Olive oil taste test

Consumer Reports

How to find the best extra-virgin olive oil

(Trader Joe’s California Estate oil)

Our taste tests show that some olive oils don’t make the grade.

Many “extra-virgin” olive oils, including some big names, don’t taste good enough to merit that description. By definition, extra-virgin olive oil is supposed to be flawless, but only the top nine of the 23 products our experts tried were free of flaws.

Consumer Reports purchased 138 bottles of extra-virgin olive oil from twenty-three manufacturers. The olive oil was sourced from a variety of countries including the U.S., Argentina, Greece, Chile and Italy.

More than half tasted fermented or stale. Two even tasted a bit like . . . let’s just say a barnyard. That problem can occur if oil is stored in vats containing sediment that has begun to ferment. The good news is that two products were excellent; one of those is a Consumer Reports' Best Buy.

You may not be able to easily spot a dud. Most people don’t sip olive oil straight from a glass, as our experts did, and foods can mask imperfections. In addition, many consumers assume that olive oil should be a liquid version of the fruit they put in a salad or martini. Wrong. Superior oils are fresh and fragrant, with complex flavors of ripe and unripe fruit, grass, herbs, nuts, or butter, for starters. If you’re used to a particular product, you might not realize what you’re missing until you do your own side-by-side comparison. It’s like learning to appreciate and enjoy fine wine.


MORE AT COnsumer Reports

Several big name brands earn some of the lowest scores

The Consumer Reports' Ratings show that you don’t need to buy oil with an Italian heritage to experience the best.

Oils produced in California surpassed those with an Italian heritage in Consumer Reports' latest taste-tests of 23 extra-virgin varieties, which are supposed to represent the pinnacle of quality. McEvoy Ranch (grown on a 550-acre property in Petaluma) and Trader Joe's California Estate, both from California, earned the highest scores and were the only products deemed "Excellent."

(See also: 8 times you shouldn't pick the fat-free option)

Three of the six "Very Good" oils also have a California pedigree: B.R. Cohn, 365 Everyday Value (Whole Foods), and California Olive Ranch. O-Live & Co. is pressed from Chilean olives. Only Lucini Premium Select and Kirkland Signature (Costco) Select Toscano are from olives grown in Italy.

Three were designated Consumer Reports' Best Buys ─ Trader Joe's California Estate and Kirkland Signature Select Toscano (Costco) ─ both at 35 cents an ounce─and 365 Everyday Value 100% Californian Unfiltered from Whole Foods, at 38 cents an ounce. 

Well-known brands, including Bertolli, Crisco, Filippo Berio, Goya, and Mazola tasted somewhat stale and had a variety of other flaws. Botticelli and Capatriti were described as old-tasting and barnyardlike. Goya, a winner in past taste-tests, was somewhat pungent and slightly bitter this time around.

What’s extra-virgin, anyway?

In Europe, the International Olive Council, chartered by the United Nations, establishes standards and works to ensure that products labeled extra-virgin, the highest grade of oil, live up to their billing; the countries do the policing. According to the IOC, extra-virgin olive oil must meet strict chemical and organoleptic (taste and smell) standards, including low levels of acidity and ultraviolet-light absorption. (High levels suggest poor processing or deterioration.) It has been extracted from mashed fruit by mechanical means, not through the use of heat or chemicals, which can reduce flavor. It should have at least some fruitiness and be free of defects in flavor and aroma.


Consumer Reports recommends using the top-rated extra-virgin olive oils in ways that will show off their strong, complex, fresh taste ─ such as drizzling them over bread. Lesser products can be used in cooking, which can mask an unpleasant taste. 



Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Missing Toddler Found Dead After She Vanished While Playing in Yard

      One-year-old Semaj Crosby was found dead in a Joliet, Ill., home.

      Inside Edition
    • Caitlyn Jenner claims she knew O.J. Simpson was guilty — and so did Robert Kardashian

      Caitlyn Jenner is revealing secrets of the Kardashian family, as well as some of her own...

      Business Insider
    • Ivanka Trump Gushes Over Melania On Her 47th Birthday

      On Sunday, a Vanity Fair report claimed that Ivanka and her stepmother have had cold interactions with each other.

