Taste test: Packaged macaroni and cheese

Epicurious
The Corrections : Jonathan Franzen (2001)

Who makes the best mac 'n' cheese? (Photo: iStockphoto)

To find the best mac 'n' cheese, our judges tasted 16 varieties—and found three that won Epicurious over.







The saying "Cheddar makes everything better!" is indeed correct. Adding it as a garnish to a veggie or a hot bowl of chili can be dish-changing; adding it to pasta makes the perfect meal: macaroni and cheese. While it's hard to beat homemade macaroni and cheese, on a hard day's night, a box of store-bought mac 'n' cheese can be a real time-saver and family-pleaser.

(See more: Taste test: All-beef hot dogs)

These days, packaged mac 'n' cheeses vary in many ways: They can be made on the stovetop, baked in an oven, or cooked in the microwave. Some are made with three or more cheeses, others even use soy. But we felt that this dish is loved by many because of its simplicity. For that reason, we narrowed our taste test selections into three categories: traditional, whole wheat, and white Cheddar, all packaged in boxed macaroni form and prepared on the stovetop. (We did not test any single-serving, frozen, or microwave-only options.)

The ultimate stovetop mac 'n' cheese should have pasta that is not mushy and does not swim in a pool of watery sauce, but is instead generously coated with Cheddar-cheesy, buttery goodness. The cheese should taste like cheese and shouldn't have overly sharp, sweet, or artificial flavors.

The 16 varieties of mac 'n' cheese we tasted are available nationwide and included the following, listed from highest to lowest score in our taste test: 365 Organic Shells & White Cheddar Cheese, Kraft Whole Grain Macaroni & Cheese Dinner, Kraft Macaroni & Cheese Dinner, Kraft Premium White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese, Annie's Creamy Deluxe Whole Wheat Shells & Extra Cheesy Cheddar Sauce, Velveeta Rotini and Cheese Whole Grain, 365 Organic Macaroni & Cheese, Annie's Homegrown Shells & White Cheddar,* Hodgson Mills Whole Wheat Macaroni & Cheese Dinner,* Simply Organic Macaroni & Cheese Dinner,* Annie's Homegrown Macaroni & Cheese,* Velveeta Original Shells and Cheese, Back to Nature Macaroni & Cheese Dinner, Pasta Roni Cheddar Macaroni,* Harvest Wheat Macaroni & Cheese Dinner,* Pasta Roni Shells & White Cheddar. (The brands marked with * received the same score.)

Methodology: In a blind taste test, five judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 16 boxes of packaged mac 'n' cheese (tubes, shells, or rotini). All options were prepared according to the stovetop directions on the packaging, using 1% milk and unsalted butter. (In several cases butter was not required and therefore not added.) We ranked them according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best). One winner within each category had us wishing every night was mac 'n' cheese night.



View gallery

.
365 Organic Shells and White Cheddar Cheese
Best Overall and Best White Cheddar

Winner: 365 Organic Shells and White Cheddar Cheese ($1.29 for 6 oz. box)

Pros: The editors noted how nicely the creamy, cheesy sauce clings to the shells. "It smells like buttery melted cheese, and the flavor is that of authentic Cheddar too!" stated one surprised judge. "Even though I was stuffed, I served myself twice!" admitted another.

Cons: Not ideal for those who prefer macaroni pasta rather than shells.




View gallery

.
Kraft Macaroni and Cheese
Best Traditional

Winner: Kraft Macaroni and Cheese (1.39 for 6 oz. box)

Pros: Many chose this as their favorite because it was not overly salty. "It was pleasantly buttery, without being too wet and soggy," noted one judge. "Creamy, comforting, and innocuous—exactly what one expects from a boxed mac 'n' cheese," declared another taster.

Cons: A virulent shade of yellow.




View gallery

.
Kraft Whole Grain Macaroni and Cheese
Best Whole Wheat

Winner: Kraft Whole Grain Macaroni and Cheese ($ 1.49 for 6 oz. box)

Pros: In addition to having an unexpectedly natural flavor (like homemade), the cheese sauce has a balanced, mild, and yet tangy taste. "Not too mushy, and the little pasta logs cling together, creating the perfect bite," noticed one judge.

Cons: Strangely sweet finish.

