Supermarket standoff: Best bacon

Bon Appetit

View gallery

Bacon taste test

Which bacon scored best? (Photo: iStockphoto)

We have embarked on a taste test tour of supermarket foods. We nibble (or sip), we score, and we share the results to help you avoid the paralysis of Brand Choice Overload.

Today's topic: bacon.

Carnivores, rejoice. This edition of Supermarket Standoff puts front and center the meat that claims unabashed adoration from food writers, chefs, and dudes 'round the world. Bacon has inspired large-scale festivals, questionable hygiene products, and an international holiday. People love bacon.

A lot of it is produced in the U.S.--more than 2 billion pounds each year--which became quite clear when we were researching for this taste test. We whittled down the large volume of brands by choosing classic hickory- or applewood-smoked versions. We included both cured and uncured bacon; the latter is rising in popularity due to health-conscious baconnoisseurs. (Not-so-fun-but-at-least-educational-fact: the term "uncured" is a little misleading, since it's meant to indicate that the bacon is free of pork-preserving sodium nitrite. But uncured bacon generally uses celery juice, which releases natural sodium nitrate and nitrite anyway.)

Some of our tasters prefer their bacon crispy and charred, while others wanted it chewy and ham-like. Whichever camp you're in, you can be guided by both our top picks and nutritionist Marissa Lippert's favorites.

Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon
Our Favorites for Flavor

#1 Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 70 calories, 6g total fat, 2g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 140mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 3g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: 10 Snacks You Thought Were Healthy But Really Aren't

Ingredients: Pork, water, brown sugar, sea salt, celery juice powder, lactic acid starter culture.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Good, homey breakfast bacon"; "This would probably be great for a sandwich but not alone"; "Really good, crispy and flavorful"; "Good salt and pork flavor, not artificial tasting"

(See also: Best potato chips)

Farmland Hickory Smoked Bacon
#2 Farmland Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 80 calories, 7g total fat, 3g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 15mg cholesterol, 260mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: Spring Pasta Recipes

Cured with: Water, salt, sugar, sodium phosphates, sodium erythorbate, sodium nitrite.

Cost: $4.49 at ShopRite in Paramus, NJ.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Smoky and woodsy"; "Tastes like it was cooked by a campfire. I like this"; "Crisped up nicely, nice salt content".

View gallery

#3 Oscar Mayer Naturally Hardwood Smoked Thick Cut Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (1 skillet-cooked slice/12g) = 60 calories, 5g total fat, 1.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 250mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

More from Bon Appetit: The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie

Cured with: Water, salt, sugar, sodium phosphates, sodium ascorbate, sodium nitrite.

Cost: $6.99 at The Food Emporium in New York City.

Blind Tasting Notes: "Lots of flavor for a crispy bacon"; "Ham-y"; It's good--not amazing".

Nutritionist Marissa Lippert's Picks

Some comments from Lippert: "The bottom line: bacon is bacon. We all know it's not the best for us in terms of fat and calorie content, but it's pretty darn delectable and just a small amount can add incredible flavor and depth to a dish. So indulge on occasion when you're really craving it.

I sifted through our options by focusing on ingredients, as usual; we're really aiming for pork, water, salt and spices--no other funny stuff necessary to cure good ol' bacon. Then I further sifted by honing in on sodium content. Bacon can be quite salty! Those brands with less salt came to the top of my list.

Be aware of how much salt is sneaking its way into your diet for disease prevention and to keep blood pressure at bay. Some sodium is essential for our bodies, but the daily recommendation is less than 2,300 mg. That's equivalent to about 1 teaspoon of table salt, or less than 1,500 mg if you're 51 and older."

View gallery

#1 Niman Ranch Applewood Smoked Uncured Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (1 skillet-cooked slice/15g) = 70 calories, 7g total fat, 2.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 135mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 2g protein.

Ingredients: Pork prepared with water, salt, turbinado sugar, celery power. Gluten-free.

Cost: $6.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: Shocking! Niman Ranch, an overall great company, turned up dead last for flavor in this competition.

Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon
#2 Nature's Rancher Uncured Hickory Smoked Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/15g) = 70 calories, 6g total fat, 2g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 140mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 3g protein.

Ingredients: Pork, water, brown sugar, sea salt, celery juice powder, lactic acid starter culture.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: Hooray! We ranked this numero uno for flavor.

View gallery

Wellshire Thick Sliced Dry Rubbed All Natural Uncured Bacon
#3 Wellshire Thick Sliced Dry Rubbed All Natural Uncured Bacon

Nutrition: One serving (2 pan fried slices/11g) = 60 calories, 3g total fat, 1.5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat, 10mg cholesterol, 220mg sodium, 0g total carbs, 4g protein.

Ingredients: Pork, water, sea salt, less than 20% of celery powder and evaporated cane syrup. Gluten and casein free.

Cost: $5.99 at Whole Foods in New York City.

