Taste test: Microwave popcorn

Epicurious

Popcorn taste test

(iStockphoto)

For many of us, it's almost impossible to watch anything on television without a bowl of popcorn in our hands: Each year, Americans consume more than 52 quarts of popped popcorn per capita, a figure that has tripled in the last three decades, according to the nonprofit Popcorn Board, an industry-funded group.

While some of that is eaten in the movie theater, the majority is devoured at home, and usually that means microwave popcorn.

There are almost as many brands of microwave popcorn as there are movie channels, so we set out to learn which makes the crunchiest, most evenly salted, most buttery-tasting kernels of all. Unfortunately, quite a few samples suffered from greasiness or an artificial butter flavor, so our task was harder than anticipated. Read on to find out which type tasted best to our judges. And once you know which brand to buy, take a look at ways to enhance the flavor even more, with our 14 delicious popcorn recipes.


View gallery

.
Best Microwave Popcorn Overall
Best Microwave Popcorn Overall

Orville Redenbacher's Light Butter
($3.29 per box of three 3.3-ounce bags )

Pros: Despite the fact that this variety is lower in fat than the standard buttered popcorns we tested, judges liked this best because it didn't sport the artificial taxicab yellow of many; nor did it taste like fake butter. "I like its particularly airy and crunchy quality," said one taster. The balance of butter and salt was especially toothsome.

Cons: A few would have liked it even saltier.

(See also: Best and worst bbq sauces)


View gallery

.
First Runner-Up, Standard Butter

First Runner-Up, Standard Butter

Orville Redenbacher's Butter
($3.49 per box of three 3.3-ounce bags)

Pros: "I am a fan of the very large and wide kernels," commented one judge. All editors commented on this variety's ideal ratio of butter and salt. One participant likened the taste to the popcorn sold at theaters: "This one reminds me of what you get at the movies, but it is so much better! It's crunchy and not neon yellow."

Cons: Quite a few testers found this type a bit too greasy.



View gallery

.
First Runner-Up, Light Butter

First Runner-Up, Light Butter

Jolly Time Healthy Pop Butter 94% Fat-Free
($2.99 per box of four 1.2-ounce mini bags)

Pros: Several editors enjoyed this variety's sweet and salty flavor. They also were fond of its caramel-like color and the size of the kernels.

Cons: This one needed more salt, some said.



The Other Contenders: The Bottom Three

Pop Secret's Butter kernels were described as slimy, cheesy, and a strange yellow. Some tasters were turned off by Black Jewell's Butter popcorn because it looked slightly blue and a bit burnt. Pop Secret Light Butter was the least favorite, because of its inconsistent flavor. Many editors were convinced that this variety was not actually "light" because it was strikingly salty and soggy. One judge added, "This tastes like it's been sitting in my cupboard for a year."

Additional Taste Test Details

All 11 varieties we evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Orville Redenbacher's Light Butter, Orville Redenbacher's Butter, Jolly Time Healthy Pop Butter 94% Fat-Free, Act II Butter, Newman's Own Light Butter, Newman's Own Butter, Smart Balance Light Butter, Act II 94% Fat-Free Butter, Pop Secret Butter, Black Jewell Butter, Pop Secret Light Butter.


Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of 11 types of microwave popcorn (6 were light butter; 5, standard butter). We followed each variety's instructions and estimated microwaving time. In most cases, the bags took longer to pop than indicated. We ranked the popcorn according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).

Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Op-Ed: We moved from New Jersey to a villa in Costa Rica and we only pay $400 a month

      The comfortable American dream doesn't compare to this paradise town in Costa Rica, writes Frederick Haywood.

