Prepared Pie Crust Taste Test

Good Housekeeping

Prepared pie crusts can save you time and effort. Many even come in their own pie tins (one less dish to wash!). The test kitchen of the Good Housekeeping Research Institute conducted a taste test of nine of the leading national brands. Testers sampled frozen, prerolled refrigerated, and dry-mix varieties — both with and without filling — to test flavor, flakiness, and how the crusts stood up to being used with a standard pumpkin pie recipe.

Wholly Wholesome

Winner

By far the flakiest contender, Wholly Wholesome Organic Traditional 9" Pie Shells ($4.39 for two) won for their natural, buttery flavor — they taste just like Grandma's.

(120 calories, 8g fat, 4g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

More from Good Housekeeping:

The Tastiest Low-Fat Ice Cream

How To Pick The Best Wine

JIFFY

Honorable Mention

The classic blue box of JIFFY Pie Crust Mix ($0.75 for the mix, which makes two crusts) produces crisp, crumbly results with a good balance of salty and sweet — all for less than a dollar for two.

(80 calories, 5g fat, 2g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

 

Pillsbury

Pillsbury Pet-Ritz Frozen Pie Crusts
($2.49 for two)

This delicate crust is sweet and moist. One taster even said it resembled buttery sugar cookies — great for desserts, but maybe not the best for savory fillings.

(80 calories, 4g fat, 1.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)




Mrs. Smith's

Mrs. Smith's 9" Deep Dish Pie Shells
($2.78 for two)

Though it has a good crunch, Mrs. Smith's Pie Shells were too dense and salty for our tasters.

(130 calories, 7g fat, 3.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

Wholly Wholesome

Wholly Wholesome Organic Whole Wheat 9" Pie Shells
($4.39 for two)

The Wholly Wholesome crusts were surprisingly tender and flaky, considering whole wheat's reputation for being grainy and tough. It has more fiber than non-whole wheat entries.

(110 calories, 8g fat, 4g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

Oronoque Orchards

Oronoque Orchards Homestyle Pie Crust
($3.10 for two)

The fall-apart, crumbly texture combined with lack of sweetness didn't win this one many fans among our testers.

(130 calories, 7g fat, 3g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

Pillsbury

Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts
($3.19 for two)

Testers deemed Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts to have an overly salty and buttery flavor, and rated this crust as too chewy and tough.

(110 calories, 6g fat, 2.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

Betty Crocker

Betty Crocker Pie Crust Mix
($2.13 for two)

With a very flaky, homemade texture, the Betty Crocker Pie Crust was too greasy and somewhat gummy to some tasters.

(110 calories, 7g fat, 2 g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust).

Marie Callender's

Marie Callender's Deep Dish Pastry Shells
($3.99 for two)

Unfortunately for Marie Callender's, this soft pasty crust tasted both bland and almost raw when cooked according to the package instructions.

(140 calories, 10 g fat, 2 g saturated fat per serving)







 

More from Good Housekeeping:

8 Secrets To A Successful Marriage

15 Foods That Help You Lose Weight

52 Home Organizing Tips

The Best Anti-Aging Beauty Products

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Investigator Believes Sex Trafficking Could Be Motive Behind Sherri Papini Kidnapping Case

      A private investigator and veteran human trafficking expert believes California mom Sherri Papini‘s case has the hallmarks of sex trafficking.

      People
    • J.J. Watt accidentally outs relationship in Christmas photo

      A picture is worth a thousand words, or in J.J. Watt’s case, a stocking. After putting the finishing touches on his holiday decor Thursday, the NFL star gave fans a glimpse of his Christmas cheer via Snapchat. But Watt may have slipped up by displaying — tucked away in the background, as Terez Owens was first to point out — a second stocking marked with a “K” for stunning soccer-playing girlfriend Kealia Ohai. Watt has yet to address the relationship publicly, though Ohai — the sister-in-law of Texans teammate Brian Cushing — talked about the pair in October. “The rumors are true. We are dating,” Ohai confirmed on the 2 Up Front podcast. “I’ve known J.J. for a really long time, and we’ve always

      New York Post q
    • The jobs report is a perfect example of fake news

      On Friday, we learned the US economy added 178,000 jobs in November and the unemployment rate fell to 4.6%, while over 95 million Americans were not in the labor force. One person can say the unemployment rate is 4.6%. Another person can look at the same report and say the unemployment rate is 40.3%.

