Supermarket standoff: Best bacon

Bon Appetit

View gallery

Bacon taste test

Which bacon scored best? (Photo: iStockphoto)

We have embarked on a taste test tour of supermarket foods. We nibble (or sip), we score, and we share the results to help you avoid the paralysis of Brand Choice Overload.

Today's topic: bacon.

Carnivores, rejoice. This edition of Supermarket Standoff puts front and center the meat that claims unabashed adoration from food writers, chefs, and dudes 'round the world. Bacon has inspired large-scale festivals, questionable hygiene products, and an international holiday. People love bacon.

A lot of it is produced in the U.S.--more than 2 billion pounds each year--which became quite clear when we were researching for this taste test. We whittled down the large volume of brands by choosing classic hickory- or applewood-smoked versions. We included both cured and uncured bacon; the latter is rising in popularity due to health-conscious baconnoisseurs. (Not-so-fun-but-at-least-educational-fact: the term "uncured" is a little misleading, since it's meant to indicate that the bacon is free of pork-preserving sodium nitrite. But uncured bacon generally uses celery juice, which releases natural sodium nitrate and nitrite anyway.)

Some of our tasters prefer their bacon crispy and charred, while others wanted it chewy and ham-like. Whichever camp you're in, you can be guided by both our top picks and nutritionist Marissa Lippert's favorites.

Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon
Our Favorites for Flavor

#1 Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 70 calories, 6g total fat, 2g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 140mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 3g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: 10 Snacks You Thought Were Healthy But Really Aren't

Ingredients: Pork, water, brown sugar, sea salt, celery juice powder, lactic acid starter culture.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Good, homey breakfast bacon"; "This would probably be great for a sandwich but not alone"; "Really good, crispy and flavorful"; "Good salt and pork flavor, not artificial tasting"

(See also: Best potato chips)

Farmland Hickory Smoked Bacon
#2 Farmland Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 80 calories, 7g total fat, 3g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 15mg cholesterol, 260mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: Spring Pasta Recipes

Cured with: Water, salt, sugar, sodium phosphates, sodium erythorbate, sodium nitrite.

Cost: $4.49 at ShopRite in Paramus, NJ.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Smoky and woodsy"; "Tastes like it was cooked by a campfire. I like this"; "Crisped up nicely, nice salt content".

View gallery

#3 Oscar Mayer Naturally Hardwood Smoked Thick Cut Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (1 skillet-cooked slice/12g) = 60 calories, 5g total fat, 1.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 250mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie

Cured with: Water, salt, sugar, sodium phosphates, sodium ascorbate, sodium nitrite.

Cost: $6.99 at The Food Emporium in New York City.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Lots of flavor for a crispy bacon"; "Ham-y"; It's good--not amazing".

Nutritionist Marissa Lippert's Picks

Some comments from Lippert: "The bottom line: bacon is bacon. We all know it's not the best for us in terms of fat and calorie content, but it's pretty darn delectable and just a small amount can add incredible flavor and depth to a dish. So indulge on occasion when you're really craving it.

I sifted through our options by focusing on ingredients, as usual; we're really aiming for pork, water, salt and spices--no other funny stuff necessary to cure good ol' bacon. Then I further sifted by honing in on sodium content. Bacon can be quite salty! Those brands with less salt came to the top of my list.

Be aware of how much salt is sneaking its way into your diet for disease prevention and to keep blood pressure at bay. Some sodium is essential for our bodies, but the daily recommendation is less than 2,300 mg. That's equivalent to about 1 teaspoon of table salt, or less than 1,500 mg if you're 51 and older."

View gallery

#1 Niman Ranch Applewood Smoked Uncured Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (1 skillet-cooked slice/15g) = 70 calories, 7g total fat, 2.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 135mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 2g protein.

Ingredients: Pork prepared with water, salt, turbinado sugar, celery power. Gluten-free.

Cost: $6.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: Shocking! Niman Ranch, an overall great company, turned up dead last for flavor in this competition.

Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon
#2 Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 70 calories, 6g total fat, 2g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 140mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 3g protein.

Ingredients: Pork, water, brown sugar, sea salt, celery juice powder, lactic acid starter culture.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: Hooray! We ranked this numero uno for flavor.

View gallery

Wellshire Thick Sliced Dry Rubbed All Natural Uncured Bacon
#3 Wellshire Thick Sliced Dry Rubbed All Natural Uncured Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/11g) = 60 calories, 3g total fat, 1.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 220mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

Ingredients: Pork, water, sea salt, less than 20% of celery powder and evaporated cane syrup. Gluten and casein free.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: This ranked smack in the middle for us; some thought it was "OK" others said it had an "almost like beef jerky textured when chewed" and other were more direct: "Ew"

*Yahoo! Shopping was not compensated by any brands listed within this article.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Trump used an unusual word in the third debate and now everyone is googling it

      Republican nominee Donald Trump is known for some unusual speech patterns.  During the third...