Our assessment: This ranked smack in the middle for us; some thought it was "OK" others said it had an "almost like beef jerky textured when chewed" and other were more direct: "Ew"

*Yahoo! Shopping was not compensated by any brands listed within this article.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Larsa Pippen Cheated on Scottie Pippen With Future, Sources Claim

      Multiple sources tell Us Weekly that Larsa Pippen cheated on Scottie Pippen with rapper Future, which led to the former NBA star’s divorce filing — read more

      Us Weekly
    • Kim Kardashian Concierge Reveals New Robbery Details: ‘They Weren’t There for Jewels’

      ET sits down exclusively with the concierge during Kim Kardashian's robbery, who recalls the terrifying events of Oct. 3.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Angry grizzly bear charges couple twice; what they did possibly saved their lives

      John and Lisa Vandenbos were scouting for fishing spots along the Lamar River in Yellowstone National Park on Saturday when they spotted an adult grizzly bear feeding on a partially consumed carcass. The grizzly bear was obviously surprised and was in no mood to share in its bounty, so it immediately charged the couple, coming to within 9 feet, according to Yellowstone National Park spokeswoman Morgan Warthin. Fortunately, the couple from Bozeman, Montana, were prepared and both quickly discharged their bear spray. “The bear initially left,” Warthin wrote. “When attempting to charge the couple again, it ran into the original cloud of bear spray. Upon making contact with the cloud, the bear retreated q
    • Woman writes bad Yelp review because of a bodega cat, and the internet destroys her

      Don't mess with the bodega cats. Walk into any corner store a.k.a bodega in New York City, and you'll find a variety of household goods, beer, probably a deli and almost definitely a resident cat. The cats keep the rats and mice away and in return, they get to hang out inside and take naps on the chip shelf. @georgeferrer A photo posted by Bodega Cats (@bodegacatsofinstagram) on Oct 11, 2016 at 4:54am PDT Usually New Yorkers tend to ignore that bodega cats may be a health code violation, because most people would prefer to see cats hanging around than rats. But recently, one Yelper decided to break the golden bodega cat rule, and gave S.K. Deli Market in the East Village a 1 star review after noticing her bodega had a cat chilling on a stack of Budweisers. Big mistake. Reviewer Diana D, who has since deleted her post, claimed she had ordered from the bodega before, but decided to pick up her food instead of getting it delivered. That's when she noticed the adorable cat protecting its store. You gotta be a miserable gentrifying ass bitch to yelp about the bodega cat — سنكامي (@SynKami) October 24, 2016 "Besides being allergic, I wonder what the health code say(s) about this?" Diana asked in her review.  Twitter user SynKami took a screen grab of the review and shared it to his followers, harshly calling out Diana  for complaining about the bodega cat. Twitter promptly erupted, and the tweet has racked up more than 7,800 retweets at the time of writing. @SynKami @asherahresearch does she realize the cat is there to keep the rats away. Dumbazz — jaja (@JaJasTweets) October 24, 2016 @SynKami tbh, I don't trust a bodega that doesn't have a cat — Carlos LaBestia (@Arturo_Ulises) October 25, 2016 S.K. Deli Market's Yelp page was flooded with positive reviews on Wednesday, supporting both the deli and cat, who's name is Ciao Bella, according to one Yelper.   According to a piece published in the New York Times about the controversy over bodega cats, fines could cost the bodega $300 to $2,000. However, a fine for rodent feces found in a store can also land a bodega with a $300 fine. "It’s hard for bodega owners because they’re not supposed to have a cat, but they’re also not supposed to have rats,” José Fernández, the president of the Bodega Association of the United States, told the New York Times.

    • Megan Fox Shares First Photo Of Predictably Gorgeous Baby Son

      When Megan Fox mates with a 90210 alum, magical things happen.

      Refinery 29 UK
    • 10 Truly Disgusting Facts About Life In Ancient Egypt

      Egypt is the land of pyramids and pharaohs, tombs filled with glittering treasures, and powerful men who ruled a country like gods. When we think of ancient Egypt, we think of the wealth and glamour of kings. But we usually leave out the dirty—and disgusting—details. 10 Lice Was So Bad That People Just Gave Up On Hair Most people shaved their heads in ancient Egypt. We know this from pictures and from records written by people in other countries who looked at Egypt’s fashion choices and puzzled over why Egyptians thought going bald was such a good look. Today, though, historians are pretty sure they know why. Lice were everywhere in ancient Egypt. The tombs of Egyptian rulers are infested with

      Listverse q
    • R.I.P. Michael Massee (1955 – 2016)

