Taste test: Cookie dough

Good Housekeeping.com

The Good Housekeeping Research Institute tested 15 cookie doughs to find these Taste Test winners and a super-simple cutout-cookie cheat.

View gallery

.

(Photo: Jesus Ayala/Studio D)

Nestlé Toll House Ultimates

Tasters’ Pick: "Chewy," "buttery," and "wonderfully chocolatey"; there's a reason these break-and-bake cookies ($3.29 for 16 oz.) are called "Ultimates."








View gallery

.

(Photo: Jesus Ayala/Studio D)


Wholly Wholesome Oatmeal Raisin


Tasters' Pick: Crisp outside and tender inside, these chunky, cinnamony cookies ($6 for 11.25 oz.), filled with "plump" raisins, taste like "homemade."











View gallery

.

(Photo: Jesus Ayala/Studio D)

Pillsbury Big Deluxe Peanut Butter Cup

Tasters' and Editors' Pick: "Decadent" and "melt-in-your-mouth" soft. Mini peanut butter cups (like the famous candy) give these cookies ($3.29 for 16 oz.) a creamy texture and "rich" chocolate flavor.











View gallery

.

(Photo: Wholly Wholesome)

Wholly Wholesome Chocolate Chip

Editors’ Pick: Our tasters enjoyed the "generous amounts of chocolate chips" in Wholly Wholesome's chocolate chip cookie dough ($5.99 for 11.25 oz.). These cookies tasted "natural" and "home-baked," and the texture was crisp. For some, it was almost too crisp — a few volunteers complained about a burnt, "smoky" flavor.




View gallery

.

(Photo: Nestlé)

Nestlé Toll House Oatmeal Scotchies

Editors’ Pick: With loads of butterscotch chips, some of our volunteers could "barely tell" Nestlé Toll House Oatmeal Scotchies ($3.29 for 16 oz.) even contained oatmeal. While these cookies were “too sweet” for some, they were just right and “oat-y” for others. The “chewy,” “soft” texture earned it most of its points.









View gallery

.

(Photo: Nestlé)

Nestlé Toll House White Chip Macadamia Nut

The "crisp" and "crunchy" Nestlé Toll House White Chip Macadamia Nut ($3.29 for 16 oz.) cookies were "the driest of the bunch." The white chocolate chips were a hit or miss based on one's personal preference, but the macadamia nuts gave the cookies a "good crunch." Tasters thought the flavor was "super buttery," "more like a butter cookie."









View gallery

.

(Photo: Pillsbury)

Pillsbury Big Deluxe Oatmeal Raisin

If you enjoy cookies on the softer side, consider Pillsbury Big Deluxe Oatmeal Raisin ($3.29 for 16 oz.) cookies, though some volunteers thought they actually tasted “too soft.” Raisin-lovers rejoiced at the “large” and “juicy” raisins.







View gallery

.

(Photo: Immaculate Baking Co.)

Immaculate Baking Co. Chocolate Chunk

The chocolate chip cookies from Immaculate Baking Co. ($3.99 for 14 oz.) are perfect for those who like their cookies soft and chewy on the inside and crispier on the outside. Unfortunately, some thought the taste was a bit "bitter," "bland," and "artificial." Tasters did appreciate the hefty chocolate chunks.






View gallery

.

(Photo: Nestlé)

Nestlé Toll House Chocolate Chip

Our volunteers found Nestlé Toll House chocolate chip cookies ($3.19 for 16.5 oz.) both "crunchy" and "chewy." Many thought the cookies tasted "homemade," but also "floury" and a bit "salty,” especially since the "very sweet" chocolate chips were sparse.



View gallery

.

(Photo: Trader Joe's)

Trader Joe's Chocolate Chip

"Tough" and "hard" was the way most of our volunteers described the chocolate chip cookies from Trader Joe's ($3.49 for 16 oz.) but "extra chocolate-y" chips helped soften the texture. The cookies' flavor was hard to pinpoint, as our tasters called the cookies as everything from "vanilla-y" and "sweet" to "bitter" and "nutty."






View gallery

.

(Photo: Pillsbury)

Pillsbury Peanut Butter

Pillsbury Peanut Butter cookies ($3.19 for 16.5 oz.) were "too one-note taste- and texture-wise" for many of our tasters, calling the cookie "plain" and "boring." Many also found the cookies "dry" and "harder to chew" than the rest.






View gallery

.

(Photo: Walmart)

Great Value Chocolate Chip

Tasters were not huge fans of Great Value chocolate chip cookies ($2.18 for 16.5 oz.). Although volunteers detected hints of coconut and vanilla in the flavor, they also described it as "artificial" and "stale." For cookie lovers who like a crunchier cookie texture, these just might satisfy.






View gallery

.

