When to scrimp and when to splurge on everyday products

From toilet paper to tissues, Consumer Reports reveals which products are worth a premium and when you can get the best for less

Consumer Reports



Years of testing has taught us that price and quality don’t always go hand in hand. But how do you know when it’s worth paying more for staples such as coffee, paper towels, and dishwasher detergents? We compared the Ratings in 10 product categories, consisting of relatively inexpensive goods typically sold at supermarkets, mass merchants, sometimes even drugstores. Forty percent of the time, a cheaper product was the smarter choice. Here’s the inside scoop on when you can scrimp and when it's worth a splurge.

View gallery


Items to scrimp on

Toilet paper

No one likes flimsy and scratchy bathroom tissue. And the great news is that you don’t have to pay a lot to get an outstanding combination of strength and performance. White Cloud 3-ply Ultra (sold at Walmart, shown) was the clear winner in Consumer Reports’ tests. At a quarter per 100 sheets, it was a bargain.

Dishwasher detergent

Finish Powerball Tabs, at 18 cents per load, did an outstanding job on dishes as well as pots without spotting or leaving mineral deposits.

More from Consumer Reports:
The best washing machines for $800 or less
14 ways to make your home more secure

Dark chocolate bars

Trader Joe’s 72% Cacao, at 60 cents per serving, was excellent (complex flavors and distinct roasted notes) and a bargain to boot. By contrast, Godiva 72% Cacao, which was equally sublime, cost more than twice as much.


Costco’s Kirkland Signature, 47 cents per serving, was everything a bacon should be: It crisped up nicely and consistently, had balanced fat and meat flavors complemented by wood smoke, and a hint of sweetness. It was the only bacon to earn an excellent score.

View gallery


Items to splurge on

Vanilla ice cream

Ben & Jerry’s and Häagen-Dazs (both at $1.03 per serving) towered over the cheaper competition in terms of flavor and texture. Edy’s/Dryer’s, Turkey Hill, Friendly’s, Blue Bell, and Blue Bunny didn’t come close.


There was a bottleneck of fairly similar brands near the top of the rankings of coffee blends. Starbucks House Blend earned the highest score, narrowly, in blind tastings, at $11.37 per pound. Inexpensive stalwarts including Folger’s and Maxwell House were low rated.


Using any sunscreen is better than none, but the product is only part of the equation. You need to rely on clothing and hats to protect your skin, too, and judiciously reapply an ounce (2 tablespoons to cover your face and body) every 2 hours. The lotion we tested that offered optimal UVA and UVB protection was Coppertone Water Babies SPF 50 (shown). At $1.38 per ounce, it’s a modest splurge.

Paper towels

Bounty Duratowel, at $4.04 per 100 square feet, proved outstanding. It offered excellent absorbency, wet strength, and scrubability. For tough jobs or repeated use, no other towel came close.

AA batteries

Lithium batteries performed much better than alkalines, especially in cameras, which tend to drain a charge quickly. Alkalines cost far less, and some perform almost as well as lithiums in low-drain devices such as flashlights and remotes. Among the lithiums, Energizer Ultimate, at $5.50 per pair, was the standout. Once dead, both types can generally be tossed in the trash.

Facial tissue

Puffs Ultra Soft & Strong lived up to its name. The tissues were the only ones judged excellent at resistance to tearing and stretching. That strength comes in handy if you’re battling a cold or allergies. And they were soft, too, though slightly less so than a few others that compromised on toughness. Puffs Ultra Strong, at $1.69 per 100 sheets, outperformed less expensive tissues from store brands such as Costco, Walmart, Whole Foods, Target, and Walgreens, as well as those from Scotties and several Kleenex versions.

