Supermarket Standoff: Barbecue sauces

Bon Appetit

When they're not busy tasting dishes over and over, Bon Appétit's food editors are tasting other stuff like different brands of chicken stock. Because while we're into making things from scratch, sometimes there just isn't time to brown veal bones for rich broth, or simmer strawberries into preserves. When we do cut corners, though, we want to do it in the tastiest possible way -- hence the taste tests of store-bought items.

Kraft Thick 'n Spicy
Photo courtesy of amazon.com

Today's item: barbecue sauce. Sure, Food Editor Hunter "Carolina Boy" Lewis might have a mean recipe handed down to him by his great grandfather, but most of us don't.

The good news? Many bottled sauces -- some of them made by big companies, some of them by two dudes with a passion and a big ol' stockpot -- are darn good. Here are six of our favorites.


Kraft Thick 'n Spicy

This is what we recommend using in place of our All-American Barbecue Sauce. (Don't worry: you'll still be very patriotic.)

It's balanced and so thick that it works well for dipping, too.

$1.99 at Fairway in New York City.

Bone Suckin' Sauce
Photo courtesy of buybonesuckin.com

Bone Suckin' Sauce

The thinnest of the bunch, this sauce is sweet and vinegary with a touch of chili heat. It would be great for pulled pork.

$4.99 at Fairway in New York City.








Rufus Teague Touch O' Heat
Photo courtesy of rufusteague.com

Rufus Teague Touch O' Heat

Leave it to the test kitchen cooks to have body builder-like palates. They detected anchovy, celery seed, tamarind, and raisin flavors in Teague's sauce. "This will stick to your ribs, literally," one of them said.

$4.99 at Fairway in New York City.


Trader Joe's Kansas City Style

"This is a total cheat sheet sauce." Translation: It's adaptable, and you could "put it on chicken and fake that it's charred." It's smoky, sweet, and has a pronounced tomato flavor.

$2.69 at Trader Joe's in New York City.




Bull's-Eye Original
Photo courtesy of amazon.com

Bull's-Eye Original

This is the smoky, thick concoction that we all grew up on. And we don't plan to stop using it, either.

$1.99 at Fairway in New York City.






Whole Hog Café #4

This world-class BBQ joint (with the trophies to prove it) in Little Rock, Ark., turns out a host of great sauces. Our favorite is the traditional Southern vinegar and spice.

$6.95 at wholehogcafe.com.


As for health -- not always a contradiction when talking BBQ--our nutritionist Marissa Lippert says go for the Bone Suckin' Sauce. "It's significantly lower in sodium than the others, a bit lower in sugar and about half the calories."


More from Bon Appétit:

25 One-Bite Appetizers

Junk Food Makeover: Healthier Chicken Nuggets

Top 20 Best-Tasting Burger Recipes

Healthy French Fry Alternatives

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Kendall Jenner’s See-through Top Leaves Photographers Seeing Stars

      Kendall Jenner dazzled the crowd in a black and white plaid gown as she walked the runway for Givenchy’s fall/winter 2017-2018 collection at Paris Fashion Week on Friday. But it was on the streets of the City of Light on Saturday where the 21-year-old supermodel really left photographers seeing stars.

      People
    • After Being Stared Down by a Couple in Cracker Barrel, This Dad Received a Note About Parenting

      When Kevon Smith Sr. sat down for breakfast at Cracker Barrel with his son Kevon Jr. in Willoughby, OH, he had no idea he was going to make headlines just for being a good dad. Kevon noticed a couple staring and smiling at him and his 3-month-old son, and although he was confused, he just went on with the meal. "I noticed this older couple over in the corner," he said. "They kept smiling at me and I was looking at my son like, 'What is going on?'" But when Kevon left the restaurant, it all made sense, as he saw a note on his car from the couple praising his parenting along with cash to cover his breakfast. "Today your meal is on my wife and me," it read. "Enjoy that baby as long as God intends.

