Prepared Pie Crust Taste Test

Good Housekeeping

Prepared pie crusts can save you time and effort. Many even come in their own pie tins (one less dish to wash!). The test kitchen of the Good Housekeeping Research Institute conducted a taste test of nine of the leading national brands. Testers sampled frozen, prerolled refrigerated, and dry-mix varieties — both with and without filling — to test flavor, flakiness, and how the crusts stood up to being used with a standard pumpkin pie recipe.

Wholly Wholesome

Winner

By far the flakiest contender, Wholly Wholesome Organic Traditional 9" Pie Shells ($4.39 for two) won for their natural, buttery flavor — they taste just like Grandma's.

(120 calories, 8g fat, 4g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

More from Good Housekeeping:

The Tastiest Low-Fat Ice Cream

How To Pick The Best Wine

JIFFY

Honorable Mention

The classic blue box of JIFFY Pie Crust Mix ($0.75 for the mix, which makes two crusts) produces crisp, crumbly results with a good balance of salty and sweet — all for less than a dollar for two.

(80 calories, 5g fat, 2g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

 

Pillsbury

Pillsbury Pet-Ritz Frozen Pie Crusts
($2.49 for two)

This delicate crust is sweet and moist. One taster even said it resembled buttery sugar cookies — great for desserts, but maybe not the best for savory fillings.

(80 calories, 4g fat, 1.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)




Mrs. Smith's

Mrs. Smith's 9" Deep Dish Pie Shells
($2.78 for two)

Though it has a good crunch, Mrs. Smith's Pie Shells were too dense and salty for our tasters.

(130 calories, 7g fat, 3.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

Wholly Wholesome

Wholly Wholesome Organic Whole Wheat 9" Pie Shells
($4.39 for two)

The Wholly Wholesome crusts were surprisingly tender and flaky, considering whole wheat's reputation for being grainy and tough. It has more fiber than non-whole wheat entries.

(110 calories, 8g fat, 4g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per pie shell)

Oronoque Orchards

Oronoque Orchards Homestyle Pie Crust
($3.10 for two)

The fall-apart, crumbly texture combined with lack of sweetness didn't win this one many fans among our testers.

(130 calories, 7g fat, 3g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

Pillsbury

Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts
($3.19 for two)

Testers deemed Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts to have an overly salty and buttery flavor, and rated this crust as too chewy and tough.

(110 calories, 6g fat, 2.5g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust)

Betty Crocker

Betty Crocker Pie Crust Mix
($2.13 for two)

With a very flaky, homemade texture, the Betty Crocker Pie Crust was too greasy and somewhat gummy to some tasters.

(110 calories, 7g fat, 2 g saturated fat per serving; 8 servings per crust).

Marie Callender's

Marie Callender's Deep Dish Pastry Shells
($3.99 for two)

Unfortunately for Marie Callender's, this soft pasty crust tasted both bland and almost raw when cooked according to the package instructions.

(140 calories, 10 g fat, 2 g saturated fat per serving)







 

More from Good Housekeeping:

8 Secrets To A Successful Marriage

15 Foods That Help You Lose Weight

52 Home Organizing Tips

The Best Anti-Aging Beauty Products

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Hernandez suicide notes ordered released ahead of funeral

      BRISTOL, Conn. (AP) — Aaron Hernandez's family turned out Monday for a private funeral to say their farewells to the former NFL star, and a judge ordered that three suicide notes he left be turned over by the time he is buried.

      Associated Press
    • Man takes drone out for a sunset flight, drone gets shot down

      It was around sunset on Easter Sunday, April 16, when Brad Jones took his DJI Inspire 2 out for a flight in front of his home. Jones hoped, as he does on most nights, to capture some of the forested and hilly scenery in the environs of his hometown, Oliver Springs, Tennessee—about 30 miles west of Knoxville. “I flew down over my aunt’s house, and I heard a gunshot within the first three to four minutes of flight,” Jones told Ars. “So I sped up and flew back towards my house.” After a few more minutes, he flew back westward. He had just switched the drone’s camera mode from video to taking still photos in RAW format. “I took two pictures then I heard the gunshot, and all of a sudden my drone started

      Ars Technica q
    • Serena Williams issues powerful response to Ilie Nastase's racist comments about her unborn child

      Falling pregnant with her fiance’s baby should have been the most exciting and happiest time of tennis champ Serena Williams’ life. Serena Williams has responded to Ilie Nastase’s remark. The 35-year-old beauty wrote: “It disappoints me to know we live in a society where people like Ilie Nastase can make such racist comments.