      Yahoo Finance
    • The 69 Most Delish Fall Soups (71 photos)

      These easy autumn soup recipes will warm you up. From Delish

      Delish
    • Sherri Papini’s Hometown Rallies Around Her on Return Home After Abduction

      When the news broke that Redding, California, mom Sherri Papini was found safe on Thanksgiving morning after being missing for three weeks, residents exhaled with relief, the city’s mayor tells PEOPLE exclusively. Papini, 34, vanished while out for a jog on Nov. 2. After three weeks, the mom-of-two was found around 4:30 a.m. Thanksgiving Day on the side of a road — about 150 miles south of her Redding home.

      People
    • Mummified Body In Woman's Attic Believed To Be Missing Grandson

      A Pennsylvania woman made a disturbing discovery on Wednesday when she found a badly decomposed body in the attic of her home. Authorities suspect it’s her grandson, who disappeared two years ago. Zanobia Richmond, 65, heard something fall in the upstairs of her Erie home Wednesday afternoon, according to Erie’s WICU 12 News. When she went to investigate, she was shocked to discover a badly decomposed body had fallen against her attic door. Erie County Coroner Lyell Cook is now working to confirm the identity of the body, but told The Erie Times-News officials are confident the body is Richmond’s missing grandson, Dyquain Rogers. “That is where he lived,” Cook said. Authorities will use dental

      The Huffington Post q
    • Trump Speaks With Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-Wen, Breaking Policy

      President-elect Donald Trump spoke Friday with Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen by phone, according to the Trump transition team, breaking with decades of delicate U.S. policy on China. Friday night, Trump issued two tweets defending the move, which may cause tensions with China. Meanwhile, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi downplayed the call Saturday, describing it as "just a small trick by Taiwan" that he believed would not change U.S. policy toward China, according to Hong Kong's Phoenix TV.

      Good Morning America 51 min ago
    • Here's how much interns will make at companies like Facebook and Google in 2017

      Some big companies are paying their interns more than $8,000 a month.

      CNBC.com q
    • Massive sea otter jumps into California man's kayak on his birthday

      ELKHORN, Calif., Dec. 2 (UPI) -- A man kayaking in California ended up with a unique story when a massive sea otter jumped into the boat with him. John Koester was kayaking with his wife, Heather VanNes, to celebrate his birthday Monday in the Elkhorn Slough, near Watsonville, when they spotted a raft of sea otters in the distance. The couple said they made sure to keep at least 50 feet away from the animals, but one of the curious otters quickly swam over to Koester and jumped onto his kayak. VanNes snapped a photo of the massive otter and posted it to Facebook. The couple estimated the creature was about the size of a German shepherd and weighed 80 to 85 pounds. They said the otter was a calm

      UPI q
    • Gronk's post-surgery report: 'Dance floor tomorrow night, here I come'

      Gronkowski has suffered a range of injuries this season, and the herniated disc that required surgery was perhaps the final straw for 2016. Without Gronkowski, the Patriots now lack their most significant weapon, and the AFC race is now wide open.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Miscarriage of justice

      ON AUGUST 11th Sandra, a 19-year-old Salvadorean, went to her school’s nurse with stomach pains and a fever. She dashed to the toilet. What happened next is disputed. Her lawyer, Bertha Deleon, says she felt a spasm, looked down to see a dead fetus, fainted and woke up in hospital. Police said she gave birth and murdered her baby. According to Ms Deleon, a doctor later concluded that Sandra had been at most five months pregnant and had an infection known to cause miscarriage. Yet she was charged with infanticide. In most countries where abortion is illegal, only doctors who carry it out are punished. But El Salvador is one of a handful of countries that prosecute women for having them. Between

      The Economist q
    • ABC Head Channing Dungey Says Donald Trump Made Her Rethink Programming Strategy

      ABC Entertainment Group president Channing Dungey reevaluated the way she programs the network following the election of Donald Trump.

      The Wrap
    • Forget Black Friday, Best Buy is about to host a ‘Special Edition’ sale

