Frozen pizza taste test

Good Housekeeping

View gallery

.
Tombstone Original Extra Cheese

(Courtesy of Tombstone)

We're a nation addicted! Americans spend over $3 billion a year on frozen pizzas. Here, you'll find yummiest buys in cheese, veggie and pepperoni varieties.

THE OVERALL WINNERS

Winner for Cheese:

Tombstone Original Extra Cheese ($5 for 20.5-oz. pizza)

This "fresh-tasting" pie is layered with "tangy" sauce and tons of "gooey" cheese. Its crisp yet "doughy" crust got a thumbs-up, too.

Tasters' Pick: This “flavorful” pizza was praised for its crispy yet "doughy" crust, “gooey” cheese, and “fresh” tasting sauce. A few tasters thought it had a kick from spices that made it taste like pepperoni.

View gallery

.
Amy's Roasted Vegetable Pizza

(Courtesy of Amy's)

Winner for Veggie:

Amy's Roasted Vegetable Pizza ($8.29 for 12-oz. pizza)

Tasters flipped for this pizza's bold flavor ("It tastes better than it looks") and barely noticed that there was no cheese under the "sweet" caramelized onions, peppers, and mushrooms.

Taster’s Pick: Tasters loved this “unique” flavored pizza with its “sweet” caramelized onions, peppers, and mushrooms. Its “pillowy” yet crisp crust had tasters drooling.



View gallery

.
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Red Baron)

Winner for Pepperoni: Taster's Pick

Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni ($4.50 for 20.6-oz. pizza)

Earning points for "homemade flavor," this pizza impressed tasters with a "crunchy" but "chewy" crust that was "not too thick or thin." Also earning raves were the spicy pepperoni slices — for a real kick of flavor — atop gooey sauce.

 

(See also: Vanilla ice cream taste test)



View gallery

.
Amy’s Cheese

(Courtesy of Amy's)

CHEESE:
Editors' Pick
Amy’s Cheese | $7.19

This pizza was applauded for its “homemade” taste. Tasters loved its “thick and crispy” crust, as well as its “tasty,” “super tomato-y” sauce.






View gallery

.
Stouffer's Cheese French Bread Pizza

(Courtesy of Stouffer's)

Stouffer's Cheese French Bread Pizza | $3.19

Tasters were split on this pizza from Stouffer’s. While some loved its “sweet” sauce and “flaky” French bread crust, others thought it had “too many spices,” lacked cheese, and tasted more like garlic bread than pizza.






View gallery

.
CPK Crispy Thin Margherita

(Courtesy of California Pizza Kitchen)

CPK Crispy Thin Margherita | $6.49

While tasters loved the bits of chopped tomato on top of this pie, they were less than impressed with its “sour” and “artificial” taste and its “chewy” texture.









View gallery

.
Totino's Cheese

(Courtesy of Totino's)

Totino's Cheese | $1.39

Many tasters liked the “crunch” of this pizza’s “light,” “flaky” crust, but found the sauce had an “acrid,” “fake” aftertaste from the dried herbs.







View gallery

.
Jack's Cheese

(Courtesy of Jack's)

Jack's Cheese | $3.59

While some tasters raved about this pie’s “fresh” and “spicy” flavor, others thought it tasted “bland” and “stale.” They were also divided on its crust with some calling it “rubbery” and others saying it had a “decent crunch.”







View gallery

.
Archer Farms Wood-Fired Margherita

(Courtesy of Target)

Archer Farms Wood-Fired Margherita | $4.99


Although some tasters appreciated the basil leaves on this pie, the herbs weren’t enough to save it. “Not a ton of flavor,” wrote many testers. One taster summed it up best, “crisp, but no flavor!”





View gallery

.
DiGiorno Crispy Flatbrea

(Courtesy of DiGiorno)

VEGGIE: Editors' Pick

DiGiorno Crispy Flatbread | $6.59

Tasters praised this pizza from DiGiorno for its “classic” pizza taste with natural-tasting veggies, “great basil flavor,” and ultra-crispy crust. They were also fans of its tangy sauce that had “a little kick.”




View gallery

.
Newman's Own Roasted Vegetable

(Courtesy of Newman's Own)

Newman's Own Roasted Vegetable | $6.99

The thin, crispy crust and bold, “flavorful” veggie taste of this pie were a huge hit. Those looking for a milder flavor thought that the herbs and veggies were a little “overpowering.” One taster thought that there was “more veggie than pizza.”






