Green all-purpose cleaners lose out to a veteran

Consumer Reports
Green Cleaners Test

Can one household cleaner vanquish tough kitchen stains such as grease and grape juice; soap scum and other bathroom scourges; and stubborn mineral deposits left by hard water?

To find out, we applied those and other common stains to tiles; sprayed or wiped on 19 all-purpose cleaners, and inserted the tiles into our special scrubbing apparatus. In our tough tests, only Pine-Sol Original cleaned well enough to be recommended, earning high marks on all stains. It did so without streaking, and at 9 cents per ounce is a CR Best Buy.

MORE AT COnsumer Reports

All-purpose cleaners are typically used to clean such household surfaces as kitchen counters and bathroom tiles. In our labs we pit them against four soil types—grease, grape juice, ketchup and mustard that we spread on glass, ceramic and metal tiles. Then it's on to the soap scum test.

Finally, we see if the cleaners leave streaks behind. Only the Pine-Sol aced that test. It was also very good at removing stains and soap scum and was the only cleaner to make our list of top-picks.

Green Works Cleaner
Two green cleaners topped our list of sprays but neither were good enough to be recommended. Seventh Generation Natural All-Purpose Cleaner was very good at removing soap scum but needed extra elbow grease to remove the food and was only so-so on the streaking test.

Green Works All-Purpose Cleaner performed similarly but didn’t do quite as well on the soap scum test. Another green cleaner landed near the bottom of the rankings despite its upbeat name.

Whip-It Earth Friendly Miracle Cleaner Multi-Purpose had trouble removing both soap scum and food soil and left streaks behind as well.

(See also: Best stain removing products and cleaning tips)

Keep in mind that not all green claims are meaningful. Here's what our experts say about the claims you'll see in the cleaning supplies aisle.



Claim. USDA Organic.
Definition. At least 95 percent of ingredients must be plant-based.
Brand. Green Mission.
Our take. Meaningful.

Claim. Leaping Bunny
Definition. Company pledges that no animal testing was used in developing the product.
Brand. Seventh Generation.
Our take. Meaningful.

Claim. EPA's Design for the Environment (DfE).
Definition. Product uses ingredients deemed "safest in class" by government.
Brand. Green Works.
Our take. Meaningful.

Claim. Natural.
Definition. Implies no added synthetic ingredients. But no standard exists, and even truly all-natural products aren't necessarily safer than synthetic ones.
Brands. Method, Seventh Generation, Trader Joe's, Whip-It.
Our take. Not meaningful. Look for more specific claims.

Claim. Earth-friendly or Ecological.
Definition. Implies no harm to the environment. But no standard exists, and the Federal Trade Commission cautions against use of the term.
Brands. Ecover, Whip-It.
Our take. Not meaningful.

Claim. Nontoxic.
Definition. Implies no harm to health. But no standard exists.
Brands. Green Mission, Method, Seventh Generation, Whip-It.
Our take. Not meaningful.




Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Amber Rose and Val Chmerkovskiy Hold Hands in Los Angeles

      Amber Rose and Dancing with the Stars‘s latest champ were spotted holding hands as they walked to Delilah in Los Angeles on Friday night. Rose, 33, was all smiles in a black velvet romper and knee-high boots, while the younger Chmerkovskiy brother, 30, sported an all-black ensemble.

      People
    • That Viral Video of a Man Punching a Kangaroo Actually Has a Sad Backstory

      Video of an Australian man boxing a kangaroo to save his dog went viral last week, but there is more to the story than meets the eye. Greig Tonkins and his pals were on a boar hunting trip with their friend Kailem Barwick, a 19-year-old who was diagnosed with terminal cancer, hoping to catch an elusive "tonner"—a wild boar that weighs more than 100 kilograms (around 220 pounds), the Daily Mail reported. This Guy Punched a Kangaroo In Face to Save a Dog During the trip, one of the dogs ran into a kangaroo while chasing a scent. Tonkins quickly ran to the dog's aide and intervened, first distracting the kangaroo and causing it to release the dog from a headlock. Thankfully the dog was wearing protective

      Esquire q
    • ‘Big Bang Theory’ Stars Jim Parsons, Kaley Cuoco Pay Tribute To Simon Helberg

      Simon Helberg is celebrating his 36th birthday today, and his co-stars have shared sweet messages for him on Instagram.