      CNBC
    • Kellyanne Conway sidelined from TV after Flynn debacle

      Kellyanne Conway, once the most visible spokesperson for the Trump White House, has been sidelined from television appearances for making statements that were at odds with the administration's official stance, White House sources told CNNMoney on Wednesday. Conway has not given a television interview since early last week. On that Monday, she claimed that former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn had the president's "full confidence." Hours later, Flynn resigned. The following day, Conway claimed Flynn had offered to resign, even though White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer said Trump had asked Flynn for his resignation. She has not given a television interview since then. Those statements,

      CNN Money q 41 min ago
    • David Cassidy Opens Up About His ‘Beautiful’ Son — and Why He Doesn’t Have a Relationship with His Daughter

      After revealing that he has been battling dementia since 2015, David Cassidy is opening up about his complicated relationships with his two children – Beau and Katie. “I’ve never had a relationship with her,” Cassidy, 66, exclusively tells PEOPLE of his only daughter — who has appeared on Gossip Girl and Arrow. “I’m proud of her,” adds Cassidy.

      People
    • California Spillway Opens for First Time in 20 Years Amid Recent Storms

      Many braved fierce winds to take a look at a sight that hasn`t been seen since 1997 -- the opening of the Don Pedro reservoir spillway in Northern California.

      Tribune
    • 7 Reasons The Latest Donald Trump Rumour Is The Most Disturbing Yet

      Of all the disturbing stories to emerge surrounding the month-old Donald Trump administration, one of the latest threatens to, well, trump all the others.

      The Huffington Post UK q
    • Bill Gates supposedly has long way to go to catch the real richest man in the world

      Coming in at around $86 billion, Bill Gates has ridden his Microsoft fortune straight to the top of the Forbes list of the world’s richest men. Then again, the business magazine doesn’t take into account ...

      MarketWatch q
    • Stunning space discovery: 7 Earth-size planets found orbiting dwarf star

      CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. -- For the first time ever, astronomers have discovered seven Earth-size planets orbiting a nearby star - and these new worlds could hold life. This cluster of planets is less than 40 light-years away in the constellation Aquarius, according to NASA and the Belgian-led research team who announced the discovery Wednesday. The planets circle tightly around a dim dwarf star called Trappist-1, barely the size of Jupiter. Three are in the so-called habitable zone, where liquid water and, possibly life, might exist. The others are right on the doorstep. Scientists said they need to study the atmospheres before determining whether these rocky, terrestrial planets could support some

      CBS News q
    • Malia Obama in Ultimate Rich Kids' Ski Trip Pic (PHOTO)

      Malia Obama is on an Aspen vacay that will absolutely make you HATE your life when you see who she's posing with in what has to be the richie richiest photo of all time. Here's the answer key for who's who in this shot, taken last weekend at Cloud Nine Alpine Bistro in Aspen: 1. Malia 2. Elizabeth Tisch, daughter of NY Giants co-owner Steve Tisch 3. Audrey Kotick, daughter of Activision/Blizzard CEO Robert Kotick (think Call of Duty money) 4. Fashion designer Monique Lhuillier 5. Jamie Tisch, ex-wife of Steve 6. Tom Bugbee, Monique Lhuillier's husband 7. Holden Tisch, daughter of Steve 8. Zachary Tisch, son of Steve 9. Tassilo von Furstenberg, grandson of Diane von Furstenberg When President

      TMZ q
    • Amazon’s One-Day-Only, $8.62 Discount Is Too Good to Miss: Here Are 5 Things You Need to Buy Right Now

      Attention shoppers: Big things are happening on Amazon today. For one-day-only, the shopping site (which rarely offers discount codes) is giving customers $8.62 off any purchase of $50 or more with the code “BIGTHANKS” at checkout. It actually reflects Amazon’s record-high 86.27 ranking by the Harris Poll of Corporate Reputation. Which really just means it’s time to get your credit cards out!

      People 43 min ago
    • Mom’s Heartbreaking Photo of 10-Year-Old Son Shows Painful Reality of Cancer

      Drake, 10, in a photo meant to provide a raw depiction of what life is like for a cancer patient. This photo of a bald 10-year-old boy wearing a diaper and leaning on the bathroom sink with a pained look on his face is quickly going viral on Facebook. “The picture I’m posting is from this morning,” Drake’s mother captioned the image of her son, who is currently undergoing chemotherapy for leukemia, “and before you scream and cry ‘Why would she post a picture of him in a pull up, the indecency’, well 1.

