Taste test: Canned tuna

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best canned tuna taste test

Tuna taste test (Photo: iStockphoto)

Epicurious taste tested 13 canned chunk light tunas, in water and oil, and reeled in a few winners.

Everyone has a preferred flavor enhancer for a "mean" tuna salad—celery, apples, relish, olives...the list goes on. But the key ingredient has got to be the tuna itself: Not even a whole jar of mayonnaise can salvage a smelly, soggy can of fish.








Canned tuna meat should be firm and flaky, but never mushy. It should be moist but not watery (and certainly not dry). And it has to look appetizing before it's dressed up with seductive ingredients.

It was not easy deciding which tunas to feature in our taste test. They come in cans, glass jars, and even pouches, and can be packed in water, vegetable oil, or olive oil. Even more confusing: Tuna varieties sold in cans include albacore, yellowfin, skipjack, and tongol. After much research, we chose to focus our test on canned chunk light skipjack and tongol in both water and oil. Why? Light meat, ie: chunk light tuna (in oil and water) accounts for 75 to 80 percent of annual domestic canned tuna consumption in the U.S., according to The Tuna Council.

(See more: Best and worst bbq sauces)

There is a health issue too: Chunk light skipjack and tongol generally have lower levels of mercury than albacore and yellowfin (for more information, read Mercury in Canned Tuna and the Seafood Selector entry on canned tuna from the Environmental Defense Fund).

To "catch" the best chunk light canned tuna, we tasted 12 varieties available nationwide, including the following, listed from highest to lowest score in our tests: 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water, Starkist Gourmet Choice Solid Light Tuna Fillet in Olive Oil*, Wild Planet Wild Skip Jack Light Tuna (no water)*, Miramonte Tongol Tuna in Spring Water**, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Water**, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Water, Cento Solid Pack Light Tuna, Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, and Progresso Solid Light Tuna in Olive Oil.

(The brands marked with * received the same score. The same is true for those marked with **.)

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of chunk light canned tuna. All were drained and served as is (without any mayonnaise or other condiments or garnishes). We ranked them according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being the best). One tuna was a real catch, while two others got good marks from the judges.


View gallery

.
Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water
Best Overall

Epi Top Pick: Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water ($1.39 for 6 oz. can)

Pros: Aside from being the least expensive of all the winners, this firm yet chunky (not mushy) light-colored tuna impressed tasters.

"It has a subtle, clean ocean flavor; it tastes natural," said one editor. "I love how it's firm yet chewy, and perfectly salted," observed another.

Cons: Appeared dry at first glance.


View gallery

.
Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil

First Runner-Up: Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil ($1.89 for 5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated the firm white fish meat, which had a slight smoky accent to it. One taster noted: "This is the first canned tuna I've enjoyed without tons of added mayo."

Cons: Salty and slightly oily.



View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water
Second Runner-Up: Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water ($1.89 for 6.5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated this tuna's moist appearance and chewy texture. "It tastes like fish but it's not too pungent and has no aftertaste," said one judge. Environmentally minded shoppers may also appreciate that this tuna is marketed as wild-caught.

Cons: The meat's two-toned coloring (with reddish and yellow patches) might be unappetizing to some.


The Other Contenders

Progresso brand may have won our taste buds over in the Chicken Noodle Taste Test , but their tuna product was judged the least desirable among the 12 competitors in this taste test. Editors were turned off by the "pungent" fishy smell and its lingering aftertaste.

Two other well known name brands did not fare well: Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil was described as bland and chalky, while Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil appeared soft, mushy, and overly moist. But judges did commend Starkist for not being overly salty, and the Chicken of the Sea tuna's "smokiness" convinced judges that it would be more appealing once drained and mixed with a dollop of mayo.



Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Missing man found dead in belly of 7m-long PYTHON in Indonesia

      Villagers in Indonesia were left horrified when they discovered the body of a missing man inside the belly of a giant snake. A six-minute video on the website of the Tribun Timur publication shows villagers slicing open the 7m-long python’s carcass to reveal the legs and torso of the 25-year-old victim, named Akbar Salubiro. Junaedi, the secretary of Salubiro village in West Sulawesi province, said that villagers began searching for Akbar on Monday night after realising he had not returned from his palm oil crops.

      Yahoo News UK
    • Love, Marriage – and Babies! How the Property Brothers Finally Settled Down – and Why They Still Live Together

      The Property Brothers Jonathan Scott and Drew Scott stay connected. As the stars of HGTV’s most popular series, Property Brothers, Drew and Jonathan Scott, 38, have spinoff shows, a bestselling book (their second, It Takes Two: Our Story, comes out Sept. 5), their own production company and a collection of furniture and decor. “This is the most humbling, unexpected, fantastic place to be in my life,” Jonathan tells PEOPLE of his relationship with girlfriend, Jacinta Kuznetsov, 28, a development producer at Scott Entertainment.

      People
    • Dog owner fatally mauled by Staffordshire bull terrier while he was being 'interviewed for BBC documentary'

      A dog owner mauled to death by his Staffordshire bull terrier was allegedly being interviewed by the BBC when the horrific attack took place. The man’s cause of death was recorded as hypovolemic shock and damage to the airway – with the injuries said to be consistent with a dog bite. The dog remains in secure kennels after being seized by police – who have since confirmed that the animal is not prohibited under the Dangerous Dogs Act.

