Supermarket standoff: Dill pickles

Bon Appetit
Pickle taste test

Photo: iStockPhoto

We have embarked on a taste test tour of supermarket foods. We nibble, we score, and we share the results to help you avoid the paralysis of Brand Choice Overload.

Today's topic: pickles.

Taste tests like those required for this Supermarket Standoff series have the potential to ruin your childhood. When a brand you grew up with doesn't hold up in a blind tasting, the very foundations of your being seem to crumble (as ours did with ice cream and tomato soup). BA's dill pickle tasting was possibly one of the worst in that category. We just don't know what to believe anymore.

After this jarring (ha!) experience, we recommend that you make your own pickles with this awesome recipe. But if you MUST purchase a jar, we've done the work to determine which is the best, flavor-wise; we also had nutritionist Marissa Lippert pore over the ingredient information to determine which brands are healthiest. To the results!


View gallery

.
Walmart Great Value Dill Spears

Photo courtesy of Walmart.com

Our Favorites for Flavor


#1. Walmart Great Value Dill Spears (TIE)

Nutrition: One serving (28 g) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Saturated Fat (g) 0; Cholesterol (mg) 0; Sodium (mg) 210; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Sugars (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: Cucumbers, Water, Distilled Vinegar, Salt, Calcium Chloride, Polysorbate 80, Natural Flavor, Yellow 5.
Cost: $1.96 at Walmart near Boston, MA.
Blind Tasting Notes: "Tastes like a cafeteria pickle" that's "sort of mushy." Some didn't like the "neon glow," but appreciated the "milder tang" and the "briny, sweet flavor." Overall, a "classic dill spear."

(See also: Photos from food ads vs. the real thing)



View gallery

.
Boar's Head Whole Kosher Dill

Photo courtesy of boarshead.com

#1. Boar's Head Whole Kosher Dill (TIE)

Nutrition: One serving (1/2 pickle) contains: Calories (kcal) 5; Total Fat 0g; Sodium 290mg; Total Carbohydrate 1g; Protein 0g.
Ingredients: Cucumbers, Water, Vinegar, Salt, Garlic, Spices, Natural Flavors, Calcium Chloride, 1/10 of 1% Sodium Benzoate as a Preservative, EDTA, Tumeric.
Cost: $3.99 at shoprite.com
Blind Tasting Notes: "Crisp and mild" with a "clean" taste and "great crunch." One taster noted, "the only not bad one."






View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of Trader Joe's

#3. Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Nutrition: One serving (1 oz) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: gherkins, distilled vinegar, salt, mustard seed, granulated garlic, cumin, natural flavorings (dill, garlic), calcium chloride, turmeric.
Cost: $2.29 at Trader Joe's in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: These pickles were "not exciting," but they were a "good middle of the road." They have a "good crunch and bite" and were "tangy enough."



Nutritionist Marissa Lippert's Picks

Comments from Lippert: "All of the pickle brands had essentially the exact same nutrient facts--similar in calories, fat and sodium. We're really just talking cucumbers, salt, vinegar and garlic, here. In order to make my top three choices, I went a step further and weeded out those brands that included more preservatives and/or artificial coloring in the ingredient lists. My picks may spoil a little faster, but I'd much rather chomp on a pickle naturally colored with a bit of turmeric instead of food dye.



View gallery

.
Woodstock Organic Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of woodstock-foods.com

Woodstock Organic Kosher Dill Pickles (Deli Style)

Nutrition:One serving (about 1/2 lg. pickle) contains: Calories (kcal) 5; Fat (g) 0g; Sodium (mg) 290; Carbohydrates (g)1g; Total Sugars (g) 0g; Protein (g) 0g.
Ingredients: organic cucumbers, water, organic distilled vinegar, salt, calcium chloride, organic garlic chips, organic dillweed oil, organic gum Arabic, organic natural spice flavors, xanthan gum.
Cost: $5.39 on vitacost.com
Blind Tasting Notes: These came in dead last. Tasters found "hints of dish soap," "too many weird spices," and a "pool water flavor." Although they were nice and crunchy, their flavor did not cut it.




View gallery

.
Whole Foods 365 Organic Kosher Dill Spears

Photo courtesy of Whole Foods

Whole Foods 365 Organic Kosher Dill Spears

Nutrition: One serving (38g/ bout 3/4 spear) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) <1; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: organic cucumbers, water, organic vinegar, salt, organic dehydrated garlic, calcium chloride, natural flavors, organic turmeric (for color).
Cost: $3.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: "Too sour and sweet," but with a "good crunch," and a nice "deli-style appearance."