      International Business Times
    • On his birthday, his 13-year-old sister hugged him. Then he shot her in the head

      On Martaevious Santiago’s 17th birthday, he shot his 13-year-old sister in the back of the head. She had just hugged him in the kitchen of the family’s Florida City home, police said. As they separated and Tedra King walked away, Martaevious pointed a loaded semiautomatic handgun at her. Then he pulled the trigger and killed her. Martaevious told police it was an accident. The shooting happened Tuesday night inside a modest Florida City subdivision called Washington Park. Outside the home on Wednesday, shocked family members — some on the way to identify the young girl’s body at the morgue — demanded privacy. “Everybody that knows a word of prayer, please pray for the Bess family,” close family

      Miami Herald q
    • In pictures: North Korea carries out massive military test in show of might (14 photos)

      North Korea has conducted what it has called its largest ever combined live-fire drill in an incredible display of power . Hundreds of tanks massed on the coast for the exercise, which involved the firing of more than 300 large-calibre artillery pieces and included submarine torpedo-attacks on mock enemy warships. The secretive state’s official media reported that leader Kim Jong-Un personally observed the show of might. Tensions have been simmering in the region as the relationship between Kim Jong-un and Donald Trump deteriorates. The latest military exercise, celebrating the the anniversary of the founding of the North Korean army, is a stark reminder of the damage North Korea could inflict on neighbouring South Korea. It had been suggested that Kim Jong-un would use the occasion to carry out the country’s sixth nuclear test. MORE: Chernobyl disaster: The nuclear ghost town 31 years later MORE: Pictures of the week: Sunrises, soldiers and sumo wrestlers

      Yahoo News UK
    • United Airlines: Giant rabbit's mysterious death sends Twitter hopping with hilarious memes

      A giant 10-month-old continental rabbit named Simon, set to become the biggest in the world, was mysteriously found dead after a United Airlines flight from London to Chicago on Monday (24 April). Edwards said the giant rabbit was being delivered to its new owner – a celebrity whom she did not identify. The animal was found dead in the cargo hold where it was placed after the plane landed in Chicago.

      International Business Times
    • What It's Like to Live With Treacher Collins

      "What I really think has had the most impact on me is the realization that I'm 34 years old and I've never had a boyfriend."

      Cosmopolitan
    • Warriors, Charles Barkley and Bob Ley pay tribute to fired ESPN workers

      Charles Barkley said he had worked closely with ESPN journalists down the years. After a tumultuous day at ESPN, in which the broadcaster laid off around 100 employees on Wednesday, including some of the network’s most popular on-air and online personalities, tributes were paid to those who lost their jobs. Perhaps the most striking came from the Golden State Warriors.

      The Guardian
    • Mom Tells Teachers Her Daughter Is "Done" With Homework in Bold Email

      If you ever worried about why your child was coming home with hours upon hours of homework each night, Bunmi Laditan — the mom behind The Honest Toddler blog — can not only relate, but she can also serve as a reminder that you have the power to put a stop to it. "My kid is done with homework," she wrote in a heated Facebook post. "I just sent an email to her school letting her know she's all done. I said 'drastically reduce' but I was trying to be polite because she's finished." She noted how her 10-year-old daughter, Maya — who is in school from 8:15 a.m. to 4 p.m. and still has two to three hours of homework each evening — "loves learning" but has become more and more stressed by school. She's

      PopSugar q
    • People
    • Kim Kardashian Speaks Out About Caitlyn Jenner’s ‘Hurtful’ Book: ‘My Heart Breaks for My Mom’

      Kim opened up about Caitlyn’s book in a tell-all interview on “The Ellen DeGeneres Show.”

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Fox News' Jesse Watters appears to make lewd Ivanka Trump joke then takes abrupt holiday

      A Fox News presenter is taking a break from TV after he made a joke about Ivanka Trump that was widely interpreted as a sexual innuendo. Moments after suggesting left-wingers booing the first daughter, were being disrespectful, Jesse Watters said he "liked how she was speaking into that microphone", before smirking at his fellow presenters. Mr Watters said during a live broadcast: "It’s funny, the left says they really respect women, and then when given an opportunity to respect a woman like that, they boo and hiss.

      The Independent
    • Even Donald Trump's birthday tweet to Melania has a factual error it in