      Business Insider
    • After ‘jealous rage,’ killer sentenced to life without parole in Target parking lot murder

      The eight-foot projection screen dropped from a courtroom ceiling. The surveillance video began to play. And from her seat in the second row, Cassandra Atkens — in court Thursday to watch her daughter’s killer be sentenced — knew what she was about to see. The video showed how light it still was at 7:17 p.m. June 1, 2015, in a Target store parking lot in Germantown where Atkens’s daughter, Mariam “Shadé” Adebayo, had agreed to meet ex-boyfriend Donald Bricker one more time. She was there to tell him it really was over. He pulled up in his truck, then got in her car and brought out a .44-caliber, replica-style black-powder revolver — a gun that he’d ordered online and that had arrived just that

      Washington Post q
    • Can my family refuse inheritance from my abusive former husband?

      This wife says the last thing she wants is her ex-spouse’s money.

      MarketWatch q
    • 16 Glorious Years of Heidi Klum Slaying at Halloween (17 photos)

      We all know that one person who goes in on Halloween , year after year. Their costumes are always the most original, funny, or downright terrifying at any party, and — let’s be honest — they can make you feel totally low-effort in comparison (yes, even though you went out and purchased Eggo waffles to go with your El from Stranger Things costume). Heidi Klum is obviously that person , only it’s impossible to resent her, because, well, you’ll never find yourself at the same party as her. Klum loves Halloween so much, she’s hosted an annual Halloween bash every year since 2000 (in 2011, she blessed us with two). She’s managed to consistently top her costumes year after year, and it’s an amazing thing to behold. To celebrate the endless font of Heidi’s Halloween inspiration, we put together every look she’s worn over the last 15 years. Read on to see the evolution of Heidi’s Halloween style. See more Halloween style, tricks, and treats!

      Yahoo Style
    • Redskins players and coaches react to 'disrespectful,' 'out of line' Stephen A. Smith

      As he's known to do, ESPN's Stephen A. Smith ranted about the Redskins, calling the team losers. The fuss started in the immediate moments after the Redskins beat the Eagles last Sunday. Chris Baker and Ricky Jean Franois celebrated the win in the tunnel with cameras rolling, and Smith eventually watched the video.

      CSN Mid-Atlantic q
    • Paulina Gretzky pole-dances in Las Vegas

      Dustin Johnson’s future wife documented her night inside Sin City nightclub on Snapchat.

      New York Post q
    • Kate Gosselin Accuses Ex-Husband Jon of Having an “Inappropriate Relationship” With Daughter Hannah, 12 (EXCLUSIVE)

      Kate Gosselin has gone to the police with some serious accusations against her ex-husband, Jon Gosselin. In addition to allegations that he’s a drug dealer, the mom-of-eight, 41, is claiming that the 39-year-old has an “inappropriate relationship” with their 12-year-old daughter Hannah, In Touch has exclusively learned. Hannah (Photo Credit: Getty Images) In the police report obtained exclusively by In Touch, Kate claimed Jon once “kidnapped” Hannah by taking her from school; Kate told police “that she detects suspicious behavior between Jonathan and their [then] 10-year-old daughter.” An insider tells In Touch the allegations upset Jon. “Jon had no idea at the time that she accused him of having

      In Touch Weekly q
    • The internet is enamored with George H.W. Bush's 1993 letter to Bill Clinton

      In the midst of the chaotic lead-up to November's election, a 1993 letter from outgoing President George H.W. Bush to incoming President Bill Clinton has the internet nostalgic for political seasons past. Bush penned the letter on Jan. 20, 1993, the day of Clinton's first inauguration. The previous November, he'd failed to secure a second term in office. SEE ALSO: So that's 3 presidential debates, 0 climate change questions Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton posted the letter to Instagram in June: You may have noticed a letter that went viral on the internet this week. The letter is from George H.W. Bush’s presidential library. I hadn’t read it in a long time, until yesterday. It moved me to tears, just like it did all those years ago. It’s the letter that President Bush left in the Oval Office for my husband, back in January of 1993. They had just fought a fierce campaign. Bill won, President Bush lost. In a democracy, that’s how it goes. But when Bill walked into that office for the very first time as President, that note was waiting for him. It had some good advice about staying focused on what mattered, despite the critics. It wished him happiness. And it concluded with these words: “You will be our President when you read this note. I wish you well. I wish your family well. Your success is now our country’s success. And I am rooting hard for you. George.” That’s the America we love. That is what we cherish and expect. A photo posted by Hillary Clinton (@hillaryclinton) on Jun 14, 2016 at 4:25pm PDT After wishing Bill "great happiness" in the White House, Bush writes: "Your success is now our country's success. And I am rooting hard for you." Those sharing the 1993 letter invoke Bush's words as an example of losing with dignity.  In contrast, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump made headlines during Wednesday's debate when he declared that he may not accept the results of November's election should Clinton win. In a speech on Thursday, he followed up on that statement: He will accept the results of the election if he's the winner . The internet's response: A perfect night to re-read this letter from President George H. W. Bush to President Bill Clinton. — Chris Sacca (@sacca) October 20, 2016 George Bush to Bill Clinton, having lost the election. Compare and contrast to the toxic orange warthog who leads the Republicans today. — Alex Andreou (@sturdyAlex) October 20, 2016 George Herbert Walker Bush defined presidential. In light of #Trump's aversion to democracy, this letter Bush left for Clinton is #mustread — Charles Adler (@charlesadler) October 20, 2016 Forget politics. This letter from Bush #1 to Clinton is filled with a grace and elegance Trump is incapable of understanding. — Richard Marx (@richardmarx) October 20, 2016 George Bush, Sr.'s great outgoing letter to Bill Clinton. The problem is, it's impossible to imagine Trump being man enough to write this... — Seth MacFarlane (@SethMacFarlane) October 20, 2016

