How to come out on top when buying a mattress

Consumer Reports
Finding a new mattress

(Photo: Thinkstock)

Five tips for choosing the best mattress, plus three new tricks for your old mattresses.

Getting a good night’s rest doesn’t have to cost a fortune.  Consumer Reports’ most comprehensive test of mattresses found models that performed well and cost under $1,000.

”You don’t have to spend thousands to get a great mattress,” said Bob Markovich, home and yard editor for Consumer Reports.  “Our first full performance ratings make it easier to find one that works for you and your sleep partner if you have one – and we found there are many affordable options.”

MORE AT CONSUMER REPORTS

Consumer Reports tested 12 models from Ikea, Sealy, Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster and Tempur-Pedic, plus Costco’s Novaform brand.  Simmons’ performance varied the most in this test.  The manufacturer’s Beautyrest Glover Park Firm Pillowtop (sold at Sears), a CR Best Buy at $780, topped the ratings of conventional, innerspring mattresses while its ComforPedic Loft Crestwood Luxury Plush, $1,920, earned the lowest scores among foam models and overall.

Overall, foam models fared a bit worse than innerspring mattresses in Consumer Reports’ tests.   The recommended Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Simplicity, $1,200, earned the highest scores.  But Sleep Innovations Novafoam Memory Foam Collection Serafina (Costco), a CR Best Buy at $900, virtually tied the Tempur-Pedic for $300 less. 

When it comes to mattress shopping, roughly 40 percent of surveyed subscribers said that they had buyer’s remorse. 


Finding a new mattress

Five Tips for Choosing a New Mattress

Consumer Reports’ latest tests confirm that more coils, fancier fabrics and frills found on pricier models don’t guarantee a better mattress.  And the best mattress isn’t always necessarily the firmest, even for those who suffer from pain.




  1. Try before buying. Don’t rely on softness or firmness claims – nearly half the mattresses Consumer Reports tested were softer than promised.  Gauge comfort by lying on any mattress in consideration.  Spend at least ten minutes on each side, back, and stomach – depending on typical sleep position.

    (See also: Consumer Reports best vacuums)

  2. Win the name game. Mattress makers offer some lines nationally.  Those available at major retailers like Macy’s, Sears, and Sleepy’s are typically exclusive to those chains.  And because retailers often change model names, it’s hard to compare models store to store so use Consumer Reports performance ratings as a guide.

  3. Consider the winter months. Using a temperature-controller chamber, Consumer Reports tests found three innerspring and three memory-form mattresses that were better at retaining body heat, which should help keep users warm when the weather turns cold without feeling clammy when it’s hot.

  4. Keep an old box spring if possible.  Replacing the box spring that goes beneath a mattress can cost anywhere from $150 to more than $300.  For those swapping out an innerspring mattress for a new one, keep the box spring if it is not sagging or damaged.  If switching to memory foam, a solid platform may be necessary to provide enough support.  However, for both foam and innerspring mattresses, some brands require consumers to purchase their box spring purchase to receive the full warranty.

  5. Don’t forget to haggle.  Most mattresses have huge markups that allow retailers to run frequent “sales” of up to 50 percent off.  But don’t wait for a promotion to save – one-third of Consumer Reports’ subscribers who haggled slashed $150 or more off the price.

Three New Tricks for Old Mattresses

People typically keep their mattresses roughly ten years before replacing them. Consumer Reports recommends tossing any mattress that shows sags or lumps.  For a mattress that looks serviceable but causes discomfort, try these quick fixes before buying a new one.

  1. Flip or rotate it.  Many older, conventional innerspring mattresses can often be flipped and rotated.  But models with an obvious top layer can only be rotated.  And those with different firmness levels for each sleep partner, including some memory-foam can’t be flipped or rotated.

  2. Check the pillow.  A firmer or softer one may be what it takes to nod off. Evaluate the firmness of pillows by putting them on a flat surface and compressing them to about half of their original thickness; the more pressure needed, the firmer the pillow.