      International Business Times
    • South Dakota State scores touchdown on fantastic trick play where they hide the runner with the ball

      South Dakota State took an early 7-0 lead on North Dakota State on Saturday with one of the more...

      Business Insider
    • Why Gaslighting Is Such a Secretly Sinister Form of Emotional Abuse

      Once in a while, it's normal to have a fleeting moment where you question your own sanity, like when you're severely sleep deprived or stressed out. But if a relationship leaves you constantly second-guessing your own instincts and feelings, you may be a victim of a sophisticated form of emotional ...

      xoJane
    • Ask Amy: Ex-husband wants to issue STD warning

      DEAR AMY: My wife of more than 40 years and I had a mutual parting of ways five years ago. We harbor no searing animosity toward one another and we regularly talk in civil and polite tones. She thought I was going in the wrong direction, but I quickly made an effort to meet a new woman through online dating. I was successful in that venture. My ex joined many different clubs and organizations and eventually fell in with a man whose company she enjoys. Happy ending? I wish. I was happy for my ex, but women I met online told me that this guy continues to occupy a spot in the online dating scene, messaging women about his availability. It is not my business, but I’d also rather not have her contract

      MercuryNews.com q
    • Dear Abby: Ratty clothes on boy may be a ploy

      DEAR ABBY: You missed the mark in your answer to “Mother Doesn’t Know Best” (July 7), whose 8-year-old stepson arrives for visits in old, ill-fitting clothing, even though the father purchases new clothes for him on every visit. I live in Ohio, and the state considers housing, food, electricity, gas and running water as part of the makeup of child support. I know this firsthand. You also need to know if the mother is working and if she contributes to her son’s support. What about other expenses (toys, haircuts, uniforms, etc.)? Part of the problem may be that Stepmom and Dad live across the country and aren’t there to see what exactly goes on day to day. Yes, the little boy shouldn’t be showing

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • Kirk Douglas Turns 100 — With Help From Son Michael and Catherine Zeta-Jones

      The Spartacus star, who was given an honorary Academy Award in 1996 for his many accomplishments in the movie biz, hasn’t made public appearances in the past few years, and although he’s not on social media himself, he’s getting birthday wishes from his nearest and dearest. Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta-Jones, of course, led the charge, paying tribute to “Dad” and “Pappy” — with the actress posting an especially cute video featuring Kirk the Dancing King.

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • The Obamas Couldn't Look More Glam in Final White House Holiday Card

      Happy holidays from the Obama family, to yours. President Barack, First Lady Michelle, and their daughters Malia, and Sasha Obama all look as stunning as ever on their 2016 Christmas card, sent out to a lucky few million around the United States. The photo was taken at the Obamas' first state dinner as a whole family--Sasha and Malia had yet to attend one of the black tie events--back in March of this year. If you didn't receive a card in the mail (don't worry, neither did we), never fear,

      InStyle
    • San Jose teacher booked on charges of felony sexual assault with minor

      A San Jose high school community is in shock this morning, over the arrest of one of their teachers. Police accuse her of luring a student into a sexual relationship.

