Vanilla ice cream taste test results


View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo: Schrempp Erich)

Yahoo editors have selected this article as a favorite of 2013. It first ran on Yahoo Shopping on Feb. 1st and was one of the most popular stories of the year.

Epicurious indulged in 13 brands of vanilla ice cream, but only one got rave reviews from the editors.

W hen it comes to vanilla ice cream, you might be tempted to ask whether there's really that much of a difference in taste from one brand to another. But having tried 13 different brands of vanilla, we can positively confirm it: Not all vanilla is created equal.

In search of the best vanilla scoop, we started by excluding French vanilla and vanilla bean varieties in favor of plain old basic vanilla. What did we want from the perfect pint? A natural-looking frozen scoop that can be enjoyed in a bowl, on top of a sugar cone, or à la mode.

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Whole Foods)

Best Vanilla Ice Cream:
Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream

Pros: "This one really stood out because of its perfectly milky taste and whipped mousselike consistency," stated one judge.

Others liked its snow-white appearance and the fact that it's made from only six ingredients.

Cons: Can be bought only at Whole Foods Market.

Editors' Rating: 4 forks out of 4

View gallery

Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Breyers)

First Runner-Up:
Breyers Natural Vanilla ($4.99)

Pros: All judges commended this pick for being just sweet and creamy enough, capturing the essence of vanilla.

Cons: Some believed it lacks that signature vanilla fragrance.

Editors' Rating: 3.5 forks out of 4

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of Ben & Jerry's)

Second Runner-Up:
Ben & Jerry's Vanilla ($4.69)

Pros: "Good, thick consistency and precise vanilla flavor," stated one judge. "Creammmy," said another.

Cons: Contains more fat per serving than the others.

Editors' Rating: 3 forks out of 4

View gallery

Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test

(Photo courtesy of SoCo Creamery)

The Other Contenders

Most tasters thought SoCo Creamery was icy and tasted fruity, almost pineapple-y. 365 Organic was an unappealing yellow color, very thick and surprisingly bland.

And while we're fans of Blue Marble's other flavors, their brand's vanilla missed the mark: "Tastes like bad vanilla frosting," said one judge. "Needs a serious dosage of hot fudge," suggested another.

Additional Taste Test Details

All 13 types of vanilla ice cream evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Whole Foods Market Vanilla Ice Cream, Breyers Natural Vanilla, Ben & Jerry's Vanilla, La Salle, Turkey Hill Original Vanilla, Häagen-Dazs, Graeter's, Stonyfield Farm Gotta Have Vanilla, Ronnybrook Farm, Edy's Slow Churned Classic Vanilla, SoCo Creamery, 365 Organic, Blue Marble.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 13 types of vanilla ice cream. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Foods That Are Keeping You Up at Night

What's in Season: Your Winter Produce Guide 

How to Pick the Best Diet for Your Lifestyle

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • This professor says it's time to kill your 401(k)

      More than half of American workers — roughly 55 million — don't have access to a retirement savings plan on the job. Here's a potential fix.

    • At Least 38 Democratic Congress Members Plan to Skip the Inauguration

      At least 38 Democratic members of Congress have announced they will skip Donald Trump's Friday inauguration. While some made their decision in previous weeks, several more have now come forward, citing the president-elect's perceived insult of Rep. John Lewis as the final straw.Trump lashed out at the civil rights icon after Lewis said he didn't view Trump as "a legitimate president." Lewis, a Georgia Democrat who protested alongside the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., also said he would not attend the inauguration. ...

      Good Morning America
    • Connecticut Politician Arrested for Groping a Woman After a Disagreement

      Connecticut Republican politician Christopher von Keyserling was having a political disagreement with a female colleague when the unnamed 57-year-old woman said to him that we’re living in a “a new world,” politically speaking. To that, the 71-year-old member of the representative town meeting and an outspoken commentator on town affairs allegedly responded, “I love this new world, I no longer have to be politically correct,” according to an arrest warrant, says Time.

