Taste test: Mustard

Epicurious
Mustard taste test

Mustard taste test (Photo: Thinkstock)

Epicurious sampled 19 brands and discovered 3 that really cut the mustard.







Mustard, that splendid complement to soft pretzels, hot dogs, and salad dressings, has an extensive repertoire. One of the oldest spices in the world, it's also one of the most widely consumed. According to the Encyclopedia of Spices, the ancient Chinese, Greeks, and Romans used it, and France's King Louis XI loved it so much that he is said to have carried a pot of the golden goodness with him throughout his travels, in case he found himself in a mustard-free zone.

Mustard is a condiment to be reckoned with. Its storied reputation has much to do with its ability to improve the taste of sandwiches, potato salads, glazes, and meats. Even umami-rich ketchup needs a little dry mustard to make it great. (Seriously, it's often a homemade ketchup ingredient.)

Before mustard can do its magic, the sauce itself needs to be top-notch. That's where we chime in. Mustard varieties are endless. There are beer mustards, fruit mustards, and whole-grain mustards. For our taste test, we opted to stick to the basics: yellow and honey mustards. Read below to see which ones are welcome at our next grilling session.


Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
Best Mustard Overall
Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
($3.35 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "It's got everything I would want in a mustard. It's savory, bold, and it doesn't look like a yellow school bus." Judges appreciated that this mustard had a natural appearance and a flavor that held its own.

Cons: Some found it to be salty.





Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard
First Runner-Up, Yellow Mustard
Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard

($1.69 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "The ideal mustard!" exclaimed one judge. "It's not too much of anything—not too vinegary, salty, or sweet. Just right!" Judges also enjoyed its smooth consistency.

Cons: The color seems a somewhat more artificial yellow than the others.

(See more: Taste test: All-beef hot dogs)



Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
First Runner-Up, Honey Mustard
Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
($2.55 per 10.5-ounce bottle)

Pros: One judge described Bookbinder's as "delicately sweet, a nice blend." Another taster proclaimed it "hands down the best honey mustard I've ever had!"

Cons: Not the most appealing color.



The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Not only is Colman's Mustard an extreme yellow, but it's too spicy and tart, and has an alarming aftertaste. Visually, Eden Organic Yellow Mustard looks a lot like pâté. All the judges were turned off by its mealy texture and acidic flavor. Lastly, 365 Organic Yellow Mustard looks more like a mousse than mustard. And one editor pointed out that it's "hazardously sour."

Additional Taste Test Details

All 19 varieties of mustard evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Nathan's Deli-Style, Bookbinder's Honey, Gold's Honey, Gulden's Yellow Squeeze, French's Classic Yellow, Organicville Yellow, Plochman's Yellow, Annie's Organic Honey, Billy Bee Original Yellow, Thumann's Real Honey, Hellmann's Honey, Annie's Organic Yellow, Billy Bee Original Honey, Emeril's Smooth Honey, Inglehoffer Honey, Woeber's Honey, Colman's, Eden Organic Yellow, 365 Organic Yellow.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 19 types of mustard (ten yellow and nine honey). All were squirted on hot dogs. Mustards were ranked according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • This baby wombat thinks it’s a dog and we don’t have the heart to tell him otherwise

      Marsupials can be so dang cute, like this baby wombat that thinks it’s a dog. We’re no experts on wombat behavior, but…

      Hello Giggles
    • Grandmother Finds the Mummified Body of Her Missing Grandson in the Attic 2-Years After He Was Reported Missing | B. Scott

      21-year-old Dyquain Rogers was reported missing on November 1st, 2014. On Wednesday, a mummified body believed to be the young man’s was found in the attic of his grandmother’s home. Investigators believe he committed suicide. via NY Daily News: Relatives of Dyquain Rogers are demanding a complete autopsy after the coroner said the death was likely a suicide, according to GoErie.com. “I don’t believe any of this stuff,” aunt Erica Jeffries-Jordan told the news website. “I want answers.” Rogers was last seen in the same house where he was found, which is also where he lived, Erie County Coroner Lyell Cook told the news website. Rogers was reported missing on Nov. 4, 2014. The body was in the Erie

      B. Scott | lovebscott.com q
    • China Lodges Diplomatic Protest After Trump's Call With Taiwan's President

      China has lodged "solemn representations" with the United States over a phone conversation Friday between President-elect Donald Trump and the president of Taiwan, the Chinese foreign ministry said. Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Geng Shuang told reporters in Beijing that China urged the relevant parties in the United States to handle Taiwan-related issues "cautiously and properly" to avoid "unnecessary interference" in the China-U.S. relationship. "There is only one China in the world, and Taiwan is an inseparable part of Chinese territory,” Shuang said.

      Good Morning America
    • Texas woman shoots, kills husband during struggle

      A man is dead, apparently shot to death by his wife during a struggle, according to the Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office.

      KABC – Los Angeles
    • Inside the Alleged Abduction of California Mom Sherri Papini

      Keith Papini details what happened before his wife was found alive.

      ABC News q
    • Fatal warehouse fire in Oakland (25 photos)

      Up to 40 people were feared dead in a huge fire that tore through a rave party held in a warehouse near San Francisco, authorities said, warning that the initial death toll of nine would likely rise once crews swept the stricken building. Oakland Fire Chief Teresa Deloach Reed said most of those who perished in the blaze that started about 11:30 pm (0730 GMT) Friday were thought to have died on the upper floor of the two-story warehouse known as Oakland Ghostship. “It must have been a very fast-moving fire,” she told reporters. It was not immediately known what sparked the inferno at the electronic dance music party attended by an estimated 50 to 100 people. By mid-day Saturday, fire crews had not yet been able to fully sweep the scene and officials braced for more casualties once rescuers entered the building. (AFP) See more news-related photo galleries and follow us on Yahoo News Photo Tumblr.

