Taste test: Mustard

Mustard taste test

Mustard taste test (Photo: Thinkstock)

Epicurious sampled 19 brands and discovered 3 that really cut the mustard.

Mustard, that splendid complement to soft pretzels, hot dogs, and salad dressings, has an extensive repertoire. One of the oldest spices in the world, it's also one of the most widely consumed. According to the Encyclopedia of Spices, the ancient Chinese, Greeks, and Romans used it, and France's King Louis XI loved it so much that he is said to have carried a pot of the golden goodness with him throughout his travels, in case he found himself in a mustard-free zone.

Mustard is a condiment to be reckoned with. Its storied reputation has much to do with its ability to improve the taste of sandwiches, potato salads, glazes, and meats. Even umami-rich ketchup needs a little dry mustard to make it great. (Seriously, it's often a homemade ketchup ingredient.)

Before mustard can do its magic, the sauce itself needs to be top-notch. That's where we chime in. Mustard varieties are endless. There are beer mustards, fruit mustards, and whole-grain mustards. For our taste test, we opted to stick to the basics: yellow and honey mustards. Read below to see which ones are welcome at our next grilling session.

Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
Best Mustard Overall
Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
($3.35 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "It's got everything I would want in a mustard. It's savory, bold, and it doesn't look like a yellow school bus." Judges appreciated that this mustard had a natural appearance and a flavor that held its own.

Cons: Some found it to be salty.

Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard
First Runner-Up, Yellow Mustard
Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard

($1.69 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "The ideal mustard!" exclaimed one judge. "It's not too much of anything—not too vinegary, salty, or sweet. Just right!" Judges also enjoyed its smooth consistency.

Cons: The color seems a somewhat more artificial yellow than the others.

(See more: Taste test: All-beef hot dogs)

Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
First Runner-Up, Honey Mustard
Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
($2.55 per 10.5-ounce bottle)

Pros: One judge described Bookbinder's as "delicately sweet, a nice blend." Another taster proclaimed it "hands down the best honey mustard I've ever had!"

Cons: Not the most appealing color.

The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Not only is Colman's Mustard an extreme yellow, but it's too spicy and tart, and has an alarming aftertaste. Visually, Eden Organic Yellow Mustard looks a lot like pâté. All the judges were turned off by its mealy texture and acidic flavor. Lastly, 365 Organic Yellow Mustard looks more like a mousse than mustard. And one editor pointed out that it's "hazardously sour."

Additional Taste Test Details

All 19 varieties of mustard evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Nathan's Deli-Style, Bookbinder's Honey, Gold's Honey, Gulden's Yellow Squeeze, French's Classic Yellow, Organicville Yellow, Plochman's Yellow, Annie's Organic Honey, Billy Bee Original Yellow, Thumann's Real Honey, Hellmann's Honey, Annie's Organic Yellow, Billy Bee Original Honey, Emeril's Smooth Honey, Inglehoffer Honey, Woeber's Honey, Colman's, Eden Organic Yellow, 365 Organic Yellow.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 19 types of mustard (ten yellow and nine honey). All were squirted on hot dogs. Mustards were ranked according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Charlize Theron: I Am Very Fat Right Now

      "When I went home to speak at the opening of the International AIDS conference [in July], I stood in front of an audience of thousands and made a plea to end the deadly stigma and discrimination that puts the burden of AIDS on the world's most vulnerable people," Theron said. "I argued that we should focus on the ones that are hardest to reach, the poor, young people, women, girls, gay and transgender people—the people bearing the brunt of the epidemic. "It wasn't long after I gave this speech talking about how we couldn't forget the most vulnerable among us that I realized I had forgotten someone," she continued. "I had forgotten to mention sex workers, some of the most stigmatized people in

      E! Online q
    • Kelly Clarkson Reveals the One 'American Idol' Competitor That Could Have Beat Her

      The 34-year-old singer makes an admission to Harry Connick Jr.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Woman Accidentally 'Steals' Subaru, Brings it Back With Apology Note and Gas Money

      Oops. 'Sorry I stole your car,' read the note inside Erin Hatzi's Subaru.

      Inside Edition
    • The Sixers Fan Who Flipped Off Russell Westbrook Is A Doctor Who Claims He Was Provoked

      Immediately after this happened, everyone wanted to know this dude’s identity (and, if you’re Jeff Van Gundy, why Westbrook wasn’t allowed to go into the stands and beat the hell out of him). As it turns out, Philly.com learned that this Sixers fan is named Richard Harkaway, and when he’s not trying to get a rise out of All-NBA guards, he’s a urologist in Philadelphia. In this instance, after standing up to boo and being provoked by Russell Westbrook calling attention to my being overweight, my action in response was clearly inexcusable and I am embarrassed.