      Yahoo Style
    • Bob Beckel Returned, to Bash Trump On Fox News

      In a semi-surprise, that big ol’ growly, liberal bear in suspenders, Bob Beckel, reclaimed his chair on Monday’s edition of The Five. Beckel, who’d been dumped by Fox News in 2015 (and underwent, as he said on Monday, three back operations), is a sleeker grumpy ol’ bear now, having dropped 35 pounds. The other four of The Five — Eric Bolling, Kimberly Guilfoyle, Greg Gutfeld and Dana Perino — seemed genuinely pleased to see Beckel, whose seat had been filled most recently by Juan Williams.

      Yahoo TV
    • CNN spinoff to win Time Warner deal approval makes no sense, AT&T CEO says

      AT&T Chairman and CEO Randall Stephenson tells CNBC from Davos he sees opposition to the Time Warner mega-merger fading as the details emerge. q
    • Everything Aaron and Jordan Rodgers Have Said About Their Family Feud

      Quarterback Aaron Rodgers may have led the Green Bay Packers to a narrow victory during Sunday night’s playoff game against the Dallas Cowboys, but his family did not share in the celebration. According to a new interview with The New York Times published Sunday, Ed Rodgers confirmed that he’s not on speaking terms with his son following the 32-year-old NFL star’s rise in popularity. Word of the family’s rift became public knowledge last spring when the quarterback’s younger brother Jordan appeared on JoJo Fletcher‘s season of The Bachelorette.

    • Scientists Learn Why Women Go Through Menopause by Studying Killer Whales

      Scientists allege in a recent study that menopause, when females no longer produce eggs to bear children, was an evolutionary development that helps end conflict between mothers and daughters. In the study, the researchers state that menopause helps alleviate strife between females and keeps them from being a sexual threat to their offspring. The study was conducted at the University of Exeter and examined one of only three species on the planet that undergo menopause — killer whales.

      Yahoo Beauty
    • Oil production in Asia declining at record levels: Wood Mackenzie

      Oil production in Asia-Pacific is declining at a rate not seen elsewhere in the world, Wood Mackenzie has warned. q
    • Parents of Accused Teen Stabber in 'Slender Man' Case Speak Out for the 1st Time

      The parents of Anissa Weier, one of two 12-year-old girls who allegedly stabbed another girl 19 times in an effort to impress fictional internet character “Slender Man,” said today they were as shocked by the 2014 attack as everyone else. "It was really kind of surreal from the time I got the phone call," Bill Weier, Anissa's father, told “Good Morning America” today of his reaction to news of his daughter's alleged connection to the incident in the woods of a Milwaukee, Wisconsin, suburb. Anissa Weier and Morgan Geyser have been charged with the attempted murder of Payton Leutner, who was purportedly their friend at the time of the attack, and are expected to be tried as adults this year in a Wisconsin court.

      Good Morning America
    • George Michael’s Cousin Blasts Fadi Fawaz as He Says ‘Too Many Questions Have Come Up’ About Death

      George Michael‘s cousin, Andros Georgiou, is speaking out for the first time about apparently growing rift between Michael’s family and his boyfriend Fadi Fawaz and the questions the family has surrounding the singer’s untimely death. Shortly after his shocking death, Fawaz claimed that he had discovered Michael dead in his bed on Christmas morning in the singer’s Oxfordshire, England, home.

    • Team Trump Steps Up Intimidation of Government Ethics Officer

      The government ethics officer who last week criticized President-elect Donald Trump for his decision not to divest himself of his assets before taking office is now under fire from both Trump’s transition team and the chairman of a committee in the House of Representatives that could stand in the way of his agency’s legislative reauthorization. Without presenting any evidence, Reince Priebus, Trump’s incoming chief of staff, on Sunday accused Walter Shaub, the head of the Office of Government Ethics, of being ethically compromised himself. The anger at Shaub arose primarily from remarks he delivered at the Brookings Institution last week, in which he declared Trump’s plan to hand over management of his company to his sons while retaining ownership a “meaningless” gesture that does nothing to ameliorate the conflicts of interest he will face as president.

