Orange juice taste tested

Good Housekeeping
Courtesy of Natalie's Orchid
Island Juice Company

Orange juice is like liquid sunshine, and Americans quaff 1.6 billion gallons, on average, every year.

To weed out the, er, lemons, the GHRI tested 12 different orange juices—some with pulp, some without.

See which ones our testers chose as their main squeeze.


Natalie's Orchid Island Juice Company Gourmet Pasteurized Orange Juice

First Place: Natalie's Orchid Island Juice Company Gourmet Pasteurized Orange Juice ($6 for 64 fl. oz.) trounced the competition with its "fresh-squeezed" taste and "just the right amount of pulp." It's no wonder one participant wrote that it "tastes like a real orange": This brand contains nothing but 100 percent Florida orange juice — squeezed, then pasteurized and shipped (not frozen or stored). (

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

More from
Good Housekeeping:

16 Healthy Foods Swaps

10 Stars Who Look Better With Age

Courtesy of Florida's Natural

Florida's Natural Premium Home Squeezed Orange Juice

Runner-Up: Florida's Natural Premium Home Squeezed Orange Juice ($3 for 64 fl. oz.) impressed with its "classic," "pleasingly fresh-squeezed flavor." However, a couple of tasters noted a slight bitterness.

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Noble Organic

Noble Organic Juice

While some taste testers found Noble Organic Juice ($4.29 for 32 fl. oz.) too sweet, most enjoyed its "floral" finish and smooth body. ( (

120 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Simply Orange

Simply Orange

Several participants found Simply Orange ($3.79 for 59 fl. oz.) too thin and "a little metallic" tasting, but agreed on its pleasant balance of sweet and tart.

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Tropicana

Tropicana Pure Premium Some Pulp

Taste testers deemed the pulp level ideal in Tropicana Pure Premium Some Pulp ($3.49 for 64 fl. oz.), but many disliked its slight acidity. One tester said it "tastes like it was made from concentrate."

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Tropicana

Tropicana Pure Premium No Pulp

Although most participants commented on the "bitter aftertaste" of Tropicana Pure Premium No Pulp ($3.49 for 64 fl. oz.), most enjoyed its level of sweetness and found it "pretty tasty."

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Florida's Natural

Florida's Natural No Pulp

Almost all tasters agreed on the bitterness of Florida's Natural No Pulp ($3 for 64 fl. oz.), but many loved its texture and found it "a little more natural than the others."

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Organic Valley

Organic Valley Pulp Free Orange Juice

Although some tasters found Organic Valley Pulp Free Orange Juice ($6 for 64 fl. oz.) reminiscent of "airline OJ," many found it "tangy" and fresh.

120 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Odwalla

Odwalla Orange Juice

A few volunteers thought Odwalla Orange Juice ($3.29 for 15.2 fl. oz.) had an artificial flavor, while they all agreed that it tasted "sweet and sugary."

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Organic Valley

Organic Valley Orange Juice with Pulp

Although many liked the amount of pulp in this juice, several participants agreed that Organic Valley Orange Juice with Pulp ($6 for 64 fl. oz.) "tastes more like a tangerine" than an orange and was a bit too tart.

120 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Minute Maid

Minute Maid Original

Just about every taster commented on the bitterness and "strange aftertaste" of Minute Maid Original ($3.29 for 64 fl. oz.); however, some enjoyed the "smooth texture."

110 calories per 8 oz. serving

Courtesy of Minute Maid

Minute Maid Pulp Free

The majority of our volunteers found Minute Maid Pulp Free ($3.29 for 64 fl. oz.) sweet, but too thin with a "slight plastic" flavor.