View gallery


Copyright © 2006-2014 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Inside Edition
    • A deleted text message from vengeful gangster may get Aaron Hernandez off hook for double murder

      The text message was sent way back on July 5, 2013. Perhaps because its sender, Alexander Bradley, realized it held unwanted power, like the capability of impacting his immunity deal in an Aaron Hernandez double murder trial, let alone rocking the entire case altogether. In a plea deal, Bradley, however, gave authorities full access to his phone, including deleted and otherwise privileged communication with his lawyer.

      Yahoo Sports
    • Someone guessed a very wrong answer on last night’s “Wheel of Fortune,” and it’s going viral

      Ever watch a game show and question why the contestants aren’t figuring out the blatantly obvious answer right in front of them?…

      Hello Giggles
    • We Let Our Baby Cry It Out, and 10 Years Later, This Is What Happened

      Three months into this parenting gig, I'd had enough. Our bedtime routine with our infant son had turned into a two-hour affair that left me and my husband eating dinner at 10 p.m., me up with indigestion for another few hours, and only a few hours of shut-eye before I had to wake up for the day. I was preparing to go back to work, and no amount of concealer, corrector, or eye masks could hide the dark purple circles that had become permanent fixtures under my eyes, never mind function like a thinking adult in an office job. I needed a solution, and I needed one quick. My own parents swore by "Ferberizing" me, and I was willing to give it a try. Ferberizing, or "crying it out," is a sleep training

      PopSugar q
    • Aaron Rodgers' Green Bay house is for sale, and you might even be able to afford it!

      We don’t dabble in real estate too much here at the Shutdown Corner, but we just could not help ourselves with this listing that came on the market — and onto our radar.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Mysterious equipment spotted on SpaceX drone ship

      CAPE CANAVERAL — Stephen Marr had his suspicions when he photographed a mysterious piece of equipment atop SpaceX's drone ship at Port Canaveral on Monday. "I knew there was something different there," Marr, 34, said. So he did what any lover of space and social media would do: He posted it online. Reddit users quickly propelled Marr's clear, high-resolution photo to the top of the website's SpaceX community and so began discussion that the object was likely a highly anticipated robot that would interact with Falcon 9 first stages. "Optimus Prime," as some have nicknamed it, could one day secure first stages after they land on SpaceX's autonomous spaceport drone ships. Like previous upgrades,

      USA Today q
    • Trump's son criticizes London mayor after attack

      Washington (CNN)President Trump's son is criticizing the mayor of London in the immediate aftermath of an attack in the city that killed four and wounded about 40 on the grounds of the UK Parliament. Trump's son, Donald Trump Jr., manages the Trump Organization and has no role in the White House, but he remains an occasional surrogate for his father. The younger Trump also occasionally calls out the President's political opponents on Twitter, the venue he chose Wednesday to weigh in on the incident in Britain. "You have to be kidding me?!" Trump Jr. tweeted, as he shared an article from The Independent, and paraphrased its headline as: "Terror attacks are part of living in big city, says London

      CNN q
    • Shop Bella Hadid's Sexy Cut-Out Swimsuit For Your Next Vacation (106 photos)

      While it's easy to dress straight from the latest runways when you're a celebrity, these A-Listers prove it's still possible (and just as easy) to look chic in budget-friendly fashion. Click through to shop the latest celebrity looks, all for under $250 , that won't break the bank. From Harper's BAZAAR

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Fan wearing Nolan Ryan jersey has no idea he’s two feet from Nolan Ryan

      You have to be a really dedicated Astros fan to show up to a minor league spring training game.

      Sports Illustrated
    • Texas Teacher, 27, Accused of Improper Relationship with 17-Year-Old Male Student

      Texas Teacher Allegedly Had Improper Relationship with Student

    • Teacher Takes Smiling Mugshot After Being Accused of Inappropriate Relationship with Student

      A 26-year-old Texas teacher`s mugshot has gone viral after she was accused of having an improper relationship with a 17-year-old student.