      Our Tweeter in Chief Donald Trump, is known for playing fast and loose with facts, but you'd think a birthday message to his wife would be a nice softball. He can garner a few awws and then move on.  Nope. SEE ALSO: The only Melania in the White House is this photograph On Wednesday, Melania Trump celebrated her birthday. And like most loved ones do on their spouse's birthday, Donald Trump took to Twitter to send his best wishes to his wife. HAPPY BIRTHDAY to our @FLOTUS, Melania! https://t.co/rYYp51mxDQ pic.twitter.com/np7KYHglSv — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) April 26, 2017 However, when it came to the graphics, there was a ball drop. Or a star drop, if you will. If you look closely you'll notice that the flag in that graphics package only has 39 stars, which leaves out quite a number of states.  And because nothing escapes the internet, Twitter definitely noticed. There are only 39 stars on that flag, sir. https://t.co/KATgoLIQUv — Dan Zak (@MrDanZak) April 27, 2017 This is so weird: The American flag on @FLOTUS Melania Trump's birthday card only has 39 stars. H/t: @eventsforgood pic.twitter.com/IYd2hdOXGJ — Christina Wilkie (@christinawilkie) April 27, 2017 Very weird. Since the 39 star flag was never official since we went from 38 to 42 states in 1890. https://t.co/TG5JWAPOA3 — MyNinjaTurtle (@MyNinjaTurtle) April 27, 2017 @chrislhayes Wonder which 11 states are slated for destruction? #39StarFlag pic.twitter.com/KKkIS1ElZB — kathy greenstone (@KathyGreenstone) April 27, 2017 To make matters even more worse, this is not the first time Donald Trump has shared the 39-star flag. As MSNBC's Chris Hayes pointed out, Donald Trump also shared the flag at the end of the video welcoming freed Egyptian American Aya Hijazi who was imprisoned in Cairo. @christinawilkie @FLOTUS @eventsforgood IT'S THE SAME FLAG IN THE END OF THIS VIDEO!!!! https://t.co/jZOSS7VjNh — Christopher Hayes (@chrislhayes) April 27, 2017 Someone in the WH graphics operation has a 39-star flag saved on their computer as the current flag and is using it everything! — Christopher Hayes (@chrislhayes) April 27, 2017 For reference, Mr. President, we've never actually had a 39-star flag in the history of the United States.  The design was actually created in 1889 when flag makers were anticipating the addition of the Dakotas to the United states. Flag makers incorrectly assumed that what we know as North Dakota and South Dakota would be admitted to the US as only one state, not two. The New York Times notes:  Long story short, flag makers jumped the gun, so now 39-star flag was never an official flag. They are now just collectors items. Note: there was never an official 39-star flag, but some folks thought there would be 39 states in 1889, so some flags were actually created — Brian Ruh (@brianruh) September 5, 2016 WE NEVER EVEN HAD A 39 STAR FLAG https://t.co/XpMS0LMd97 — SheriffFruitfly (@sherifffruitfly) April 27, 2017 Now, to be fair, this is probably just a graphic design mistake from the White House art department, not a comment on how many states Trump wishes we had. But the fact stands: The. President. Of. The. United. States. Tweeted. A. Fake. Flag. Happy Birthday, Melania!

      Mashable
    • Recovering heroin addict explains why it's so hard to stay clean — even in rehab

      Andi Peterson, a 26-year-old Utah resident, suffered a years-long heroin addiction before she was old enough to vote. Like many suffering in today's opioid crisis, Peterson got hooked after being introduced to prescription opioids at 16. Peterson had more advantages to getting clean than many affected by opioids. Her parents were supportive and she had health insurance and access to drug treatment centers. But even still, it took her the better part of a decade, half a dozen stints in treatments centers, and finally a year in prison before she finally broke free three years ago.  While she saw many addicts succeed in treatment and rehabilitation centers, they never worked for her. And she said

      Business Insider q
    • Missing Man`s Body Found Encased in Concrete

      Police say the body of a Missouri man who had reportedly walked away from an assisted living center was found in a shipping container filled with cement.

      Tribune
    • “80 sets of invisible eyes rolling”: senators unimpressed by White House North Korea brief

      Wednesday afternoon, nearly the entire membership of the US Senate packed into a bus and headed to the White House grounds for an unprecedented classified briefing from top Trump administration officials on North Korea policy. Such a huge meeting, on such a volatile topic, had people wondering — was the United States about to announce some risky new policy on North Korea? According to senators who attended the briefing, it was a whole lot of nothing.

      Vox.com q
    • Jeff Goldblum joined the “Jurassic World” sequel, and everyone on the internet made the same “Jurassic Park” joke

      In full disclosure, when I first heard that Jeff Goldblum would be joining the Jurassic World sequel, reprising his role as Dr. Ian…

      Hello Giggles
    • Russian Navy Ship Sinks Off The Turkish Coast After Crashing Into Cargo Vessel

      A Russian naval intelligence ship sank off Turkey's Black Sea coast on Thursday after colliding with a vessel carrying livestock and all 78 personnel on board were evacuated, Turkey's coastal safety authority said. It occurred 18 miles (29 km) from Kilyos village on the Black Sea coast just north of Istanbul, broadcaster NTV said. Turkish authorities dispatched a tugboat and three fast rescue vessels, the coastal safety authority said.

      Newsweek
    • Erin Moran's Husband Releases a Heartbreaking Statement About How She Died

      She passed away at home, holding her husband's hand.

      Country Living
    • Here’s Everyone Laid Off at ESPN, From Andy Katz to Trent Dilfer (Updating List)

      ESPN announced Wednesday that it would lay off roughly 100 on-air personalities and writers, TheWrap has learned. The names of impacted, now-former employees are starting to become public.

      The Wrap 39 min ago