110 calories per 8 oz. serving






More from Good Housekeeping:

Coolest New Kitchen Gear For 2012

The Best New Low-Cal Meals

Haircuts That Take Off 10 Years

The Best New Makeup Under $20



Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Girl Savagely Edits Her Former Friend Out of Picture See the Hilarious Results

      Girl Hilariously Photoshops Friend Out of Picture

    • Fake Florida doctor who ‘enhanced’ buttocks with cement, caulking gets 10 years for manslaughter

      From a Florida prison in November 2011, Shatarka Nuby penned a letter to the state’s health department about her cosmetically enhanced buttocks. Her rear end had hardened and turned black, she wrote. Side effects from the years-old injections left the mother of three feeling sick. And she claimed her surgeon — Oneal Ron Morris — was the same faux cosmetic doctor that police had arrested and accused of pumping a near-lethal formula of cement, mineral oil, bathroom caulking and Fix-a-Flat tire sealant into other women’s bodies. Her patients called her “Duchess.” Officials began investigating and interviewed Nuby. But four months later, she was dead. The official cause of death was respiratory failure

      Washington Post q
    • Seventeen
    • Chris Kattan Tells All About His Secret 20-Year Health Nightmare After Breaking His Neck

      DWTS' Chris Kattan Reveals Devasting History of His Broken Neck Nightmare

    • Ohio State CB Kendall Sheffield Lost his Black Stripe Faster Than Any Buckeye Ever Has

      Urban Meyer instituted a tradition at Ohio State University when he became the Buckeyes' head coach in 2012. Every freshman or first-year Buckeye ...

      STACK q
    • Fake doc gets prison for deadly butt injections

      A woman dubbed the “Toxic Tush” doctor will spend a decade behind bars for using Super Glue and Fix-a-Flat tire sealant to enlarge women’s behinds and causing one patient to die. Oneal Ron Morris, 36, who is transgender, was sentenced to 10 years Monday in Florida’s Broward County court after pleading guilty to manslaughter and injecting several women with the toxic mixture, according to CBS Miami. Shatarka Nuby, 31, died after receiving as many as 10 injections from Morris between 2007 and 2010. She paid Morris as much as $2,000 for the deadly procedures, the Sun-Sentinel reported. “There’s no closure. Putting [Morris] in jail won’t bring her back,” said Nuby’s aunt Juanita in court. Morris,

      New York Post q
    • WWE's Paige: 'I wanted to physically harm myself' after photo leak

      "Not only for what millions was telling me but because my family and my husband were suffering the same fate from the internet because of my mistake," she wrote in a statement released on Twitter on Monday night. Paige, a two-time Divas champion who has been sidelined following neck surgery, acknowledged last week that "personal and private photos of mine were stolen" and shared without her consent. In Monday night's tweet, she spoke about the harm and the hurt the incident brought. "The one thing that was the hardest was thinking 'my husband is going to leave me' 'my family will disown me' but I'm blessed beyond words to have a family and a husband that stuck by me because they know who I am," she wrote.

      USA Today q
    • The Democratic National Committee just asked all its staffers to resign

      The newly-elected Democratic National Committee chairman Tom Perez has asked all of the...

      Business Insider
    • Hedge Fund Exec Swindled by Bernie Madoff Jumps to His Death From NYC Hotel

      Charles Murphy's hedge fund lost $7 billion to Madoff's Ponzi scheme.

      Inside Edition
    • Selena Gomez and The Weeknd Can’t Keep Their Hands to Themselves (6 photos)

      There's no debate: The hottest couple of the year (so far) is undoubtedly Selena Gomez and Abel Tesfaye, aka The Weeknd . The duo was first spotted just weeks after Tesfaye's breakup with model-of-the-moment Bella Hadid , kissing outside the back entrance of a restaurant--you can't out-sneak those eager-beaver paparazzi! From there, things just clearly heated up with Gomez and her new beau taking trips to Florence , Venice , Paris --where she very publicly planted a kiss on his cheek --and Dave & Busters . He even named dropped her in his song "Party Monster," further fueling the fire. VIDEO: Inside Selena Gomez's $3 Million Texas Home 5343744158001 And it's not just their romantic getaways that are riling up Selena-Weeknd shippers: the two were spotted getting cozy at a Grammy's after-party last month, Gomez attended one of his concerts in Amsterdam and was later seen wearing his tour merch , plus the songstress Instagrammed herself in what fan are convinced is Tesfaye's sweatshirt : a red champion hoodie. Most recently, the pair headed up north for a quiet weekend in The Weeknd's hometown of Toronto, where they reportedly rented out an entire movie theater to see Get Out. Scroll down below to see all of their cutest moments so far.