    • ‘Wheel of Fortune’ contestant had all but 1 letter and still got phrase wrong

      This is heartbreaking. OMG this just Happened.pic.twitter.com/Q0CYxM8jJB— ⛄Mike☃️ (@MBragiel) March 21, 2017No. No. No. No. This actually happened?On Tuesday, a contestant on Wheel of Fortune was literally one letter away from winning. The answer should have been staring them right in the face. A Streetcar NAMED Desire.Even if you’re not familiar with the play, the word name just fits perfectly. ...

      SB Nation q
    • “It’s a Disaster. It’s a Nightmare.” Is a Civil War Brewing Inside Fox

      “No one is missing her anymore,” one Fox News insider told me recently. This person was referring, of course, to Megyn Kelly, the network’s former star who left for NBC earlier this year. Kelly’s move may have signaled a rightward lurch for NBC, which appears to be coming to terms with its place in our new Trumpian reality. (MSNBC also recently hired Kelly’s former colleague Greta Van Susteren.) But the move may be more significant for her former stomping ground, Fox News, which appears to be in the midst of its own regressive (if highly rated) culture change. During Kelly’s reign, “it was always all about Megyn,” one former Fox colleague told me. Now, it’s all about the Old White Men. It’s worth

      vanityfair.com q
    • Here's what Tony Romo trade prospects look like as Cowboys approach critical period

      The Tony Romo clock is running out. With offseason workouts set to begin in only a few weeks – and the Dallas Cowboys unlikely to risk having their ousted former starter show up and expose himself to injury – the moment to make a decision on Romo has arrived for Dallas. If the Cowboys are going to trade him, next week’s league spring meetings mark the last best chance for Dallas to pry something loose from another NFL team in exchange for the 14-year veteran.

      Yahoo Sports
    • Who is Mary Elizabeth Taylor? Social Media Loses It Over Woman at Gorsuch Hearing

      She's been sitting behind Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch during his confirmation hearings.

      Inside Edition
    • Race in America: White Veteran Kills Black Man in NYC to 'Make A Statement'

      A white Army veteran traveled from Maryland to New York City to kill a black man to "make a statement" in the media capital of the world, New York Police Department officials said Wednesday. Jackson was carrying a handful of knives in his pocket when he arrived at the police station, Reuters reported. Shortly after coming across Timothy Caughman, who was searching through garbage on the street, he stabbed him in the chest and back, police said. Jackson told police he left Baltimore Friday and traveled to New York City by bus "because it is the media capital of the world and he wanted to make a statement," Bill Aubrey, a deputy chief at the New York Police Department, told reporters. "It was revealed that the attack on Timothy Caughman was clearly racially motivated.

    • US flies nuclear-capable B-1B bomber after North Korea's failed missile test

      The US flew a nuclear-capable B-1B bomber over the Korean peninsula on Wednesday, 22 March, hours after North Korea's failed missile test. Although it was part of the ongoing US-South Korea joint military exercises, it is seen as a strong warning to the reclusive Kim Jong-un regime.

      International Business Times
    • Bonner Bolton Explains That Unintentional Grab of DWTS Partner Sharna Burgess

      Bonner Bolton Explains Groping Sharna Burgess on DWTS

    • Texas teacher grins in mugshot after being arrested for sexual relationship with student

      A science teacher was all smiles when her mugshot was taken on Monday (20 March), despite facing charges of engaging in a sexual relationship with her student. Sarah Fowlkes, a 27-year-old science teacher from Lockhart, Texas, turned herself in at the Lockhart Police Station on a warrant and was booked into the Caldwell County Jail, police confirmed. Fowlkes, who had worked for the school district since October 2014, was allegedly in a relationship with a 17-year-old male student, the Houston Chronicle reported.

      International Business Times
    • APNewsBreak: California may face 'significant risk' from dam

      SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — California is courting a "very significant risk" if a damaged spillway on the nation's tallest dam is not operational by the next rainy season, and the state's plan for the work leaves no time for any delays, a team of safety experts has warned in a report obtained Wednesday by The Associated Press.

      Associated Press