscriptionsFanatics
- $2,499.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Tip Cap Spotlight Photograph with 2023 AL Cy Young Stats Inscriptions - Limited Edition #1/1 Signed in Green InkFanatics
- SAVE $150.00$449.99$599.99Gerrit Cole & Jacob deGrom Autographed BaseballFanatics
- $209.99and upSports Memorabilia - Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball - Autographed BaseballsAmazon & 1 more
- SAVE $2.50$7.49$9.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Unsigned Pitching PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $82.50$247.49$329.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Gold Leather BaseballFanatics
- $499.99Gerrit Cole & CC Sabathia New York Yankees Autographed BaseballFanatics
- SAVE $112.50$337.49$449.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball Shadow BoxFanatics
- $149.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Hero Series Bobblehead MLB BaseballAmazon
- $399.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Go Yankees" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $85.00$254.99$339.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and Mahogany Display CaseFanatics
- SAVE $2.50$7.49$9.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Unsigned Pitching vs. Philadelphia Phillies PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $100.00$299.99$399.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Cole Train" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $90.00$269.99$359.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Framed 16'' x 20'' Pitching PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $67.50$202.49$269.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Home Pitching PhotographFanatics
- $209.99and upGerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Home Pitching PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- SAVE $87.50$262.49$349.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and Sublimated Debut Display CaseFanatics
- SAVE $2.50$7.49$9.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Unsigned Pitching vs. Toronto Blue Jays PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $70.00$209.99$279.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Road Pitching PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $67.50$202.49$269.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Road Pitching PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $80.00$239.99$319.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Framed 8" x 10" Pitching PhotographFanatics
- $76.80Gerrit Cole Signed Autographed Glossy 8x10 Photo Pittsburgh Pirates - Schwartz Sports CoaEtsy
- SAVE $12.50$37.49$49.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Debut Gold Glove with Image Display CaseFanatics
- SAVE $75.00$224.99$299.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2022 MLB All-Star Game Logo BaseballFanatics
- $449.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Framed 20" x 24" Jersey Number CollageFanatics
- SAVE $67.50$202.49$269.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Pinstripes Side View PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $92.50$277.49$369.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Deluxe Framed 8" x 10" Pitching PhotographFanatics
- $499.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Era Cap with "23 AL CY" InscriptionFanatics
- $251.99and upGerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and Gold Glove Display Case with Image - Autographed MLB GlovesAmazon & 1 more
- $449.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2023 American League Cy Young Award Baseball ShadowboxFanatics
- SAVE $75.00$224.99$299.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2022 Topps Now #1014 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated CardFanatics
- $449.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Framed Baseball with 2,000 Career Strikeouts Shadowbox CollageFanatics
- $249.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Player-Issued #45 Navy Nameplate from 2024 MLB Spring TrainingFanatics
- $369.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Alternate White Chrome Rawlings Mini Batting Helmet - Fanatics ExclusiveFanatics
- SAVE $75.00$224.99$299.99Gerrit Cole Pittsburgh Pirates Autographed 2012 Bowman Chrome Prospects #BCP86 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated CardFanatics
- $599.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Player-Issued #45 Gray Jersey from the 2023 MLB SeasonFanatics
- $299.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2023 Topps Now #577 #/23 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated CardFanatics
- $49.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2023 American League Cy Young Award Sublimated Display Case with ImageFanatics
- SAVE $12.50$37.49$49.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2021 MLB All-Star Game Gold Glove Display Case with ImageFanatics
- $49.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Framed 2023 American League Cy Young Award 15" x 17" CollageFanatics
- SAVE $75.00$224.99$299.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2020 Topps Series 1 Photo Variation #68 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated CardFanatics
- SAVE $87.50$262.49$349.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and 2022 MLB All-Star Game Gold Glove Display Case with ImageFanatics
- $799.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2023 American League Cy Young Award White Nike Authentic Jersey with "23 AL Young" InscriptionFanatics
- $399.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Tip Cap Spotlight Photograph - Signed in Blue Limited Edition of 50Fanatics
- $419.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 2023 Topps Now Purple #335 #/25 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Card with "Fastest to 2000" InscriptionFanatics
- $279.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Photo Print with "2023 AL Cy Young" Inscription - Art and Signed by Maz Adams - Limited Edition #23/23Fanatics
- $99.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Framed 2023 American League Cy Young Award 16" x 20" Collage with a Capsule of Game-Used Dirt - Limited Edition 500Fanatics
- $3,999.99Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Autographed Game-Used #45 Gray Jersey vs. Toronto Blue Jays on September 27, 2023 with Multiple Inscriptions - Worn During Innings 1-6Fanatics
- $1,649.99Aaron Judge & Gerrit Cole & Gleyber Torres & DJ LeMahieu New York Yankees Multi-Signed Framed Bronx Bombers Four Baseball Shadowbox CollageFanatics
- $1,199.99Aaron Judge & Gerrit Cole New York Yankees Multi-Signed Framed Two Baseball Shadowbox CollageFanatics
- $9.872022 Bowman #95 Gerrit Cole New York Yankees BaseballAmazon
- $10.00New York Yankees Gerrit Cole Fanatics eGift Card ($10-$500)Fanatics