    • Texas man sentenced to 15 years for assaulting pregnant girlfriend

      LUBBOCK, Texas -- Jacob Pauda, 31, was found guilty of domestic violence and sentenced to 15 years in prison Monday, according to CBS affiliate KLBK-TV. Last week, Pauda was convicted of violently assaulting his pregnant girlfriend in February 2016, according to police reports. He reportedly chased her with a butcher’s knife. “[Pauda] then ran towards [the victim] with a closed right fist punched [her] repeatedly an unknown amount of times on the left side of [the victim’s] face,” according to the police report. SEE MORE: Outrageous mugshots The victim was able to call her mother to come get her.  But then Pauda became violent again.  According to a police report, the victim said the suspect

      CBS News q
    • Petition to Melania Trump: Move to the White House or pay for your own security at Trump Tower

      A petition to force First Lady Melania Trump to move to the White House or to pick up the costs for her security at Trump Tower has surpassed the 130,000 mark. The first lady intends to stay in New York until the couple's 11-year-old son Barron finishes the school year in June. "The US taxpayer is paying an exorbitant amount of money to protect the First Lady in Trump Tower, located in New York City," the petition states.

      International Business Times
    • Reality TV Show Drops People into the Wild for a Year, Doesn't Tell Them Show is Canceled

      After a year spent in the isolation of the Scottish wilderness, the contestants of Channel 4’s 'Eden' have returned to civilization, where they’ve been greeted by a few surprises.

      Entertainment Weekly
    • Killing of 3 teens during burglary may test Oklahoma 'stand your ground' law

      Three teen burglary suspects were shot and killed Monday by a homeowner's son armed with an assault rifle in Oklahoma -- which has a "stand your ground" law -- and the alleged getaway driver in the case was arrested on felony murder and other charges, authorities said. Oklahoma law presumes homeowners have a fear that justifies use of defensive force just by virtue of someone breaking into a home. A decision on charges for the shooter as well as formal charges for the alleged getaway driver, would be determined in the coming days, prosecutors said.

      Good Morning America
    • Only 1 person said anything remotely interesting about Tony Romo at the NFL owners meetings

      Plenty of questions were asked about Romo, but everyone had little to say. Tony Romo has been one of the biggest stories of this offseason, despite the fact that he’s still on the Dallas Cowboys roster and no moves have been made to change that. Romo’s under contract with the Cowboys, which means that teams have to tread lightly to avoid tampering.

      SB Nation q
    • FCC warns consumers about new 'Yes' phone scam

      The Federal Communications Commission is warning consumers about a new scam that is hooking consumers with just one word: Yes. According to the FCC, the scam begins as soon as a person answers the phone. "The caller then records the consumer's 'Yes' response and thus obtains a voice signature.

      Good Morning America
    • Special Ed Teacher Arrested Over Alleged Relationship With Student at All-Boys Middle School: Cops

      Rebecca Goerdel, 28, was arrested Friday for the alleged relationship with an unnamed boy.

      Inside Edition
    • Kate Middleton Hits the Art Scene in Lacy Green Gown

      The Temperley emerald green gown Kate Middleton wore to the National Portrait Gallery in London stole the show. Kate Middleton enjoyed an evening of art Tuesday wearing an emerald green gown. The duchess attended a gala dinner at the National Portrait Gallery in London wearing a green lace belted Temperley gown with sheer sleeves and gold open-toed shoes and carrying a $242 gold clutch from Wilbur and Gussie.

      Yahoo Style
    • People