Taste test: Milk chocolate Easter bunnies


View gallery

Lindt Milk Chocolate Bunny

(Photo courtesy of Lindt)

For many of us, it's just not Easter without a chocolate bunny in our basket. With all the options in the supermarket, we wanted to find a hollow milk chocolate bunny that would satisfy both kids and adults—without breaking the bank (this isn't the year for $100 mail-order bunnies).

We purchased eight brands, with and without foil. All are available at drugstores or supermarkets, with the exception of Godiva (sold online or at its boutique stores).

Prices ranged from $3.29 to $23.50.

Methodology: In the blind taste test, nine judges compared the appearance, flavor, and consistency of the bunnies. We then ranked them according to the standard Epicurious four-fork rating system. One Epi Top Pick emerged from the group, earning a three-and-a-half-fork rating.

Best Overall

Epi Top Pick: Lindt Milk Chocolate Bunny (Pictured above left)
($4.50 per 3.5 oz. bunny)
Editors' rating: 3.5 forks out of 4

Pros: Dressed in intensely yellow-gold foil and a red bow, this bunny is as elegant as it is tasty. One tester likened its pleasant scent to sweetened condensed milk. Its flavor is "delightfully creamy!" as one taster put it. "It just melts in your mouth," commented another editor. "Tastes like good European chocolate with a subtle accent of caramel," stated another. It just so happens that it's also the least expensive of the winners.

Cons: None. We can only say good things.

(See more: Taste test: Baked hams for Easter)

View gallery

Hershey's Bliss Milk Chocolate Bunny

(Photo courtesy of Hershey's)

First Runner-Up: Hershey's Bliss Milk Chocolate Bunny
($4 per 4 oz. bunny)
Editors' rating: 3 forks out of 4

Pros: "This cute bunny with its sassy eyelashes reminds me of a Peter Cottontail illustration," said one editor. Encased in a detailed burnished yellow layer of foil, this chocolate is the darkest of them all. "As a dark chocolate lover, I appreciate the hint of semisweetness that lingers with each bite," stated one taster.

Cons: One editor described it as "spongy," while another disliked its "chewy" texture.

Godiva Bertie the Milk Chocolate Bunny

(Photo courtesy of Godiva)

Second Runner-Up: Godiva Bertie the Milk Chocolate Bunny
($25.00 per 9 oz. bunny)
Editors' rating: 2.5 forks out of 4

Pros: This bunny got high marks for presentation. "I am drawn to its simple and classic look," commented one tester. Packaged in a decorative pastel box, this creamy, rich, and cocoa flavored bunny had editors pleased.

Cons: Overly sweet aftertaste. The most expensive of all.

Prices and availability subject to change.

More at Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • A Marine’s .50 caliber sniper rifle failed during a firefight — so he called customer service

      The Barrett M107 .50-caliber long-range sniper rifle is a firearm made for the modern war on terrorism. While Barrett’s reputation of “flawless reliability” has made the M107 the sniper weapon of choice, the rifle is just like any other essential tool: It often breaks when you need it most. Don Cook, a Marine veteran who’s been maintaining M107s for more than two decades, told National Geographic in 2011 that he one day received a call to Barrett’s workshop from a harried young Marine. During maintenance of the unit’s M107, the Marine had bent the ears of the rifle’s lower receiver; the next day, after engaging the enemy, they discovered the rifle wouldn’t fire consistently.

      Business Insider q
    • 'I picked up daddy's hand, and it just fell,' said 3-year-old after he found murdered father

      LUCASVILLE, Ohio — Just a couple weeks ago as they were driving on Union Hill Road, Brentley Rhoden told his mom he saw his dad: He was in the sky following them. Didn't she see him? the 4-year-old asked his mom. Didn't she see him? "He was so excited. He was saying: 'He's right there. He's right there. He's right there. He's right there on that star," Chelsea Robinson said Friday, a year to the day she dropped Brentley off at his dad's trailer to spend the night not knowing what would unfold mere hours later. "I don't see what he sees,'' she said. But she knows what her little boy needs. She pulled the car over and waited as Brentley spent a full 10 minutes talking to his dad, Clarence "Frankie"

      USA Today q
    • Witness describes tense incident involving flight attendant and woman with stroller

      NEW YORK -- A witness says she saw what led up to tense moments that were captured on video Friday aboard an American Airlines flight.   Passengers say an American Airlines flight attendant hit a mother of twins with a stroller during boarding of the aircraft, which was preparing to leave for Dallas from San Francisco. Passenger Olivia Morgan said she saw the male flight attendant wrestling the stroller away from the woman, CBS News transportation correspondent Kris Van Cleave reports. “He rips it away from her, and it almost hits her little baby’s head,” Morgan said. “I said to him something like, ‘What are you doing? You almost hit that baby in the head!’” Morgan said. “And then he was just

      CBS News q
    • Mother of Suspected South Carolina Serial Killer Todd Kohlhepp Found Dead

      Todd Kohlhepp's Mother Regina Tague Found Dead

    • Texas police capture rattlesnake stared down by 'fearless cat'

      April 24 (UPI) -- A Texas police department shared photos from the capture of a massive rattlesnake spotted by bird-watchers hanging out next to a "fearless cat." The Laguna Vista Police Department said the Bay Area Birders of LV reported they were on a walking trail Thursday when they spotted the snake. The department shared several photos from the capture, including one of the snake appearing to be in the strike position while a "fearless cat" watches it from mere feet away. "We ask that you all use caution and are aware of your surroundings when walking on the walking trail or any other locations. Generally, rattlesnakes emerge from hibernation in March or April, or when the average daytime

      UPI q
    • R.I.P. Unicorn Frapp: Why it will haunt us forever

      When Starbucks unveiled their short-lived Unicorn Frappuccino, the world didn't know what it was in for. The now iconic drink may have ended Sunday, but the effects of the mania will haunt us all.

