Taste test: Canned tuna

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best canned tuna taste test

Tuna taste test (Photo: iStockphoto)

Epicurious taste tested 13 canned chunk light tunas, in water and oil, and reeled in a few winners.

Everyone has a preferred flavor enhancer for a "mean" tuna salad—celery, apples, relish, olives...the list goes on. But the key ingredient has got to be the tuna itself: Not even a whole jar of mayonnaise can salvage a smelly, soggy can of fish.








Canned tuna meat should be firm and flaky, but never mushy. It should be moist but not watery (and certainly not dry). And it has to look appetizing before it's dressed up with seductive ingredients.

It was not easy deciding which tunas to feature in our taste test. They come in cans, glass jars, and even pouches, and can be packed in water, vegetable oil, or olive oil. Even more confusing: Tuna varieties sold in cans include albacore, yellowfin, skipjack, and tongol. After much research, we chose to focus our test on canned chunk light skipjack and tongol in both water and oil. Why? Light meat, ie: chunk light tuna (in oil and water) accounts for 75 to 80 percent of annual domestic canned tuna consumption in the U.S., according to The Tuna Council.

(See more: Best and worst bbq sauces)

There is a health issue too: Chunk light skipjack and tongol generally have lower levels of mercury than albacore and yellowfin (for more information, read Mercury in Canned Tuna and the Seafood Selector entry on canned tuna from the Environmental Defense Fund).

To "catch" the best chunk light canned tuna, we tasted 12 varieties available nationwide, including the following, listed from highest to lowest score in our tests: 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water, Starkist Gourmet Choice Solid Light Tuna Fillet in Olive Oil*, Wild Planet Wild Skip Jack Light Tuna (no water)*, Miramonte Tongol Tuna in Spring Water**, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Water**, Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Water, Cento Solid Pack Light Tuna, Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil, Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil, and Progresso Solid Light Tuna in Olive Oil.

(The brands marked with * received the same score. The same is true for those marked with **.)

Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of chunk light canned tuna. All were drained and served as is (without any mayonnaise or other condiments or garnishes). We ranked them according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being the best). One tuna was a real catch, while two others got good marks from the judges.


View gallery

.
Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water
Best Overall

Epi Top Pick: Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Chunk Light Tongol Tuna Packed in Spring Water ($1.39 for 6 oz. can)

Pros: Aside from being the least expensive of all the winners, this firm yet chunky (not mushy) light-colored tuna impressed tasters.

"It has a subtle, clean ocean flavor; it tastes natural," said one editor. "I love how it's firm yet chewy, and perfectly salted," observed another.

Cons: Appeared dry at first glance.


View gallery

.
Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil

First Runner-Up: Bumble Bee Chunk Light Tuna in Oil ($1.89 for 5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated the firm white fish meat, which had a slight smoky accent to it. One taster noted: "This is the first canned tuna I've enjoyed without tons of added mayo."

Cons: Salty and slightly oily.



View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water
Second Runner-Up: Trader Joe's Tongol Chunk Light in Water ($1.89 for 6.5 oz. can)

Pros: Editors appreciated this tuna's moist appearance and chewy texture. "It tastes like fish but it's not too pungent and has no aftertaste," said one judge. Environmentally minded shoppers may also appreciate that this tuna is marketed as wild-caught.

Cons: The meat's two-toned coloring (with reddish and yellow patches) might be unappetizing to some.


The Other Contenders

Progresso brand may have won our taste buds over in the Chicken Noodle Taste Test , but their tuna product was judged the least desirable among the 12 competitors in this taste test. Editors were turned off by the "pungent" fishy smell and its lingering aftertaste.

Two other well known name brands did not fare well: Starkist Chunk Light Tuna in Vegetable Oil was described as bland and chalky, while Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil appeared soft, mushy, and overly moist. But judges did commend Starkist for not being overly salty, and the Chicken of the Sea tuna's "smokiness" convinced judges that it would be more appealing once drained and mixed with a dollop of mayo.



Prices and availability subject to change.