View gallery

.
Freschetta Brick Oven Mushroom Spinach

(Courtesy of Freschetta)

Freschetta Brick Oven Mushroom Spinach | $6.69

Our tasters longed for more sauce on this pizza, which might have prevented it from having a texture that was “a little like cardboard.” Its impressive amount of gooey cheese wasn’t enough to cover up its “hard” crust, although the big chunks of “yummy mushrooms” were appreciated by volunteers.





View gallery

.
Archer Farms Mediterranean Arugula

(Courtesy of Target)

Archer Farms Mediterranean Arugula | $5.02

While some tasters liked this pizza's “fresh” tasting tomato and basil, others thought the flavor “odd” and “watery.” Some were also turned off by the dough and cheese, which they thought were too “thick” and “chewy.”






View gallery

.
CPK Crispy Thin Roasted Vegetable

(Courtesy of California Pizza Kitchen)

CPK Crispy Thin Roasted Vegetable | $6.49

While some tasters liked the “crispy” texture of this pie and said it “tastes like homemade,” others thought its “unpleasantly sweet” sauce tasted “oddly mustardy” and was “heavy on the herbs.” “Whoa garlic!” expressed the general sentiment of many tasters.








View gallery

.
Annie's Rising Crust Spinach Mushroom

(Courtesy of Annie's)

Annie's Rising Crust Spinach Mushroom | $9.99

Although one taster thought this was the “best looking” pie of the bunch, almost all tasters agreed that this pizza was “weird,” “tasteless,” and “too doughy.” Likening it to spinach dip, several tasters even asked, “Is this pizza?”







View gallery

.
Tombstone Veggie

(Courtesy of Tombstone)

Tombstone Veggie | $4.99

Although tasters thought the veggies on this pie tasted “fresh,” there simply were not enough of them. Its satisfyingly crunchy crust also gained it some points, which it promptly lost by virtue of its “too sweet” sauce.







View gallery

.
Kashi Roasted Vegetable

(Courtesy of Kashi)

Kashi Roasted Vegetable | $5.99

This pie’s “garden tasting” veggies weren’t enough to save it from its “soggy” crust and “cardboard” texture. Tasters thought that it needed a lot more cheese and sauce.







View gallery

.
DiGiorno Pepperoni

(Courtesy of DiGiorno)

PEPPERONI:

DiGiorno Pepperoni | $6.59

Editors’ Pick: This “chewy” contender (one taster even said it was a dead ringer for “deep dish”) was praised for its “flavorful” pepperoni and “good amount of cheese.” Unfortunately, this pie lost a few points for those seeking a crisper crust.




View gallery

.
Tombstone Pepperon

(Courtesy of Tombstone)

Tombstone Pepperoni | $4.99

Despite this pizza’s “unpleasantly soft” and doughy crust, tasters loved the “bold” flavor of the chopped pepperoni bits evenly distributed over the pie.







View gallery

.
Market Pantry Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Target)

Market Pantry Pepperoni | $2.77

Tasters thought this pizza’s crust was “too thin” with a “cardboard-like” texture. However, its pepperoni and cheese added a “deep” and “spicy” flavor that they couldn’t get enough of.







View gallery

.
Stouffer's Pepperoni French Bread Pizza

(Courtesy of Stouffer's)

Stouffer's Pepperoni French Bread Pizza | $3.19

This pie’s French bread crust was “too thick” for our tasters, who wanted less dough and more pepperoni. However, its “spicy” yet “sweet” sauce was a success.








View gallery

.
Totino's Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Totino's)

Totino's Pepperoni | $1.39

Although some tasters praised this pie’s “sweet sauce,” most thought it had a “weird aftertaste” and needed more cheese and pepperoni. Also, its thin crust was a little “mushy” for our volunteers.






View gallery

.
Freschetta Signature Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Freschetta)

Freschetta Signature Pepperoni | $6.69

Although tasters were not fans of this pizza’s “soft” texture, its “spicy,” “salty” pepperoni was a huge hit. Volunteers also complained that it was a bit too “oily.”







View gallery

.
365 Thin Crust Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Whole Foods)

365 Thin Crust Pepperoni | $4.99

This thin crust pie was “too sweet” for some tasters, who also didn’t care for the “shreds of pepperoni.” Others appreciated its “nice garlicky flavor” and hints of basil.








View gallery

.
Jack's Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Jack's)

Jack's Pepperoni | $3.59

Although this pizza’s “rubbery” crust and “fake pepperoni” taste left most tasters unimpressed, they loved that it had more sauce and cheese than many of the other pies.







View gallery

.
CPK Signature Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Target)

CPK Signature Pepperoni | $6.49

Tasters agreed that this pie lacked the zesty pepperoni flavor they were expecting. Overall, this pizza was also too “soggy” and “gummy” for their liking.







