Taste test: All-beef hot dogs

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Hot dogs

(Photo: Thinkstock)

After a blind taste test of 13 hot dog brands, we discovered one good enough to eat without a bun—plus two other notable franks.

Admit it: One of the best things about going to any sporting event or barbecue is having an excuse to eat a mouthwatering hot dog. Is it the event that makes the frank or the frank that makes the event? We believe in the power of a good weenie. We think the dog does make the difference.

The ideal frank should be juicy, not mushy. It needs to be firm and have some snap when bitten into. It should have a robust flavor with a good balance of smoke and spice. Most importantly, it should be able to stand on its own, with or without condiments and buns.

To pin down this perfect dog we tasted 13 varieties available nationwide. All brands were all-beef (no pork blends) and fully cooked. Several were marketed as all-natural and/or organic.

Methodology: In a blind taste test, seven judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of the hot dogs one at a time. All dogs were grilled at the same temperature until browned. (Some required more cooking time, since the thickness of the dogs varied.) We ranked them according to the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being highest). One wiener was anointed our top pick, receiving 3 1/2 forks. Two runners-up would certainly find a spot on our grill.



View gallery

.
Nathan's Beef Franks
Best Overall

Epi Top Pick: Nathan's Beef Franks ($5.69 for 8-count pack)

Pros: "This dog has a smoky-sweet spiciness and is perfectly juicy," commented one taster. "I love how it's not mushy like Play-Doh; it has an unyielding consistency and a good wide girth," stated another.

One taster said it best: "I knew it was the winner when I tasted it cold and it was still appetizing."

Cons: A bit greasy.

(See more on Yahoo! Shopping: Laptops, Cell Phones, Women's Fashion)



View gallery

.
Thumann's Beef Frankfurters
First Runner-Up:

Thumann's Beef Frankfurters ($6.99 for 8-count pack; available in more than 38 states, check company Web site for details)

Pros: " There's a pickled sweet aroma, which I could taste in each bite," said one editor. "The neutral color and good, snappy skin made me feel like I was eating a classic New York City street 'furter."

Cons: A little on the skinny side.



View gallery

.
Oscar Meyer Premium Beef Franks
Second Runner-Up:

Oscar Meyer Premium Beef Franks ($2.99 for 8-count pack)

Pros: "This pick has a very distinct taste," said one taster. "It's nicely seasoned with garlic and an intense smokiness that reminds me of beef jerky." Other judges found it not overly greasy and with just the right firm bite.

Cons: This dog was oddly red and the texture spongy.


*Prices and availability subject to change.





More from Epicurious:

Easy Family Dinners

25 Sandwich Makeovers

How to Eat Your Spring Veggies


Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • 'You're a disgrace': Donald Trump Jr slammed for criticising Sadiq Khan only hours after London attack

      The son of U.S. President Donald Trump has been slammed as a ‘disgrace’ after he appeared to criticise London mayor Sadiq Khan on Twitter, only hours after a terror attack at the Houses of Parliament left four people dead – including a police officer.

      Yahoo News UK
    • Lioness attempts to attack tourists but leap falls way short; video

      As a vehicle carrying tourists made its way past a lion enclosure in the Serengeti Safari section of the Estrella Biopark in Montemorelos, Mexico, a lioness went into a crouching position as if stalking the visitors. Then it decided to attack, which was a horrible idea by Elsa the lioness, as footage captured by tourist Jan Adrian Diaz proves: The lioness obviously underestimated its leaping ability as it fell into the large moat that surrounds the enclosure and keeps tourists safe for instances such as these. Elsa wasn’t even close to reaching the other side of the trench. The male lion, meanwhile, remained lying in its position, no doubt unimpressed by the lioness’ antics. A park spokesperson

      GrindTV.com q
    • Kelvin Gastelum Surprised Anderson Silva Accepted the Fight

      Following his UFC Fight Night Fortaleza first-round knockout win over Vitor Belfort, Kelvin Gastelum called for a fight against former middleweight champion Anderson Silva. A couple of days after the callout, Silva agreed to face Gastelum at UFC 212 on June 3 in Rio de Janeiro.

      MMA Weekly
    • A deleted text message from vengeful gangster may get Aaron Hernandez off hook for double murder

      The text message was sent way back on July 5, 2013. Perhaps because its sender, Alexander Bradley, realized it held unwanted power, like the capability of impacting his immunity deal in an Aaron Hernandez double murder trial, let alone rocking the entire case altogether. In a plea deal, Bradley, however, gave authorities full access to his phone, including deleted and otherwise privileged communication with his lawyer.

      Yahoo Sports
    • Aaron Rodgers' Green Bay house is for sale, and you might even be able to afford it!

      We don’t dabble in real estate too much here at the Shutdown Corner, but we just could not help ourselves with this listing that came on the market — and onto our radar.

      Shutdown Corner
    • What Happened to ‘The Little Couple’? Get the Latest on Jen Arnold and Bill Klein and Their Show!