More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Kendall Jenner’s See-through Top Leaves Photographers Seeing Stars

      Kendall Jenner dazzled the crowd in a black and white plaid gown as she walked the runway for Givenchy’s fall/winter 2017-2018 collection at Paris Fashion Week on Friday. But it was on the streets of the City of Light on Saturday where the 21-year-old supermodel really left photographers seeing stars.

      People
    • 10 Facts About Charles Manson's Imprisonment That Will Disgust You

      Infamous convicted murderer Charles Manson has spent nearly five decades imprisoned since his death sentence in 1971 was commuted to life. Suffice it to say that his peculiar behavior behind bars is far from that of a model prisoner. The following 10 facts take a glimpse into the life of a caged madman as well as the bizarre fan base his lunacy attracts. 10 A Disturbing Fan Base Despite the fact that Manson undoubtedly has had a lot of “alone” time—over four decades locked away in protective custody in a California state prison—he receives plenty of fan mail to keep him occupied as well as continuous meet-and-greet requests. In fact, Manson has received more mail than any other prisoner in the

      Listverse q
    • Steelers forced to evacuate hotel at 3 am after a Boston-area man allegedly pulled a fire alarm

      The Pittsburgh Steelers may not have a full night of sleep as they go into the biggest game of...

      Business Insider
    • Michelle Obama's side-eye during Donald Trump inauguration becomes hilarious Twitter meme

      Michelle Obama has won the internet again, with her side-eye during President Donald Trump's inauguration held on 20 January. The former first lady's facial expressions during the event have been turned into one of the best memes on Twitter. The Obamas welcomed the Trump family into the White House with a gift, but Michelle's sideward glance while receiving a gift wrapped present from Melania has sent Twitter users into a frenzy.

      International Business Times UK q
    • Obama Can’t Stop Speechifying As President Trump Signs First Bill, Forcing TV Networks To Make Choices

      “Michelle and I, we really have been milking this goodbye thing,” former President Barack Obama said, accurately, today as he began to give yet another speech, not long after President Donald Trump delivered his Inaugural Address. “So it behooves me to be brief,” he told staff and supporters at Joint Base Andrews, as cable news networks attempted to cover Obama while simultaneously covering Trump as he began signing orders immediately after leaving the site of his…

      Deadline
    • We Need to Talk About That Hot Mesh Swimsuit Jennifer Lawrence Wears in Passengers

      It's not uncommon for us to leave the movie theater itching to shop. This year gave way to plenty of films packed with stylish looks, from Natalie Portman's Chanel suit in Jackie to Emma Stone's yellow dress in La La Land. While you might not expect Passengers to be a film that sparks your fashion senses, it turns out Jennifer Lawrence couldn't leave us hanging. The actress, who plays Aurora, wears a white mesh one-piece throughout a handful of scenes, including the clip below. Its zipper-front closure lends it a sporty touch, but the piece reminds us of a lingerie bodysuit, making it equally sexy. If you're headed somewhere warm, it's just the right time to pick up the Melissa Odabash design.

      PopSugar q
    • The Fried Chicken Everyone Is Talking About In Your State (52 photos)

      With help from our friends at Foursquare , we found the best-rated fried chicken spots across America. Did we get your state right? From Delish

      Delish
    • After Being Stared Down by a Couple in Cracker Barrel, This Dad Received a Note About Parenting

      When Kevon Smith Sr. sat down for breakfast at Cracker Barrel with his son Kevon Jr. in Willoughby, OH, he had no idea he was going to make headlines just for being a good dad. Kevon noticed a couple staring and smiling at him and his 3-month-old son, and although he was confused, he just went on with the meal. "I noticed this older couple over in the corner," he said. "They kept smiling at me and I was looking at my son like, 'What is going on?'" But when Kevon left the restaurant, it all made sense, as he saw a note on his car from the couple praising his parenting along with cash to cover his breakfast. "Today your meal is on my wife and me," it read. "Enjoy that baby as long as God intends.

