Forget 4K Ultra HD TVs: I want an OLED TV

Consumer Reports
LG OLED TV at CES 2013

Last week's Consumer Electronics Show was a great opportunity to check out the two newest TV technologies, Ultra HD and OLED—sometimes in side-by-side comparisons.

During a live webcast in which I was interviewed along with USA Today's Mike Snider, we were asked which of these new kinds of TVs we'd personally buy, if money weren't an issue.

I didn't have to think very long before replying, "OLED."


MORE AT COnsumer Reports

Of course, not everyone will share my view. And once we're able to get a few Ultra HD TVs and OLED sets in our labs for testing, perhaps I'll change my mind. But based on demos at the show from several major TV brands, the OLED TVs I saw represented the most impressive change from what I'm currently getting from my 1080p TVs.

Don't get me wrong—there's a lot to like about Ultra HD TVs. Certainly the high-resolution 4K screens look great and let you get incredibly close to the TV without seeing any visible pixel grid (called the "screen-door effect"). For many of us, this means that you'll be able to get a larger screen while maintaining the same seating distance.

And for now, OLED manufacturers are having a tough time making larger OLED sets; the current size limitation is about 55 or 56 inches. At CES, we saw Ultra HD prototypes as large as 110 inches, and the few already being sold are 84-inchers. During the show, several companies announced models in the 55- to 75-inch range, a more suitable size for most prospective buyers, although I question whether a 55-inch Ultra HD TV can adequately showcase the higher resolution.

(See also: Cheap ways to turn your TV into a 'smart' one)

It's also likely that Ultra HD TV prices will fall faster than those of OLED sets. Ultra HDs are essentially LCD TVs with a higher pixel density, so they can be manufactured on the same production lines as standard LCDs. OLED TVs require a new manufacturing process, and yields so far haven't been great, which will likely keep prices high for a longer period of time.

But that's also Ultra HD TV's weakness: These 4K sets essentially remain LCD TVs, with many of that format's drawbacks—most notably backlight-uniformity issues, limited viewing angles, and often, mediocre contrast levels. Yes, the images look sharper, but most viewers will notice it only with top-quality source material, and 4K Blu-rays are at least a year away.

OLED, however, is a new type of TV, and it's the perfect vehicle for demonstrating that image detail is only one of a handful of attributes that contribute to great-looking picture. OLED TVs feel to me like an entirely new TV-viewing experience. Blacks levels are so deep that you to need see them to believe them.

In the first OLED demo I ever saw a few years ago—in room that could go almost absolutely dark—the TV seemed to disappear when the lights turned off; the images seemed to float in space. (When we tested the first production OLED TV, Sony's $2,500 11-inch XEL-1, we had to buy new test equipment to measure its black levels.)

OLEDs also deliver ultra-high-contrast images, with bold, vibrant colors that jump off the screen. Add with better-than-plasma brightness, unlimited viewing angles, and energy efficiency that trumps even LED-based LCD TVs, OLED delivers a dynamic viewing experience I just didn't get with the Ultra HD sets I saw.

Of course, the next iteration of OLED TVs will be sets that also have 4K Ultra HD resolutions. There were several 4K OLEDs on display at CES, and of course, they looked great. But even when I was watching clips on the 1080p OLED sets, never once did I think, "Boy, if this set only had four times more pixels..." When TV is doing everything else right, you get the impression of a sharper, more dynamic image, even when the resolution hasn't been increased.

As always, I'm looking forward to getting some of these new TVs into our labs this year for thorough testing, and I'm curious to see if our head TV engineer, Claudio Ciacci, will share my initial opinion. Either way, both Ultra HD and OLED are exciting developments for those of us who spend a lot of time looking at TVs.

But with prices expected to be north of $10,000 for TVs using either of these technologies, we'll be a little more excited by yet another development: making them affordable for the average consumer.


Copyright © 2006-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • China is sending the US a new message about North Korea

      Beijing appears to be sending fresh signals about its view on North Korea, in order to convince Trump to take less aggressive action.