  3. Top it off.  A mattress topper can improve a too-hard bed.  Consumer Reports tests have found that paying more for foam- and feather-filled toppers didn’t guarantee more comfort. 



Copyright © 2006-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Classmates Keep Missing Boy’s Desk Empty as Tribute After Friend Allegedly Helps Murder Him

      The recent discovery of a missing Alaska teen’s dead body, weeks after he vanished — and the subsequent arrest of one of his friends — has shaken their small community. In mourning 16-year-old David Grunwald, they are also remembering his life: One his teachers tells PEOPLE the boy’s desk chair is being kept empty in tribute to the funny and eager student, who dreamed of being a pilot. “We all miss him,” Zack Lanphier, David’s former high school teacher at Mat-Su Career & Tech, tells PEOPLE.

      People
    • Victoria’s Secret Apologizes to Customer Booted During ‘Shopping While Black’ Incident

      Victoria’s Secret has apologized to a woman who was asked to leave the store. A woman shopping at a Victoria’s Secret in the Quintard Mall in Oxford, Ala., says she was shocked and dismayed to be asked to leave the store. Traveling nurse Kimberly Houzah says she and a second black shopper were made to leave after a store manager caught another black woman shoplifting.

      Yahoo Style
    • Chart shows exactly how Trump's tax plan could affect you

      While some richer taxpayers could benefit from Trump's proposed reforms, others may end up paying more.

      CNBC
    • Bindi Irwin posted the sweetest goodbye message to her boyfriend, and our hearts are melting and breaking all at once

      Long distance relationships are HARD, but not impossible. Just look at Bindi Irwin (daughter of the late Steve Irwin) and her American boyfriend, pro…

      Hello Giggles
    • Pennsylvania Teen, 18, Streamed Fatal Car Crash on Facebook Live

      A teenage driver was streaming to Facebook Live while she drove along a Pennsylvania highway just before a tractor-trailer rear ended her vehicle after midnight Tuesday, killing her and a passenger in a fiery wreck. Brooke Miranda Hughes, 18, was behind the wheel on Interstate 380 near Tobyhanna as she live-streamed her car ride with 19-year-old friend, Chaniya Morrison-Toomey, who can be heard saying “Are you going live?” in the now-deleted footage, according to the Associated Press. Before Hughes could answer, bright lights flash inside the car and sounds of screeching tires can be heard, followed by seven-minutes of blackness, the Scranton Times-Tribune reported.

      People
    • Yahoo Finance Video
    • Husband who hasn’t had sex in years asks, ‘Is this normal?’

      Hi, Carolyn: Should I be worried that my wife and I have had no sex for literally years? I am guessing it is at least three years. Not even heavy make-out sessions. It just seems that my wife has no interest. I am afraid to broach the subject for fear of a negative answer. We don’t sleep in the same bed anymore either. I am a big snorer and chose to sleep in the guest room. It’s fine because she is a light sleeper and I am happier that she is getting her sleep. I do use a CPAP but it does come off sometimes. The no-sex thing just happened over time. We have both gained some weight but we are not obese — we could both lose 20 or 30 pounds. Is this normal or should we seek help? J.: Should I be

      Washington Post q
    • Days of Our Lives Star Joseph Mascolo, Who Played Stefano, Dead at 87

      Joseph Mascolo, who played iconic villain Stefano DiMera on the NBC daytime soap Days of Our Lives, has died. He was 87 years old. Mascolo passed away Thursday after a long battle with Alzheimer’s disease, the show said in a statement on Friday. He joined the Days cast in 1982 and made crime lord/business tycoon Stefano DiMera into one of the most hated (and most loved) bad guys in soap-opera history. Mascolo left and returned to the role of Stefano several times over the years, even joining CBS’ The Bold and the Beautiful for an extended stint from 2001 to 2006. But he always came back to Days, most recently for the character’s death earlier this year. He also made appearances on TV shows like