      Yahoo News Photo Staff 45 min ago
    • In ultra liberal Key West, a Trump supporter answers his critics with an obscene letter

      Joni Bernstein says she just couldn’t take it anymore. Bernstein, a Hillary Clinton supporter and activist who attended the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia and marched with Black Lives Matter, said she had to confront the owner of the large Trump/Pence campaign sign planted outside a scooter shop on the city’s main artery, North Roosevelt Boulevard. “It felt like a kick in the stomach,” said Bernstein, 52, a massage therapist and 20-year resident of the island. “I have no regrets of speaking out and trying to let someone know we are the walking wounded around here and to show us a little respect.” So she tried to reach Alvin Crockett of Florida Keys Cycles, 2222 N. Roosevelt Blvd.,

      Miami Herald q
    • McGregor directs expletive-laced tirade towards Mayweather: I'll knock him out

      UFC lightweight champion Conor McGregor had stern words for Floyd Mayweather Jr and Paulie Malignaggi as a move to boxing nears fruition.

      Sporting News
    • Woman Who Ate ‘Carbs All Day Every Day’ Drops 100 Lbs. After Eliminating Bread from Her Diet

      Kristina Guice had always been “the fat kid in school,” she says, so when the Tucson, Arizona, native got accepted to graduate school across the country in Long Island, New York, she decided this was her opportunity to make a change. Guice, 25, had recently lost a close friend — who had also been her weight loss inspiration — and got accepted to graduate school just two weeks later.

      People
    • New Fake Amazon Email Scam Is Incredibly Easy to Fall For

      Have you ordered anything from Amazon in the past couple of weeks? Are you planning to in the next couple? If either is true, you might easily be victimized by a real-looking email, supposedly from Amazon, explaining that there's a problem with your order and asking you to re-enter some information. Whatever you do, don't comply. Both Amazon Prime members and non-members are reporting receipt of a very legit-looking email with the subject line, "Your Amazon.com order cannot be shipped." It begins: Hello, There was a problem processing your order. You will not be able to access your account or place orders with us until we confirm your information. Click here to confirm your account. It goes on

      Inc Magazine q
    • Batman V Superman: Zack Snyder Reveals New Look At Knightmare Suit

      Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice was a jumpstart for the DC Extended Universe, running on from the fairly standalone Man of Steel into a massive wider world to rival Marvel’s. As a results, along with introducing Batman, Wonder Woman and Lex Luthor, it was full with loads of easter eggs and hints at what to come, ranging from the subtle (Robin’s suit in the Batcave, pointing towards an Under the Hood adaptation) to the painfully obvious (Diana Prince opening up Quicktime files of the metahumans). The most pointed pieces of foreshadowing was the Knightmare sequence: during his quest to crack Lex Luthor’s drive, Bruce Wayne (Ben Affleck) was subjected to a dream/vision/time travel journey (take

      Screen Rant q
    • This dog waits for his human to get off the school bus everyday even though she’s been away at college for months — just more proof that dogs are too good for us

      Carly Dunn left for college months ago – but her dog still hasn’t stopped waiting for her to get off the school bus…

      Hello Giggles
    • New details emerge in Joe McKnight shooting and release of shooter

      After hearing criticisms of his office for releasing the man who admitted to shooting former NFL running back Joe McKnight, Jefferson Parish Sheriff Newell Normand held a press conference to reveal some details of the case, including that the man who shot McKnight was in his car when he fired all three shots. McKnight was shot and killed on Thursday afternoon in New Orleans. Authorities said that Ronald Gasser, 54, shot McKnight.

      Shutdown Corner
    • The real message behind the Carrier deal isn’t those 800 jobs

      Embedded in this Indiana deal is a much stronger signal about the urgency of the Trump-Pence economic policies that the skeptics overlook, writes Michael J. Hicks.

      MarketWatch q
    • 5 Reasons Why a Woman Falls Out of Love

      Has the lady in your life lost that loving feeling? Here's why.

      The Cheat Sheet q 29 min ago
    • Inside Edition
    • 50 Cent on Kanye West’s Breakdown: ‘You Could See That Coming’

      While many found Kanye West‘s breakdown and hospitalization shocking, fellow rapper 50 Cent says he actually wasn’t too surprised. “That was interesting because I kind of felt like you could see that coming,” 50 Cent said on the topic during a Watch What Happens Live appearance, Thursday. 50 Cent, 41, appeared on the New York City-filmed Bravo talk show with actress Leah Remini.

      People
    • Chrissy Metz on Her This Is Us Character’s Impending Weight Loss: ‘It Wasn’t Mandated in the Contract’

      Chrissy Metz wants to clarify that her This Is Us contract does not say she has to lose weight. The 37-year-old actress had previously revealed to PEOPLE that she would have to go on the same weight loss journey as her character Kate does on the show. While her character Kate decided to get gastric bypass surgery on the show, Metz was clear that the weight loss isn’t mandated and that she doesn’t have to get to a particular size.

      People
    • 10 Best Things to Buy at Dollar Stores for the Holidays (and 1 Big Thing to Avoid)

      Thrifty holiday shoppers know where to go to save on seasonal necessities: the dollar store. The everything-is-a-buck-or-so retailers fit the bill for a wide array of must-have items for holiday entertaining and gift giving.

      Kiplinger.com q
    • This is No. 1 financial regret of older Americans

      The most significant money regrets that Americans have.

      MarketWatch q