View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Nutrition: One serving (1 oz) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: gherkins, distilled vinegar, salt, mustard seed, granulated garlic, cumin, natural flavorings (dill, garlic), calcium chloride, turmeric.
Cost: $2.29 at Trader Joe's in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: These were third on our list for flavor. Yay!








More at Bon Appetit:

Bon Appétit's Guide to the Ultimate Burger

25 Ways to Use Sriracha

25 One-Bite Appetizers

10 Quick and Easy School-Night Dinners

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Katie Holmes’ hair transformation is the best cut we’ve seen so far this spring

      ‘Tis the season for spring haircuts! When the weather gets warm again, we love to trade our long locks for something light and airy….

      Hello Giggles
    • Rabbit set to be world's biggest dies on United Airlines flight in fresh PR disaster

      United Airlines has confirmed they are investigating reports that a giant rabbit died while travelling to Chicago on one of its transatlantic flight. Simon, a three-foot continental rabbit, was reportedly travelling from Heathrow to Chicago’s O’Hare Airport after the 10-month old bunny was purchased by a celebrity owner. ‘The client who bought Simon is very famous.

      Yahoo News UK
    • How a Mom's Fitbit Led Police to Charge Her Husband with Her Murder

      How a Mom's Fitbit Led Police to Charge Her Husband with Her Murder

      People
    • ESPN to lay off about 100 employees today, including on-air talent

      It’s a dark day at ESPN. The sports broadcasting network sent a memo to employees early Wednesday, informing them that a series of previously announced layoffs would take place today. The number of employees cut will be around 100, Fox News has learned.  The memo, from ESPN President John Skipper, noted that the network’s new talent lineup will be announced soon. The layoffs are expected to impact some of the network’s popular on-air personalities. “Dynamic change demands an increased focus on versatility and value, and as a result, we have been engaged in the challenging process of determining the talent—anchors, analysts, reporters, writers and those who handle play-by-play—necessary to meet

      Fox News q
    • Can You Spot The Snake In This Photo?

      If you can, you have better eyes than most

      Esquire
    • Tarek El Moussa Just Revealed What Pushed Him to File For Divorce and It Might Shock You

      When Tarek El Moussa filed for divorce from wife and HGTV partner in crime Christina El Moussa in December 2016, we had a lot of questions, and now, he's telling all. Tarek recently sat down with Us Weekly to talk about what caused his split, as well as that shocking incident where Christina called the cops on her then-husband in May of last year. "It was a gradual thing over time," the Flip or Flop star said when asked about what went wrong in his marriage. "We were both very busy people with health issues and kids. We didn't fight, we just grew apart." He explained that his battle with cancer took a toll on their relationship, as well as Christina's fertility issues and their miscarriage after

      PopSugar q
    • America's Ugliest College Campuses (13 photos)

      These college campuses emphasize brains over beauty.

      Travel+Leisure
    • Remember ‘Growing Up Gotti’? See What the Cast Looks Like Today!

      It’s hard to believe that it’s been more than a decade since we first met Victoria Gotti and her three sons on one of TV’s earliest reality shows, Growing Up Gotti! The show followed Victoria — the daughter of famed mob boss John Gotti — as she raised her three spiky-haired, bratty sons, John, Carmine, and Frankie. So what are the boys up to today? Keep reading to find out! Carmine Gotti Agnello (Photo Credit: Getty Images, Instagram) Carmine — the oldest of the family — has stayed out of the spotlight, and has surprisingly kept a lower profile than his brothers since the show went off the air. Based off his social media, it would appear he’s still super close with his brothers and his mom. Today,

      In Touch Weekly q
    • Amazon’s $96 sound bar is so good it doesn’t need a separate subwoofer