      A lot of reality shows have come and gone — but few captured our hearts quite like The Little Couple! Since fans first met Jen Arnold and Bill Klein back in 2009, we watched them adopt two children, rooted for Jen as she battled cancer, and so much more. But since the final episode of Season 8 aired more than a year ago, fans have often asked what happened to The Little Couple? Right now, it would appear that The Little Couple is in “limbo” because of a lawsuit between LMNO, the series’ production company, and Discovery, TLC’s parent network. Back in June, LMNO filed a $7 million breach-of-contract and copyright infringement against Discovery — in which they accuse the network giant of conspiring

      In Touch Weekly q
    • Rick Perry accuses Texas A&M’s first gay student body president of stealing election

      Bobby Brooks, a junior at Texas A&M, made history this month when he was elected as the university’s first openly gay student body president. Nearly two decades prior, Rick Perry, also an A&M alumnus, made his own bit of university history when he became the first Aggie to serve as governor of Texas. But for their shared school pride, these men and their accomplishments had nothing to do with each other. That changed Wednesday, when Perry, the country’s current energy secretary chose to plunge into campus politics, claiming publicly that Brooks stole the election from another student. That student, Robert McIntosh, is the son of a prominent Republican fundraiser in Dallas who campaigned for Trump

      Washington Post q
    • Flying from New York to London in 3 hours could soon be a...

      Boom Supersonic is working to bring supersonic travel to transoceanic travelers in just a few years.

      CNBC Videos
    • Shop Bella Hadid's Sexy Cut-Out Swimsuit For Your Next Vacation (106 photos)

      While it's easy to dress straight from the latest runways when you're a celebrity, these A-Listers prove it's still possible (and just as easy) to look chic in budget-friendly fashion. Click through to shop the latest celebrity looks, all for under $250 , that won't break the bank. From Harper's BAZAAR

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Donald Trump Jr sparks storm over terror comments made by London Mayor Sadiq Khan

      Donald Trump Jr slammed the mayor of London on Wednesday (22 March) just hours after the deadly terror attack in Westminster that has left at least four dead, including the attacker. The eldest son of President Donald Trump tweeted: "You have to be kidding me?!: Terror attacks are part of living in big city, says London Mayor Sadiq Khan," along with a link to an article by The Independent from September 2016.

      International Business Times
    • Dear Abby: Friends are ignoring the loss of our cat

      DEAR ABBY: We recently lost one of our cherished pets, our oldest cat, Mandy. We never had children, so our pets ARE our children. I get that people who have never had pets don’t understand the joy and unconditional love they can bring. But I don’t understand why people we thought were close to us haven’t acknowledged our loss in any way. Some of them have — or had — pets at one time. A few did send cards or emails, and they were so appreciated. Their kindness will never be forgotten. Mandy wasn’t sickly. She just stopped eating one day. When we took her to the vet a few days after trying everything we could think of, the diagnosis was kidney cancer. A couple of days later we had to make the

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • Apple just bought the app it once crowned 'most innovative' and made it free for everyone

      If you can't beat it, buy it. That's what Apple did on Wednesday when it acquired an app...

      Business Insider
    • Inside Edition
    • Someone guessed a very wrong answer on last night’s “Wheel of Fortune,” and it’s going viral

      Ever watch a game show and question why the contestants aren’t figuring out the blatantly obvious answer right in front of them?…

      Hello Giggles
    • Teen Mom 2: Javi Marroquin finally confesses how he learnt about ex Kailyn Lowry's pregnancy

      Reality TV couple Javi Marroquin and Kailyn Lowry never fail to surprise their fans – whether it is their shocking divorce news or the recent pregnancy announcement. The Teen Mom 2 star Javi has now made a confession about his ex's baby news and revealed how he got to know that Kailyn was expecting. "Lincoln is actually the one who told me [Kailyn] was having a baby," the 24-year-old reality TV star told E! News.

      International Business Times
    • SB Nation q
    • Video shows suspected London attacker barreling across Westminster Bridge

      Dramatic video of Wednesday's terrorist incident in London shows the suspected attacker barreling across Westminster Bridge in a car. Surveillance video of the bridge broadcast by the BBC this evening shows the car weaving in and out of traffic as it crosses the bridge. A seriously injured woman was later pulled from the river and received medical treatment, an official with the Port of London Authority told ABC News.

      Good Morning America
    • The Trump kids are in Aspen and it's ruining everyone else's hygge

      It is uncool to stay home during spring break, so the Trump kids are vacationing in Aspen with their families this week. Unfortunately, they seem to be making everyone around them miserable. According to Vanity Fair, numerous other vacationers are not pleased with the chaos Ivanka, Eric and Donald "Stump", Jr. seem to have brought with them to Colorado — including unbearable traffic, crowded restaurants and a rumored 100-person security presence. SEE ALSO: The internet isn't too happy about Ivanka Trump's fancy dress tweet "They're everywhere. There are so many of them," one mom said. "Everyone is complaining. Everyone is annoyed." And with good reason. How is anyone supposed to relax and embrace hygge with such a strong odor of complicity in the air? To be fair, the Trumps have had a hectic week too. Eric and his wife Lara announced that they're having a baby, and little Tristan Trump broke his leg on the slopes.  Eric and I are excited to add a boy to our pack in September!  #BabyTrump A post shared by Lara Trump (@laraleatrump) on Mar 20, 2017 at 8:27am PDT Tiffany Trump, for the record, did not go to Aspen. Perhaps she is in Gulf Shores instead. WATCH: Trump never has to buy sunglasses again because Obama's photographer will shade him forever

      Mashable
    • Trump Jr. Called a 'Disgrace' for Criticizing London Mayor

      London (AP) -- Donald Trump Jr. is facing criticism for tweeting in the hours after Wednesday's London attack a months-old comment from London Mayor Sadiq Khan that terror attacks are part of living in ...

      Bloomberg
    • Sharna Burgess and Bonner Bolton Address Dating Rumors After Steamy DWTS Premiere: 'We Are Not a Couple'

      DWTS: Sharna Burgess and Bonner Bolton Address Dating Rumors, Unintentional Grab

      People