      Yahoo Celebrity UK
    • The Latest: US Navy conducting exercises with Japan, S.Korea

      PYONGYANG, North Korea (AP) — The Latest on tensions on the Korean Peninsula (all times local):

      Associated Press
    • Jennifer Lopez’s twins made a surprise appearance on “Ellen,” and totally stole the show

      Jennifer Lopez stopped by The Ellen DeGeneres Show this week, and while Ellen was (naturally!) dying to hear about her new romance and first…

      Hello Giggles
    • Witness describes tense incident involving flight attendant and woman with stroller

      NEW YORK -- A witness says she saw what led up to tense moments that were captured on video Friday aboard an American Airlines flight.   Passengers say an American Airlines flight attendant hit a mother of twins with a stroller during boarding of the aircraft, which was preparing to leave for Dallas from San Francisco. Passenger Olivia Morgan said she saw the male flight attendant wrestling the stroller away from the woman, CBS News transportation correspondent Kris Van Cleave reports. “He rips it away from her, and it almost hits her little baby’s head,” Morgan said. “I said to him something like, ‘What are you doing? You almost hit that baby in the head!’” Morgan said. “And then he was just

      CBS News q
    • A Marine’s .50 caliber sniper rifle failed during a firefight — so he called customer service

      The Barrett M107 .50-caliber long-range sniper rifle is a firearm made for the modern war on terrorism. While Barrett’s reputation of “flawless reliability” has made the M107 the sniper weapon of choice, the rifle is just like any other essential tool: It often breaks when you need it most. Don Cook, a Marine veteran who’s been maintaining M107s for more than two decades, told National Geographic in 2011 that he one day received a call to Barrett’s workshop from a harried young Marine. During maintenance of the unit’s M107, the Marine had bent the ears of the rifle’s lower receiver; the next day, after engaging the enemy, they discovered the rifle wouldn’t fire consistently.

      Business Insider q
    • Erin Moran Was Broke And Homeless When She Died

      “Happy Days” star Erin Moran was broke and homeless when she died.

      International Business Times
    • Exit Bill O’Reilly: Here’s How Many Staff Meetings Fox News Has Held About His Scandal (Exclusive)

      After Roger Ailes left Fox News amid sexual harassment allegations last summer, parent company 21st Century Fox promised it understood the severity of the situation and would improve its corporate culture. Another Fox News employee also said there have been no company meetings about the matter, telling TheWrap that “everyone is on guard now” in the newsroom. Fox News would not confirm or deny whether it has held a company-wide meeting to address employees’ concerns.

      The Wrap
    • Aaron Hernandez news raises new questions for fiancée, law enforcement

      After Aaron Hernandez's suicide, new questions have emerged, including the motive of the Odin Lloyd murder and whether or not prison officials were monitoring him.

      NBC Sports q
    • Gone in 30 seconds: Mob of up to 60 juveniles robs passengers on BART train, officials say

      Authorities said it happened in 30 seconds: A throng of up to 60 juveniles mobbed a Bay Area Rapid Transit train Saturday in Oakland and mugged passengers. At least two people were injured and required medical attention. The youngsters were spotted by witnesses hastily jumping over fare gates before boarding a Dublin-bound train just after 9:20 p.m. at the Coliseum Station on San Leandro Street, according the BART Police Department. Once the minors entered the train, police said, they swarmed passengers and robbed six people by force. Another passenger was robbed on the railway platform. Authorities said a purse, duffel bag and five cellphones were taken during the robberies. At least two passengers

      Los Angeles Times q
    • In call to Trump, Chinese leader urges restraint over NKorea

      WASHINGTON (AP) — As the world braces for a possible North Korean nuclear test, Chinese President Xi Jinping on Monday urged restraint in a call to President Donald Trump. America's U.N. envoy warned of a strike if Pyongyang attacks a U.S. military base or tests an intercontinental ballistic missile.

      Associated Press
    • Wheaton College mourns freshman killed during track event

      Wheaton College is in mourning after a 19-year-old student was killed in a bizarre accident at a track meet.

      WLS – Chicago
    • The most beautiful dresses from Bridal Fashion Week (23 photos)

      If there’s one thing all women love, it’s looking at wedding dresses. Bridal Fashion Week kicked off in NYC this weekend, showcasing beautifully crafted dresses from internationally renowned designers, including Vera Wang, Jenny Packham and Oscar De La Renta. Interested? We thought so. With embroidered detail to die for, and silhouettes that are fit for a princess, this is what the future of wedding dresses looks like. Be prepared to fall head over heels in love. Follow us on   Instag r am  and   Facebook  for non-stop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day. For Twitter updates, follow  @YahooStyleUK.  Read more from Yahoo Style UK: A new tattoo trend could spell the end of wedding rings The best dressed celebrity couples of all time

      Yahoo Style UK 55 min ago
    • Dancing With the Stars Week 6 Recap: Did the Right Couple Go Home?

      Dancing With the Stars might not be a scripted series, but it knows how to bring the drama — and just in time for May Sweeps! Even though the Season 24 eliminations have been predictable thus far (Chris Kattan, we hardly knew you!), the ABC series closed out its sixth week with a doozy: After reuniting […]

      TVLine.com
    • Happy Days Star Erin Moran Died of Stage 4 Cancer, Authorities Reveal

      Erin Moran, best known for her role as Joanie Cunningham on Happy Days died of stage 4 cancer.

      People
    • Arkansas executes 2 inmates on the same gurney, hours apart

      Two inmates received lethal injections on the same gurney Monday night about three hours apart as Arkansas completed the nation's first double execution since 2000, just days after the state ended a nearly 12-year hiatus on administering capital punishment. While the first inmate, Jack Jones, was executed on schedule, shortly after 7 p.m., attorneys for the second, Marcel Williams, convinced a federal judge minutes later to briefly delay his punishment over concerns about how the earlier one was carried out. Initially, Gov. Asa Hutchinson scheduled four double executions over an 11-day period in April.

      Business Insider UK