Vanilla ice cream taste test results

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo: Schrempp Erich)

Yahoo editors have selected this article as a favorite of 2013. It first ran on Yahoo Shopping on Feb. 1st and was one of the most popular stories of the year.

Epicurious indulged in 13 brands of vanilla ice cream, but only one got rave reviews from the editors.

W hen it comes to vanilla ice cream, you might be tempted to ask whether there's really that much of a difference in taste from one brand to another. But having tried 13 different brands of vanilla, we can positively confirm it: Not all vanilla is created equal.



In search of the best vanilla scoop, we started by excluding French vanilla and vanilla bean varieties in favor of plain old basic vanilla. What did we want from the perfect pint? A natural-looking frozen scoop that can be enjoyed in a bowl, on top of a sugar cone, or à la mode.



View gallery

.
Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Whole Foods)

Best Vanilla Ice Cream:
Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream
($3.59)

Pros: "This one really stood out because of its perfectly milky taste and whipped mousselike consistency," stated one judge.

Others liked its snow-white appearance and the fact that it's made from only six ingredients.

Cons: Can be bought only at Whole Foods Market.

Editors' Rating: 4 forks out of 4




View gallery

.
Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Breyers)

First Runner-Up:
Breyers Natural Vanilla ($4.99)

Pros: All judges commended this pick for being just sweet and creamy enough, capturing the essence of vanilla.

Cons: Some believed it lacks that signature vanilla fragrance.

Editors' Rating: 3.5 forks out of 4




View gallery

.
Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Ben & Jerry's)

Second Runner-Up:
Ben & Jerry's Vanilla ($4.69)


Pros: "Good, thick consistency and precise vanilla flavor," stated one judge. "Creammmy," said another.

Cons: Contains more fat per serving than the others.

Editors' Rating: 3 forks out of 4









View gallery

.
Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of SoCo Creamery)

The Other Contenders

Most tasters thought SoCo Creamery was icy and tasted fruity, almost pineapple-y. 365 Organic was an unappealing yellow color, very thick and surprisingly bland.

And while we're fans of Blue Marble's other flavors, their brand's vanilla missed the mark: "Tastes like bad vanilla frosting," said one judge. "Needs a serious dosage of hot fudge," suggested another.



Additional Taste Test Details

All 13 types of vanilla ice cream evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream, Breyers Natural Vanilla, Ben & Jerry's Vanilla, La Salle, Turkey Hill Original Vanilla, Häagen-Dazs, Graeter's, Stonyfield Farm Gotta Have Vanilla, Ronnybrook Farm, Edy's Slow Churned Classic Vanilla, SoCo Creamery, 365 Organic, Blue Marble.



Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 13 types of vanilla ice cream. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.


More from Epicurious:

Foods That Are Keeping You Up at Night

What's in Season: Your Winter Produce Guide 

How to Pick the Best Diet for Your Lifestyle

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Father and Son Repeatedly Raped Teen Relative While Imprisoning Her for Years, Police Allege

      Timothy Ciboro, 53, and Esten Ciboro, 28, are charged with kidnapping, rape and endangering a child in their care, according to court documents obtained by PEOPLE. Esten Ciboro told the court his Bible is “the only law book that truly matters” and that “there’s a great deal of strategy in Scripture” that he uses in every facet of his life, according to the paper. Timothy and Esten were arrested in May after a 13-year-old girl allegedly escaped from the home in which she claimed to have been imprisoned on and off for more than two years, WTOL reports.

      People
    • Defense Secretary Mattis' first message to the troops tells you everything you need to know about his leadership style

      Defense Secretary James Mattis put out his first all-hands message to everyone in the...

      Business Insider
    • The letter I had to write to my child’s teacher

      I was only in the classroom for 45 minutes, but that was long enough to compel me to write a letter to the teacher once I left. I’ll be honest, I have zero qualifications as it relates to child education. My only qualification and reason for being in a kindergarten class that day is my oldest child is a kindergartner. He attends a public school and I was in his classroom as a parent volunteer. His teacher had asked parents to sign up to help during the daily Literacy Center portion of the morning. I was excited to go in, see my son in his classroom, and meet his classmates. When I arrived, the class was sitting on the floor, singing, and drawing the alphabet in the air with their fingers. Mrs.

      Washington Post q
    • College Football Player Allegedly Stalked Then Murdered Cheerleader Ex After Their Breakup

      A college football player had become obsessed with his cheerleader ex-girlfriend, stalking her for weeks before he murdered her in her home in November, authorities allege in a new indictment. William Riley Gaul, 18, was indicted Wednesday in Knox County, Tennessee, on charges of first-degree murder, especially aggravated stalking, tampering with evidence and employing a firearm during a dangerous felony. Investigators claim that early on Nov. 21, he fatally shot 16-year-old Emma Walker through a wall in her family’s home in Knoxville, Tennessee, while she slept.

      People
    • Johnny Galecki Explains Why Leonard Wears Lensless Glasses In ‘Big Bang Theory’

      Johnny Galecki recently explained why Leonard’s glasses don’t have lenses in “Big Bang Theory” Season 10.