The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Pasta Roni Cheddar Macaroni was one of the least favored due to its un-cheesiness. One editor said it best: "There's no cheese taste at all! But if you like buttery milk, then this might be your choice."

Judges were surprised to find out that Harvest Wheat Macaroni & Cheese is marketed as being artificial flavor- and preservative-free. "Not only does the cheese taste fake and sweet, but the sauce does not coat the pasta like it should," said one tester.

Pasta Roni Shells & White Cheddar received zero forks from four out of the five judges. "Sauce looks like glue!" stated one judge. "A little pasty, and it tastes like chicken," declared another.

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Investigator Believes Sex Trafficking Could Be Motive Behind Sherri Papini Kidnapping Case

      A private investigator and veteran human trafficking expert believes California mom Sherri Papini‘s case has the hallmarks of sex trafficking.

      People
    • J.J. Watt accidentally outs relationship in Christmas photo

      A picture is worth a thousand words, or in J.J. Watt’s case, a stocking. After putting the finishing touches on his holiday decor Thursday, the NFL star gave fans a glimpse of his Christmas cheer via Snapchat. But Watt may have slipped up by displaying — tucked away in the background, as Terez Owens was first to point out — a second stocking marked with a “K” for stunning soccer-playing girlfriend Kealia Ohai. Watt has yet to address the relationship publicly, though Ohai — the sister-in-law of Texans teammate Brian Cushing — talked about the pair in October. “The rumors are true. We are dating,” Ohai confirmed on the 2 Up Front podcast. “I’ve known J.J. for a really long time, and we’ve always

      New York Post q
    • Trump's Carrier speech 'absolutely chilling,' economic analyst says

      Economic policy analyst Jimmy Pethokoukis called Donald Trump's Carrier speech the worst economic speech buy a politician in decades.

      CNBC
    • Man who police say killed Joe McKnight released without being charged

      The NFL world was shocked to hear news Thursday that former New York Jets and Kansas City Chiefs running back Joe McKnight was shot and killed in New Orleans. There was more shock on Friday with news that the man authorities say shot McKnight was released without being charged. The New Orleans Times-Picayune and Baton Rouge Advocate said Ronald Gasser, 54, who authorities say shot McKnight, was released overnight without being charged “as of yet,” a Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office spokesman said.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Inside Edition
    • Mummified Body In Woman's Attic Believed To Be Missing Grandson

      A Pennsylvania woman made a disturbing discovery on Wednesday when she found a badly decomposed body in the attic of her home. Authorities suspect it’s her grandson, who disappeared two years ago. Zanobia Richmond, 65, heard something fall in the upstairs of her Erie home Wednesday afternoon, according to Erie’s WICU 12 News. When she went to investigate, she was shocked to discover a badly decomposed body had fallen against her attic door. Erie County Coroner Lyell Cook is now working to confirm the identity of the body, but told The Erie Times-News officials are confident the body is Richmond’s missing grandson, Dyquain Rogers. “That is where he lived,” Cook said. Authorities will use dental

      The Huffington Post q
    • This baby with amazing hair is going to make your day.

      LONDON — Remember Baby Bear, the Irish tot with a glorious mane of luscious locks?   Well, there's a new hairy child in town.  Her name is Alexandra and, at just 2-months-old, she has a head of hair that is sure to win the internet's heart like the bouffanted babes that have come before her.  SEE ALSO: A very big-haired baby interrupts live Kim Kardashian TV report Reddit user brngrhm84 uploaded this image of his baby girl, and it has since gone viral because HOLY COW that's a lot of hair: As a bald man, I'm very proud of my 2 month old's hair from aww Let the photoshop battles begin. BONUS: Baby falling off table caught by lightning quick 9-year-old brother

      Mashable q
    • Sasha Obama’s $695 Christmas-Tree-Lighting Coat Just Made It to the Top of Our Wish Lists

      The Obamas had their final Christmas-tree lighting on the Ellipse in President’s Park last night, and of course, the first family showed up in style. While they all looked great, with Barack keeping it simple with a long, black coat, a suit, and a burgundy scarf, and Michelle wearing a black coat with a metallic pattern on the front, we were particularly digging Sasha’s outerwear — a faux-fur deep navy blue Opening Ceremony coat.

