Taste test: Mustard

Epicurious
Mustard taste test

Mustard taste test (Photo: Thinkstock)

Epicurious sampled 19 brands and discovered 3 that really cut the mustard.







Mustard, that splendid complement to soft pretzels, hot dogs, and salad dressings, has an extensive repertoire. One of the oldest spices in the world, it's also one of the most widely consumed. According to the Encyclopedia of Spices, the ancient Chinese, Greeks, and Romans used it, and France's King Louis XI loved it so much that he is said to have carried a pot of the golden goodness with him throughout his travels, in case he found himself in a mustard-free zone.

Mustard is a condiment to be reckoned with. Its storied reputation has much to do with its ability to improve the taste of sandwiches, potato salads, glazes, and meats. Even umami-rich ketchup needs a little dry mustard to make it great. (Seriously, it's often a homemade ketchup ingredient.)

Before mustard can do its magic, the sauce itself needs to be top-notch. That's where we chime in. Mustard varieties are endless. There are beer mustards, fruit mustards, and whole-grain mustards. For our taste test, we opted to stick to the basics: yellow and honey mustards. Read below to see which ones are welcome at our next grilling session.


Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
Best Mustard Overall
Nathan's Deli-Style Mustard
($3.35 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "It's got everything I would want in a mustard. It's savory, bold, and it doesn't look like a yellow school bus." Judges appreciated that this mustard had a natural appearance and a flavor that held its own.

Cons: Some found it to be salty.





Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard
First Runner-Up, Yellow Mustard
Gulden's Yellow Squeeze Mustard

($1.69 per 12-ounce bottle)

Pros: "The ideal mustard!" exclaimed one judge. "It's not too much of anything—not too vinegary, salty, or sweet. Just right!" Judges also enjoyed its smooth consistency.

Cons: The color seems a somewhat more artificial yellow than the others.

(See more: Taste test: All-beef hot dogs)



Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
First Runner-Up, Honey Mustard
Bookbinder's Honey Mustard
($2.55 per 10.5-ounce bottle)

Pros: One judge described Bookbinder's as "delicately sweet, a nice blend." Another taster proclaimed it "hands down the best honey mustard I've ever had!"

Cons: Not the most appealing color.



The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Not only is Colman's Mustard an extreme yellow, but it's too spicy and tart, and has an alarming aftertaste. Visually, Eden Organic Yellow Mustard looks a lot like pâté. All the judges were turned off by its mealy texture and acidic flavor. Lastly, 365 Organic Yellow Mustard looks more like a mousse than mustard. And one editor pointed out that it's "hazardously sour."

Additional Taste Test Details

All 19 varieties of mustard evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Nathan's Deli-Style, Bookbinder's Honey, Gold's Honey, Gulden's Yellow Squeeze, French's Classic Yellow, Organicville Yellow, Plochman's Yellow, Annie's Organic Honey, Billy Bee Original Yellow, Thumann's Real Honey, Hellmann's Honey, Annie's Organic Yellow, Billy Bee Original Honey, Emeril's Smooth Honey, Inglehoffer Honey, Woeber's Honey, Colman's, Eden Organic Yellow, 365 Organic Yellow.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 19 types of mustard (ten yellow and nine honey). All were squirted on hot dogs. Mustards were ranked according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Under Armour Just Released $300 Sneakers That May Be Its Coolest Looking Ones Ever

      Don't even try to knock this one from Under Armour, sneaker heads.

      TheStreet.com q
    • Dear Abby: Family thinks ill husband is faking it

      DEAR ABBY: My husband has been sick and unable to work for several years due to a debilitating illness. He has been home taking care of the kids while I have been working full time. We have lost everything because of the financial burden of his illness. I am very grateful to my parents for helping us financially during this tough time. Unfortunately, I believe some of my family think my husband is faking his illness. This is hurtful since they have known him for a long time (we’ve been married 12 years). My sister recently asked him in a rather nasty way why he doesn’t just go get a job, and I’m beginning to think that my parents share her sentiment. He already feels guilty and worthless for

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • Cosmo
    • Dog owner fatally mauled by Staffordshire bull terrier while he was being 'interviewed for BBC documentary'

      A dog owner mauled to death by his Staffordshire bull terrier was allegedly being interviewed by the BBC when the horrific attack took place. The man’s cause of death was recorded as hypovolemic shock and damage to the airway – with the injuries said to be consistent with a dog bite. The dog remains in secure kennels after being seized by police – who have since confirmed that the animal is not prohibited under the Dangerous Dogs Act.

      Yahoo News UK
    • 12 Things to Know About Jared Kushner (13 photos)

      Donald J. Trump's son-in-law will head up a new White House Office with a broad mandate to bring private sector methods and approaches to the government. From Town & Country

      Town & Country
    • Guilty German Shepherd can't hide shame

      You be the judge: Is Shadow the German Shepherd guilty or not? The evidence is a bit overwhelming...