      PopSugar q
    • Punter Pat McAfee Fired Off A Tweetstorm About The Colts GM Right After He Was Fired

      The Indianapolis Colts fired GM Ryan Grigson on Saturday. It seemed like a move that needed to happen, as Indy’s on-field performance over the last few years has declined while rumblings of a rift between Grigson and Chuck Pagano have been out there for a while. McAfee has been in Indianapolis since 2009, so he’s seen the inner workings of this organization before and during the Grigson years.

      UPROXX
    • Ivanka Trump Has a Princess Moment in Carolina Herrera at Inaugural Balls

      For inauguration events, Ivanka Trump wore three Oscar de la Renta ensembles. But for the grand finale, the first daughter switched things up and opted for a piece from Carolina Herrera.

      Yahoo Style
    • Husband sends marriage to the dogs

      Dear Amy: Shortly after my husband and I began dating, he bought a large-breed puppy. He took the dog everywhere he went. We then moved in together, we got another small, mixed-breed dog that we hoped would keep the large dog busy, since he was always demanding my husband's attention. One evening, the large dog snapped at me (he was 6 years old at this point). My husband was very upset, and he was going to put him down, for fear that he had "turned." I begged him not to. About four months later, the large dog growled at me, and my husband took him to the pen outside. While outside, the dog bit my husband several times, so he was put down. My husband now wants to get another dog of the same breed

      Chicago Tribune q
    • Someone tripped the fire alarm overnight at the Steelers team hotel in New England

      Pittsburgh TV station KDKA reported someone caused a false fire alarm at the Steelers team hotel around 3 a.m. local time on Sunday morning. #BREAKING: Confirmed false alarm at #Steelers hotel in Boston.

      SB Nation q
    • Julie Bowen Faces Criticism for Joking About Barron Trump During Inauguration

      Julie Bowen has come under fire for her comments about Barron Trump. Julie Bowen made Donald Trump’s inauguration more fun to watch, but not everyone appreciated her witty banter. The Modern Family star, who often details the funny antics of her own three sons, posted a few Instagram photos during the ceremony focusing on Barron Trump, the 10-year-old son of the new president and his wife, Melania.

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • Barron Trump plays peekaboo with nephew while his father signs first presidential documents

      President Trump's 10-year-old son, Barron, played peekaboo with his nephew, Theodore, while his father was signing his first official documents as president.

      Yahoo News Video
    • 2 Reasons It's Dumb to Take Social Security Benefits at 62 -- The Motley Fool

      If you find yourself in one of these two circumstances, claiming Social Security early is dangerous and dumb.

      The Motley Fool q
    • Trump's Press Secretary Falsely Claims: 'Largest Audience Ever to Witness an Inauguration, Period'

      In his first official White House briefing, Sean Spicer blasted journalists for “deliberately false reporting,” and made categorical claims about crowd-size at odds with the available evidence.

      The Atlantic q
    • Michelle Obama was given a gift and didn’t know what to do with it and we’re like “girl, same”

      If you’ve ever been on the receiving end of a gift, you know it can sometimes be kind of awkward. Don’t get us…

      Hello Giggles
    • Bella Hadid Wears Totally Sheer Shirt Without a Bra -- See the Daring Pic!

      The 20-year-old model was spotted out in Paris on Friday.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Federer shows iron-man quality to reach quarters

      By Ian Ransom MELBOURNE (Reuters) - Roger Federer showed his 35-year-old legs may yet still carry him to a long-awaited 18th grand slam title as he overhauled fifth seed Kei Nishikori in a five-set slog to reach the Australian Open quarter-finals on Sunday. Having issued a reminder of his class in the 90-minute rout of Tomas Berdych, Federer flaunted his endurance by prevailing 6-7(4) 6-4 6-1 4-6 6-3 after a three hour and 26 minute battle under the lights at Rod Laver Arena. After six months out of the game to recover from a knee injury, Federer's fairytale return will continue against giant-killing German Mischa Zverev, who sensationally ousted top seed Andy Murray on the same centre court only hours before.

      Reuters