(Photo: Pillsbury)

Pillsbury Simply Chocolate Chip

Tasters were divided on the texture of Pillsbury Simply chocolate chip cookies ($3.29 for 14 oz.) with some finding it too thin for their liking and others calling it "melt in your mouth." They also couldn't agree on the flavor with some considering its richness "greasy" and others deeming it "buttery." All tasters, however, longed for more chocolate, complaining that there were "not enough chips."






View gallery

.

(Photo: Nestlé)

Nestlé Toll House Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

While some tasters thought that these cookies ($3.19 for 16 oz.) lacked peanut butter flavor, most described the cookies as "very nutty," possessing a "nice balance between peanut butter and chocolate taste." Unfortunately, the texture was described as "very chewy," to the point of being almost "rubbery."


More at Good Housekeeping:
Amazing Gingerbread Houses
Best Anti-Aging Beauty Products
15 Foods to Help You Lose Weight
Haircuts That Take Off 10 Years
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • So What Happened Last Night In Sweden? Donald Trump Saw It On Fox News – Update

      Updated 2:07 pm Sunday, with Trump response  President Donald Trump has explained his Sweden comment: He saw it on Fox. “My statement as to what’s happening in Sweden was in reference to a story that was broadcast on @FoxNews concerning immigrants & Sweden,” he’s just tweeted. My statement as to what's happening in Sweden was in reference to a story that was broadcast on @FoxNews concerning immigrants & Sweden. — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) February 19…

      Deadline
    • Inside Edition
    • 12 workers fired for skipping work during 'Day Without Immigrants' protest in Oklahoma

      Twelve employees of a Tulsa-area restaurant are without a job after skipping work on the "Day Without Immigrants."

      KABC – Los Angeles
    • Father and Son Killed In Head-On Collision With One Another

      Police said alcohol was a factor in the crash.

      Inside Edition
    • Under Armour made some huge mistakes that are turning into a nightmare

      Under Armour isn't cool anymore, according to a recent analyst note. 

      Business Insider
    • James Harden won't leave Russell Westbrook's side before All-Star Game

      Westbrook has got at least one person in his corner. Russell Westbrook and Kevin Durant didn’t sit with each other during the Western Conference All-Star photoshoot before the 2017 NBA All-Star Game. Instead, Westbrook sat with James Harden, who maintains good standing with Thunder guard despite playing on separate teams.The 2017 Western Conference #NBAAllStar Team! pic.twitter.com/f27m7Gr71d— NBA (@NBA) February 20, 2017In a video posted by RealGM, you can see Westbrook chatting with Harden while Durant stands in the far corner, toying with a basketball. ...

      SB Nation q
    • Plus-size model Hunter McGrady looks amazing in the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue and on the red carpet

      Hunter McGrady is amazing body-positive role model in the new Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition.

      Hello Giggles
    • Father and Son Killed in Head-On Collision After Their Cars Crash into Each Other While Returning Home

      Alabama investigators claim that alcohol played a considerable role in a horrific head-on collision that killed a father and son that were driving separate vehicles early Saturday. According to AL.com, Jeffrey Morris Brasher, 50, and Austin Blaine Brasher, 22, were both killed in a crash that occurred shortly after 4 a.m. on Saturday. • Pick up PEOPLE’s special edition True Crime Stories: Cases That Shocked America, on sale now, for the latest on Casey Anthony, JonBenét Ramsey and more.

      People
    • J.K. Rowling has the best response to Trump's non-existent Sweden attack

      The internet can't get enough of President Donald Trump's "last night in Sweden" remarks, including, of course, J.K. Rowling. Never one to shy from a little fun at the expense of the U.S. president, the author joined in on Twitter's response to Trump's confusing reference to a terrorist attack that didn't actually happen. SEE ALSO: Internet turns to @Sweden on Twitter after Trump appears to invent terror attack Literally the biggest incident of Sweden last night was a horse called Biscuit being rescued from a well. https://t.co/CAYsHhpt6z — Grapey (@Grapeykins) February 19, 2017 #MakeBiscuitDryAgain https://t.co/C7rPpZrcNf — J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) February 19, 2017 Naturally, Rowling's hashtag kicked off a whole new riff on Trump's Sweden comments.  Poor Biscuit, after #BowlingGreen, why didn't Sweden see this coming and do something to prevent such an atrocity? #MakeBiscuitDryAgain — Bren (@bnboring) February 19, 2017 Thanks to your prayers @jk_rowling Biscuit soon dry again #MakeBiscuitDryAgain @ChelseaClinton pic.twitter.com/shs4SnlM7P — Leif Pagrotsky (@leifpagrotsky) February 19, 2017 What's that, Lassie?! Who fell down the well?? #swedenincident #MakeBiscuitDryAgain https://t.co/6Aoc9yfzz0 — MJ (@meencat) February 19, 2017 A quick refresher: During a speech at a rally in Melbourne, Florida, held Saturday night, Trump sandwiched a vague reference to Sweden between references to recent terrorist attacks in Germany, France and Belgium.  From a transcript of his speech:  As many have noted, nothing close to the attacks he referenced in his speech happened in Sweden on Friday night. Even Sweden's former prime minister struggled to make sense of Trump's comment: Sweden? Terror attack? What has he been smoking? Questions abound. https://t.co/XWgw8Fz7tj — Carl Bildt (@carlbildt) February 19, 2017 As for the horse, let's all hope its OK after its terrifying ordeal.  [H/T: Huffington Post] BONUS: The secret love affair between Harry Potter and Voldemort