      Rumble
    • Gordon Ramsay Reveals the 1 Place You Should Never Eat

      Sure, Gordon Ramsay has high standards, but is there really anything he would never eat? Turns out it's more of a place where he would never eat rather than one specific food — and that's on a plane. In an interview with Refinery29, Gordon revealed his feelings about airplane food and why those feelings might be justified. "There's no f*cking way I eat on planes," he said. "I worked for airlines for 10 years, so I know where this food's been and where it goes, and how long it took before it got on board." Yikes. The man has a point — there's no denying that airplane food is not the best. So what's a traveler to do to avoid midflight hunger, according to the world-renowned chef? If you're like

      PopSugar q
    • 2017 NFL mock draft: Blockbuster trade not the only top-5 shocker

      The most fun mock drafts are the ones that veer away from conventional wisdom, especially when projecting big trades early in the first round. If you’re a fan of such things, the latest 2017 NFL mock draft from NFL.com’s Lance Zierlein should grab your attention. The surprises start early in this one, as Zierlein has the Carolina Panthers trading up six spots to No. 2 overall. The target? Stanford edge defender Solomon Thomas: The Panthers have an additional second-round pick that helps facilitate a move up to target a versatile pass rusher who can be moved up and down the defensive line in rush situations. Carolina could certainly use a disruptive presence like Thomas on the edge, but in this

      The Draft Wire q
    • Woman Survives Vicious Attack by Her Husband

      The following material contains graphic images that may be disturbing. Parents are advised that these images may not be suitable for young children.

      The Doctors TV
    • 'Survivor: Game Changers' Host Jeff Probst Weighs In on Hurricane Debbie

      Each week host Jeff Probst will answer a few questions about the most recent episode of Survivor: Game Changers. ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: I am fascinated by the whole Debbie meltdown at Brad and there’s a lot I want to get into with that. First off, I know you’re busy looking at all three tribes when you call a challenge, so how much did you notice her yelling at Brad throughout the immunity competition and then what was her demeanor like after they won? JEFF PROBST: How much I am able to hear is really challenge dependent. In this challenge, it was so big and so loud I didn’t hear any of the back and forth between Debbie and Brad. Otherwise, you can bet I would have been commenting! And because

      Entertainment Weekly q
    • Missing man found dead in belly of 7m-long PYTHON in Indonesia

      Villagers in Indonesia were left horrified when they discovered the body of a missing man inside the belly of a giant snake. A six-minute video on the website of the Tribun Timur publication shows villagers slicing open the 7m-long python’s carcass to reveal the legs and torso of the 25-year-old victim, named Akbar Salubiro. Junaedi, the secretary of Salubiro village in West Sulawesi province, said that villagers began searching for Akbar on Monday night after realising he had not returned from his palm oil crops.

      Yahoo News UK
    • Girl Savagely Edits Her Former Friend Out of Picture See the Hilarious Results

      Girl Hilariously Photoshops Friend Out of Picture

      People
    • Matt Hardy and Brother Nero 'are coming' to WWE: Will they fight at WrestleMania 33?

      After "Broken" Matt Hardy and his brother Jeff aka "Brother Nero" quit TNA (Impact Wrestling) in February this year, rumours began circulating about the Hardys making their WWE return with fans intensely debating about the brothers' comeback. Matt replied, "Did someone say #BROKEN?

      International Business Times
    • How to lose friends and 'exfoliate' people — Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner, is caught between 2 worlds, and his friends are cutting ties

      Signing up to carry out Donald Trump's vision of America has come at a cost to many of the...

      Business Insider
    • How a Body Positive Blogger Stopped Trolls in Their Tracks With 1 Bikini Pic

      Body positivity blogger Ana Carolina Rojas has nothing to hide, not even the hate she receives from trolls. Rojas was minding her own business, enjoying a beautiful, warm day of sunbathing and sharing it with her followers when a troll attacked.

      Yahoo Style
    • 911 Call Released in 'Make My Day' Home Invasion Killings

      Three teens are dead, and a 21-year-old woman has been arrested.

      Inside Edition
    • The New England Patriots

      The New England Patriots have a fairly lengthy history of bending the NFL's rules. Here's a look at the 4 biggest scandals in Patriots history.

      The Cheat Sheet q 40 min ago
    • Kris Bryant's dad has some advice that LaVar Ball can't afford to ignore

      If Mike Bryant isn’t considered the prototypical sports father, he probably should be. His dedication to helping his son, Kris Bryant, develop into the reigning National League MVP on the field, and a respected member of every community he belongs to off the field, are matched by few and topped by none. A lot of the same could be said about LaVar Ball, the father of UCLA standout and future NBA lottery pick Lonzo Ball. The dedication and support measure up, but his seemingly unquenchable thirst to make headlines and share the spotlight with his son are in stark contrast to Mr. Bryant’s. In fact, it’s to the point now where even Mike Bryant felt the need to weigh in with some very wise and important advice for Mr. Ball.

      Big League Stew
    • Matt Damon and George Clooney Disagree on the Meaning of 'Business Casual'

      One actor went for a fancy hoodie, while the other took a casual approach to suiting with no tie and an unbuttoned collar

      People
    • Michelle Kwan's Husband Files for Divorce

      1 3/29/2017 10:35 AM PDT Michelle Kwan's marriage is on ice, because her husband has just filed for divorce. According to legal docs, Clay Pell cites irreconcilable differences for the breakdown of his marriage to the 36-year-old, 5-time world champion figure skater and 2-time Olympic medalist.   Clay is mum on spousal support but he does want her to foot the bills from his lawyer. The couple married in January 2013. 35-year-old Clay was a White House National Security staffer under President Obama. He also ran unsuccessfully for Governor of Rhode Island. They have no kids so if there's legal beef, it will be over property.

      TMZ q