      The Fiscal Times
    • The 2017 Hall of Fame ballot: How we'd vote on the rest of the returnees

      As you’ve seen over the past two weeks, we’ve done our best to focus on the 13 candidates we feel present the most interesting case for induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Others, like Tim Raines and Lee Smith, are in their final bid on the Baseball Writers Association of America’s ballot. Jeff Kent is in his fourth year on the Hall of Fame ballot.

      Big League Stew
    • Authorities: Trooper was shot by driver who caused rollover

      PHOENIX (AP) — An Arizona state trooper who was beaten and shot while responding to a traffic collision on Interstate 10 was attacked by a Mexican man who was responsible for the one-vehicle rollover, authorities said.

      Associated Press
    • Prince Harry Introduced Meghan Markle to Kate Middleton

      Here are three of the day’s hottest stories to get you caught up on all things celebrity: Prince Harry’s girlfriend Meghan Markle just met Kate Middleton and Princess Charlotte. According to a report in the Sun, the Suits actress met Harry’s sister-in-law at Kensington Palace. Markle had previously met Prince William, two months ago. Dax Shepard shared an adorable throwback pic of him and wife Kristen Bell. The couple have been together for nearly a decade (and were married in 2013), and the actor posted the below photo from nine years ago. ...

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • ‘Congrats Big Sis!’ Pink and Carey Hart Throw a Party for Daughter Willow Three Weeks After Welcoming Son Jameson

      On Sunday, Pink and husband Carey Hart shared a photo from a big-sister party they threw for their 5½-year-old daughter Willow Sage, who just helped welcome her little brother Jameson Moon into the world on Dec. 26. “Congrats Big Sis! #bigsisterparty,” the singer, 37, captioned a photo of herself, Willow and a snoozing Jameson. Mother and daughter flash their pearly whites at the camera, amidst a background of festive balloons.

    • Elite North Korean defector says more diplomats waiting to defect to Seoul: Yonhap

      More high-level North Korean diplomats are waiting to defect to South Korea from their overseas posts in Europe, Pyongyang's former deputy ambassador to London said on Tuesday, according to the Yonhap News Agency. Thae Yong Ho defected to South Korea in August last year and since December 2016 has been speaking to local media and appearing on variety television shows to discuss his defection to Seoul and his life as a North Korean envoy. "A significant number of North Korean diplomats came to South Korea recently," Thae said, according to Yonhap.

    • Massive Alligator Strolls Casually Past Florida Tourists

      Video shows the gator without a care in the world.

      Inside Edition
    • Pakistani mother sentenced to death for daughter's 'honour killing'

      A mother who murdered her own daughter and set her alight for marrying the man of her choice has been sentenced to death, officials said Tuesday, in a case that had revolted many in Pakistan. Zeenat Bibi, aged 16, was doused with kerosene and set alight in June last year in Pakistan's teeming cultural capital Lahore, a little over a week after she wed 20-year-old motorcycle mechanic Hasan Khan against her family's wishes. A judge in an anti-terror court in Lahore sentenced her mother Perveen Bibi to death on murder and terrorism charges, prosecutor Mian Mohammad Tufail told AFP.

    • Priyanka Chopra Thanks Fans for Their Support After Fall: ‘I Will Be OK’

      Priyanka Chopra‘s Quantico character has survived terrorist bombings, kidnappings, and some pretty intense battles on her hit ABC drama — and it looks like Chopra is just as tough! “Thank you for all your warm thoughts and well wishes,” she wrote.

    • Who's Winning The Trump vs. Lewis Feud Now?

      The spat between the congressman and president-elect has sent two of Rep. John Lewis' books to the top of Amazon's bestseller list.

      International Business Times