View gallery

.
Annie's Pepperoni

(Courtesy of Annie's)

Annie's Pepperoni | $9.99

Tasters described this pie’s crust as “tough” and “artificial tasting.” While some enjoyed its very spicy pepperoni, others thought it was too “greasy” and lacked flavor.






More from Good Housekeeping:

11 Decadent Valentine’s Day Dessert Ideas

10 Ways to Spice Up Your Relationship

Top 10 Must-Have Products for Your Home

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • United Airlines stopped girls in yoga pants from boarding flight — even after promoting leggings as travel wear

      As boarding incident gains social-media traction, airline explains the passengers in question were flying on passes typically used by employees and their families.

      MarketWatch q
    • These teen girls were told to cover up on a United Airlines flight because they were wearing leggings

      Get ready to feel your blood boil, friends. Early Sunday morning, an anti-gun violence advocate named Shannon Watts began tweeting about a…

      Hello Giggles
    • People
    • Fox News host demands Paul Ryan resign hours after Trump promotes her show

      Donald Trump: Jeanine Pirro calls for Paul Ryan to resign

      Entertainment Weekly
    • Amy Schumer shared a hilariously relatable moment about trying to get intimate with her bae

      Thanks to actress and comedian Amy Schumer’s story about giving her boyfriend a blow job, we now have the most hilarious and…

      Hello Giggles
    • 7 Outdated Clothing Items Men Need to Immediately Throw Out

      Instead of waiting to do your annual spring cleaning, take the initiative now. If you see any of these items in your closet, it's time to remove them ASAP.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • NY officer's body camera reveals horrific murder-for-hire crime scene

      Kelley Clayton was found brutally murdered inside her Elmira, New York, home.

      ABC News q
    • Morning Jolt: Sears Has Finally Admitted That It's Dead

      This zombie retailer is on its deathbed.

      The Street q
    • Samira Wiley Ties The Knot With Lauren Morelli

      Samira Wiley and Lauren Morelli are now married.

      International Business Times
    • The Browns' best player makes it clear why Cleveland didn't want Colin Kaepernick

      The Browns have needed a good quarterback for … oh, just since they returned to Cleveland in 1999. They settled for Brock Osweiler this offseason in a stunning trade, and maybe he will be the answer for them that he wasn’t for the Texans. In the process, though, the Browns made pretty clear that they weren’t interested in Colin Kaepernick, the 29-year-old who led the 49ers to the Super Bowl all of four years ago and has put up better numbers than Osweiler almost across the board. Why did they resist the free agent? Let Joe Thomas, the Browns’ 10-year Pro Bowl left tackle and team captain, explain: Now, Thomas’ point ignores two important truths: Kaepernick has been very good as a starter in the

      For The Win q
    • United Airlines Tried to Bar Girls From Flight for Wearing Leggings

      On a flight from Denver to Minneapolis early Sunday morning, Shannon Watts observed a United Airlines gate agent refuse to allow two young girls on the plane because they were wearing leggings. 1) A @united gate agent isn't letting girls in leggings get on flight from Denver to Minneapolis because spandex is not allowed? Watts objected to the policy, saying that it sexualizes young girls who were simply wearing comfortable clothing.

      Yahoo Style
    • Christina El Moussa faces fans fury for 'inappropriate' bikini photo with daughter: 'What mother does this?'

      Flip Or Flop co-host Christina El Moussa has landed in hot water over a recent Instagram picture. Fans of the reality TV star flipped after she shared a bikini-clad picture with her seven-year-old daughter Taylor, and took to the picture-sharing site to criticise her "sickening ways". "Welcome to the family!!" the El Moussa matriarch had captioned the adorable picture celebrating the arrival of the newest member of the family – a French bulldog named Cashie.

      International Business Times
    • 2 missing Fayetteville children found stabbed to death in Hoke County

      Fayetteville police said the children were at the center of a domestic-related incident between Tillman Freeman, 30, and his wife, and Freeman left with the children.

      WTVD – Raleigh/Durham
    • This customer-invented secret drink got so popular at Starbucks it’s now officially on the menu!

      Starbucks has always given us what we want. From our beloved pumpkin spice lattes in the fall to newly released breakfast items,…

      Hello Giggles
    • The Most Powerful Heroines in Literature (Because #WomensHistoryMonth) (11 photos)

      The Most Powerful Heroines in Literature (Because #WomensHistoryMonth)

      People
    • 'I'm not going to deny that': Congressman responds to report that Trump said he was 'destroying the Republican Party'

      Rep. Charlie Dent on Sunday would not deny a report that President Donald Trump told the...