      Mashable
    • Fox News' Chris Wallace to Reince Priebus: 'You don't get to tell us what to do'

      Fox News Sunday host Chris Wallace and White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus clashed Sunday over President Trump's tweet labeling the media an "enemy of the American people." "I don't have any problem with you complaining about an individual story" or bias, Wallace said. "But you went a lot further than that — or the president went a lot further than that he said that the 'fake media' — not certain stories — the 'fake media' are an 'enemy to the country.'" Priebus pushed back, arguing that the issue is "not just two stories" that may be marred by bias or error but "24 hours a day, seven days a week" of cable news programming that focuses not on the Trump administration's policy accomplishments

      The Week q
    • Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliot has interaction with police

      Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliot was detained by police in Columbus, OH on Friday night. He was headed to The Social Bar when a cop flashed a flashlight in his face. Zeke was then detained for about four minutes, according to TMZ. The TMZ report reads as follows: Ezekiel Elliott’s night was abruptly interrupted by cops after they detained and questioned him….before letting him go. An eyewitness tells us the Cowboys star was on his way to The Social bar Friday night in Columbus, OH when suddenly, and for unknown reasons, a cop lit a flashlight on his face and detained him for about 4 minutes….before letting him go. There is no word on why the officer detained Elliot, but a video was

      Cowboys Wire q
    • Shocking image shows Kim Jong-nam's final moments after he was assassinated

      Shocking images of the moment Kim Jong-nam was assassinated in a Malaysian airport have emerged for the first time. The half-brother of North Korea's dictator Kim Jong-un was poisoned on 13 February, allegedly by two women believed to be acting on behalf of the rogue state. It was originally thought the two women involved were North Korean spies, but it emerged on Saturday that at least one of the women – Sisi Asiyah, 25, from Indonesia – believed they were taking part in a television prank, though this has not been officially confirmed.

      International Business Times UK q
    • This dog arrived at a shelter with a seriously detailed notebook from a kid who adored him, and we’re crying

      Today in super cute and completely heartbreaking news, a dog recently arrived at the Humane Society of Utah with VERY specific instructions…

      Hello Giggles
    • EXCLUSIVE: 'The Walking Dead' Boss Spills on That Shocking Lie-Filled Reunion, and the 'Brutal' Savior War Ahead!

      If you do not want to be spoiled, get out of here immediately -- but avoid the junkyards!

      Entertainment Tonight
    • DeMarcus Cousins to the Pelicans is the new big NBA trade rumor

      The deal would send Boogie to New Orleans in exchange for Buddy Hield and a bunch of first-round picks. UPDATE: The trade is happening. DeMarcus Cousins is reportedly heading to the Pelicans for Buddy Hield, Tyreke Evans, Langston Galloway, and multiple draft picks.

      SB Nation q
    • Unidentified man in photo called suspect in Indiana girls' killings

      The girls disappeared while hiking in a forest.

      ABC News q
    • In pictures: Sunday's FA Cup action (38 photos)

      In pictures: Sunday’s FA Cup action Goalscorer: Ibrahimovic

      Yahoo Sport UK
    • After Donald Trump claims there was a tragedy in Sweden, people have hilarious suggestions of what it might have been

      First there was the “Bowling Green massacre,” the nonexistent incident mentioned by President Trump’s adviser Kellyanne Conway to justify the Muslim travel ban….

      Hello Giggles
    • Fox News' Chris Wallace grills Reince Priebus: 'You don't get to tell us what to do'

      Fox News Sunday host Chris Wallace and White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus clashed Sunday over President Trump's tweet labeling the media an "enemy of the American people." "I don't have any problem with you complaining about an individual story" or bias, Wallace said. "But you went a lot further than that — or the president went a lot further than that he said that the 'fake media' — not certain stories — the 'fake media' are an 'enemy to the country.'" Priebus pushed back, arguing that the issue is "not just two stories" that may be marred by bias or error but "24 hours a day, seven days a week" of cable news programming that focuses not on the Trump administration's policy accomplishments

      The Week q