      Yahoo News UK
    • Matt Damon and George Clooney Disagree on the Meaning of 'Business Casual'

      One actor went for a fancy hoodie, while the other took a casual approach to suiting with no tie and an unbuttoned collar

      People
    • Gordon Ramsay Reveals the 1 Place You Should Never Eat

      Sure, Gordon Ramsay has high standards, but is there really anything he would never eat? Turns out it's more of a place where he would never eat rather than one specific food — and that's on a plane. In an interview with Refinery29, Gordon revealed his feelings about airplane food and why those feelings might be justified. "There's no f*cking way I eat on planes," he said. "I worked for airlines for 10 years, so I know where this food's been and where it goes, and how long it took before it got on board." Yikes. The man has a point — there's no denying that airplane food is not the best. So what's a traveler to do to avoid midflight hunger, according to the world-renowned chef? If you're like

      PopSugar q
    • Rumor Roundup: Goldberg/Lesnar, Rock/Diesel, Ranallo

      Speculating on the rumors surrounding pro wrestling is a favored pastime of many fans, perhaps second only to actually watching the matches. In this daily column, we take a look at the latest rumors being churned out by the pro wrestling rumor mill. Important reminder: Rumors are just that -- rumors. None of this has been confirmed as legitimate news or fact, it's just circulating around the pro wrestling rumor mill. Remember, take it all with a grain of salt. Rumors for the Day: WWE definitely plans on Goldberg’s match with Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 33 to last longer than their Survivor Series encounter. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reports sources have told them Mauro Ranallo’s hiatus

      Cageside Seats q
    • Wal-Mart Has a Unique Way to Cut Down on Shoplifting -- The Motley Fool

      The company has a program that avoids calling the police.

      The Motley Fool q
    • Python vs. Man: Indonesian Police Find Body In Stomach Of Giant Snake [VIDEO]

      A man who went missing in Indonesia was found dead in an unlikely place – inside the stomach of a snake measuring at more than 20 feet long. The 25-year-old victim who was only identified as Akbar went to the island of Sulawesi to work on his palm oil crops Sunday morning. But he never made it back home.  Akbar had been missing for an entire day, Mashura, a spokesperson for the police in West Sulawesi province told BBC Indonesian. A search party was formed Monday night. Read: Why Did Snake Kill 2 Boys In Canada? Python Euthanized After Children’s Deaths  In the midst of the search, police saw a dead python near Akbar’s house. They also noticed his boots imprinted inside the snake’s stomach, according

      International Business Times q
    • Remy Ma and Papoose Get Real Like Never Before About Why Their Marriage Works

      For our new podcast, the couple opens up like never before and reveals how they fostered their unbreakable bond.

      Essence
    • ASU Student Receiving Death Threats for FB Post

      "I think my duty as an empowered immigrant and an empowered woman is to use that empowerment to speak for those who are still too scared."

      Cosmopolitan
    • 'Property Brothers' stars Drew and Jonathan Scott open up about romance, settling down

      Drew and Jonathan Scott have charmed viewers for years as HGTV's "Property Brothers." Now, the twins, 38, are opening up on how they charmed the lucky ladies in their lives."The moment I saw her, it was her energy," Drew told People magazine of his fiancée, Linda Phan. "She's beautiful, but she had this energy about her that I absolutely loved."Drew Scott and Phan met in 2010, and became engaged in December. She works as creative director at Scott Brothers Entertainment, Drew and Jonathan Scott's production company. ...

      Good Morning America
    • Girl Savagely Edits Her Former Friend Out of Picture See the Hilarious Results

      Girl Hilariously Photoshops Friend Out of Picture

      People
    • Matt Damon Says Ben Affleck Has Been 'Mr. Mom-ing It' Since Completing Rehab

      Matt Damon Says Ben Affleck Has Been 'Mr. Mom-ing It' Since Completing Rehab

      People
    • Michelle Kwan's Husband Files for Divorce

      1 3/29/2017 10:35 AM PDT Michelle Kwan's marriage is on ice, because her husband has just filed for divorce. According to legal docs, Clay Pell cites irreconcilable differences for the breakdown of his marriage to the 36-year-old, 5-time world champion figure skater and 2-time Olympic medalist.   Clay is mum on spousal support but he does want her to foot the bills from his lawyer. The couple married in January 2013. 35-year-old Clay was a White House National Security staffer under President Obama. He also ran unsuccessfully for Governor of Rhode Island. They have no kids so if there's legal beef, it will be over property.

      TMZ q
    • Mama June Regrets Her Weight Loss Surgery

      The long recovery time took a toll.

      Delish
    • Guilty German Shepherd can't hide shame

      You be the judge: Is Shadow the German Shepherd guilty or not? The evidence is a bit overwhelming...

      Rumble
    • Star Tracks: Wednesday, March 29, 2017 (131 photos)

      Star Tracks: Wednesday, March 29, 2017

      People
    • Amal Clooney Shows Off Baby Bump in Chic Red Dress in London -- See the Pics!

      The 39-year-old attorney is hard at work in London while husband George Clooney promotes his new film in Las Vegas.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Petition puts US first family's costly logistics in crosshairs

      First Lady Melania Trump, who lives at the family's New York City penthouse, should move to the White House or pay for the cost of protecting Trump Tower, an online petition said Wednesday. "The US taxpayer is paying an exorbitant amount of money to protect the First Lady in Trump Tower, located in New York City," the Change.org petition says. Melania Trump has said she will stay in New York to allow her 11-year-old son, Barron, to finish the year.

      AFP
    • The New England Patriots

      The New England Patriots have a fairly lengthy history of bending the NFL's rules. Here's a look at the 4 biggest scandals in Patriots history.

      The Cheat Sheet q