      Business Insider
    • Berkeley killing renews debate over gender pronouns

      BERKELEY, Calif. (AP) — Pablo Gomez Jr. was a University of California, Berkeley, senior majoring in Latino studies and a prominent campus activist when authorities say he stabbed to death a popular elementary-school teacher.

      Associated Press
    • Iggy Azalea Goes Twerk Crazy in New 'Mo Bounce' Music Video

      The 26-year-old rapper knows how to work it.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • WATCH: Cristiano Ronaldo joins historic club with sick far-post free kick

      Cristiano Ronaldo made history on Saturday in World Cup Qualifying against Hungary. After scoring a sweet goal in the first half , he scored an even better one in the second half with a brilliant free kick. And that goal was his 70th international strike, joining the 70-goal club for European players, which also includes just Miroslav Klose and Ferenc Puskas. Here is the goal: What a way to get it. It’s tough enough to go far post, but to do it from that distance is absurd. 

      CBS Sports q
    • United Airlines bans 2 girls with leggings from flight because they weren't 'properly clothed'

      United Airlines is in hot water after a dress code incident on Sunday morning.  In a series of live tweets, activist Shannon Watts explained that two girls who were wearing leggings were asked by the United Airlines gate agent to either change clothing or not board their flight to Minneapolis.  SEE ALSO: Teenagers spot fire on plane flying overhead, avert major disaster 1) A @united gate agent isn't letting girls in leggings get on flight from Denver to Minneapolis because spandex is not allowed? — Shannon Watts (@shannonrwatts) March 26, 2017 2) She's forcing them to change or put dresses on over leggings or they can't board. Since when does @united police women's clothing? — Shannon Watts (@shannonrwatts) March 26, 2017 3) Gate agent for flt 215 at 7:55. Said she doesn't make the rules, just follows them. I guess @united not letting women wear athletic wear? — Shannon Watts (@shannonrwatts) March 26, 2017 "This behavior is sexist and sexualizes young girls. Not to mention that the families were mortified and inconvenienced," Watts explained on Twitter.  "As the mother of 4 daughters who live and travel in yoga pants, I'd like to know how many boys @ United has penalized for the same reason. Their father, who was allowed to board with no issue, was wearing shorts," she wrote.  Another girl in grey leggings was allowed to fly after changing into a dress, according to Watt's tweets.  After a large amount of backlash from Twitter users, United Airlines responded to angry inquiries online, citing a dress code that appears in their "Contract of Carriage" that allows them to "refuse passengers who are not properly clothed."  @finallydeirdre UA shall have the right to refuse passengers who are not properly clothed via our Contract of Carriage. ^FS — United (@united) March 26, 2017 "Casual attire is allowed as long as it looks neat and is in good taste for the local environment," the airlines also tweeted. @PattyArquette Casual attire is allowed as long as it looks neat and is in good taste for the local environment. (1/2) — United (@united) March 26, 2017 The internet was outraged, both over United's actions and its public response to the controversy.  @united @PattyArquette Friendly Advice, United: No one is nearly as offended by a little girl in spandex as they are by this situation. — Nick Bolton (@NickBolton13) March 26, 2017 @shannonrwatts There are women in leggings and bathing suits in a recent @united safety video. https://t.co/b1xByiCZ3f — Ian Schafer (@ischafer) March 26, 2017 The only place @united's Contract of Carriage mentions clothing is regarding safety. Were these dangerous leggings? https://t.co/gQhX7l943d — Chris (@filmbuffcw) March 26, 2017 @shannonrwatts Hey, @united, you know how this ends, right? Images of women in leggings tagging you on social as they fly your competition. — Jenn (@jennvzande) March 26, 2017 Please #mansplain to me why a 10 yr old in leggings is "inappropriate attire" #boycottunited https://t.co/YOaqd7d8wm — Girl Science (@GoGirlScience) March 26, 2017 The @united response to this leggings thing is a case study on how not to respond to a brand crisis https://t.co/stO7dco5co — laura olin (@lauraolin) March 26, 2017 Mashable has reached out to United Airlines for comment and will update this post accordingly.  UPDATE: March 26, 2017, 2:14 p.m. EDT The two girls were United Airlines "pass riders," defined by the company as "United employees or their eligible dependents standing by on a space-available basis."  There is a separate dress code for pass riders, unrelated to United Airlines previous citations of the "Contract of Carriage," that remains "internal policy" and will not be released, according to a statement made to NBC's Colorado affiliate, 9 News. WATCH: Airbus is redefining the future of flying.

      Mashable