      It used to be that if you wanted to add decent sound to your TV, you need to spend upwards of $1,000 on a surround sound system. The the home audio market got much more competitive, and prices began to fall. Things really took a turn when companies began launching sound bars, which cost less to make and didn't require users to run cables all over their homes. Fast-forward to today, and you can get a solid sound bar with a wireless subwoofer for between $200 and $300. And then there's the AmazonBasics 2.1 Channel Bluetooth Sound Bar with Built-In Subwoofer , a 4-star rated home audio solution that costs less than $100. The nifty design builds the sub right into the sound bar itself, delivering great sound, a compact design, and the easiest possible installation. Here are a few more details from the product page: 31.5-inch sound bar with built-in subwoofer enhances home-audio systems (not compatible with universal or TV remotes) Bluetooth technology v2.1 + EDR with A2DP & AVRCP for seamless streaming from various devices Full-range stereo speakers; up to 92 dB (2.1 channels) 4-piece 2-inch round frame; mid- to high-range drivers; 4-by-2.7-inch sub-range driver; 2-piece passive radiator 3 sound modes: Standard, News, and Movie; remote control and wall-mount hardware included; measures 31.5 by 3.2 by 3.5 inches (W x H x D)

      BGR News
    • US Navy fires warning flare at Iran vessel in Persian Gulf

      DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — A U.S. Navy guided-missile destroyer fired a warning flare toward an Iranian Revolutionary Guard vessel coming near it in the Persian Gulf, an American official said on Wednesday, the latest tense naval encounter between the two countries.

      Associated Press
    • High School Student Dies After Being Punched at Party

      An 18-year-old high school student in Illinois who was about the graduate died after police say he was hit during an incident at a party Saturday night.

      Tribune
    • Caitlyn Jenner kept rudely interrupting Kelly Ripa on ‘Live’

      It’s “Live with . . . Caitlyn!” On Tuesday morning’s “Live with Kelly” show, Caitlyn Jenner was a guest — and possibly one of the rudest ever. Jenner, who appeared to promote her memoir, “The Secrets of My Life,” continuously cut off Kelly Ripa and guest co-host, John Leguizamo. At one point, Jenner even turned the tables on Ripa, asking when she first identified as a female. “Just think about that,” she said, pointing her manicured finger at Ripa. “When did you know you were a girl?” Jenner then made Leguizamo her target, asking him how he enjoyed dressing in drag in the 1995 comedy, “To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar.” The painful 15-minute interview consisted of endless, self-congratulatory

      New York Post q
    • ESPN will cut 100 on-air personalities today

      ESPN is cutting 100 on-air personalities, and more than 100 employees in total. It's a result of rising programming costs and falling subscriber numbers. Here are the full details of the layoffs.

      Yahoo Finance
    • Esquire
    • 'Devastated' Chris Soules Speaks Out After Arrest for Allegedly Leaving the Scene of Deadly Crash

      Devastated Chris Soules Speaks Out After Arrest for Allegedly Leaving Scene of Deadly Crash

      People
    • Fox News anchor accuses White House of 'trying to cover up Michael Flynn scandal'

      A Fox News anchor has accused the White House of behaving in a way consistent with a “cover-up” over the actions of former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn. Although the network is frequently accused of being a cheerleader for President Donald Trump, host Shepard Smith did not hold back in his comments, made after the House Oversight Committee said Mr Flynn appeared to have broken the law in receiving payments from Russian organisations and the Turkish Government. Mr Flynn resigned in February after it emerged he had misled Vice President Mike Pence over conversations he had with a Russian ambassador.

      The Independent
    • Man threw girlfriend's autistic twins, 4, into bitterly cold sea while high

      A Boston man is accused of throwing his girlfriend's four-year-old autistic twins into bitterly cold water at a beach on Monday (24 April) while high on heroin. Mikel Anthony Hilerio, 29, of Roxbury, has been charged with two counts of recklessly endangering a child. A police report described the state of the children after troopers were called to the scene by witnesses.

      International Business Times
    • ‘Happy Days’ Star Erin Moran’s Husband Pens Heartbreaking Letter Chronicling Her Cancer Battle

      In the aftermath of former “Happy Days” star Erin Moran’s shocking death this past weekend, rumors have begun to circulate regarding the nature of the actress’ untimely passing. Her co-star Scott Baio added fuel to the fire by saying that he was less than shocked about the news during an interview on “The Bernie and Sid... Read more »

      Variety
    • New Video Shows United Passenger Before Dragging Incident

      A security officer asserted that Dr. David Dao "refused to leave" his seat and "folded his arms tightly,” but his attorney calls the description “utter nonsense.”

      Yahoo View
    • There’s a snake hidden in this photo, and it’s nearly impossible to spot

      As if we needed more proof that snakes are truly the shadiest, here’s something else to justify why we’ve grouped them together…

      Hello Giggles