      Black Friday and Cyber Monday are behind us at this point, but the special Christmas sales are just getting started. Best Buy on Friday announced its first "Special Edition Tech collection" sale. Beginning on December 4th, Best Buy will start selling a “one-of-a-kind” collection of products that you might not find anywhere else this holiday season. DON’T MISS: A 75-year-old’s excellent Tweet may be the only good thing in 2016 Best Buy will have the following products in limited quantities, both online and in select stores, “so when they’re gone, they’re gone.” Mind you, the list does not include some of the hottest tech gadgets in town, like the iPhone 7 or the PS4 Pro. But that doesn’t make the sale any less exciting. Here’s what’s included in Best Buy’s first Special Edition Tech collection: Shinola Magnolia Edition Red Belt Runwell Turntable, $2,499.98 Lenovo Yoga 910 Glass-Lid Laptop, $1,299.99 DJI Phantom 4 Quadcopter in Black, $1,199.99 The Beatles Collectible 1964 Pro-Ject Turntable, $649.98 GoPro HERO5 Black 4K Action Camera plus Best Buy Holiday Sweepstakes for a chance to win a trip to the 2017 X Games, $399.99 Beats Unity Edition Studio Wireless Headphones: available in USA, Mexico and Canada colors, $379.99 each Harry Potter 8-Film SteelBook Box Set, $99.99 kate spade new york Activity Tracker, $98 TUMI Aston Wrap Folio for Surface Pro, $79.99 South Park Character Figures 3-Pack, $39.99 Team Liquid Razer Deathadder Chroma Elite Mouse and Goliathus Mouse Mat, $69.99 South Park Character Figures 3-Pack, $39.99 Finally, you should also know that Best Buy offers you free shipping on select Special Edition products and all other products from now through December 24th. Best Buy Introduces Special Edition Tech Collection for the Holidays New collection features limited-edition tech gifts; most exclusive to Best Buy  MINNEAPOLIS—Friday, Dec. 2, 2016—This year, Best Buy is making it possible for customers to find that unique, one-of-a-kind gift that stands out from the rest. Today, Best Buy announced its first ever Special Edition Tech collection, a set of 11 limited-quantity tech gadgets—most of which are available only at Best Buy. This list of gadgets includes an exclusive Shinola turntable, a Bazooka-pink kate spade new york activity tracker, a Lenovo Yoga laptop individually numbered with a painted depth glass cover and more. These products will be available in select Best Buy stores and most will be available at BestBuy.com starting this Sunday, Dec. 4. Many are available for a limited time only, and once they’re gone, they’re gone. Best Buy's Special Edition Tech 2016: · Shinola Magnolia Edition Red Belt Runwell Turntable, $2,499.98 · Lenovo Yoga 910 Glass-Lid Laptop, $1,299.99 · Beats Unity Edition Studio Wireless Headphones: available in USA, Mexico and Canada colors, $379.99 each · kate spade new york Activity Tracker, $98 · DJI Phantom 4 Quadcopter in Black, $1,199.99 · TUMI Aston Wrap Folio for Surface Pro, $79.99 · The Beatles Collectible 1964 Pro-Ject Turntable, $649.98 · GoPro HERO5 Black 4K Action Camera plus Best Buy Holiday Sweepstakes for a chance to win a trip to the 2017 X Games, $399.99 · Harry Potter 8-Film SteelBook Box Set, $99.99 · South Park Character Figures 3-Pack, $39.99 · Team Liquid Razer Deathadder Chroma Elite Mouse and Goliathus Mouse Mat, $69.99 This year, customers can take advantage of free shipping on select Special Edition products and all products, with no minimum, on BestBuy.com through Dec. 24. Make the most of your Special Edition tech with help from Best Buy’s Geek Squad® Agents. Agents are available in-store, in-home and online to assist 24/7/365. Visit www.bestbuy.com/geeksquad for details and to schedule an appointment.

      BGR News
    • Five Things To Know About Sherri Papini and Her Family

      In early November, California mother Sherri Papini mysteriously vanished after she left her Redding, California, home for a routine jog. “It all started with a first kiss in middle school,” Sherri wrote on the blog for her 2009 wedding. Sherri moved away and lost touch with Keith for several years, she writes on the blog.

      People
    • Inside Edition
    • Trump voter has buyer’s remorse after Steve Mnuchin picked for treasury secretary

      Teena Colebrook purchased a triplex in Hawthorne, Calif., in 1998. Now her home is one of 36,000 foreclosures by OneWest, a bank that became known as “a foreclosure machine.” Donald Trump’s pick for treasury secretary, Steve Mnuchin, headed an investment group that formerly owned that bank, and Colebrook holds Mnuchin responsible for her foreclosure.

      Yahoo News Video
    • What 'are so many of them doing?' 95 million not in US labor force

      The November jobs report looked pretty good on the surface except for one number that popped off the page: 95 million Americans out of the labor force.

      CNBC
    • Officials: Bodies of Missing Mother, Daughter Found in Well

      North Carolina authorities say bodies of mother, teen-age daughter found in a well, three days after they were reported missing

      ABC News q
    • Former NFL player Joe McKnight shot dead in New Orleans

      Former NFL player Joe McKnight was shot dead in New Orleans on Thursday in what police described as “a possible road rage incident.”

      Next Media Videos