- $43.99Don Mattingly Framed MemorabiliaWayfair
- $112.49and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball 2Fanatics & 1 more
- $13.99Don Mattingly (5) Assorted Baseball Cards Gift PackAmazon
- $499.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Captain Bobblehead MLB BaseballAmazon
- $4.00Don Mattingly 1994 Studio Baseball Card | As Pictured | 567Etsy
- $125.00Don Mattingly Autographed Rawlings OML Baseball- JSA W *BlueAmazon
- $7.00Don Mattingly 1987 Boardwalk & Baseball Card | As Pictured | 1435Etsy
- $153.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Hitman" InscriptionFanatics & 2 more
- $15.00Don Mattingly 12 Stickers, Oddball | Original Issue | As Pictured | 1231Etsy
- $224.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Louisville Slugger BatFanatics & 1 more
- $162.49Don Mattingly 2022 Topps Chrome Black Gold Auto Card #/50Etsy
- $150.00Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Project 2020 King Saladeen /2763 #47StockX
- $34.00Don Mattingly 40 Baseball Cards | As Pictured | Original Issue | 0987Etsy
- $83.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Fielding PhotographFanatics & 2 more
- $37.99Don Mattingly Los Angeles Dodgers Manager Bobble Los Angeles Dodgers BobbleheadAmazon
- $164.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Donnie Baseball" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $90.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Fielding PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $19.77Don Mattingly 20-card set with 2-piece acrylic case [Misc.]Amazon
- $209.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Collection Authentic Jersey - WhiteFanatics & 3 more
- $83.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Hitting PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $119.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball and Mahogany Display CaseFanatics & 1 more
- $24.00Don Mattingly 16 Different Baseball Cards | Original Issue | As Pictured | 01374Etsy
- $299.99Don Mattingly New York Yankees Field Stripe Bighead Bobblehead MLB BaseballAmazon
- $164.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "1985 AL MVP" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $9.00Don Mattingly 1990 Classic Yellow Baseball Card | As Pictured | Original Issue | 1621Etsy
- $149.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "9x Gold Glove" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $9.00Don Mattingly 1988 Classic Blue Baseball Card | As Pictured | Original Issue | 1622Etsy
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed White Majestic Cooperstown Collection Replica JerseyFanatics & 1 more
- $224.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Collection Authentic Jersey - WhiteFansEdge & 1 more
- $50.00Don Mattingly Colored Pencil Drawing Lithograph Limited Edition Print #d To 300Etsy
- $209.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Collection Authentic Jersey - WhiteFanatics & 2 more
- $65.00Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Baseball Rookie Card RC #8 Graded PSA 7Amazon
- $149.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "12th Captain 1991-1995" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $153.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Deluxe Framed 8" x 10" Hitting PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $12.79Don Mattingly Bighead Yankees T-Shirt Cotton Crew Top Toddler White Short SleeveEtsy
- $3.95Don Mattingly Hi 1995 Score #564 Gold Rush Parallel Baseball Card - New York YankeesEtsy
- $97.49and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Swing Through The Zone PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Louisville Slugger Bat with "Hitman" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $153.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Deluxe Framed 8" x 10" Fielding PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $153.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Baseball with "Get Rid of Those Sideburns!" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $224.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed White Alternate Chrome Mini Batting Helmet - Fanatics ExclusiveFanatics & 1 more
- $12.00Don Mattingly 1989 Starting Line-Up Baseball Card | As Pictured | Original Issue | 1200Etsy
- $76.00Don Mattingly New York Yankees The Captain Signed 11x14 Composite Photo Hall Of FameEtsy
- $149.00Don Mattingly Psa 8 1981 Nashville Sounds Baseball Card | Original Issue | As Pictured | 861Etsy
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Louisville Slugger Bat with "Donnie Baseball" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $146.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 16'' x 20'' Fielding with Shades Framed PhotographFanatics & 1 more
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Black Louisville Slugger Bat with "85 AL MVP" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $99.00Don Mattingly Psa 7 1982 Columbus Clippers Baseball Card | Original Issue | As Pictured | 860Etsy
- $165.00Don Mattingly Autographed NY Yankees 16x20 P/S Jersey w/Insc.-Beckett W HologramAmazon
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Navy Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Collection Replica Batting Practice JerseyFanatics & 2 more
- $164.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Batting Photograph with Donnie Baseball InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $149.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Rawlings Baseball with "MLB DEBUT 9-8-82" InscriptionFanatics & 1 more
- $299.99and upDon Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed Rawlings Mach Pro White Alternate Chrome Replica Batting Helmet - Fanatics ExclusiveFanatics & 1 more
- $50.00Don Mattingly Leaf Red Border 18/35 Game Used Patch Card | Original Issue | As Pictured | 1504}Etsy
- $9.99Vintage Don Mattingly New York Yankees Lapel Pin Mlb Baseball 1990 New Deadstock Hat Cap Snapback Fitted ClubEtsy
- $9.99Vintage Don Mattingly New York Yankees Lapel Pin Mlb Baseball 1990 New Deadstock Hat Cap Snapback Fitted ClubEtsy
- $29.701984 Don Mattingly Rc Topps Card #8, Sharp Corners, No CreasesEtsy
- $22.99Yankees Don Mattingly 3 Card Collector Home Plate Plaque to Amazon!Amazon
- $139.57Autographed Don Mattingly Official Rawlings Major League Baseball with COAAmazon
- $19.99Sports Impressions Baseball Don Mattingly - BoxedReplacements, Ltd.