Taste test: Microwave popcorn

Epicurious

Popcorn taste test

(iStockphoto)

For many of us, it's almost impossible to watch anything on television without a bowl of popcorn in our hands: Each year, Americans consume more than 52 quarts of popped popcorn per capita, a figure that has tripled in the last three decades, according to the nonprofit Popcorn Board, an industry-funded group.

While some of that is eaten in the movie theater, the majority is devoured at home, and usually that means microwave popcorn.

There are almost as many brands of microwave popcorn as there are movie channels, so we set out to learn which makes the crunchiest, most evenly salted, most buttery-tasting kernels of all. Unfortunately, quite a few samples suffered from greasiness or an artificial butter flavor, so our task was harder than anticipated. Read on to find out which type tasted best to our judges. And once you know which brand to buy, take a look at ways to enhance the flavor even more, with our 14 delicious popcorn recipes.


View gallery

.
Best Microwave Popcorn Overall
Best Microwave Popcorn Overall

Orville Redenbacher's Light Butter
($3.29 per box of three 3.3-ounce bags )

Pros: Despite the fact that this variety is lower in fat than the standard buttered popcorns we tested, judges liked this best because it didn't sport the artificial taxicab yellow of many; nor did it taste like fake butter. "I like its particularly airy and crunchy quality," said one taster. The balance of butter and salt was especially toothsome.

Cons: A few would have liked it even saltier.

(See also: Best and worst bbq sauces)


View gallery

.
First Runner-Up, Standard Butter

First Runner-Up, Standard Butter

Orville Redenbacher's Butter
($3.49 per box of three 3.3-ounce bags)

Pros: "I am a fan of the very large and wide kernels," commented one judge. All editors commented on this variety's ideal ratio of butter and salt. One participant likened the taste to the popcorn sold at theaters: "This one reminds me of what you get at the movies, but it is so much better! It's crunchy and not neon yellow."

Cons: Quite a few testers found this type a bit too greasy.



View gallery

.
First Runner-Up, Light Butter

First Runner-Up, Light Butter

Jolly Time Healthy Pop Butter 94% Fat-Free
($2.99 per box of four 1.2-ounce mini bags)

Pros: Several editors enjoyed this variety's sweet and salty flavor. They also were fond of its caramel-like color and the size of the kernels.

Cons: This one needed more salt, some said.



The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Pop Secret's Butter kernels were described as slimy, cheesy, and a strange yellow. Some tasters were turned off by Black Jewell's Butter popcorn because it looked slightly blue and a bit burnt. Pop Secret Light Butter was the least favorite, because of its inconsistent flavor. Many editors were convinced that this variety was not actually "light" because it was strikingly salty and soggy. One judge added, "This tastes like it's been sitting in my cupboard for a year."

Additional Taste Test Details

All 11 varieties we evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Orville Redenbacher's Light Butter, Orville Redenbacher's Butter, Jolly Time Healthy Pop Butter 94% Fat-Free, Act II Butter, Newman's Own Light Butter, Newman's Own Butter, Smart Balance Light Butter, Act II 94% Fat-Free Butter, Pop Secret Butter, Black Jewell Butter, Pop Secret Light Butter.


Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 11 types of microwave popcorn (6 were light butter; 5, standard butter). We followed each variety's instructions and estimated microwaving time. In most cases, the bags took longer to pop than indicated. We ranked the popcorn according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Costco Releases December Deals Worth $1,400 in Savings

      Costco has released its latest monthly deals — dozens of discounts worth more than $1,400. To view all discounts available this month, visit Costco’s “December Savings” page. If you shop at a Costco club, you will see these discounts noted on price tags and automatically deducted at the register.

      Money Talks News
    • Ask Amy: Marriage on the rocks needs quick help

      Dear Amy: My wife and I have been married for almost 10 years. We are in our mid-30s. We don’t have children. We have hit a brick wall. She says that she completely resents me for not going to family functions and doing couples activities. I will try harder to do more of these things. She has said that she has changed and that we’ve grown apart. She has taken up different activities outside the home. She is taking dancing lessons and is working out at the local gym every day. She is out every other night, sometimes until quite late. We don’t eat dinner together anymore, and I’ve had many sleepless nights worrying about our relationship. I’m extremely concerned and worried about our marriage!

      Washington Post q
    • Anna Faris on Chris Pratt Cheating Rumors: ‘It Made Me Feel Incredibly Insecure’

      The actress sat down with Nocturnal Animals star Isla Fisher on a recent episode of her podcast, Anna Faris Is Unqualified, and the two got to talking about the challenges of being in a public relationship. Fisher, who’s married to Borat star Sacha Baron Cohen, told Faris that she prefers not to talk about her husband or children in interviews. “Chris and I, we talk about this a lot,” Faris responded.

      People
    • Investigator Believes Sex Trafficking Could Be Motive Behind Sherri Papini Kidnapping Case

      A private investigator and veteran human trafficking expert believes California mom Sherri Papini‘s case has the hallmarks of sex trafficking.

      People
    • Layoffs? 5 Types of Employees Who Are First to Be 'Fired'

      "Layoffs" is a dreaded word no matter where you work, and it can be difficult to know what to expect. However, these employees are often the first to go.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • SportsFlash - Dallas escapes Minnesota with win

      Yahoo Sports takes a look at the evening's top stories including the Cowboys improving to 11-1 and another NFL team is closer to moving to Los Angeles.

