Tastiest frozen treats

Consumer Reports

Our tasters put to the test 21 fruit bars, ice cream bars and sandwiches.

View gallery

.

“Good Humor” may conjure happy memories of summer days when you were a kid. But that was then. Our latest tests of frozen treats found that the dark-chocolate Good Humor bars sold in stores have a thin, waxy, crumbly coating over ice cream with flavors of artificial vanilla and a hint of wooden stick.

Our trained tasters found a bunch of better options among 21 strawberry fruit bars, chocolate-covered ice cream bars, and ice cream sandwiches. See the Ratings, below.

Taste

The best have the flavors of real fruit, vanilla, or chocolate. The lower-rated have drawbacks such as artificial-tasting flavors and gummy or chalky texture.

Fruit bars: 365 Everyday Value (Whole Foods) is excellent, with large chunks of fruit and a big, fresh-strawberry flavor. Whole Fruit, Dreyer’s/Edy’s, and Blue Bell are very good, with a nice fruit flavor, though they’re slightly gummy.

More from
Consumer Reports:

Top-rated air conditioners

Gas grill buying guide

Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers or sponsors on Yahoo!

  Ice cream bars: Häagen-Dazs and Dove are rich, with strong dairy and vanilla tastes and a flavorful dark-chocolate coating. The Häagen-Dazs ice cream is especially dense; Dove has a thicker chocolate coating. The coating of Julie’s Organic has a cocoa note and is slightly chalky.

Ice cream sandwiches: Walgreens Old Fashioned is the only tested sandwich that doesn’t taste of artificial flavors or have a gummy texture. Its wafers are soft and cakelike, with a big cocoa flavor.

Nutrition.

The fruit bars have 70 to 110 calories and are fat-free. (FYI, ice pops we looked at—Popsicle Air Heads—have similar calories ounce for ounce but no fruit.) The sandwiches have 100 to 180 calories and about 1 to 6 grams of fat; the bars top out at 280 calories and 20 grams of fat. The treats have about 10 to 25 grams of sugars. Some sugars, including fructose and lactose (from fruit and milk), are naturally occurring; others are added and make for empty calories. The products with dietetic names—Skinny Cow and Weight Watchers—didn’t necessarily have fewer calories and scored lower than most.

Bottom Line.

Try one of the eight excellent or very good frozen treats. Ice cream bars generally cost slightly more than the other types. Some bars and sandwiches look bigger than others, but most weigh 2 to 3 ounces.

How did dairy-free fare?

So Delicious Dairy Free Vanilla Minis sandwiches aren’t so delicious. The innards (organic soy milk is the first ingredient) have a mild artificial-vanilla flavor, and the wafers are soft and sticky. Tofutti Dairy Free Cuties Vanilla sandwiches consist of gummy, artificially flavored innards (corn syrup solids, soy, and tofu) between sticky wafers that taste a little stale.

View gallery

.

 

Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Mom lets daughter's school know her 10-year-old is 'done' with homework

      Making tough calls for your children is a vital aspect of parenting. One brave mother stepped up to the parenting plate for her child, sharing an email she sent to her daughter's school explaining that her 10 year old is "done with homework" because of the undue stress it causes. SEE ALSO: Instead of telling women who might get pregnant they can't drink, study suggests trusting them Bunmi Laditan, a mom blogger in Quebec, explained on Facebook that she told her daughter's school that her child would be "drastically reducing" the homework she'd be completing, but that she "was trying to be polite because [her daughter is] finished." “I just sent an email to her school letting her know she’s all done,” the mother wrote. "Over the past four years I've noticed her getting more and more stressed when it comes to school," the troubled mother wrote, "And by stressed I mean chest pains, waking up early, and dreading school in general." Laditan explained that her daughter often does homework until 6:30 p.m., with little to no time to relax after dinner. “Is family time not important?” she wrote, “Is time spent just being a child relaxing at home not important? Or should she become some kind of junior workaholic at 10 years old?" “Children need downtime after school the same way adults need downtime after work. They need to play with their siblings," she continued. Laditan later commented on her own post to further explain her point of view. Image: bunmi laditan/facebookThe mother clarified that she wasn’t blaming her daughter’s "incredible" teachers, and that she simply feels the system isn’t working for her child. “I can’t watch her unravel anymore and be filled with so much stress at age 10,” she explained. Parents, teachers, and even therapists sounded off in the post's comment section in support of Laditan, relating similar experiences with children in their own lives. Image: kim tang/facebook Image: Katie chavarria/facebook Image: Erin avirett/facebook Image: jamie ellam davis/facebookSeems like this mom might be on to something. WATCH: This NYU student went undercover as a worker in a Chinese iPhone factory

      Mashable
    • ‘SportsCenter’ anchor agrees politics are hurting ESPN

      ESPN’s sweeping staff cuts are not just the result of ambitious TV rights deals and an overburdened budget, popular “SportsCenter” anchor Linda Cohn suggested Thursday. The network may be losing the subscriber revenue not just because of cord-cutting, Cohn allowed, but because viewers are increasingly turned off by ESPN inserting politics into its sports coverage. “That is definitely a percentage of it,” Cohn said Thursday on 77 WABC’s “Bernie and Sid” show when asked whether certain social or political stances contributed to the stupor that resulted in roughly 100 employees getting the ax this week. Cohn agreed with the argument that certain sports fans may have disapproved of the way ESPN covered polarizing figures such as Roger Goodell, Colin Kaepernick and Caitlyn Jenner.