      October 27, 2016 by Prolific American actor Michael Massee has passed away aged 61, his agency Greene & Associates has confirmed. EW is reporting that he died on October 20th after a battle with cancer. Massee amassed almost 80 screen credits in his career, including roles in Seven, The Game, Lost Highway, Catwoman, The Amazing Spider-Man and The Amazing Spider-Man 2, while on the small screen he appeared in the likes of 24, The X-Files, Criminal Minds and Supernatural. His voice work included The Batman animated series, as well as voicing Bruce Banner in Ultimate Avengers and Ultimate Avengers 2. Massee is also known for his role in 1994’s The Crow, where he was the actor who fired the fatal

      Flickering Myth q
    • Tim Tebow answered Stephen A. Smith's dumb question with a riveting inspirational speech

      Hate on Tim Tebow all you want, but there’s no denying he’s one of the most motivational guys in sports — period. On Tuesday he appeared with Stephen A. Smith on First Take and dropped the best speech you’ll hear all week. When he was criticized for taking a long shot at making an MLB roster, Tebow dropped the hammer.

      SB Nation q
    • Singer Pulled From National Anthem at 76ers Game Over 'We Matter' Jersey

      Singer Sevyn Streeter posted a video about the incident on Twitter.

      ABC News q
    • Clinton nearly doubles lead over Trump in latest CNBC survey

      Clinton leads Trump by 46 percent to 37 percent among registered voters in a two-way race in new CNBC All-America Survey.

    • VIDEO: Man pistol whips scary clown prankster in California

      A video showing a man dressed as a clown scaring random people in Northern California has gone viral after one man pistol whipped the prankster.

      KABC – Los Angeles
    • The Weirdest Marriage Advice Your Great, Great Grandmother Ever Received (10 photos)

      There's one thing absent-minded husband and wives really weren't supposed to do. From Country Living

      Country Living
    • Fisherman surprised at animal creating huge wake on Upper Klamath Lake; video

      Scott Ross was fishing for rainbow trout on the glassy waters of Upper Klamath Lake in Oregon on Saturday when he spotted in the distance an animal swimming toward him, creating a huge wake. He told the Herald and News that at first he thought it could be an otter. “What caught my attention was how big of a wake it was leaving and how fast it was moving,” Ross told the newspaper. Ross noticed Gerald Holt flying his drone nearby and asked him if he could capture aerial footage of the swimming animal, which was out quite a ways. Holt obliged and sent his drone out over Upper Klamath Lake where he caught up with the animal and began filming. “I was really conscious to stay away from it, not to harm q
    • The Internet Wants To Collectively Hug Kim Kardashian

      Kim Kardashian has rarely been spotted in public since she was robbed in Paris. But a new photo of one such sighting has her fans even more worried about Kim. The photo shows an incredibly morose looking Kardashian getting some ice cream with her BFF Jonathan Cheban. Kim supporters have been tweeting offers for group hugs and well wishes to the reality star, since the ice cream photo began circulating online.

      Refinery 29 UK
    • World Series of Poker player lectures another about being a bully

      Poker is generally a quiet game with occasional banter, but Englishman William Kassouf just doesn’t shut up.

      Sporting News
    • Michael Massee, Actor Who Accidentally Killed Brandon Lee During Filming of 'The Crow,' Dies at 61

      Michael Massee, the actor who unfortunately will forever be known as the man who accidentally shot and killed Brandon Lee on the set of the 1994 film The Crow, has died. Massee’s death was first announced by actor Anthony Delon and confirmed to The Hollywood Reporter by a representative of his agent at Greene & Associates in Los Angeles. In just his second movie appearance, Massee was playing a character known as Funboy when he fired a revolver that had been improperly prepared by crew members at Brandon Lee, the son of famed martial arts star Bruce Lee.

      The Hollywood Reporter
    • Self-made millionaire: Don't put money in your 401(k)

      Grant Cardone has other ideas about how to get well-positioned for retirement.

    • We finally know how much Nintendo made from Pokémon Go

      Nintendo reported its second-quarter earnings (pdf) for 2016 today, and it broke out its profits from Pokémon Go for the first time. The company made ¥12 billion ($115 million) from licensing fees through from the game, which flow through affiliated firms including the Pokémon Company. The profit Nintendo would see from Pokémon Go was a…

    • Democrats ask judge to sanction Republicans over Trump

      The Democratic National Committee on Wednesday asked a U.S. judge to hold the Republican National Committee in contempt of court over allegations that Donald Trump encouraged his supporters to intimidate minority voters. The DNC accused Republicans in a court filing of violating a longstanding consent decree, which restricts Republicans' ability to question voters at the polls and prevent those people from casting a ballot. During the presidential campaign, Republican nominee Trump has asked followers to "watch" for fraud in the Nov.8 presidential election in certain areas where minority voters reside, even though no evidence of fraud exists, the filing said.

    • These floating head makeup tutorials are FREAKISHLY awesome

      Normally when we imagine Halloween makeup tutorials we imagine beauty vloggers instructing us on how to apply makeup like Wednesday Addams or…

      Hello Giggles