Taste test: Best canned tomatoes

The Daily Meal

View gallery

.
Scalfani

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

This time of year, the last thing anybody should be eating is fresh tomatoes. Usually imported from Mexico, they're bland, juiceless, and mealy, not even a vague recollection of what a tomato in the summer tastes like, and the hothouse-grown ones aren't much better.

So what about canned tomatoes?





Now before you scoff, turn up your nose, and walk away in disgust, muttering something about never choosing canned food over fresh, bear in mind that a good canned tomato product should taste better, much better, than a "fresh" tomato in winter. It should have a nice balance of sweet and tangy, and be soft enough to break down nicely when making sauce, but not so soft as to be "mushy." But most importantly, it should taste like, well, a tomato.

Granted, nobody's going to be making salsa or salads with canned tomatoes, but if your heart's desire is a nicely balanced tomato sauce for your pasta dish, or a base to flavor a soup or stew, a canned tomato product is the way to go. That is, unless you happen to be of Italian-American descent, in which case you probably spent one last weekend in summer jarring tomatoes with the family, and this story will likely serve as mere entertainment. The rest of us look on in envy.

Either way, we wanted to get to the bottom of this. So we lined up 11 brands and eight members of our editorial staff for a classic blind taste test of whole canned tomatoes.


#1 — Sclafani (Pictured above)

Average Score: 82.9/100

Price: $2.59 for 28 ounces ($0.09 per ounce)

"Great texture" and "nice balance" with the right amount of salt and a fresh flavor (as close as canned gets to fresh, at least) helps Sclafani cinch the win.


View gallery

.
Ciao

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#2 — Ciao

Average Score: 81.3/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

These "small dark plum[s]" that "taste like [they] could go right into sauce" are D.O.P. from the Sarnese-Nocerino area of Italy. "It almost tastes like a homemade sauce in and of itself," wrote one editor. If you're looking for a "sweet, meaty" tomato with "perfect tang and sweet balance" this is the one to look for. It's worth every penny.


View gallery

.
Hunt's

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#3 — Hunt's

Average Score: 79.4/100

Price: $2.69 for 28 ounces ($0.10 per ounce)

These "small round tomatoes" have "good tomato flavor" and "good sweet-sharp balance" with a "meaty" and "firm" texture. A good all-purpose canned tomato.




View gallery

.
Vantia

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#4 — Vantia

Average Score: 79.1/100

Price: $4.99 for 35 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

Another imported Italian brand, Vantia's "elongated plum shape" tomatoes did well thanks to "very meaty" texture and juiciness. One editor even went so far as to write, "Great balance across the board; now this I imagine in grandma's sauce."



View gallery

.
Tuttorosso

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#5 — Tuttorosso

Average Score: 75.6/100

Price: $1.69 for 28 ounces ($0.06 per ounce)

These tomatoes were considered "firm" relative to the others, and these "full tomatoes that aren't soggy are good enough to eat alone" wrote one editor. They're "very juicy" with "good structural integrity" wrote another editor. If you're looking for a firm, round tomato with decent flavor, this might be it.



View gallery

.
San Marzano

(Photo: flickr/petit hiboux)

#6 — San Marzano

Average Score: 75.5/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

The San Marzano brand, with its illustrated, elongated red tomatoes on a white background, has become nearly synonymous with "authentic" Italian home cooking, but these aren't Italian at all. They're American-grown, and they don't have the characteristic elongated San Marzano varietal shape; instead, they're round. Although one editor said that he "enjoyed eating it all on its own," others weren't quite convinced. They thought the tomatoes were "watery and bland," that they had a "stewed taste," and were "a bit mushy inside."



View gallery

.
Muir Glen

(Photo: Muir Glen)

#7 — Muir Glen

Average Score: 73.0/100

Price: $3.59 for 28 ounces ($0.13 per ounce)

We were actually expecting a better showing for this popular, premium American brand, but these "plum shaped" tomatoes' "acidic and tangy" flavor didn't sit well with our editors, and their texture, which was "too mushy" meant that this brand scored in the middle of the pack.



View gallery

.
Rega Rega

(Photo: Jane Bruce)

#8 — Rega Rega

Average Score: 72.9/100

Price: $3.99 for 28 ounces ($0.14 per ounce)

A brand of D.O.P. tomatoes from the Sarnese-Nocerino area of Italy that made a mediocre showing. These "partly peeled, huge plum[s]" have a "mushy" texture and "no standout flavor." That's disappointing because at $0.14 per ounce, it's on the pricier end of our test suite. Not worth the money.