      Yahoo Beauty
    • Aaron Hernandez Prison Phone Calls to NFL Star Could Impact Murder Case

      Prosecutors believe Aaron Hernandez's 2015 prison phone conversations with NFL star Mike Pouncey could help prove Aaron murdered two people in 2012.  TMZ Sports has obtained court docs in which prosecutors are asking the judge in the case to admit transcripts of the phone calls as evidence in Aaron's double murder trial.  Essentially, prosecutors believe the calls show Hernandez uses the word "try" as a way to describe being disrespected ... and talks to Pouncey about how he responds when someone "tries" him.  Officials say Hernandez felt the victims in the homicide case were "trying" him before he shot them to death later that night.  The first phone call with Pouncey went down on April 3, 2015:

      TMZ q
    • Snoopy Snuggles! Hoda Kotb’s Newborn Daughter Haley Joy Gets Oversized Gift from Andy Cohen

      Hoda Kotb‘s adopted newborn daughter Haley Joy is already being showered with gifts from her mom’s famous friends! On Wednesday, Kotb shared a sweet photo to Twitter of an oversized Snoopy sent to Haley Joy from Bravo personality — and Peanuts superfan — Andy Cohen. Kotb surprised Today audiences on Tuesday when she announced she had adopted Haley Joy.

      People
    • Flip or Flop's Christina El Moussa ends romance with family contractor amid messy divorce from Tarek

      Less than a month after splitting from her husband and co-star Tarek El Moussa, Flip or Flop host Christina sparked speculations of a new romance. "Christina is single and being in a relationship is the last thing on her mind," Us Weekly quoted Cassandra Zebisch, a representative for the reality TV star as saying.

      International Business Times UK q
    • America’s Best Fish and Chips (10 photos)

      Few dishes are more synonymous with the British Isles than fish and chips, but some truly spectacular versions can be found in the US as well.

      The Daily Meal
    • Mexico says it 'will not accept' Trump's new immigration plans, and it could retaliate

      This week, the Trump administration detailed new immigration plans that would expand the pool of...

      Business Insider
    • Fearing "feral hog apocalypse," Texas approves drastic measures

      Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller has approved pesticide targeting wild pigs, but the move has upset hunters, who have gathered 12,000 signatures in opposition

      CBS News q
    • Once Renowned Surgeon Sentenced to Life Behind Bars for Intentionally Maiming Patients

      Christopher Duntsch once billed himself as the best neurosurgeon in all of Dallas.

      Inside Edition
    • A girl named Ehlena and a dog named Wonder win at U.S. Supreme Court

      The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday sided with a disabled Michigan girl whose school refused to let her bring her service dog to class, making it easier for students like her to seek redress for discrimination in federal court. The justices ruled 8-0 that Ehlena Fry, 13, and her parents may not be obligated to go through time-consuming administrative appeals with the local school board before suing for damages for the emotional distress she said she suffered by being denied the assistance of her dog, a goldendoodle named Wonder. "We are thankful that the Supreme Court has clarified that schools cannot treat children with disabilities differently or stand in the way of their desired independence." The justices sent the case back to a lower appeals court to determine whether Ehlena's complaint involves the impermissible denial of a proper special education.

      Reuters
    • Money
    • Security tightened after break-in attempts to remove Kim Jong-nam's body from mortuary

      Malaysian police have tightened security after there were break-in attempts at the hospital mortuary where assassinated Kim Jong-nam's body has been kept, police said on Wednesday (22 February). Malaysian authorities had turned down North Korea's repeated demands for sending the body to Pyongyang amid rumours that Kim Jong-un – the current leader of the reclusive state and half-brother of the deceased – was behind the assassination. Addressing a news conference on Wednesday, national police chief Khalid Abu Bakar said they were taking adequate measures to safeguard the body at the mortuary after several attempts were made to break into the facility, apparently to remove the corpse.

      International Business Times UK q