Taste test: Canned tuna

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best canned tuna taste test

Tuna taste test (Photo: iStockphoto)

Epicurious taste tested 13 canned chunk light tunas, in water and oil, and reeled in a few winners.

Everyone has a preferred flavor enhancer for a "mean" tuna salad—celery, apples, relish, olives...the list goes on. But the key ingredient has got to be the tuna itself: Not even a whole jar of mayonnaise can salvage a smelly, soggy can of fish.








Canned tuna meat should be firm and flaky, but never mushy. It should be moist but not watery (and certainly not dry). And it has to look appetizing before it's dressed up with seductive ingredients.

It was not easy deciding which tunas to feature in our taste test. They come in cans, glass jars, and even pouches, and can be packed in water, vegetable oil, or olive oil. Even more confusing: Tuna varieties sold in cans include albacore, yellowfin, skipjack, and tongol. After much research, we chose to focus our test on canned chunk light skipjack and tongol in both water and oil. Why? Light meat, ie: chunk light tuna (in oil and water) accounts for 75 to 80 percent of annual domestic canned tuna consumption in the U.S., according to The Tuna Council.

(See more: Best and worst bbq sauces)

There is a health issue too: Chunk light skipjack and tongol generally have lower levels of mercury than albacore and yellowfin (for more information, read Mercury in Canned Tuna and the Seafood Selector entry on canned tuna from the Environmental Defense Fund).

To "catch" the best chunk light canned tuna, we tasted 12 varieties available nationwide, including the following, listed from highest to lowest score in our tests: 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water, Starkist Gourmet Choice Solid Light Tuna Fillet in Olive Oil*, Wild Planet Wild Skip Jack Light Tuna (no water)*, Miramonte Tongol Tuna in Spring Water**, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Water**, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Water, Cento Solid Pack Light Tuna, Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, and Progresso Solid Light Tuna in Olive Oil.

(The brands marked with * received the same score. The same is true for those marked with **.)

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of chunk light canned tuna. All were drained and served as is (without any mayonnaise or other condiments or garnishes). We ranked them according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being the best). One tuna was a real catch, while two others got good marks from the judges.


View gallery

.
Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water
Best Overall

Epi Top Pick: Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water ($1.39 for 6 oz. can)

Pros: Aside from being the least expensive of all the winners, this firm yet chunky (not mushy) light-colored tuna impressed tasters.

"It has a subtle, clean ocean flavor; it tastes natural," said one editor. "I love how it's firm yet chewy, and perfectly salted," observed another.

Cons: Appeared dry at first glance.


View gallery

.
Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil

First Runner-Up: Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil ($1.89 for 5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated the firm white fish meat, which had a slight smoky accent to it. One taster noted: "This is the first canned tuna I've enjoyed without tons of added mayo."

Cons: Salty and slightly oily.



View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water
Second Runner-Up: Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water ($1.89 for 6.5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated this tuna's moist appearance and chewy texture. "It tastes like fish but it's not too pungent and has no aftertaste," said one judge. Environmentally minded shoppers may also appreciate that this tuna is marketed as wild-caught.

Cons: The meat's two-toned coloring (with reddish and yellow patches) might be unappetizing to some.


The Other Contenders

Progresso brand may have won our taste buds over in the Chicken Noodle Taste Test , but their tuna product was judged the least desirable among the 12 competitors in this taste test. Editors were turned off by the "pungent" fishy smell and its lingering aftertaste.

Two other well known name brands did not fare well: Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil was described as bland and chalky, while Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil appeared soft, mushy, and overly moist. But judges did commend Starkist for not being overly salty, and the Chicken of the Sea tuna's "smokiness" convinced judges that it would be more appealing once drained and mixed with a dollop of mayo.



Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • 15-Year-Old Allegedly Decapitated Missing Classmate in ‘Horrific, Horrific Murder’

      Lee Manuel Viloria-Paulino walked out the door of his house on the night of Nov. 18 — and was never seen alive again. On Saturday, weeks after his disappearance, one of Lee’s classmates at Lawrence High School in Lawrence, Massachusetts, was arrested and charged with allegedly murdering and decapitating the 16-year-old, PEOPLE confirms. “This was a horrific, horrific murder,” Essex District Attorney Jonathan Blodgett said at a news conference on Saturday.

      People
    • No bail for 15-year-old charged with decapitating classmate

      LAWRENCE, Mass. (AP) — A 15-year-old boy charged with killing a high school classmate whose headless body was found near a river said in a police report made public Monday that they had gone to smoke marijuana together and he had last seen the classmate alive.

      Associated Press
    • Devastated Parents Speak Out After 1 Piece of Holiday Cake Killed Their Son

      When 11-year-old Oakley Debbs ate a piece of cake over the Thanksgiving holiday weekend, his family had no idea that it had the potential to kill him. Oakley had a peanut allergy and when he realized his mistake, his family was alarmed but gave him Benadryl, which seemed to do the trick. His mom, Merrill, explained to WMTW that the allergy medicine had always worked in the past after an accidental consumption of nuts. She also shared that he felt "great" for the rest of the evening after taking the medicine. However, his condition took a drastic turn later that night and he went from playing with cousins and his twin sister to vomiting. Within minutes the child could no longer breathe. "He was

      PopSugar q
    • Republican success opens door to amending US Constitution

      JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — The November election put Republicans in full control of a record number of state legislatures around the country, a level of power that gives the party an unprecedented opportunity: change the U.S. Constitution.

      Associated Press
    • In 2005, a U.S. Navy Sub Ran Into a Mountain

      In 2005, the nuclear attack submarine USS San Francisco suddenly stopped dead in its tracks. The ship's crew were thrown about, some over distances of 20 feet, and the majority of the 137-member crew suffered one injury or another—including one that would later prove fatal. Further inspection would explain what happened, and reveal that the submarine's bow looked like a crushed soda can. USS San Francisco had run into an undersea mountain. On that day, January 8, 2005, the San Francisco had been approximately 360 miles southeast of Guam, traveling at flank speed (more than 30 knots). The navigational charts used by the ship's crew failed to show a seamount, or undersea mountain, protruding from

      Popular Mechanics q
    • Abducted jogger skips town with family and leaves dogs behind

      REDDING, Calif. — The California mom found beaten and bloody on a highway after going missing for three weeks has skipped town with her husband — and left their two dogs behind. Sherri and Keith Papini left their home in Redding with their two kids but decided not to bring the dogs, friends said. A “buddy of Keith’s” was at the Papini home on Sundust Road on Saturday around noon — and told a Post reporter he was there to “walk the dogs.” He then took the smaller dog on a leash and said he “couldn’t answer any questions” and “I’m going to go walk her now.” He said he was there “just helping out.” A neighbor who has lived next to the Papini house, which is Keith’s childhood home, and has known

      New York Post q
    • Anna Kendrick Makes A Striking Point While Discussing Last Tango Rape Scene

      Over the weekend, an old video surfaced of Italian director Bernardo Bertolucci admitting that the infamous rape scene in Last Tango In Paris was planned without the consent of actress Maria Schneider. Anna Kendrick responded to Evans, pointing out that actress Maria Schneider had said the scene was done without her consent, but her allegations were largely ignored. Kendrick said in a tweet, "Ms Schneider stated this several years ago.

      Refinery 29 UK
    • Self-made millionaire: If you want to get rich, start working 95 hours a week

      Stop doing the 9-to-5 and start doing 95, advises businessman Grant Cardone.

      CNBC.com q
    • Sherri Papini’s Husband Breaks Down in Tears Describing How She Survived Weeks in Captivity

      Sherri Papini “literally lived through hell” during her 20-plus days in captivity — being branded and beaten and losing about 15 percent of her body weight — her husband, Keith Papini, told ABC News in an interview that aired Monday. Sherri appears to have coped by imagining she was with Keith and their children Tyler, 4, and Violet, 2. “The things she told me,” Keith told ABC’s Matt Gutman, in an on-camera interview on Good Morning America, before breaking down in tears.