      CNBC
    • A Marine’s .50 caliber sniper rifle failed during a firefight — so he called customer service

      The Barrett M107 .50-caliber long-range sniper rifle is a firearm made for the modern war on terrorism. While Barrett’s reputation of “flawless reliability” has made the M107 the sniper weapon of choice, the rifle is just like any other essential tool: It often breaks when you need it most. Don Cook, a Marine veteran who’s been maintaining M107s for more than two decades, told National Geographic in 2011 that he one day received a call to Barrett’s workshop from a harried young Marine. During maintenance of the unit’s M107, the Marine had bent the ears of the rifle’s lower receiver; the next day, after engaging the enemy, they discovered the rifle wouldn’t fire consistently.

      Business Insider q
    • Witness describes tense incident involving flight attendant and woman with stroller

      NEW YORK -- A witness says she saw what led up to tense moments that were captured on video Friday aboard an American Airlines flight.   Passengers say an American Airlines flight attendant hit a mother of twins with a stroller during boarding of the aircraft, which was preparing to leave for Dallas from San Francisco. Passenger Olivia Morgan said she saw the male flight attendant wrestling the stroller away from the woman, CBS News transportation correspondent Kris Van Cleave reports. “He rips it away from her, and it almost hits her little baby’s head,” Morgan said. “I said to him something like, ‘What are you doing? You almost hit that baby in the head!’” Morgan said. “And then he was just

      CBS News q
    • Gone in 30 seconds: Mob of up to 60 juveniles robs passengers on BART train, officials say

      Authorities said it happened in 30 seconds: A throng of up to 60 juveniles mobbed a Bay Area Rapid Transit train Saturday in Oakland and mugged passengers. At least two people were injured and required medical attention. The youngsters were spotted by witnesses hastily jumping over fare gates before boarding a Dublin-bound train just after 9:20 p.m. at the Coliseum Station on San Leandro Street, according the BART Police Department. Once the minors entered the train, police said, they swarmed passengers and robbed six people by force. Another passenger was robbed on the railway platform. Authorities said a purse, duffel bag and five cellphones were taken during the robberies. At least two passengers

      Los Angeles Times q
    • This is what’s left after the ‘Mother of all Bombs’ hit Afghanistan

      A remote area in Afghanistan barely shows signs from the US military’s “Mother of All Bombs,” its largest non-nuclear device ever deployed in combat — a scarred mountainside, burned trees and ruined mud-brick structures. Images and video from the blast site also offer little evidence of how much human damage it inflicted, though Afghan officials last week said 94 militants were killed, Reuters reported. Since the GBU-43 Massive Ordnance Air Blast bomb was dropped on a fortified tunnel complex used by suspected ISIS jihadists in Nangarhar province, access to the site has been controlled by US and Afghan troops battling the terror group. A witness viewed the site from several hundred yards away because the US military said that continued fighting prevented reporters or independent investigators from getting close.

      New York Post q
    • Texas police capture rattlesnake stared down by 'fearless cat'

      April 24 (UPI) -- A Texas police department shared photos from the capture of a massive rattlesnake spotted by bird-watchers hanging out next to a "fearless cat." The Laguna Vista Police Department said the Bay Area Birders of LV reported they were on a walking trail Thursday when they spotted the snake. The department shared several photos from the capture, including one of the snake appearing to be in the strike position while a "fearless cat" watches it from mere feet away. "We ask that you all use caution and are aware of your surroundings when walking on the walking trail or any other locations. Generally, rattlesnakes emerge from hibernation in March or April, or when the average daytime

      UPI q
    • Dowd: New poll is 'good news, bad news, really bad news' for Trump

      The Powerhouse Roundtable debates President Trump's progress as we approach 100 days in office.