      New York Post q
    • “I Think I’m Going to Hang It Up, LOL”: Aaron Hernandez Note to Prison Boyfriend

      Aaron Hernandez knew his prison boyfriend before either of them was locked up, says the attorney for that inmate.

      Newsweek
    • United Airlines has reached a settlement with the passenger who was dragged off a plane

      United Airlines has reached an out-of-court settlement with David Dao. According to Thomas...

      Business Insider
    • 'GMA' Deals and Steals on must-have Mother's Day gifts

      Tory Johnson is back with exclusive “Deals and Steals” on must-have products to celebrate Mother’s Day.  Score big savings on gifts the mother figure in your life will love, including jewelry, sunglasses and more. The must-have items are discounted by at least 50 percent for “GMA” viewers and start at just $2.50.

      Good Morning America
    • Nick Cannon Reveals Whether He's Sleeping With Ex-Wife Mariah Carey

      The former 'America's Got Talent' host also reveals the "most diva thing" he's ever seen the singer do.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • On his birthday, his 13-year-old sister hugged him. Then he shot her in the head

      On Martaevious Santiago’s 17th birthday, he shot his 13-year-old sister in the back of the head. She had just hugged him in the kitchen of the family’s Florida City home, police said. As they separated and Tedra King walked away, Martaevious pointed a loaded semiautomatic handgun at her. Then he pulled the trigger and killed her. Martaevious told police it was an accident. The shooting happened Tuesday night inside a modest Florida City subdivision called Washington Park. Outside the home on Wednesday, shocked family members — some on the way to identify the young girl’s body at the morgue — demanded privacy. “Everybody that knows a word of prayer, please pray for the Bess family,” close family

      Miami Herald q
    • Melania Trump’s American-Designed Military Suit

      First lady Melania Trump is supporting homegrown talent with her latest outfit. She chose to wear a khaki green, military-inspired suit by Altuzarra to meet with Argentina’s President Mauricio Macri and First Lady Juliana Awada. Altuzarra, which is designed by Joseph Altuzarra, is a top New York label, beloved for crisp tailoring and playful details. Previous FLOTUS Michelle Obama was also a fan of the brand. Here, Melania proves she has a keen eye for coordination, as she’s matched the snakeskin trim of the suit to the pattern of her pointy toe pumps. Just one day after her 47 birthday, FLOTUS used some creative styling tricks to complete this refined look, including the artfully rolled up sleeves

      The New York Observer q
    • The lawyer for the United passenger dragged off a plane is suddenly singing the airline's praises after settlement

      Thomas Demetrio, the attorney for the passenger who was dragged off a United flight...

      Business Insider
    • Man kicked off Delta Air Lines flight for needing to use the bathroom

      Kimi Hamilton was travelling from Atlanta to Milwaukee on a Delta Air Lines plane when he urgently needed to use the toilet as take-off proceedings were underway. In fellow passenger Krista Rosolino's view, Hamilton's removal from the April 18 flight was an outrage and so was everyone else's forced exit from the plane when it returned to the gate in Atlanta. The Delta Air Lines quick-take on this incident is that federal law requires passengers to comply with crew instructions or run the risk of being seen as a security threat.

      International Business Times
    • Mom Tells Teachers Her Daughter Is "Done" With Homework in Bold Email

      If you ever worried about why your child was coming home with hours upon hours of homework each night, Bunmi Laditan — the mom behind The Honest Toddler blog — can not only relate, but she can also serve as a reminder that you have the power to put a stop to it. "My kid is done with homework," she wrote in a heated Facebook post. "I just sent an email to her school letting her know she's all done. I said 'drastically reduce' but I was trying to be polite because she's finished." She noted how her 10-year-old daughter, Maya — who is in school from 8:15 a.m. to 4 p.m. and still has two to three hours of homework each evening — "loves learning" but has become more and more stressed by school. She's

      PopSugar q
    • Physician who was dragged off flight settles with United

      The passenger who was dragged off a United flight after he refused to give up his seat to airline employees settled with the airline for an undisclosed sum Thursday in an apparent attempt by the company ...

      Associated Press
    • David Dao, United Passenger Dragged Off Plane, Settles for Undisclosed Sum

      United Airlines and Dr. David Dao have reached a settlement agreement just weeks after he was dragged off of a flight, stirring up a national controversy over passenger rights. The settlement agreement dictated the payout amount was not to be made public. United has been plagued by an intense public backlash after video emerged showing a bloodied Dao being dragged of a flight by Chicago Department of Aviation officers in order to make room for airline employees.