      People
    • Jayson Williams speaks following release from prison

      60 MINUTES SPORTS spoke with the former NBA player, who spent 26 months in prison for murdering his limo driver. See the full interview Tuesday, Dec. 6th only on SHOWTIME.

      Yahoo Sports Videos
    • Sasha Obama Embraces the Season's Biggest Trend (57 photos)

      Following their European tour with First Lady Michelle Obama earlier last summer, the first daughters are bringing their chic sense of style to the streets of NYC for a father-daughter weekend with the President. Since moving into The White House eight years ago, Sasha and Malia Obama's style has transformed along the way. Click through for a look back at the teenagers' best fashion moments over the years. From Harper's BAZAAR

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Classmate arrested after Mass. teen found decapitated along river

      LAWRENCE, Mass. – A classmate has been arrested in the murder of a Massachusetts teenager who was found decapitated along the Merrimack River, about 40 miles north of Boston, reports CBS Boston. The 15-year-old suspect pleaded not guilty to a first-degree murder charge in the death of 16-year-old Lee Manuel Viloria-Paulino Monday. The teen will be charged as an adult. His lawyer did not argue for bail. Viloria-Paulino’s body was found near the Merrimack River in Lawrence on Thursday by a woman walking her dog. Police recovered the head nearby. He had been missing since Nov. 18.  Essex District Attorney Jonathan Blodgett says the motive for the killing is unclear and remains under investigation.

      CBS News q
    • Petition to Reverse Election Results Is Popular

      Over 4.7 million people have signed it.

      Cosmopolitan
    • Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos’ son is 19 now and the internet is freaking out over how attractive he is

      Beautiful people often have beautiful kids, and this is no exception. Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos’ oldest son is 19 and super…

      Hello Giggles
    • Jennifer Aniston declines Brad Pitt's dinner invite as it 'would be an insult to Justin Theroux'

      Brad Pitt reportedly invited his former wife Jennifer Aniston for dinner when they both were in London recently. The Horrible Bosses actress is said to have declined the offer as she thought meeting Pitt "would be an insult" to her husband Justin Theroux. Pitt and Aniston split in January 2005 after five years of marriage.

      International Business Times UK q
    • Mom Gets Inspired by Her Baby Girl to Lose 130 Lbs.: ‘I Wanted Her to Look up to Me’

      Kassidy Linde had reached 260 lbs. when she completely lost her self-confidence. “It got to the point that whenever I would look in the mirror, I wasn’t able to find anything beautiful about myself,” Linde, 25, tells PEOPLE.

      People
    • Cam Newton explains why he didn't have a tie and violated Panthers' dress code

      Cam Newton has had some interesting press conferences, some combative ones, some short ones, but none like the one he had on Sunday night. Newton was benched for the first series of Sunday night’s game against the Seattle Seahawks for a dress-code violation. Panthers coach Ron Rivera wouldn’t get into details, but Newton said it was because he didn’t wear a tie on the team’s flight to Seattle.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Biggest Loser Winner Ali Vincent on Her Struggles After Regaining 112 Lbs.: ‘I Feel Ashamed’

      Ali Vincent made history as the first female to win weight loss competition show The Biggest Loser in 2008 after losing 112 lbs. — but in April, Vincent, 41, revealed that she had regained almost all of the weight she had lost. Vincent recently revealed that she was the victim of a sexual assault while getting a massage, and believes much of her weight gain came from dealing with the emotional fallout. Vincent announced that she was joining Weight Watchers to get her weight back on track, but says she is still struggling with the emotional aspects of her weight gain now.

      People
    • Little Girl Drowned While Babysitter Smoked Meth

      The girl's mother told the babysitter not to let the girl anywhere near the pool, police said.

      Cosmopolitan