      Zoomin TV
    • Plus-Size Model Poses in Swimwear to Send a Powerful Message

      Posing in swimwear and showing off skin can be uncomfortable, even scary for some. But Alex LaRosa, a plus-size model, doesn't fall into that category.

      Yahoo Style
    • United ripped me out of my seat and threw me in the back of the plane

      ​A Manhattan socialite whose pals include first daughter Tiffany Trump ​​is suing United Airlines saying she was traveling to London last year ​when she was yanked out of business class​ by an attendant​, cursed at and ​ultimately ​forced into a middle seat in the back of the plane. Karen Shiboleth, the Instagram-loving daughter of wealthy New York lawyers, was headed to the UK from Newark Liberty International Airport to start a master’s degree program in international relations at Kings College on Sept. 10, 2016. Then she used American Express points plus $500 in fees to upgrade to an economy plus seat. Finally, when she was at the airport, she upgraded again, forking over an additional $1,150 for business class seat 1B.

      New York Post q
    • Sean Hannity Facing Sexual Harassment Allegations

      Former Fox News guest Debbie Schlussel said she was never invited back to Fox News after she turned down Hannity’s advances.

      International Business Times
    • Met Gala Red Carpet, Best Olsen Twins Met Gala Gowns (11 photos)

      Met Gala 2015 Red Carpet, Best Olsen Twins Met Gala Gowns

    • Here's the cold LinkedIn message that prompted a CEO to give the sender a job

      Kathryn Minshew, cofounder and CEO of careers advice and job listings site The Muse, wasn't yet looking to hire a head of marketing in 2012. Then she received a LinkedIn message from Elliot Bell that changed her mind. Bell was hired as the director of marketing a few months later; he worked at The Muse for four years. Here's the full text of the LinkedIn Message he sent Minshew. It's reprinted in "The New Rules of Work," the new book Minshew co-authored with her cofounder Alex Cavoulacos, who is COO of The Muse. Hi Kathryn, While slightly out of place, I attended the Women 2.0 conference yesterday with EatDrinkJobs and had the chance to see you pitch. I was blown away by you, your team, and most

      Business Insider q
    • Photo Of Husband Supporting Wife With Cancer Has The Internet Weeping

      On April 14, Mackenna Newman, 17, tweeted a photo of her dad Jon posted up outside his wife Marci’s bedroom, writing, “My mom has to stay in her room in isolation for her cancer radiation so my dad set up a desk at her door to keep her company and I’m crying.”

      The Huffington Post q
    • Hernandez suicide notes ordered released ahead of funeral

      BRISTOL, Conn. (AP) — Aaron Hernandez's family turned out Monday for a private funeral to say their farewells to the former NFL star, and a judge ordered that three suicide notes he left be turned over by the time he is buried.

      Associated Press
    • Australia, New Zealand hit back at North Korea threat

      Australia and New Zealand stiffened their rhetoric against North Korea Sunday after the isolated state threatened Canberra with a nuclear strike, urging it to think twice before "blindly and zealously toeing the US line". The move comes as US Vice President Mike Pence wraps up an Asia tour, which has included visits to South Korea, Japan and Australia partly to reassure allies amid fears that Pyongyang may be readying for a sixth nuclear test. "If Australia persists in following the US' moves to isolate and stifle North Korea... this will be a suicidal act," a North Korean foreign ministry spokesman said after Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop called the hermit state a "serious threat".

    • Off-Duty NYPD Officer Critically Injures 2 Women While Drunk Behind the Wheel: Cops

      Neville Smith, 32, rear-ended a Honda as he merged onto a highway before dawn Sunday.

      Inside Edition
    • Your Favorite Chips Are Being Recalled For A Terrifying Reason

      Frito-Lay is voluntarily recalling its jalapeño-flavored Lay's Kettle Cooked potato chips and jalapeño-flavored Miss Vickie's Kettle Cooked potato chips over fears that the seasoning they used could have been contaminated with Salmonella. Frito-Lay's supplier recently recalled their seasoning blend, which included jalapeño powder that may contain Salmonella, an organism that can cause fever, nausea and abdominal pain in healthy adults, as well as more serious and potentially fatal infections in those with weakened immune systems. Even though no Salmonella was found in the seasoning supplied to them, Frito-Lay decided to pull the chips, "out of an abundance of caution." No illnesses have been

      Delish q
    • Former 'Deadliest Catch' star Jake Harris arrested for car theft, drug possession, report says

      Former “Deadliest Catch” star Jake Harris was reportedly arrested this weekend for stealing a car and drug possession. Law enforcement told TMZ that the 31-year-old and an unidentified female drove to Phoenix from Washington last week for what the duo described as a “vacation.”  The woman told police that on Friday morning, Harris left their hotel with her car. She reported the vehicle as stolen when she couldn’t get in touch with him but found Harris at a Circle K the next day.  Phoenix PD officers showed up and searched Harris. They reportedly found Xanax, a prescription medication used to treat anxiety disorders, as well as crystal meth, which he admitted was for personal use. The celebrity

      Fox News q
    • Mel B's Former Nanny Sues Her for Libel, Claims They Carried on a Sexual Relationship

      Lorraine Gilles' lawsuit paints a very different picture.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • A new report reveals Obama misled the public about a quiet giveaway to Iran

      The Obama White House’s high-profile prisoner swap with Iran in 2016 was a much bigger gift to Iran than the administration ever let on. A number of them were involved in helping Iran procure lethal technology for its military, and at least one of them was accused of helping Iran procure critical equipment for the very nuclear programs the Obama administration was trying to halt with the nuclear deal it struck the year before, according to the article.

      Vox.com q