Vanilla ice cream taste test results


View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo: Schrempp Erich)

Yahoo editors have selected this article as a favorite of 2013. It first ran on Yahoo Shopping on Feb. 1st and was one of the most popular stories of the year.

Epicurious indulged in 13 brands of vanilla ice cream, but only one got rave reviews from the editors.

W hen it comes to vanilla ice cream, you might be tempted to ask whether there's really that much of a difference in taste from one brand to another. But having tried 13 different brands of vanilla, we can positively confirm it: Not all vanilla is created equal.

In search of the best vanilla scoop, we started by excluding French vanilla and vanilla bean varieties in favor of plain old basic vanilla. What did we want from the perfect pint? A natural-looking frozen scoop that can be enjoyed in a bowl, on top of a sugar cone, or à la mode.

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Whole Foods)

Best Vanilla Ice Cream:
Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream

Pros: "This one really stood out because of its perfectly milky taste and whipped mousselike consistency," stated one judge.

Others liked its snow-white appearance and the fact that it's made from only six ingredients.

Cons: Can be bought only at Whole Foods Market.

Editors' Rating: 4 forks out of 4

View gallery

Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Breyers)

First Runner-Up:
Breyers Natural Vanilla ($4.99)

Pros: All judges commended this pick for being just sweet and creamy enough, capturing the essence of vanilla.

Cons: Some believed it lacks that signature vanilla fragrance.

Editors' Rating: 3.5 forks out of 4

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Ben & Jerry's)

Second Runner-Up:
Ben & Jerry's Vanilla ($4.69)

Pros: "Good, thick consistency and precise vanilla flavor," stated one judge. "Creammmy," said another.

Cons: Contains more fat per serving than the others.

Editors' Rating: 3 forks out of 4

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of SoCo Creamery)

The Other Contenders

Most tasters thought SoCo Creamery was icy and tasted fruity, almost pineapple-y. 365 Organic was an unappealing yellow color, very thick and surprisingly bland.

And while we're fans of Blue Marble's other flavors, their brand's vanilla missed the mark: "Tastes like bad vanilla frosting," said one judge. "Needs a serious dosage of hot fudge," suggested another.

Additional Taste Test Details

All 13 types of vanilla ice cream evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream, Breyers Natural Vanilla, Ben & Jerry's Vanilla, La Salle, Turkey Hill Original Vanilla, Häagen-Dazs, Graeter's, Stonyfield Farm Gotta Have Vanilla, Ronnybrook Farm, Edy's Slow Churned Classic Vanilla, SoCo Creamery, 365 Organic, Blue Marble.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 13 types of vanilla ice cream. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Foods That Are Keeping You Up at Night

What's in Season: Your Winter Produce Guide 

How to Pick the Best Diet for Your Lifestyle

Recommended for You

  • Man murdered wife's family and then killed her as she attended funeral service in 'evil plot'

    A man has been found guilty of executing an "evil plot" in which he killed his sister-in-law and father-in-law to lure his wife to their funerals, where he then murdered her. Samuel Velasco Gurrola, 41, conspired to kill his wife Ruth Sagredo and her family with the help of his two siblings in the US town of El Paso in Texas. As Ruth Sagredo joined her sister's funeral procession, Gurrola murdered her.

    International Business Times ONC UK q
  • The Walking Dead: Negan's Victim Speaks Out on 'Messed-Up' Exit

    Warning: The following doesn’t just contain spoilers for the Season 7 premiere of The Walking Dead, it contains big ol’ bashed-in skull-shaped spoilers. So if you’ve yet to watch the episode — and think you’ll be able to bear to — proceed no further. Glenn’s death in Sunday’s Walking Dead premiere was meant to be — and […]
  • Saturday Night Live: Tom Hanks Exposes a Surprising Truth About Trump Supporters

    The final debate sketch wasn’t the only time Tom Hanks and Saturday Night Live decided to roast Donald Trump. S.N.L. hasn’t exactly been gentle on Trump supporters this election season. Or did you miss that fake ad last year where the show unflinchingly compared them to Nazis? So, knowing some biting political commentary is coming, it’s surprising to see Tom Hanks—who, earlier in the night, leaned into his gentle, “America’s Dad” persona—put on that red “Make America Great Again” cap for a “Black Jeopardy!” sketch. But, either way, it was good to see Hanks behind the old Jeopardy! podium where he made such a splash playing a dumbed down version of himself opposite Will Ferrell’s Alex Trebek back

    HWD q
  • US: Philippines' Duterte sparking distress around the world

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — America's top diplomat for Asia said Monday that Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's controversial remarks and a "real climate of uncertainty" about his government's intentions have sparked distress in the U.S. and other countries.

    Associated Press
  • 5 Denim Styles Every Girl Should Own (16 photos)

    When it comes to denim, more is more is more in our book. While we have classic silhouettes on lock, fall is ushering in a fresh batch of looks embracing ’90s style via new wave design. Here, the latest trends to add to your wardrobe now, from designer buys to under $100 takes. These looks are stand out.

    The Zoe Report
  • Police baffled by couple found dead next to untouched bags of Taco Bell — and not much else

    Cameron and Courtney Hulet were lying on their living room floor when a neighbor saw them. The neighbor didn’t think much of it. She heard moans and figured they were asleep. She closed the front door, which the couple had a habit of leaving open, David Uhl, manager of the southeast Michigan village of Dundee, told The Washington Post. It was Tuesday morning. The neighbor didn’t see the Hulets all day, she told authorities. She went back to check on them later that night. They were still lying next to each other. Taco Bell bags and drinks sat next to them on a table, untouched. The woman had a male friend check on them, Uhl said. Police were called to the apartment shortly before midnight on

    Washington Post q
  • Michael Crabtree touched his shoulder and was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct

    Michael Crabtree is one unsportsmanlike conduct penalty from an automatic ejection after getting penalized for doing nothing wrong. Oakland Raiders wide receiver Michael Crabtree wasn’t able to avoid the penalty Sunday, even though he didn’t even do one. Crabtree celebrated a 2-yard touchdown pass against the Jacksonville Jaguars just before halftime by tossing the ball.