    • This photo of a dog with a mouthful of ladybugs is freaking out pet owners

      The photo that Kansas veterinarian Lindsay Mitchell posted to Facebook looked so unreal and disturbing that some who saw it went right to the hoax-busting website Snopes to verify it. But that didn’t stop the photo from being shared more than 53,000 times since it went up last week. Mitchell, of Hoisington, Kan., posted a graphic picture of a dog with a mouthful of Asian lady beetles. Ladybugs aren’t so cute when 30 to 40 of them are stuck to the roof of a dog’s mouth. “This is the second pup I have seen like this today. If your pet is drooling or foaming at the mouth look for these lady bugs. They cause ulcers on the tongue and mouth and have a very painful bite,” she wrote on the Hoisington

      The Charlotte Observer q
    • VIDEO: Man pistol whips scary clown prankster in California

      A video showing a man dressed as a clown scaring random people in Northern California has gone viral after one man pistol whipped the prankster.

      KABC – Los Angeles
    • Dear Abby: Daughter, 5 kids abruptly move in

      DEAR ABBY: I have been with my wife for 16 years. She has a grown daughter who’s the mother of eight kids, but she only has five with her at this time. My problem is, the daughter got evicted, and all of a sudden she brought her belongings to the house. She didn’t ask or anything, she just showed up with the five kids and they are driving me up the wall. I already have two adolescent kids, so seven ain’t heaven. I have tried to talk with my wife, but she doesn’t listen. I’m fed up, Abby, and I’m looking for other accommodations. They have been here for two weeks and — by the way — my sons are now in school while her five are running wild in the house. Am I wrong for leaving? — NEEDS MY OWN SPACE

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • Cancer From Chemicals? 3 Household Products That Are Known Carcinogens

      These cancer-causing agents are most likely in your home and used almost everyday. Here are the carcinogenic products to avoid.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • Queen Elizabeth II Went Inside a Grocery Store and Her Reaction Is Priceless

      Queen Elizabeth II visited a grocery store in Poundbury, England on Thursday, and no one seemed more surprised by the trip than the Queen herself.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Fore Twenty Golf Tournament: Behind the Scenes (11 photos)

      The Fore Twenty Golf Tournament is like a corporate outing with a vibe about as corporate as a caddie shack. Its field of 128 is composed of a motley cast of characters who spend more time in head shops than pro shops.

    • Bus driver dies after being set on fire

      'Open the back door' The passengers managed to escape the bus through a rear door, assisted by a taxi driver who saw the incident. "I was walking to the bus stop, trying to get to the taxi rank when I saw a bus pull in," the taxi driver, named as Aguek Nyok, told CNN affiliate 7 News. "When I looked at the back door, people were lining up trying to get out, but they can't. "The only thing I can hear is 'open the back door, open the back door.'" No evidence of terror links The motive for the attack was unclear, Stewart said, but added that there was no evidence that there were terror links, or any racial motive involved. Six people were treated at a hospital for smoke inhalation. Police Superintendent

      CNN q
    • Vince McMahon on selling WWE: 'We're open to anything'

      Vince McMahon has said that he would entertain offers for the sale of WWE. Since its inception in 1948, the wrestling entertainment company has largely remained a family-controlled enterprise. When the WWE chairman was asked if he was willing to sell the business to a large conglomerate in the near future during an earnings call on Thursday, he said: "We're open to anything".

      International Business Times UK q
    • Van Noy: 'I was shocked" to be traded from Lions to Patriots

      It's no wonder linebacker Kyle Van Noy, who started in all seven Lions games this season, reacted the way he did when he was dealt to the Patriots earlier this week. "I was shocked to go from starting there to traded," Van Noy said during his first back-and-forth with Patriots reporters.

      Comcast SportsNet New England q
    • James Packer Is ‘Definitely Not Getting Back Together’ with Mariah Carey as Their Split Turns Ugly: Source

      Mariah Carey and James Packer‘s breakup is turning into a battle of he-said she-said.

    • Trump says he won’t promise to work with Hillary Clinton if she becomes president, and we’re hmmm-ing over here

      This election has been the messiest we’ve ever seen, and arguably the messiest ever, period. On top of everything, Trump says he won’t commit…

      Hello Giggles
    • That Was Fast! The Walking Dead’s Steven Yeun Got a New Gig

      On Thursday, The Walking Dead’s beloved star stopped by Conan to discuss Sunday’s heartbreaking episode following his character’s brutal murder, and Yeun revealed that he already snagged a fun new gig. “Yeah, it’s me,” Yeun admitted. The best part in the montage came when a special red head appeared alongside Yeun — The Walking Dead‘s second victim, Michael Cudlitz.

    • 8 Types of Unflattering Clothes That Can Make You Look 10 Pounds Heavier

      You may not be able to lose weight overnight, but you can be sure not to pack on any additional pounds by staying away from these unflattering clothes.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • Entertainment Tonight
    • Amazon's $99 Prime problem

      The e-tailer's weaker earnings highlight the dilemma it faces with a capped $99 annual fee. But it's looking to boost subscriptions elsewhere.

      CNET q