      TVLine q
    • Coupled Up: Malika Haqq and 'Jersey Shore' Star Ronnie Magro Are Dating [Photos] | B. Scott

      Malika Haqq and Jersey Shore alum Ronnie Magro are officially an item! The new couple met and connected while filming the second season of E!’s relationship rehab series Famously Single and have been going strong for about a month now. via E!: “We had a lot in common from the start and it was an instant friendship. The attraction quickly became a mutual romance,” Malika and Ronnie tell E! News exclusively. “Our support for one another through this challenging experience made us strong in a very short period of time. We had an opportunity to really get to know each other living in such close quarter.” The lovebirds added, “Our family and friends are aware that we are together and extremely supportive

      B. Scott | lovebscott.com q
    • UPS Driver Who Spotted 'Call 911' Scrawled on Package Helps Save Captive Woman

      A 3-year-old child was locked in a room of the house during the ordeal.

      Inside Edition
    • Critics: Alabama execution helps case against sedative

      Critics of a drug used to sedate inmates before they are put to death said Friday that an Alabama execution in which a prisoner heaved his chest, coughed and appeared to move bolstered their argument that the drug should not be used in lethal injections. Alabama prison officials insisted there was no reason to believe Robert Bert Smith Jr. suffered after receiving the first of three drugs. The debate focuses on midazolam, a drug that has been used in executions that were called into question in several other states.

      Associated Press 29 min ago
    • Some Trump supporters threaten to boycott 'Star Wars' on rumors Disney flatly denies

      "Star Wars: Rogue One" will soon be released in cinemas, but some fans are threatening to pull their support for the latest entry in the series.

      CNBC
    • Two Malibu property owners fined $5.1 million for blocking access to public beach

      For decades, some Malibu property owners have made it hard for the public to reach public beaches. On Thursday, the California Coastal Commission fined two of those property owners more than $5.1 million for denying surfers, sand castle builders, kite flyers, sun bathers, yoga enthusiasts and other beachgoers access to the sand that is theirs by state law. In one of those decisions, the commission had battled for nine years with Dr. Warren M. Lent and his wife, Henny, before unanimously approving Thursday’s cease-and-desist order for the couple and fining them about $4.2 million for diverting a public easement to private use at an expensive oceanfront rental they own at Las Flores Beach. “This represents an attitude we often see in Malibu — that the shore is our private backyard,” said Commissioner Mark Vargas, who made the motion at Thursday’s hearing for a $4.185-million fine.

      Los Angeles Times q
    • Parents Are Furious at This Bestselling Author for Buying $23,600 Worth of ‘Hatchimals’

      Sara Gruen wrote Water for Elephants, and now she’s written a plea to her fans to help her cause. New York Times bestselling author Sara Gruen has a big problem on her hands — well, 166 problems, to be exact. Right after the Black Friday rush, Gruen learned that this season’s must-have gift is Hatchimals: interactive, battery-operated “animals” that live inside “eggs” that eventually hatch to reveal a surprise creature once you’ve nurtured and cared for your egg during its gestation.

      Yahoo Beauty
    • This Classic '80s Trend is About to Make a Huge Comeback (13 photos)

