Supermarket standoff: Dill pickles

Bon Appetit
Pickle taste test

Photo: iStockPhoto

We have embarked on a taste test tour of supermarket foods. We nibble, we score, and we share the results to help you avoid the paralysis of Brand Choice Overload.

Today's topic: pickles.

Taste tests like those required for this Supermarket Standoff series have the potential to ruin your childhood. When a brand you grew up with doesn't hold up in a blind tasting, the very foundations of your being seem to crumble (as ours did with ice cream and tomato soup). BA's dill pickle tasting was possibly one of the worst in that category. We just don't know what to believe anymore.

After this jarring (ha!) experience, we recommend that you make your own pickles with this awesome recipe. But if you MUST purchase a jar, we've done the work to determine which is the best, flavor-wise; we also had nutritionist Marissa Lippert pore over the ingredient information to determine which brands are healthiest. To the results!


View gallery

.
Walmart Great Value Dill Spears

Photo courtesy of Walmart.com

Our Favorites for Flavor


#1. Walmart Great Value Dill Spears (TIE)

Nutrition: One serving (28 g) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Saturated Fat (g) 0; Cholesterol (mg) 0; Sodium (mg) 210; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Sugars (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: Cucumbers, Water, Distilled Vinegar, Salt, Calcium Chloride, Polysorbate 80, Natural Flavor, Yellow 5.
Cost: $1.96 at Walmart near Boston, MA.
Blind Tasting Notes: "Tastes like a cafeteria pickle" that's "sort of mushy." Some didn't like the "neon glow," but appreciated the "milder tang" and the "briny, sweet flavor." Overall, a "classic dill spear."

(See also: Photos from food ads vs. the real thing)



View gallery

.
Boar's Head Whole Kosher Dill

Photo courtesy of boarshead.com

#1. Boar's Head Whole Kosher Dill (TIE)

Nutrition: One serving (1/2 pickle) contains: Calories (kcal) 5; Total Fat 0g; Sodium 290mg; Total Carbohydrate 1g; Protein 0g.
Ingredients: Cucumbers, Water, Vinegar, Salt, Garlic, Spices, Natural Flavors, Calcium Chloride, 1/10 of 1% Sodium Benzoate as a Preservative, EDTA, Tumeric.
Cost: $3.99 at shoprite.com
Blind Tasting Notes: "Crisp and mild" with a "clean" taste and "great crunch." One taster noted, "the only not bad one."






View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of Trader Joe's

#3. Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Nutrition: One serving (1 oz) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: gherkins, distilled vinegar, salt, mustard seed, granulated garlic, cumin, natural flavorings (dill, garlic), calcium chloride, turmeric.
Cost: $2.29 at Trader Joe's in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: These pickles were "not exciting," but they were a "good middle of the road." They have a "good crunch and bite" and were "tangy enough."



Nutritionist Marissa Lippert's Picks

Comments from Lippert: "All of the pickle brands had essentially the exact same nutrient facts--similar in calories, fat and sodium. We're really just talking cucumbers, salt, vinegar and garlic, here. In order to make my top three choices, I went a step further and weeded out those brands that included more preservatives and/or artificial coloring in the ingredient lists. My picks may spoil a little faster, but I'd much rather chomp on a pickle naturally colored with a bit of turmeric instead of food dye.



View gallery

.
Woodstock Organic Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of woodstock-foods.com

Woodstock Organic Kosher Dill Pickles (Deli Style)

Nutrition:One serving (about 1/2 lg. pickle) contains: Calories (kcal) 5; Fat (g) 0g; Sodium (mg) 290; Carbohydrates (g)1g; Total Sugars (g) 0g; Protein (g) 0g.
Ingredients: organic cucumbers, water, organic distilled vinegar, salt, calcium chloride, organic garlic chips, organic dillweed oil, organic gum Arabic, organic natural spice flavors, xanthan gum.
Cost: $5.39 on vitacost.com
Blind Tasting Notes: These came in dead last. Tasters found "hints of dish soap," "too many weird spices," and a "pool water flavor." Although they were nice and crunchy, their flavor did not cut it.




View gallery

.
Whole Foods 365 Organic Kosher Dill Spears

Photo courtesy of Whole Foods

Whole Foods 365 Organic Kosher Dill Spears

Nutrition: One serving (38g/ bout 3/4 spear) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) <1; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: organic cucumbers, water, organic vinegar, salt, organic dehydrated garlic, calcium chloride, natural flavors, organic turmeric (for color).
Cost: $3.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: "Too sour and sweet," but with a "good crunch," and a nice "deli-style appearance."