      Yahoo Sports Videos
    • Ravenous 14-foot python caught with 3 deer in its gut

      A Burmese python in the Everglades with a penchant for venison gulped down three whole deer — one doe and two fawns — before wildlife officials captured and euthanized it, a new study reveals. The gustatory feat sets a record: It's the first invasive Burmese python (Python molurus bivittatus) caught with three deer in its gut, said study co-lead author Scott Boback, an associate professor of biology at Dickinson College in Pennsylvania. The python probably attacked and ate the deer at different times over a 90-day period, Boback said. That time span may seem long, but it's actually quite surprising that a snake would eat three enormous meals in a relatively short window, Boback told Live Science.

      Fox News q
    • This baby with amazing hair is going to make your day.

      LONDON — Remember Baby Bear, the Irish tot with a glorious mane of luscious locks?   Well, there's a new hairy child in town.  Her name is Alexandra and, at just 2-months-old, she has a head of hair that is sure to win the internet's heart like the bouffanted babes that have come before her.  SEE ALSO: A very big-haired baby interrupts live Kim Kardashian TV report Reddit user brngrhm84 uploaded this image of his baby girl, and it has since gone viral because HOLY COW that's a lot of hair: As a bald man, I'm very proud of my 2 month old's hair from aww Let the photoshop battles begin. BONUS: Baby falling off table caught by lightning quick 9-year-old brother

      Mashable q
    • Sasha Obama’s $695 Christmas-Tree-Lighting Coat Just Made It to the Top of Our Wish Lists

      The Obamas had their final Christmas-tree lighting on the Ellipse in President’s Park last night, and of course, the first family showed up in style. While they all looked great, with Barack keeping it simple with a long, black coat, a suit, and a burgundy scarf, and Michelle wearing a black coat with a metallic pattern on the front, we were particularly digging Sasha’s outerwear — a faux-fur deep navy blue Opening Ceremony coat.

      Yahoo Style
    • Bill Belichick once changed his mind on hiring an assistant when the coach wanted to check with his wife first

      Along with Bill Belichick and Tom Brady, one of the most recognizable faces on the New England...

      Business Insider
    • Dear Abby: Husband's venture drains family savings

      DEAR ABBY: My husband of 23 years, “Gerald,” quit his job to start his own law firm. He told me about it only after he had quit. I have tried to be supportive, but seven months down the line, he has spent all our “rainy day” cash and earned only one paycheck. We have two teenagers, one who will be going to college in a year. I took a high-paying job a year ago to help pay down our mortgage and fund our son’s college expenses. Gerald claimed the bonus money he received when he quit his old job belonged to him to fund the new venture. He’s now saying that seven months is too little time to make any huge decisions, but we are now going to start liquidating our 401(k)s. This is where I draw the line.

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • Rihanna Takes High-Waisted Pants to New Heights (138 photos)

      Rihanna is just as much a sartorial risk taker as she is a musical hit maker. Leave it to the singer to step out in a sheer dress with nothing underneath, an ensemble made entirely of pink fur, or her special edition chaps-style Manolo boots under only a t-shirt. She may crush the red carpet each time she walks on it (the 2014 CFDA's, anyone?) but don't let that distract from her equally impressive streetwear. Here, keep up to date on her boldest looks. From Harper's BAZAAR

      Harper's Bazaar 39 min ago
    • Five Things To Know About Sherri Papini and Her Family

      In early November, California mother Sherri Papini mysteriously vanished after she left her Redding, California, home for a routine jog. “It all started with a first kiss in middle school,” Sherri wrote on the blog for her 2009 wedding. Sherri moved away and lost touch with Keith for several years, she writes on the blog.

      People
    • Oncology Nurse Diagnosed with Cancer Writes Apology Letter to Patients: ‘I’m Sorry, I Didn’t Get It’

      Oncology nurse Lindsay Norris never imagined she’d be told the three words she had said to dozens of patients before: You have cancer. In a blog post published on Nov. 14, titled ‘Dear every cancer patient I ever took care of, I’m sorry.

      People
    • Boy, 14, Allegedly Shoots His Mom and 8-Year-Old Brother Dead as They Sleep: Cops

      Fourteen-year-old Jacob Remaley will be tried as an adult, police said.

      Inside Edition
    • Kickstarter 'universe in a sphere' is a desk ornament designed to awe you

      New Kickstarter campaign “Universe in a Sphere” is a stunning glass sphere, containing a hyper-detailed 3D representation of not just our own galaxy, but a hefty chunk of the observable universe as we know it.

      Digital Trends
    • Trump's Carrier speech 'absolutely chilling,' economic analyst says

      Economic policy analyst Jimmy Pethokoukis called Donald Trump's Carrier speech the worst economic speech buy a politician in decades.

      CNBC.com q
    • Hero Pit Bull Puppy Saves Teen from Attempted Rape

      Apollo the 5-month-old pit bull puppy is getting extra hugs today, after saving his owner’s girlfriend from a terrifying attack. According to the New York Post, 18-year-old Maya Fairweather was visiting her boyfriend, Carlos Guzman, at his apartment in the Red Hook neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York, on Monday night. Around 10 p.m., the teen decided to take Guzman’s puppy, Apollo, for a walk.

      People
    • Mom Fights Back Against Cruel Meme of Terminally Ill Toddler

      According to Jenny Smith of Ranburne, Alabama, a photo of her terminally ill 3-year-old son was turned into a callous Internet meme after someone lifted a photo from Facebook. She reached out to the sites, asking them to remove the meme.

      Good Morning America