Taste test: Best canned tomatoes

The Daily Meal

View gallery

.
Scalfani

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

This time of year, the last thing anybody should be eating is fresh tomatoes. Usually imported from Mexico, they're bland, juiceless, and mealy, not even a vague recollection of what a tomato in the summer tastes like, and the hothouse-grown ones aren't much better.

So what about canned tomatoes?





Now before you scoff, turn up your nose, and walk away in disgust, muttering something about never choosing canned food over fresh, bear in mind that a good canned tomato product should taste better, much better, than a "fresh" tomato in winter. It should have a nice balance of sweet and tangy, and be soft enough to break down nicely when making sauce, but not so soft as to be "mushy." But most importantly, it should taste like, well, a tomato.

Granted, nobody's going to be making salsa or salads with canned tomatoes, but if your heart's desire is a nicely balanced tomato sauce for your pasta dish, or a base to flavor a soup or stew, a canned tomato product is the way to go. That is, unless you happen to be of Italian-American descent, in which case you probably spent one last weekend in summer jarring tomatoes with the family, and this story will likely serve as mere entertainment. The rest of us look on in envy.

Either way, we wanted to get to the bottom of this. So we lined up 11 brands and eight members of our editorial staff for a classic blind taste test of whole canned tomatoes.


#1 — Sclafani (Pictured above)

Average Score: 82.9/100

Price: $2.59 for 28 ounces ($0.09 per ounce)

"Great texture" and "nice balance" with the right amount of salt and a fresh flavor (as close as canned gets to fresh, at least) helps Sclafani cinch the win.


View gallery

.
Ciao

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#2 — Ciao

Average Score: 81.3/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

These "small dark plum[s]" that "taste like [they] could go right into sauce" are D.O.P. from the Sarnese-Nocerino area of Italy. "It almost tastes like a homemade sauce in and of itself," wrote one editor. If you're looking for a "sweet, meaty" tomato with "perfect tang and sweet balance" this is the one to look for. It's worth every penny.


View gallery

.
Hunt's

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#3 — Hunt's

Average Score: 79.4/100

Price: $2.69 for 28 ounces ($0.10 per ounce)

These "small round tomatoes" have "good tomato flavor" and "good sweet-sharp balance" with a "meaty" and "firm" texture. A good all-purpose canned tomato.




View gallery

.
Vantia

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#4 — Vantia

Average Score: 79.1/100

Price: $4.99 for 35 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

Another imported Italian brand, Vantia's "elongated plum shape" tomatoes did well thanks to "very meaty" texture and juiciness. One editor even went so far as to write, "Great balance across the board; now this I imagine in grandma's sauce."



View gallery

.
Tuttorosso

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#5 — Tuttorosso

Average Score: 75.6/100

Price: $1.69 for 28 ounces ($0.06 per ounce)

These tomatoes were considered "firm" relative to the others, and these "full tomatoes that aren't soggy are good enough to eat alone" wrote one editor. They're "very juicy" with "good structural integrity" wrote another editor. If you're looking for a firm, round tomato with decent flavor, this might be it.



View gallery

.
San Marzano

(Photo: flickr/petit hiboux)

#6 — San Marzano

Average Score: 75.5/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

The San Marzano brand, with its illustrated, elongated red tomatoes on a white background, has become nearly synonymous with "authentic" Italian home cooking, but these aren't Italian at all. They're American-grown, and they don't have the characteristic elongated San Marzano varietal shape; instead, they're round. Although one editor said that he "enjoyed eating it all on its own," others weren't quite convinced. They thought the tomatoes were "watery and bland," that they had a "stewed taste," and were "a bit mushy inside."



View gallery

.
Muir Glen

(Photo: Muir Glen)

#7 — Muir Glen

Average Score: 73.0/100

Price: $3.59 for 28 ounces ($0.13 per ounce)

We were actually expecting a better showing for this popular, premium American brand, but these "plum shaped" tomatoes' "acidic and tangy" flavor didn't sit well with our editors, and their texture, which was "too mushy" meant that this brand scored in the middle of the pack.



View gallery

.
Rega Rega

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#8 — Rega Rega

Average Score: 72.9/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

A brand of D.O.P. tomatoes from the Sarnese-Nocerino area of Italy that made a mediocre showing. These "partly peeled, huge plum[s]" have a "mushy" texture and "no standout flavor." That's disappointing because at $0.14 per ounce, it's on the pricier end of our test suite. Not worth the money.