View gallery

.
Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Photo courtesy of Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's Kosher Dill Pickles

Nutrition: One serving (1 oz) contains: Calories (kcal) 0; Total Fat (g) 0; Sodium (mg) 280; Total Carbohydrate (g) 0; Protein (g) 0.
Ingredients: gherkins, distilled vinegar, salt, mustard seed, granulated garlic, cumin, natural flavorings (dill, garlic), calcium chloride, turmeric.
Cost: $2.29 at Trader Joe's in New York City.
Blind Tasting Notes: These were third on our list for flavor. Yay!








More at Bon Appetit:

Bon Appétit's Guide to the Ultimate Burger

25 Ways to Use Sriracha

25 One-Bite Appetizers

10 Quick and Easy School-Night Dinners

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Ready for Day One: Trump poised to take executive actions

      By Ayesha Rascoe and Julia Edwards Ainsley WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Donald Trump is ready to begin taking executive actions on his first day in the White House on Friday to move quickly on his pledge to crack down on immigration, build a wall on the U.S.-Mexican border and roll back policies of outgoing President Barack Obama. Trump, a Republican elected on Nov. 8, arrived in Washington on Thursday with his family to kick of a weekend of festivities and spoke to a gathering of members of his incoming administration. After being sworn in during a ceremony at the U.S. Capitol on Friday, Trump is poised to wield one of the most powerful tools of his office, the presidential pen, for executive actions that can be implemented without the input of Congress.

      Reuters 8 min ago
    • I tried Whataburger, In-N-Out, and Shake Shack — and the winner is clear

      The INSIDER Summary: • There's always been competition between the east and west coasts when it comes to burgers.  • In-N-Out takes the title as the best burger, but Whataburger's honey chicken biscuits are a solid bet too. Ah, the great debate of burger joints. If you're on the Eastern side of the USA, you may be more of a Shake Shack fan. However, for those of you on the West Coast, you may be more partial to some In-N-Out or Whataburger. Unfortunately for me, I am smack dab in the middle with many other flyover states, and close to none of these amazing burger joints. However, I do travel a lot and have had the opportunity to try all three varieties, time and time again (I just love burgers,

      Business Insider q
    • While Drama Swirls, Olivia Munn Stuns in Yellow Gown

      Olivia Munn looked gorgeous in a yellow gown with a plunging neckline. Despite the fact that Olivia Munn‘s relationship with football player Aaron Rodgers is making headlines, the actress doesn’t appear to be fazed by it. The 36-year-old was recently spotted in a glamorous yellow gown with a plunging neckline while out in New York City.

      Yahoo Style 55 min ago
    • Mark Zuckerberg is suing hundreds of Hawaiians to protect his 700-acre Kauai estate

      Mark Zuckerberg paid close to $100 million for 700 acres of beachfront property on the island of...

      Business Insider
    • Floyd Mayweather Failed Miserably At Trying To Troll Conor McGregor For Being Broke

      Floyd Mayweather is at it again, attempting to antagonize Conor McGregor as they continue their very strange beef and teasing a potential fight between the biggest star in boxing and the biggest star in mixed martial arts. The latest installment in the Mayweather-McGregor saga comes courtesy of Floyd’s Twitter, as he attempted to troll McGregor by comparing the two’s net worths. The reason he did this is because Dana White recently offered both fighters $25 million plus a negotiated pay-per-view revenue split to fight.

      UPROXX
    • Vanderpump Rules stars Stassi Schroeder, Kristen Doute, & Lala Kent In A Twitter War

      Dear Stassi Schroeder, Kristen Doute, and Katie Maloney, Your desperation is showing! And, oh my, that’s that type of thing most ‘nice girls’ would keep tucked away. Although I guess we’re dealing with mean girls here. Now listen, no one said Lala Kent was sweet or innocent, but y’all have been riding her harder than her allegedly married boyfriend is, and it’s a bit ridiculous to equate a few snippy comments with the stalking and harassment on and off Vanderpump Rules. You’re essentially looking jealous. Sincerely, Mary (a nobody with a brain) CLICK THE CONTINUE READING BUTTON FOR MORE! So, in the latest round of crazy Stassi, Kristen, and Katie are feuding with Lala on twitter. And they revealed the

      Reality Tea q
    • Daycare Workers Reveal the Things Parents Do That They Absolutely Hate

      "You spend weeks researching the best caregiver for your child and even longer on our waiting list, but once they're here, it's like you forget all about us."