      KGO – San Francisco
    • No One Voted to Destroy Social Security

      Not a single candidate in 2016 campaigned on a promise to repeal and replace Social Security or Medicare. Anyone who did would have been soundly defeated. Indeed, unlike the Republican opponents he beat, Donald Trump promised not to touch Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid. But now that the Republicans will soon be in charge of all branches of government, destroying Social Security and Medicare is on the top of their agenda. Two days after the election, Paul Ryan said, “With a unified Republican government, we can actually get things done.” One of those things is ending Medicare as we know it, as I and others have spotlighted. It turns out that Social Security is in the Republicans’ cross

      The Huffington Post q
    • Microsoft is serving up Windows 10 tablets for $49 and $59, but only on Friday

      As part of Microsoft's 12 Days of Deals, Microsoft has slashed the prices of Windows 10 tablets and 2-in-1 PCs. This particular sale is for Friday only, offering two tablets with $49 and $60 price tags, and 2-in-1 PCs starting at $179.

      Digital Trends
    • Look at South Dakota State score a playoff TD on this schoolyard trick play

      Bringing the playground to the FCS Playoffs. If South Dakota State ends up beating five-time defending national champion North Dakota State in the FCS Playoffs, this trickeration is something you can point to as a reason.Something straight out of "Little Giants"! This is how South Dakota St. just scored on NDSU...#Jackrabbits #Bison pic.twitter.com/Bl9bJPU5GP— Hobie Artigue (@HobieFOX9) December 10, 2016A 5’10 Brady Mengarelli sneaks in, giving SDSU an early lead in the Fargodome.The concept here is simple. ...

      SB Nation q
    • Town & Country
    • Stars Over 90, Then & Now (9 photos)

      Kirk Douglas turned 100 Friday. The iconic actor is one of the celebrities who's been navigating Hollywood for almost a century. That's a pretty incredible feat, and one worth celebrating — let's take a look at some the other stars who're still in the game at 90 and up.

      People
    • Russia intervened to help Trump win election: intelligence officials

      By John Walcott WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. intelligence analysts have concluded that Russia intervened in the 2016 election to help President-elect Donald Trump win the White House, and not just to undermine confidence in the U.S. electoral system, a senior U.S. official said on Friday. U.S. intelligence agencies have assessed that as the 2016 presidential campaign progressed, Russian government officials devoted increasing attention to assisting Trump's effort to win the election, the U.S. official familiar with the finding told Reuters on Friday night, speaking on condition of anonymity. The president-elect's transition office released a statement that exaggerated his margin of victory and attacked the U.S. intelligence community that Trump will soon command, but did not address the analysts' conclusion.

      Reuters
    • Inside Kirk Douglas' 100th Birthday Bash

      Kirk Douglas celebrated a milestone birthday in style. The actor turned 100 years old Friday and feted the occasion with members of his famous family and friends at the Beverly Hills Hotel in California. Douglas' son, Michael, and daughter-in-law Catherine Zeta-Jones, were at the glamorous affair with their children, Dylan Michael and Carys Zeta.

      Good Morning America
    • This guy made his wife a life-size advent calendar, and we need someone to make it for us like right now

      Other than the gifts, the food, the holiday parties, the ugly sweaters, the family time, and the time off of work, the…

      Hello Giggles
    • Prince George, Princess Charlotte to be page boy and flower girl at aunt Pippa Middleton's wedding

      Save the date for Pippa Middleton's wedding! The younger sister of Duchess of Cambridge Kate Middleton is set to marry hedge fund manager James Matthews on 20 May 2017 at St Mark's church in Englefield, Berkshire. While George is supposed to play a page boy at his aunt's wedding, his little sister will be an adorable flower girl. Contrary to popular demand though, the Duchess of Cambridge, will not be seen as a bridesmaid at the wedding, according to reports.

      International Business Times UK q
    • GOP introduces plan to massively cut Social Security

      On Thursday, Rep. Sam Johnson, a Republican from Texas and chair of the Social Security subcommittee, introduced legislation to significantly cut Social Security. For most workers, the bill would cut Social Security benefits substantially. As Michael Linden, associate director for tax and budget policy at Center for American Progress, pointed out on Twitter, a letter from Social Security’s Office of the Actuary calculated workers making around $50,000 would see checks shrink by between 11% and 35%.

      Yahoo Finance