Click here to see : How More Canned Tomato Brands Ranked



More from The Daily Meal:

15 Best Kitchen Infomercials  

4 New Twists on Ramen

5 Sauces That Will Spruce Up Your Cooking 

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Look at South Dakota State score a playoff TD on this schoolyard trick play

      Bringing the playground to the FCS Playoffs. If South Dakota State ends up beating five-time defending national champion North Dakota State in the FCS Playoffs, this trickeration is something you can point to as a reason.Something straight out of "Little Giants"! This is how South Dakota St. just scored on NDSU...#Jackrabbits #Bison pic.twitter.com/Bl9bJPU5GP— Hobie Artigue (@HobieFOX9) December 10, 2016A 5’10 Brady Mengarelli sneaks in, giving SDSU an early lead in the Fargodome.The concept here is simple. ...

      SB Nation q
    • That Viral Video of a Man Punching a Kangaroo Actually Has a Sad Backstory

      Video of an Australian man boxing a kangaroo to save his dog went viral last week, but there is more to the story than meets the eye. Greig Tonkins and his pals were on a boar hunting trip with their friend Kailem Barwick, a 19-year-old who was diagnosed with terminal cancer, hoping to catch an elusive "tonner"—a wild boar that weighs more than 100 kilograms (around 220 pounds), the Daily Mail reported. This Guy Punched a Kangaroo In Face to Save a Dog During the trip, one of the dogs ran into a kangaroo while chasing a scent. Tonkins quickly ran to the dog's aide and intervened, first distracting the kangaroo and causing it to release the dog from a headlock. Thankfully the dog was wearing protective

      Esquire q
    • Inside Kirk Douglas' 100th Birthday Bash

      Kirk Douglas celebrated a milestone birthday in style. The actor turned 100 years old Friday and feted the occasion with members of his famous family and friends at the Beverly Hills Hotel in California. Douglas' son, Michael, and daughter-in-law Catherine Zeta-Jones, were at the glamorous affair with their children, Dylan Michael and Carys Zeta.

      Good Morning America
    • Happy Holidays from the White House! A History of the Obamas’ Christmas Cards (7 photos)

      During their eight years in D.C., the family has grown increasingly merry and bright

      People
    • Prices for the original iPhone keep getting more and more absurd

      If you happen to have an iPhone 2G laying around, you might be sitting on a nice little payday, especially if you somehow never bothered to take it out of the box. Prices for the original grandaddy of Apple smartphones have steadily climbed over the years, but it's starting to get a little bit crazy. Like many Apple products, pristine examples of old models are often sought for their collectors value, even if the device itself is painfully obsolete. The iPhone is no exception. In fact, it might be the best example yet of just how crazy collector's are willing to go for a boxed, sealed Apple gadget from yesteryear. Sealed in shiny glass cases and wrapped in red ribbons, the last remaining new-in-box original iPhones are selling for thousands upon thousands of dollars, with seemingly no ceiling in sight. The "cheaper" examples are typically mint condition phones in opened boxes, and sell for a few thousand dollars, but don't expect to score a still-wrapped iPhone 2G for less than about $8,000. If you want the top-of-the-line, "display worthy" examples you can plan on a total of $15,000 or more. And no, these aren't just the listed prices for the phones; these are the prices that people are actually paying for the phones, as shown by eBay's completed listings filter. What exactly a person would do with a never-opened original iPhone that they paid $15,000 or more for remains a mystery. Perhaps it looks nice above the fireplace, or maybe it's just a really fancy paperweight. Whatever the reason, people with money to burn clearly love old iPhones.

      BGR News
    • Ask Amy: Ex-husband wants to issue STD warning

      Dear Amy: My wife of more than 40 years and I had a mutual parting of ways five years ago. Though we went our separate ways, we harbor no searing animosity toward each other and we regularly talk in civil and polite tones. My former wife thought I was going in the wrong direction, but I quickly made an effort to meet a new woman through online dating. I was successful in that venture. My ex joined many different clubs and organizations and eventually fell in with a man whose company she enjoys. Happy ending? I wish. I was happy for my ex, but women I met online told me that this guy continues to occupy a spot in the online dating scene, messaging women about his availability. It is not my business,

      Washington Post q
    • Brian Loncar laid to rest, a week after burying his daughter who killed herself  | Crime