      Redbook 18 min ago
    • Andrew Napolitano: Attorney General Loretta Lynch and a parting shot at personal freedom

      On Jan. 3, outgoing Attorney General Loretta Lynch secretly signed an order directing the National Security Agency -- America’s 60,000-person-strong domestic spying apparatus -- to make available raw spying data to all other federal intelligence agencies, which then can pass it on to their counterparts in foreign countries and in the 50 states upon request. She did so, she claimed, for administrative convenience. Yet in doing this, she violated basic constitutional principles that were erected centuries ago to prevent just what she did. Here is the back story. In the aftermath of former President Richard Nixon’s abusive utilization of the FBI and CIA to spy on his domestic political opponents

      Fox News q
    • Teen Who Was Kidnapped as a Baby Knew About Abduction, Court Records Say

      The South Carolina woman accused of kidnapping a newborn baby from a hospital in Jacksonville, Florida, in 1998 allegedly admitted to the crime over a year ago, according to court documents obtained by ABC News. Gloria Williams, 51, allegedly abducted Alexis Manigo on July 10, 1998, just hours after she was born at a Jacksonville hospital and raised the girl as her own in South Carolina. Williams allegedly posed as a nurse and told the baby's mother that the newborn had a fever and she needed to take her away, according to Jacksonville Sheriff Mike Williams.

      Good Morning America 26 min ago
    • Browns fire Robert Nunn, finalize five other assistant hires

      The Browns continue to tweak their coaching staff, and have fired another one. The team announced a number of hires, many of which have already been reported. They also added defensive line coach Robert Nunn to the group of fired defensive coaches, though he wasn’t in the initial wave of guys let go. Nunn has 17 years of NFL experience, and was previously with the Giants for six years. “Over the last two weeks I’ve spent a lot of time interviewing coaches and have had some difficult decisions to make,” coach Hue Jackson said in a release. “As I’ve said before, that’s part of my responsibility in my role as head coach of this football team as we are constantly striving for improvement and success.

      NBC Sports: ProFootballTalk q
    • The Rock Brings 15-Year-Old Daughter to the People’s Choice Awards – Then Jokingly Drops the F-Bomb During Acceptance Speech

      When Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson won the 2017 People’s Choice Award for favorite premium series actor on Wednesday, his mini-me was on hand to celebrate. Johnson, who was PEOPLE’s 2016 Sexiest Man Alive, shares Simone with ex Dany Garcia. Simone and Johnson also posed with girl group Fifth Harmony, who are performing for the first time as a foursome at the show.

      People
    • Here's the Growing List of Designers Who Refuse to Dress Melania Trump (10 photos)

      Melania Trump will become First Lady of the United States in January, a gig which typically has fashion designers falling all over themselves with excitement. But thanks to her controversial husband Donald Trump, many prominent designers have gone on the record saying they won't dress (or at least, that they're hesitant to dress) our future FLOTUS. Read their statements here. From Marie Claire

      Marie Claire
    • Dana White offers to pony up $50M for Mayweather-McGregor boxing match

      UFC president Dana White has officially thrown his hat into the Floyd Mayweather- Conor McGregor fantasy sweepstakes. White, during Friday's appearance on The Herd, offered to pay $25 million apiece to Mayweather and McGregor for a presumed boxing match. White's offer comes two days after Mayweather said he would pay McGregor a $15 million base purse to meet him in the ring.

      ABC News q
    • Beauty Secrets I Learned From CoverGirl's Nura Afia

      On brows, lashes, and making history.

      Elle
    • Dodge’s next muscle car will be faster, lighter, more powerful than the Hellcat

      Dodge has announced it will introduce a new variant of the Challenger named Demon at the New York Auto Show. The model will be faster, lighter, and more powerful than the 707-horsepower Hellcat.

      Digital Trends
    • People are talking about the confusing Photoshop fail in Selena Gomez’s Instagram selfie

      We all know that Selena Gomez is beyond beautiful and is no need of Photoshop. But one picture floating around the internet…

      Hello Giggles
    • VIDEO: Driver Licenses From Nine States Won’t Be Valid IDs for Domestic Flights in 2018

      Beginning Jan. 22, 2018, travelers from nine states will no longer be able to travel with only their driver’s licenses.

      Travel & Leisure Video
    • Olivia Munn Sports Sexy Gown for 'Ocean's Eight' Cameo in NYC as Aaron Rodgers' Family Feud Goes Public

      The 36-year-old actress is leaving very little to the imagination!

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Here's how to figure out how much home you can afford

      Self-made millionaire David Bach offers house-hunters a handy tip.

      CNBC