Click here to see : How More Canned Tomato Brands Ranked



More from The Daily Meal:

15 Best Kitchen Infomercials  

4 New Twists on Ramen

5 Sauces That Will Spruce Up Your Cooking 

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Texas Teacher, 27, Accused of Improper Relationship with 17-Year-Old Male Student

      Texas Teacher Allegedly Had Improper Relationship with Student

      People
    • A deleted text message from vengeful gangster may get Aaron Hernandez off hook for double murder

      The text message was sent way back on July 5, 2013. Perhaps because its sender, Alexander Bradley, realized it held unwanted power, like the capability of impacting his immunity deal in an Aaron Hernandez double murder trial, let alone rocking the entire case altogether. In a plea deal, Bradley, however, gave authorities full access to his phone, including deleted and otherwise privileged communication with his lawyer.

      Yahoo Sports
    • We Let Our Baby Cry It Out, and 10 Years Later, This Is What Happened

      Three months into this parenting gig, I'd had enough. Our bedtime routine with our infant son had turned into a two-hour affair that left me and my husband eating dinner at 10 p.m., me up with indigestion for another few hours, and only a few hours of shut-eye before I had to wake up for the day. I was preparing to go back to work, and no amount of concealer, corrector, or eye masks could hide the dark purple circles that had become permanent fixtures under my eyes, never mind function like a thinking adult in an office job. I needed a solution, and I needed one quick. My own parents swore by "Ferberizing" me, and I was willing to give it a try. Ferberizing, or "crying it out," is a sleep training

      PopSugar q
    • Fan wearing Nolan Ryan jersey has no idea he’s two feet from Nolan Ryan

      You have to be a really dedicated Astros fan to show up to a minor league spring training game.

      Sports Illustrated
    • Someone guessed a very wrong answer on last night’s “Wheel of Fortune,” and it’s going viral

      Ever watch a game show and question why the contestants aren’t figuring out the blatantly obvious answer right in front of them?…

      Hello Giggles
    • Trump set his lawyers on a teenage girl who made a fun internet game about him and kittens

      Hell hath no fury like a thin-skinned American president. Donald Trump has reportedly sent in the lawyers on a 17-year-old girl who made a fun web game about him. Players use a cat's paws to bash Trump's head around the page as Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You Up" plays in the background.

      International Business Times
    • Here’s What Neil Gorsuch Said About Maternity Leave

      Watch the tense exchange with a Democratic senator at his hearing.

      Fortune Videos
    • Race in America: White Veteran Kills Black Man in NYC to 'Make A Statement'

      A white Army veteran traveled from Maryland to New York City to kill a black man to "make a statement" in the media capital of the world, New York Police Department officials said Wednesday. Jackson was carrying a handful of knives in his pocket when he arrived at the police station, Reuters reported. Shortly after coming across Timothy Caughman, who was searching through garbage on the street, he stabbed him in the chest and back, police said. Jackson told police he left Baltimore Friday and traveled to New York City by bus "because it is the media capital of the world and he wanted to make a statement," Bill Aubrey, a deputy chief at the New York Police Department, told reporters. "It was revealed that the attack on Timothy Caughman was clearly racially motivated.

      Newsweek
    • Aaron Rodgers' Green Bay house is for sale, and you might even be able to afford it!

      We don’t dabble in real estate too much here at the Shutdown Corner, but we just could not help ourselves with this listing that came on the market — and onto our radar.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Inside Edition
    • How NBA is changing with sex more accessible

      NBA road teams are playing with historic levels of clear-headed competence, and one general manager knows who — make that what — to thank: Tinder. “No need to go to the clubs all night anymore,” the GM told ESPN for an in-depth feature about NBA players’ partying habits — to summarize: bottle service and dimly lit pick-ups mostly have been replaced by room service and app-arranged hook-ups. Messaging through Instagram actually is preferred to Tinder, according to ESPN. Players are known to have hotels leave keys for their road romances to get into their rooms before they even arrive. “It’s absolutely true that you get at least two hours more sleep getting laid on the road today versus 15 years

      New York Post q
    • Ex-Teacher Accused of Kidnapping Student Researched Teen Marriage a Week Before Disappearance

      Tad Cummins Researched Teen Marriage a Week Before Allegedly Kidnapping His Student