      Newsweek
    • Warriors, Charles Barkley and Bob Ley pay tribute to fired ESPN workers

      Charles Barkley said he had worked closely with ESPN journalists down the years. After a tumultuous day at ESPN, in which the broadcaster laid off around 100 employees on Wednesday, including some of the network’s most popular on-air and online personalities, tributes were paid to those who lost their jobs. Perhaps the most striking came from the Golden State Warriors.

      The Guardian
    • 1-year-old girl found dead in her Joliet Township home

      A missing 1-year-old girl was found dead inside her home late Wednesday night in southwest suburban Joliet Township after a massive search.

      WLS – Chicago
    • 43 Amazing Things To Do With Crescent Rolls (29 photos)

      If you have one ingredient on hand at all times, it should totally be crescent rolls. Looking for more versatile ingredients? Try our next-level ways to use puff pastry . From Delish

      Delish
    • Kim Kardashian Trashes Caitlyn's Memoir

      "I wish her all the success in the world, but not at our expense."

      Cosmopolitan
    • Putin Warns North Korea Situation Has ‘Seriously Deteriorated’

      Russian President Vladimir Putin warned that the crisis over North Korea’s nuclear program is deepening after the issue dominated talks with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in Moscow.

      Bloomberg
    • Even Donald Trump's birthday tweet to Melania has a factual error it in

      Our Tweeter in Chief Donald Trump, is known for playing fast and loose with facts, but you'd think a birthday message to his wife would be a nice softball. He can garner a few awws and then move on.  Nope. SEE ALSO: The only Melania in the White House is this photograph On Wednesday, Melania Trump celebrated her birthday. And like most loved ones do on their spouse's birthday, Donald Trump took to Twitter to send his best wishes to his wife. HAPPY BIRTHDAY to our @FLOTUS, Melania! https://t.co/rYYp51mxDQ pic.twitter.com/np7KYHglSv — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) April 26, 2017 However, when it came to the graphics, there was a ball drop. Or a star drop, if you will. If you look closely you'll notice that the flag in that graphics package only has 39 stars, which leaves out quite a number of states.  And because nothing escapes the internet, Twitter definitely noticed. There are only 39 stars on that flag, sir. https://t.co/KATgoLIQUv — Dan Zak (@MrDanZak) April 27, 2017 This is so weird: The American flag on @FLOTUS Melania Trump's birthday card only has 39 stars. H/t: @eventsforgood pic.twitter.com/IYd2hdOXGJ — Christina Wilkie (@christinawilkie) April 27, 2017 Very weird. Since the 39 star flag was never official since we went from 38 to 42 states in 1890. https://t.co/TG5JWAPOA3 — MyNinjaTurtle (@MyNinjaTurtle) April 27, 2017 @chrislhayes Wonder which 11 states are slated for destruction? #39StarFlag pic.twitter.com/KKkIS1ElZB — kathy greenstone (@KathyGreenstone) April 27, 2017 To make matters even more worse, this is not the first time Donald Trump has shared the 39-star flag. As MSNBC's Chris Hayes pointed out, Donald Trump also shared the flag at the end of the video welcoming freed Egyptian American Aya Hijazi who was imprisoned in Cairo. @christinawilkie @FLOTUS @eventsforgood IT'S THE SAME FLAG IN THE END OF THIS VIDEO!!!! https://t.co/jZOSS7VjNh — Christopher Hayes (@chrislhayes) April 27, 2017 Someone in the WH graphics operation has a 39-star flag saved on their computer as the current flag and is using it everything! — Christopher Hayes (@chrislhayes) April 27, 2017 For reference, Mr. President, we've never actually had a 39-star flag in the history of the United States.  The design was actually created in 1889 when flag makers were anticipating the addition of the Dakotas to the United states. Flag makers incorrectly assumed that what we know as North Dakota and South Dakota would be admitted to the US as only one state, not two. The New York Times notes:  Long story short, flag makers jumped the gun, so now 39-star flag was never an official flag. They are now just collectors items. Note: there was never an official 39-star flag, but some folks thought there would be 39 states in 1889, so some flags were actually created — Brian Ruh (@brianruh) September 5, 2016 WE NEVER EVEN HAD A 39 STAR FLAG https://t.co/XpMS0LMd97 — SheriffFruitfly (@sherifffruitfly) April 27, 2017 Now, to be fair, this is probably just a graphic design mistake from the White House art department, not a comment on how many states Trump wishes we had. But the fact stands: The. President. Of. The. United. States. Tweeted. A. Fake. Flag. Happy Birthday, Melania!

      Mashable
    • Mom Declares Her Daughter Is Done With Homework In Viral Email

      Fed up with her 10-year-old daughter’s heavy homework load, a mom decided to do something about it.

      The Huffington Post