    SB Nation q
  • Ariel Winter finally explains why she wore that swimsuit on the red carpet

    Modern Family star Ariel Winter has a great track record as a body-positive role model. She is so outspoken about her journey to feeling happy in her own skin and knows how to handle bullies without dimming her shine. That’s why we love this explanation of why she wore a swimsuit, shorts, and heels on the red carpet over the summer. Ariel debuted this look at the Just Jared 4th Annual Summer Bash hosted by Uno in Los Angeles in July. Some fans loved the look and some people hated it, but it definitely got people talking. It’s true, this is a real outfit she rocked on the red carpet! In a recent interview with People about her most controversial outfits, Ariel talked about the look. She said:

    HelloGiggles q
  • 745-Pound Woman Needs Gallbladder Surgery, Doctors Refuse

    Desperately in need of gall-bladder surgery, Katrina Randall, was rushed to the hospital on Friday. Her family hopes her latest trip leads to a life-saving procedure but there`s a catch - her family says doctors won`t operate because of her size. She weighs 740 pounds.

  • These twin brothers dancing in a supermarket are going viral and it’s cause they’re amazing

    Dancing in public is pretty much a regular activity for us. But when we discovered these twin brothers with amazing moves busting a…

    Hello Giggles
  • Top aide touts Donald Trump's 'drain the swamp' message

    That would've meant Trump running mate Mike Pence would've been term-limited out of office halfway through his 12-year tenure representing Indiana. "He was definitely living in the swamp," Conway said of Pence, who led fiscal conservative fights like opposing the bank bailout pushed by his own party's President George W. Bush. "Mike Pence would agree with Donald Trump on that: When you're there for too long, you need that fresh blood and new perspective," Conway said. "I wish there were more members like Mike Pence. If there were, we wouldn't need to have the conversation." Conway also attacked Clinton over her family foundation's acceptance of foreign contributions -- but Tapper pointed out

    CNN q
  • Kirk Cousins' Hilarious Handoff Gaffe Has Given Us The Nutfumble

    Kirk Cousins remains one of the most fascinatingly inconsistent quarterbacks in the NFL. Cousins went back to hand off to Matt Jones when he got his foot stepped on by an offensive lineman. Not really his fault! But Cousins’ desperation handoff to Jones was a bit of brilliant physical comedy that isn’t easy to forget.

  • Bella Thorne looks like a live-action Jessica Rabbit in this incredible red dress

    Bella Thorne is a red-hot fashionista and we are totally obsessed with her latest look. The 19-year-old actress has a history of…

    Hello Giggles
  • ‘Walking Dead’ Negan Victim Reveal Leaves Fans Devastated

    (Spoiler alert: Do not keep reading if you did not see the Season 7 premiere of “The Walking Dead”)

    The Wrap
  • Chelsea manager Antonio Conte denies mocking Manchester United

    "humiliate" Jose Mourinho during the 4-0 win over Manchester United. Mourinho exchanged heated words with Conte at the final whistle at Stamford Bridge, with Sky Sports reporting that the Portuguese coach was unhappy with Conte's attempts to encourage the home fans to make more noise with the score at 4-0. The 53-year-old is reported to have told Conte in Italian: "You don't celebrate like that at 4-0.

    International Business Times UK q
  • 5 Superheroes That Marvel May Never Get Back

    Though Marvel Studios has full rights to most of the company's superheroes, don't expect these to return home anytime soon.

    The Cheat Sheet q
  • Emily Ratajkowski Cheers on the L.A. Dodgers in a Midriff-Baring Crop Top, Smooches Her Boyfriend in the Stands

    Who says you have to rock a billowing jersey to show your sportsmanship? Not Emily Ratajkowski, who showcased her toned physique as she cheered on the Los Angeles Dodgers at a baseball game in L.A. on Thursday. The model and actress took a minimalist approach to dressing for the sidelines and rocked a black pair of high-waist jeans with a long-sleeve white crop top that showcased her abs. She proudly put forth her support of the hometown team with a black cap that simply read "LA"

  • MarketWatch q
  • 'Saturday Night Live' Spoofs Trump, Clinton in 3rd Presidential Debate, Tom Hanks Plays Moderator Chris Wallace

    Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton continue to provide "Saturday Night Live" with plenty of fodder. As in weeks past, Alec Baldwin and "SNL" cast member Kate McKinnon impersonated Trump and Clinton, zeroing in on the most eccentric and quirky aspects of their behavior. The fictional Trump's tone soon changed, when he was asked about reproductive rights.

    Good Morning America
  • Trump Surrogates Continue Their Apologist Tour to Election Day

    It’s a thankless job being a Donald Trump surrogate these days. The job fell to campaign manager Kellyanne Conway and Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus this weekend, and both twisted themselves in verbal knots casting the Trump campaign as something other than a foundering ship that’s headed to the bottom. After promising to deliver a “closing argument” in a speech on Saturday in Gettysburg, PA, Trump instead dedicated part of his remarks to promising to sue each of the dozen or so women who have accused him of sexual assault.

    The Fiscal Times