      International Business Times
    • Trump administration places horse 'soring' ban on hold

      WASHINGTON – A federal regulation finalized in the waning days of the Obama administration to end the abusive practice of horse soring is on hold. Just one week before President Barack Obama left office, the Department of Agriculture announced it had finalized a new regulation to update the Horse Protection Act. To become effective, the rule must be published in the Federal Register. The new rule was supposed to be published Tuesday. But on President Donald Trump’s first day in office last Friday, the White House issued a memorandum for all unpublished rules to be withdrawn and sent back to the relevant agency for review. “They pretty much put a hold on it,” said Keith Dane, senior adviser for

      The Tennessean q
    • LeBron James is absolutely livid, but can the Cavs pull off the deal he wants?

      Well, it took us a few months, but finally, LeBron James is publicly complaining about the Cavaliers roster and performance. So the NBA season has really begun. On Monday night, the Cavaliers lost their fifth game out of their last seven contests, a 124-122 loss to New Orleans in which they trailed by 20 points at one point before storming back only to fall short. In the past 1o games, the Cavaliers have been outscored by 38 points with James on the floor, an amazing stat given how much better they typically are when he's on the court. After the game, LeBron James... got into his feelings, as Klay Thompson might say. James spoke openly of his frustration with the team being unable to secure another

      CBS Sports q
    • These Rare Biracial Twins Are Beyond Adorable

      Kalani and Jarani Dean are a set of 9-moth-old twins from Quincy in Illinois who each respectively take after their mother and their father. As People reports, Kalani inherited their mother's lighter complexion, while Jarani inherited their father's darker complexion and eyes. "We're chromosome twins," their mother, Whitney Meyer, wrote on a Facebook photo post of the two.

      Refinery 29 UK
    • An asteroid is about to slip between Earth and the moon — the second near miss in 3 weeks

      Less than 3 weeks ago, while America was getting the kids to school and arriving at work, an...

      Business Insider
    • Coco Austin and Daughter Chanel ‘Did Miami’ – in Matching Swimsuits, Of Course

      Little Chanel sported a wide smile as she lounged on the chair. The photo seems to be from Austin and Chanel’s recent trip to the Florida city. “I would live in a swimsuit if I lived near a tropical place,” Austin captioned the shot of the baby waving.

      People
    • NATO in the crosshairs: Who's not paying their bills

      President Trump has a beef with NATO. He's called the alliance "obsolete" and accused other members of not spending their fair share. "We are spending a tremendous amount in NATO and other people proportionately less," he said during the campaign. "No good." When it comes to costs, Trump has a point. Only five of NATO's 28 members -- the U.S., Greece, Poland, Estonia and the U.K. -- meet the alliance's target of spending at least 2% of GDP on defense. Getting more NATO members to pay their way will be something Trump and U.K. Prime Minister Theresa May can agree on when they meet Friday at the White House. The alliance increased overall defense spending for the first time in two decades in 2015,

      CNN Money q
    • Minnesota Governor Reveals Cancer Diagnosis a Day After Fainting in Middle of Speech

      Gov. Mark Dayton made the shocking announcement the day after he passed out while delivering the state of the state address.

      Inside Edition
    • Barack and Michelle Obama Enjoy a Post-Presidency Vacation in the British Virgin Islands

      The former first couple departed Washington D.C. on Friday following the inauguration of President Donald Trump. The Obamas headed to Palm Springs, California, where they enjoyed a brief stay at the Rancho Mirage home of James Costos, ambassador to Spain and Angora under President Obama, and Los Angeles–based interior designer Michael S. Smith, who redecorated the White House while the Obamas lived there.

      People
    • Cab driver says John Elway is greatest QB ever, has no idea he’s in the back seat

      Cab driver Sam Snow couldn’t say enough good things about John Elway...but he didn’t realize the Broncos legend was right there in the back seat.

      Sports Illustrated
    • Cosmopolitan
    • Amy Smart revealed that she had her baby through a surrogate, and here’s why that’s important

      Fertility issues are a widely experienced — but seldom discussed — part of life. All too often women are ashamed or embarrassed to…

      Hello Giggles
    • Giant underwater goddess found off Turkish coast in ancient shipwreck

      A giant goddess sculpture has been found on the sea floor off the south-western coast of Turkey. The 2,700-year-old artefact was found by archaeologists investigating the contents of a 43m deep shipwreck uncovered in November 2016. Researchers from Dokuz Eylül University sifted through an area of approximately 300 sq ft off the coast of Bozburun, in Turkey's Marmaris district, hoping to uncover Mediterranean relics.

      International Business Times UK q
    • Sherri Shepherd Claims ‘Huge Victory’ amid ‘Frivolous’ Child Support Bid by Ex-Husband Lamar Sally

      Sherri Shepherd has shared news of a “huge victory” in the child support case filed against her by ex-husband Lamar Sally. A rep for the former The View co-host has confirmed to PEOPLE that a judge denied Sally’s request for an increase in child support payments for the couple’s son, Lamar Sally, Jr . Sally’s request was filed in mid-December, according to court documents obtained by PEOPLE. Shepherd and Sally’s 2-year-old — who was conceived using Sally’s sperm and a donor egg, meaning Shepherd does not have a genetic connection to the boy — was born in August 2014 after the couple broke up and has been raised since then by Sally.

      People
    • The CEO of Dippin' Dots just responded to 5 years of angry tweets from Trump's press secretary

      The CEO of Dippin' Dots just shot back at Sean Spicer, the White House press secretary, whose...

      Business Insider
    • 10 Shocking Confessions from Nannies

      "I put a hat on her until the swelling went down and stayed awake with her all night for the next 3 nights to make sure she didn't have a seizure or stop breathing."

      Redbook