- $3.95Don Mattingly Hi 1995 Score #564 Gold Rush Parallel Baseball Card - New York YankeesEtsy
- $4.99Ten 1985 Donruss Highlights Don Mattingly #36 YankeesEtsy
- $60.001987 Donruss #52 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Csg 9.5 MintEtsy
- $20.001989 Upper Deck #200 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Bgs 7.5 NrmtEtsy
- $99.952007 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Don Mattingly Certified Autograph New York Yankees Nr-MtEtsy
- $14.951993 Topps Don Mattingly Promo Sample Baseball Card New York Yankees RAREAmazon
- $60.00Don Mattingly Yankees Autographed Hand Signed #bc-21 1988 Donruss Baseball Card with LoaEtsy
- $22.99Yankees Don Mattingly 3 Card Collector Home Plate Plaque to Amazon!Amazon
- $12.79Don Mattingly Bighead Yankees T-Shirt Cotton Crew Top Toddler White Short SleeveEtsy
- SAVE $45.00$104.99$149.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball 2Fanatics
- $499.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Captain Bobblehead MLB BaseballAmazon
- SAVE $90.00$209.99$299.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Rawlings Pro Black BatFanatics
- SAVE $75.00$224.99$299.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Louisville Slugger BatFanatics
- SAVE $66.00$153.99$219.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Hitman" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $36.00$83.99$119.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Fielding PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $36.00$83.99$119.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Hitting PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $40.00$119.99$159.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and Mahogany Display CaseFanatics
- $224.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Cooperstown Collection Authentic Jersey - White - WhiteMacy's & 2 more
- $299.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Field Stripe Bighead Bobblehead MLB BaseballAmazon
- SAVE $60.00$139.99$199.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "9x Gold Glove" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $120.00$279.99$399.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed White Majestic Cooperstown Collection Replica JerseyFanatics
- SAVE $55.00$164.99$219.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "1985 AL MVP" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $50.00$149.99$199.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "12th Captain 1991-1995" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $63.00$146.99$209.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Framed 16" x 20" Pinstripe Jersey Hitting PhotographFanatics
- SAVE $39.00$90.99$129.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Swing Through The Zone PhotographFanatics
- $80.00Don Mattingly New York Yankees The Captain Signed 11x14 Composite Photo Hall Of FameEtsy
- SAVE $45.00$104.99$149.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed White Alternate Chrome Mini Batting Helmet - Fanatics ExclusiveFanatics
- SAVE $66.00$153.99$219.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Get Rid of Those Sideburns!" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $120.00$279.99$399.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Rawlings Pro Bat with "1985 AL MVP" InscriptionFanatics
- SAVE $120.00$279.99$399.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Navy Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Collection Replica Batting Practice JerseyFanatics
- $165.00Don Mattingly Autographed NY Yankees 16x20 P/S Jersey w/Insc.-Beckett W Hologram WhiteAmazon
- $399.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Rawlings Pro Bat with "Hitman" Inscription - Autographed MLB BatsAmazon
- SAVE $84.00$195.99$279.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 1984 Topps #8 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "MLB DEBUT 9-8-82" InscriptionFanatics
- $66.99and upMen's Don Mattingly Navy New York Yankees 1995 Authentic Cooperstown Collection Mesh Batting Practice Jersey - NavyMacy's & 3 more
- $9.99Vintage Don Mattingly New York Yankees Lapel Pin Mlb Baseball 1990 New Deadstock Hat Cap Snapback Fitted ClubEtsy
- $79.99and upMen's Mitchell & Ness Don Mattingly Navy New York Yankees Cooperstown Collection Big & Tall Mesh Batting Practice Jersey, Size: 5XB, BlueKohl's & 1 more
- $11.99Legends-Sports Memorabilia Price Guide - Vol. 3, No 3 Fall 1990 Yankees- Don Mattingly & Joe Dimaggio Cover + Card InsertsEtsy
- $24.99New York Yankees Great Don Mattingly Honored By His Own StampEtsy
- SAVE $100.00$299.99$399.99Fanatics Authentic Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Replica Batting HelmetFanatics
- $71.99Profile Men's MLB Don Mattingly New York Yankees Cooperstown Collection Replica Player Jersey, Navy Blue, 3XLTBelk
- SAVE $25.50$59.49$84.99Youth Mitchell & Ness Don Mattingly Navy New York Yankees Cooperstown Collection Mesh Batting Practice JerseyFanatics
- $53.99and upMen's Don Mattingly Navy/White New York Yankees Cooperstown Collection Replica Player JerseyFanatics & 1 more