    • Virginia Tech Students Made An Awful Jose Fernandez Sign To Mock Miami Football

      College students, ironically, are not always known to be the brightest of bulbs, and whoever decided to hang this banner at Virginia Tech certainly isn’t doing anything to improve that reputation. Mocking the death of Miami Marlins’ pitcher Jose Fernandez, who passed away in a tragic boating accident last month, the sign was put out in advance of the Miami Hurricanes’ visit to Blacksburg for their ACC battle on Thursday night. Whoever made this sign wanted to make sure everyone knew that they respect Fernandez, as they extended the “courtesy” to throw an RIP at the end.

    • Amy Schumer’s Instagram post about the debate is the most accurate thing we’ve ever seen

      If it’s one thing we can agree on, it’s that Amy Schumer is a comedic angel sent from the heavens above. Girlfriend…

      Hello Giggles
    • 'I'm the victim,' Iowa teacher who had sex with student says on 'Dr. Phil'

      DES MOINES — A substitute teacher accused of having sex with a 17-year-old high school student in Cedar Rapids claims the student seduced her. Mary Beth Haglin was charged in July with sexual exploitation by a teacher. On Monday, she appeared on Dr. Phil, accusing the student of seducing her and sharing sexy photos with his friends. “Many people see him as the victim and me as the perpetrator. From a psychological standpoint and from every other standpoint, I feel like I am the victim,” Haglin said on the Dr. Phil show, citing the student's intelligence and “elevated vocabulary” as part of the seduction. Haglin pleaded not guilty to sexual exploitation by a school employee. Her trial is set to

      USA Today q
    • Woman Carrying Skull on Stick Leads Police to Human Remains

      Police in Sacramento say human remains were discovered after officers confronted a transient woman seen carrying a skull on a stick Wednesday.

    • Secret Service lets Vice President Joe Biden drive his ‘Vette, and he promptly does a burnout

      Presidents and vice presidents aren't allowed to drive while holding office. When the Secret Service let the VP drive his Corvette, instant burnout. Biden has only been given special permission to drive his own car three times in eight years.

      Digital Trends
    • An 'Iron Man' Cover Is The Latest Example Of Why Pinup Artists Shouldn't Draw Teenagers

      Midtown Comics has pulled the Invincible Iron Man #1 variant cover by J. Scott Williams of Riri Williams out of her Ironheart armor. A quick peek at Midtown Comics site show the variant with a bold “DO NOT USE (Item Canceled)” declaration. Marvel representatives confirmed to me the choice to pull the cover was a joint decision from Marvel and Midtown Comics.

    • RZA Responds After Azealia Banks-Russell Crowe Incident, Says Singer Threatened and Attacked a Guest

      The Wu-Tang Clan rapper has a very different account from Banks' about how the altercation went down.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Security Footage Released of Kim Kardashian’s Alleged Robbers

      Security footage has finally surfaced of the alleged robbers who held up Kim Kardashian West at gunpoint and stole a reported $11 million worth of jewelry. French outlet M6 News released video from a side-street camera that shows the five alleged burglars — three riding bikes and two on foot — approaching Kardashian West’s Paris hotel on Oct. 3 around 2:19 a.m.... Read more »

    • Donald Trump waited for Hillary Clinton to leave the stage before abandoning his podium — and it yielded an interesting juxtaposition

      The question was in the air before the third and final presidential debate began Wednesday night:...

      Business Insider
    • Duterte didn't really mean 'separation' from U.S., Philippine officials say

      Philippine officials sought on Friday to play down comments by President Rodrigo Duterte who announced his "separation" from the United States a day earlier, saying their country will maintain U.S. trade and economic ties. Duterte made his comments in Beijing, where he was paving the way for what he calls a new commercial alliance as relations with long-time ally Washington deteriorate. "I've realigned myself in your ideological flow and maybe I will also go to Russia to talk to Putin and tell him that there are three of us against the world - China, Philippines and Russia.

    • DeAngelo Hall appreciates Brian Mitchell's response to Stephen A. Smith on Redskins comments

      The media firestorm surrounding Stephen A. Smith's comments about the Redskins, calling the team "losers" after a few players celebrated a division win last Sunday, seemingly won't die down. That doesn't mean, however, that Redskins legend and CSN/ESPN 980's Brian Mitchell wants it to continue. 

      CSN Mid-Atlantic q
    • This adorable stray kitten crashed a live news broadcast and we’re having *so* many feels

      And now for the obligatory dose of daily cat news: An adorable stray kitten crashed a live news broadcast and you will…

      Hello Giggles