      Yahoo Style
    • Officials: Bodies of Missing Mother, Daughter Found in Well

      North Carolina authorities say bodies of mother, teen-age daughter found in a well, three days after they were reported missing

      ABC News q
    • Ravenous 14-Foot Python Caught with 3 Deer in Its Gut

      A Burmese python in the Everglades with a penchant for venison gulped down three whole deer — one doe and two fawns — before wildlife officials captured and euthanized it, a new study reveals. The gustatory feat sets a record: It's the first invasive Burmese python (Python molurus bivittatus) caught with three deer in its gut, said study co-lead author Scott Boback, an associate professor of biology at Dickinson College in Pennsylvania. The python probably attacked and ate the deer at different times over a 90-day period, Boback said.

      LiveScience.com
    • The 69 Most Delish Fall Soups (71 photos)

      These easy autumn soup recipes will warm you up. From Delish

      Delish
    • 'Romney disgusts me' for the way he's now cozying up to Trump, billionaire Ken Langone says

      "Where's the self-respect?" asked GOP supporter Ken Langone, adding Mitt Romney should be "ashamed" of courting the president-elect for the State post.

      CNBC
    • Couple charged in ‘worst’ child neglect case ever seen

      Once a week, the five children under 18 and their parents would go to a family member’s house to shower and wash clothes, as their own house didn’t have running water. “The conditions in this home were the worst I’ve ever seen,” said Sarasota Police detective Megan Buck in a press release. The Sarasota Police Department arrested a Sarasota couple and charged them each with five counts of child neglect without great bodily harm, according to the department. On Monday, officers went to the home of Amanda L. Dean and Joseph P. Dromeshauser, III, both 34, in the 1300 block of 18th Street for a welfare check after a school resource officer contacted the police department, according to a probable cause affidavit.

      Miami Herald q
    • Jadeveon Clowney looks like a child wearing Vince Wilfork's jersey

      Players and coaches have to find ways to keep things fun, and the Houston Texans seem to have a good grip on that idea. Texans players decided to switch jerseys at practice Friday, and no swap was better than the one between Vince Wilfork and Jadeveon Clowney. A few Texans players switched jerseys at practice today, but the Vince Wilfork and Jadeveon Clowney swap is probably the best.

      SB Nation q
    • My Father Married a Woman Who's the Opposite of Everything He Raised Me to Be

      When I first met Cristina, my father’s Italian girlfriend, she worked at the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization headquarters in Rome. Dad worked there too, calculating budgets for international relief projects. Cristina worked in personnel and interacted with people from all over ...

      xoJane
    • Trump voter has buyer’s remorse after Steve Mnuchin picked for treasury secretary

      Teena Colebrook purchased a triplex in Hawthorne, Calif., in 1998. Now her home is one of 36,000 foreclosures by OneWest, a bank that became known as “a foreclosure machine.” Donald Trump’s pick for treasury secretary, Steve Mnuchin, headed an investment group that formerly owned that bank, and Colebrook holds Mnuchin responsible for her foreclosure.

      Yahoo News Video
    • Pennsylvania Teen Allegedly Fatally Shoots Sleeping Mom and Brother, Tries to Blame Father

      A 14-year-old boy was arrested Wednesday and charged with allegedly fatally shooting his mother and little brother while they slept, say Pennsylvania state police. Jacob Remaley of New Stanton, Pennsylvania, has been charged as an adult with two counts of criminal homicide and two counts of first-degree murder, according to court documents obtained by PEOPLE.

      People
    • Seventeen
    • Crossover Fallout: Where ‘Arrow,’ ‘The Flash,’ ‘Supergirl,’ ‘Legends’ Go From Here

      Showrunners Andrew Kreisberg and Marc Guggenheim discussed how each show moves forward in the wake of all the revelations and events that unfolded this week. “Supergirl” was mostly disconnected from the crossover, so it will continue to play out its own storylines, but the team-up did conveniently give Kara (Melissa Benoist) — courtesy of Cisco (Carlos Valdes) — a device that will make inter-universe travel between her Earth and the Earth of the rest of The CW shows as easy as pushing a button. Bonus: the Dominators will return to “Supergirl” later this season, so the rest of the cast may get their chance to meet them after missing out this time around.

      The Wrap