      "Brian Loncar died Sunday because of a broken heart because of Grace," Mike McCurley, a lawyer and close friend, said at the funeral. Hours before his death, Loncar texted McCurley about attending an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting together Monday. Now, McCurley told the audience, he pictured Brian and Grace together in heaven, sitting at a table with God, helping craft "a better marketing system for Christianity." "I can't wait to see what that is," McCurley said.  Loncar was the one to find his daughter's body, Sue Loncar said. In the days afterward, Brian had told Sue he wasn't sure he could keep living. Yet he also pledged to take time off work and find a way for them to be happy again.  He

      Dallas Morning News q
    • ‘Big Bang Theory’ Stars Jim Parsons, Kaley Cuoco Pay Tribute To Simon Helberg

      Simon Helberg is celebrating his 36th birthday today, and his co-stars have shared sweet messages for him on Instagram.

      International Business Times
    • Russia intervened to help Trump win election: intelligence officials

      By John Walcott WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. intelligence analysts have concluded that Russia intervened in the 2016 election to help President-elect Donald Trump win the White House, and not just to undermine confidence in the U.S. electoral system, a senior U.S. official said on Friday. U.S. intelligence agencies have assessed that as the 2016 presidential campaign progressed, Russian government officials devoted increasing attention to assisting Trump's effort to win the election, the U.S. official familiar with the finding told Reuters on Friday night, speaking on condition of anonymity. The president-elect's transition office released a statement that exaggerated his margin of victory and attacked the U.S. intelligence community that Trump will soon command, but did not address the analysts' conclusion.

      Reuters
    • Dana White Says Joe Rogan is Going Nowhere

      Chuck Liddell and Matt Hughes may have recently lost their “lifetime” positions with the UFC, but company president Dana White said that as long as commentator Joe Rogan doesn't want to leave that he's going nowhere. While there had been talk that new UFC owners WME-IMG might be willing to cut longtime broadcast team Mike Goldberg and Rogan loose in pursuit of a new television deal, at least one half of the team appears safe.

      MMA Weekly
    • South Dakota State ran the craziest trick play at the goal line and scored

      North Dakota State has won five straight FCS championships, so it’s going to take some extra effort from South Dakota State to knock the Bison off. Perhaps that was in the back of Jackrabbits’ coaches’ minds when the offense pulled off this incredible trick play on a first-and-goal early in their playoff game: Wow. From another angle in GIF form: That is some sneaky stuff right there. They basically hid a short runner who knelt behind the line, quietly waited a few seconds after the snap and let him run as the defense bit on the fake quarterback run the other way. See? I told you FCS football is awesome.

      For The Win q
    • San Jose teacher booked on charges of felony sexual assault with minor

      A San Jose high school community is in shock this morning, over the arrest of one of their teachers. Police accuse her of luring a student into a sexual relationship.

      KGO – San Francisco
    • Kirk Douglas Turns 100 — With Help From Son Michael and Catherine Zeta-Jones

      The Spartacus star, who was given an honorary Academy Award in 1996 for his many accomplishments in the movie biz, hasn’t made public appearances in the past few years, and although he’s not on social media himself, he’s getting birthday wishes from his nearest and dearest. Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta-Jones, of course, led the charge, paying tribute to “Dad” and “Pappy” — with the actress posting an especially cute video featuring Kirk the Dancing King.

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • Horace Grant Didn't Always Need Those Goggles, But He Kept Wearing Them For The Kids

      Horace Grant is a four-time NBA champion, but the most famous thing about him might be his eyewear. On Thursday, the NBA world learned why he wore those goggles all those years. Grant, as the story went for years, was legally blind and needed them to see.

      UPROXX
    • Inside Edition
    • ESPN's ratings are suffering, but they're far from the only ones. Here's who else is on the wane

      Most big channels lost subscribers this year, but some less-expensive options have gained ground.

      CNBC
    • People
    • Trump reportedly settles on Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson as secretary of state

      President-elect Donald Trump has reportedly selected Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson to be his...

      Business Insider
    • A Projected New York Yankees Rotation for 2017

      While the top of their staff is set, the New York Yankees rotation for 2017 has several wild cards. Here are our picks for the 5 spots.

      The Cheat Sheet q 18 min ago
    • These pics of Nina Dobrev dressed in silver will finally convince you to give body suits a chance

      We’re all about trying new trends, but one that has us a little hesitant is that one-piece body suit trend. We get…

      Hello Giggles