      ABC News Videos
    • Andrea Tantaros accuses Fox News of illegal electronic surveillance

      Former Fox News host Andrea Tantaros, having already sued the network for sexual harassment, is now accusing it of orchestrating a "criminal scheme" involving what she claims were illegal electronic surveillance and online harassment of her. In a complaint filed Monday in a Manhattan federal court, Tantaros said that her ex-bosses at Fox monitored her emails and listened to phone calls, and then conveyed "that they were doing so through cruel social media posts." The complaint asserts that a forensic examination showed that anomalies on Tantaros' laptop "are not malware or known viruses that could have been found or transmitted through 'general surfing' of the Internet." Moreover, the complaint

      CNN Money q
    • Plus-Size Model Poses in Swimwear to Send a Powerful Message

      Posing in swimwear and showing off skin can be uncomfortable, even scary for some. But Alex LaRosa, a plus-size model, doesn't fall into that category.

      Yahoo Style
    • 'I picked up daddy's hand, and it just fell,' said 3-year-old after he found murdered father

      LUCASVILLE, Ohio — Just a couple weeks ago as they were driving on Union Hill Road, Brentley Rhoden told his mom he saw his dad: He was in the sky following them. Didn't she see him? the 4-year-old asked his mom. Didn't she see him? "He was so excited. He was saying: 'He's right there. He's right there. He's right there. He's right there on that star," Chelsea Robinson said Friday, a year to the day she dropped Brentley off at his dad's trailer to spend the night not knowing what would unfold mere hours later. "I don't see what he sees,'' she said. But she knows what her little boy needs. She pulled the car over and waited as Brentley spent a full 10 minutes talking to his dad, Clarence "Frankie"

      USA Today q
    • Samira Wiley, Amanda Seyfried: 2017 Celeb Weddings (15 photos)

      Samira Wiley, Amanda Seyfried: 2017 Celeb Weddings

      People
    • Flight Attendant Gets Real About the Rash of Passenger Protests Against Airlines

      With so much turmoil being documented lately between flight crews and passengers, one flight attendant is standing up for his profession.

      Yahoo Beauty
    • 'Shattered' authors: Bill Clinton pushed for different tone in Hillary's campaign

      He wanted her to meet with swing voters, authors say.

      ABC News q
    • 5 Women Share Exactly How They Totally Transformed Their Butts

      Isabella Mabey was a sporadic exerciser—going through random waves of bingeing on cardio, always ending up bored with the lack of results. She finally was able to stick to a workout routine once she started lifting weights. "Compound lifts are really important," she says. "I do heavy-weighted squats and deadlifts, which I then complement with lighter-weighted accessory movements such as glute bridges, lunges, goblet squats, and kettlebell swings." It's the lighter-weighted accessory movements that really isolate and target her glutes, says Isabella. She spends two lifting days working on legs and booty and another day on just accessory work. "On leg day, I'll do two main lifts in five sets, each

      Women's Health q
    • Twitter employee making $160,000 in San Francisco says he's scraping by

      "I didn't become a software engineer to be trying to make ends meet," he says.

      CNBC
    • John Kasich, a former Fox News host, responds to Bill O'Reilly's ouster

      Ohio Gov. John Kasich, who hosted a Fox News program from 2001 through 2007, said he "wouldn't...

      Business Insider
    • Donald Trump Reportedly Made Melania Promise She'd 'Get Her Body Back' Before He Agreed to Have a Kid

      Here is a thought experiment: Given what you've learned about President Donald Trump over these past few months, how do you imagine he'd treat his then relatively new third wife during her first pregnancy? Would he...accompany her to appointments? Practice delivery-room breathing techniques? Prop open doors for her? Ask her, like, even one time, how she was feeling? Or...would he do this? "About six months after they married, [Trump] became pregnant with Barron—and things changed," according to Vanity Fair's new and delicious piece on Melania Trump's general unhappiness, titled "Inside the Trump Marriage: Melania's Burden." "She was 35—'checkout time' for women, as Trump once told Howard Stern-and

      ELLE q
    • North Korea threatens to sink US aircraft carrier

      Former U.S. ambassador to South Korea Christopher Hill reacts on 'Sunday Morning Futures'

      Fox Business Videos