      PopSugar q
    • The Latest: Former CIA chief says Trump should 'be ashamed'

      WASHINGTON (AP) — The Latest on President Donald Trump (all times EST):

      Associated Press
    • Ivanka Trump Has a Princess Moment in Carolina Herrera at Inaugural Balls

      For inauguration events, Ivanka Trump wore three Oscar de la Renta ensembles. But for the grand finale, the first daughter switched things up and opted for a piece from Carolina Herrera.

      Yahoo Style
    • Punter Pat McAfee Fired Off A Tweetstorm About The Colts GM Right After He Was Fired

      The Indianapolis Colts fired GM Ryan Grigson on Saturday. It seemed like a move that needed to happen, as Indy’s on-field performance over the last few years has declined while rumblings of a rift between Grigson and Chuck Pagano have been out there for a while. McAfee has been in Indianapolis since 2009, so he’s seen the inner workings of this organization before and during the Grigson years.

      UPROXX
    • Sick of robocalls? Here's how to stop them on your home phone and smartphone

      Robocalls continue to plague homeowners — especially senior citizens at home all day with a traditional land line — and the volume is worse than ever. American consumers and businesses received an estimated 29.3 billion in unwanted telemarketing calls in 2016, based on the YouMail Robocall Index released this week. Texas received the most statewide robocalls in the U.S. for the seventh consecutive month, with 283.1 million calls received in December, according to the index. The 817 area code ranked 9th in the nation in robocall volume with 22.6 million calls. Dallas and Houston made the Top 10 among cities. At the same time, the number of robocall complaints to the Federal Trade Commission increased

      Miami Herald q
    • White House press secretary attacks media for accurately reporting inauguration crowds

      (CNNMoney) "That's what you guys should be writing and covering," new White House press secretary Sean Spicer angrily lectured reporters on Saturday during his first remarks from the podium of the press briefing room. He was referring to the delay in Senate confirmation for President Donald Trump's pick to lead the CIA, Congressman Mike Pompeo, but the comment came after a long digression about how many people had shown up to watch Trump be sworn in as president. "This was the largest audience to ever witness an inauguration, period," Spicer said, contradicting all available data. Aerial photos have indicated that former president Barack Obama's first inauguration attracted a much larger crowd.

      CNNMoney q
    • Scarlett Johansson Reveals She Used Planned Parenthood When She Was 15 at Women’s March

      Scarlett Johansson got personal during the women’s march in Washington D.C. on Saturday as she spoke out about women’s health issues. “‘Have you been to the gynecologist yet?’ That was the question my mom asked me at 15 when I informed her about a change that I noticed in my body,” she said. “I’m not the type to divulge facts about my personal life, but I feel that in the face of this current political climate, it is vital that we all make it our mission to get really, really personal.

      People
    • Trump's Press Secretary Falsely Claims: 'Largest Audience Ever to Witness an Inauguration, Period'

      In his first official White House briefing, Sean Spicer blasted journalists for “deliberately false reporting,” and made categorical claims about crowd-size at odds with the available evidence.

      The Atlantic q
    • Bella Hadid Wears Totally Sheer Shirt Without a Bra -- See the Daring Pic!

      The 20-year-old model was spotted out in Paris on Friday.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Barron Trump plays peekaboo with nephew while his father signs first presidential documents

      President Trump's 10-year-old son, Barron, played peekaboo with his nephew, Theodore, while his father was signing his first official documents as president.

      Yahoo News Video
    • The Fried Chicken Everyone Is Talking About In Your State (52 photos)

      With help from our friends at Foursquare , we found the best-rated fried chicken spots across America. Did we get your state right? From Delish

      Delish
    • Michelle Obama's Reaction to Melania Trump's Gift Is Basically Meme GOLD

      When Donald and Melania Trump arrived at the White House on Inauguration Day, the new FLOTUS carried a large Tiffany's box that carried her parting gift for Michelle Obama. When the former first lady accepted the blue box, her reaction was absolutely priceless, and there were cameras all around to capture the funny moment. Twitter users everywhere also took note of Michelle's seemingly unimpressed response to the gift, noting how it's predicted to be the next best meme. And we couldn't agree more. Below is a replay of the meme-worthy moment, followed by some of the internet's most spot-on reactions.