      It's December, which means those winter excursions to the mountains are right around the corner – time to prepare your best snow bunny OOTDs for Instagram pictures along the white shimmery slopes. According to Polyvore , people have already started to look for the perfect ski attire, with searches for ski pants up 84% in comparison to last year. That may be influenced in part by the appearance of ski-inspired stirrup pants on the Fall 2016 runways at Balenciaga. In doing so, designer Demna Gvasalia set a huge trend, with mass retailers releasing similar styles shortly after his presentation. Can you blame them? Before they were an ’80s staple, they were a symbol of Old Hollywood glamour. They first made an appearance in the 1950s, when Bogner released the stirrup pants which became an instant success and were eventually nicknamed "The Bogners." Actresses like Marilyn Monroe donned the pants as they vacationed in the mountains. So if you're looking for a cute look to wear on or off the slopes this winter, get yourself a pair of stirrup ski pants! They're more flattering then the typical bulky ski pants that only make you look like a marshmallow. If you can't find one you particularly like but like the look of the stirrup, fake it till you make it , with a pair of stirrup leggings worn underneath a more form-fitting ski pant. So hit the slopes in style and shop ahead some of our favorite ski stirrups and pants. Follow us on Instagram , Facebook , and Pinterest for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day.

      Yahoo Style
    • What Happened to Sherri Papini’s Schoolmate Who Also Vanished 18 Years Ago in the Same City?

      Sherri Papini — a mom of two and former schoolmate of Tera’s who disappeared 18 years later during a jog in Redding about two-and-a-half miles from where Tera vanished — had a luckier outcome: She was found alive, but beaten and chained, on Thanksgiving morning, following an apparent abduction. “Keith came to me, and we spoke for about an hour,” Terry Smith tells PEOPLE. Sherri’s case “brought back some very vivid memories and our hearts went out to Keith and his kids,” Terry says.

      People
    • In ‘Jackie,’ Jackie Kennedy is a bad widow. That’s good.

      When I began dating the man who would eventually become my husband, my mom had only one concern: that he, 17 years my senior, would die and leave me a “young widow.” “If he lives to the same age his father did, I’ll be 43 when he dies,” I said, laughing at how far away that impossible number seemed. I turned 40 last week. My husband is in good health (for a man of his advanced age, HI HONEY!), but I’d be lying if I said there’s not a small part of my brain constantly reminding me that he — we — have three years left. “Jackie” is the story of one of the most famous young widows in history: Jackie Kennedy was 34 when her husband was assassinated. I’ve only seen the archival footage that all of

      Washington Post q
    • Mika Brzezinski says Clinton campaign wanted her 'pulled off the air'

      It sounds like Hillary Clinton's campaign was not above putting the screws to journalists who were critical of her during her presidential run. During Friday’s episode of MSNBC’s “Morning Joe,” co-host Mika Brzezinski claimed that while Clinton and Donald Trump were battling for the White House, the Clinton campaign attempted to get her “pulled off the air.” Brzezinski said the incident took place after she hinted that Clinton didn’t have the presidential election in the bag as many thought. “I was concerned the campaign was not understanding that perhaps there was an arrogance. They needed to sort of get off their high horse and understand that this isn’t over,” Brzezinski recalled on Friday.

      Fox News q
    • 'Star in a Jar' Fusion Reactor Works and Promises Infinite Energy

      For several decades now, scientists from around the world have been pursuing a ridiculously ambitious goal: They hope to develop a nuclear fusion reactor that would generate energy in the same manner as the sun and other stars, but down here on Earth. Incorporated into terrestrial power plants, this "star in a jar" technology would essentially provide Earth with limitless clean energy, forever. In a study published in the latest edition of the journal Nature Communications, researchers confirmed that Germany's Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X) fusion energy device is on track and working as planned. It works like this: Unlike a traditional fission reactor, which splits atoms of heavy elements to generate energy, a fusion reactor works by fusing the nuclei of lighter atoms into heavier atoms.

      SPACE.com q
    • Paula Broadwell breaks her silence 5 years after the Petraeus affair

      Paula Broadwell is finally breaking her silence over her affair with former CIA director and retired Gen. David Petraeus because she says she wants to reclaim her “own narrative” and career. Broadwell, a former military intelligence officer and biographer, admitted to having an extramarital affair with Petraeus, whom she met while researching a book on his life. Petraeus, who is reportedly being considered by President-elect Donald Trump for secretary of state, later admitted he shared classified information with Broadwell.

      Yahoo News