      People
    • The Trump kids are in Aspen and it's ruining everyone else's hygge

      It is uncool to stay home during spring break, so the Trump kids are vacationing in Aspen with their families this week. Unfortunately, they seem to be making everyone around them miserable. According to Vanity Fair, numerous other vacationers are not pleased with the chaos Ivanka, Eric and Donald "Stump", Jr. seem to have brought with them to Colorado — including unbearable traffic, crowded restaurants and a rumored 100-person security presence. SEE ALSO: The internet isn't too happy about Ivanka Trump's fancy dress tweet "They're everywhere. There are so many of them," one mom said. "Everyone is complaining. Everyone is annoyed." And with good reason. How is anyone supposed to relax and embrace hygge with such a strong odor of complicity in the air? To be fair, the Trumps have had a hectic week too. Eric and his wife Lara announced that they're having a baby, and little Tristan Trump broke his leg on the slopes.  Eric and I are excited to add a boy to our pack in September!  #BabyTrump A post shared by Lara Trump (@laraleatrump) on Mar 20, 2017 at 8:27am PDT Tiffany Trump, for the record, did not go to Aspen. Perhaps she is in Gulf Shores instead. WATCH: Trump never has to buy sunglasses again because Obama's photographer will shade him forever

      Mashable
    • ‘Wheel of Fortune’ contestant had all but 1 letter and still got phrase wrong

      This is heartbreaking. OMG this just Happened.pic.twitter.com/Q0CYxM8jJB— ⛄Mike☃️ (@MBragiel) March 21, 2017No. No. No. No. This actually happened?On Tuesday, a contestant on Wheel of Fortune was literally one letter away from winning. The answer should have been staring them right in the face. A Streetcar NAMED Desire.Even if you’re not familiar with the play, the word name just fits perfectly. ...

      SB Nation q
    • Shop Bella Hadid's Sexy Cut-Out Swimsuit For Your Next Vacation (106 photos)

      While it's easy to dress straight from the latest runways when you're a celebrity, these A-Listers prove it's still possible (and just as easy) to look chic in budget-friendly fashion. Click through to shop the latest celebrity looks, all for under $250 , that won't break the bank. From Harper's BAZAAR

      Harper's Bazaar
    • A teen made a website where kittens punch Trump. So, Trump unleashed his lawyers.

      President Trump is busy this week helping to make sure millions of Americans don't lose their health insuran — -sorry, I mean, shutting down a teenage girl. 17-year-old Lucy from San Francisco recently designed a site called Kittenfeed.com (initially called TrumpScratch), where users get to punch Trump's face with tiny little kitchen paws. It seemed like a pretty harmless, anti-Trump site (the kittens don't even scratch!) — until she got a letter from the lawyers of a certain "well known businessman," The Observer reports.  SEE ALSO: People can't stop sharing this cartoon about Trump's 'Muslim ban' That "internationally known" and "famous" businessman (his lawyers words, not mine) is, of course, Donald Trump. In the letter, Trump's general counsel encourages the teen to cease and desist and shut down the website.  Image: www.kittenfeed.com After receiving the letter, Lucy decided to change the name of the website to Kittenfeed.com. That wasn't enough for Trump's counsel, who reportedly continued to press the 17-year-old girl. The family is waiting to see their next move. "It’s so sad that his administration is focused more on being liked, burying real news and taking down sites like mine as they supposedly make him look bad," Lucy told The Observer. Predictably, Trump's lawyers letter had the opposite effect of their intention. After The Observer published the report yesterday, the site's visitors surged from 3,000 to 50,000. Lesson: you can mess with Trump's lawyers, but don't you ever touch an animated kitten. WATCH: Robotic glove lets people with limited hand mobility perform daily tasks

      Mashable
    • Police: White sword killer went to NY to attack black people

      NEW YORK (AP) — A white U.S. Army veteran from Baltimore bent on making a racist attack took a bus to New York, the "media capital of the world," randomly picked out a black man who was collecting bottles on the street and killed him with a sword, police said Wednesday.

      Associated Press
    • EXCLUSIVE: Brad Pitt 'Speaking Directly' With Angelina Jolie and 'Spending Time' With the Children

      A source tells ET the 53-year-old actor is feeling happy and relieved now that the custody battle has died down.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Texas teacher grins in mugshot after being arrested for sexual relationship with student

      A science teacher was all smiles when her mugshot was taken on Monday (20 March), despite facing charges of engaging in a sexual relationship with her student. Sarah Fowlkes, a 27-year-old science teacher from Lockhart, Texas, turned herself in at the Lockhart Police Station on a warrant and was booked into the Caldwell County Jail, police confirmed. Fowlkes, who had worked for the school district since October 2014, was allegedly in a relationship with a 17-year-old male student, the Houston Chronicle reported.

      International Business Times
    • Who is Mary Elizabeth Taylor? Social Media Loses It Over Woman at Gorsuch Hearing

      She's been sitting behind Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch during his confirmation hearings.

      Inside Edition