      PopSugar q
    • The Patriots have been holding back and that should scare the bejeezus out of the Steelers

      Even with Tom Brady suspended for the first four games of the regular season, the New England...

      Business Insider
    • Amber Rose shared another selfie with Dream Kardashian, and it’s peak baby fierceness

      Because photos of babies make everything all better, allow us to recommend a pretty special one. One glance at Amber Rose’s latest…

      Hello Giggles
    • Trump’s Press Secretary Slams Media Over Inauguration Crowd Size Coverage

      President Trump’s press secretary Sean Spicer, making his first statement in the White House briefing room, slammed the news media on Saturday for trying to “lessen the enthusiasm” of Trump’s inauguration through reporting on crowd size and a bust of Martin Luther King Jr. in the Oval Office. In a combative tone, Spicer insisted that... Read more »

      Variety
    • Nick Cannon Shares Throwback Photos From When He Dated Kim Kardashian

      We see you, Nick Cannon! The America’s Got Talent host reminded Us that he dated Kim Kardashian by posting two throwback photos with the social media maven to Instagram on Thursday.

      Us Weekly
    • Flight attendant shouts out all the 'nasty women' headed to the Women's March on Washington

      As hundreds of thousands of women head to Washington, D.C. ahead of Saturday's Women's March, shows of solidarity are making the rounds on the internet. Twitter user @FlorBlake shared a clip from her Spirit Airlines flight to Baltimore, where a flight attendant on board offered a show of solidarity for passengers headed to the march. SEE ALSO: How to get involved with the Women's March on Washington if you're not in D.C. Love a nasty woman flight attendant  Starting our wknd of amazing women because we can't give up! @SpiritAirlines #WomensMarchOnWashington pic.twitter.com/bWj89inKtJ — Flor Blake (@FlorBlake) January 20, 2017 "I just want to know, how many of you are going to the March on Washington?" the flight attendant asked to a show of hands and erupting cheers.  "You guys are going to the Women's March, right? Let's get a round of applause for all the nasty women on board," she said. "Stay safe, stay hydrated, have a good time, watch out for your fellow sisters. Just remember, we don't take no 'ish' from no man." On Thursday, a Southwest Airlines crew made a similar show of support when it turned on pink cabin lights for a plane full of women headed to the march. March organizers expect about 200,000 people to attend the march, while local law enforcement plans for up to 400,000, according to the New York Times . DCist reports that there are 2,066 buses registered to bring marchers to D.C. for Saturday, while 435 buses had permits to park in the city for Friday. Mashable has reached out to Spirit Airlines for comment. BONUS: Michelle Obama tears up during final speech as First Lady

      Mashable
    • Paris Jackson Makes Her Front Row Fashion Debut as Kendall Jenner and Bella Hadid Hit the Runway

      Kendall Jenner, Bella and Gigi Hadid and Kaia Gerber all found supermodel stardom after being born to famous parents, and are leading the way on today’s runways and magazine covers. Not long after her red carpet debut at the InStyle Golden Globes after party, Jackson made her FROW cameo wearing an “I Feel Love” Givenchy sweater. At the show, she bonded with fashion icon Carine Roitfeld, and made sure to commemorate the starstruck moment with a selfie.

      People
    • DeMarcus Cousins irate after Kings lose to Bulls on phantom foul call

      DeMarcus Cousins was called for a foul with 14.8 seconds to go against the Bulls with the game tied. While it doesn’t look like Cousins touched him, Wade missed the dunk and it’s likely the referee assumed there was contact. Wade made 1-of-2 free throws which ultimately put the Bulls ahead for good.

      SB Nation q