Drugstore vs Designer Makeup: When to Save and When to Splurge

US News

When shopping for cosmetics, it’s easy to be swayed by flashy displays and alluring designer-brand advertising. More and more cosmetics are being introduced into drugstores, which are aimed at helping consumers save money and claim to produce results comparable to designer lines.

Despite the variety of options lining drugstore and supermarket makeup aisles, many women are still reluctant to break away from pricey designer cosmetics. According to a 2011 study conducted by market-research firm Mintel, 50 percent of women earning an annual income of $50,000 to $74,000 said they do not intend on abandoning their designer cosmetics routine.

Regardless of which side you teeter on--drugstore or designer--not all items are created equal. Many of the designer brands you know and love are, in fact, made by the same manufacturers in the same factories as their cost-conscious drugstore counterparts.

Photo: Getty Images/Spencer Platt

More from
U.S. News:

50 Ways to Improve Your Finances in 2012

10 Ways to Improve Your Finances in 2011

9 Things You Shouldn't Buy at Grocery Stores

Choosing quality makeup products

Identifying what constitutes as a quality makeup product is the first step in getting the most bang for your buck. Take a look past the decorative packaging and start reading the fine print.

The best cosmetics have limited filler ingredients like talc, which can irritate skin and encourage breakouts. A highly regarded alternative to talc-ridden cosmetics is mineral-based makeup, which is available in designer names and drugstores alike.

Aside from potential skin reactions that makeup ingredients may produce, color pigmentation is also a key factor to detecting quality cosmetics products. Greater pigmentation means the product’s raw composition is more finely milled, leading to vivid color with less application.

Drugstore vs. Designer Makeup: When to Splurge and Save

If you’re an avid designer diva, it may be difficult to come to terms with buying drugstore cosmetics, even if you can stand to save money into the hundreds. However, there are specific makeup items sprouting up at drugstores that are identical to those found in major cosmetics retailers like Sephora, except that they priced at five times less in cost.

Concealer: Splurge

Concealer requires premium ingredients in order to provide the best effects on the skin. Poor quality may run the risk of caking, creasing, or lead to difficulty blending the product into skin. Also, the shelf-life of concealer can last up to two years for stick or powder varieties (one year for liquid concealer), so your money is able to stretch for a longer time.

Foundation: Splurge

Since foundation entails full-coverage application, it’s best to seek out those that avoid harsh ingredients that can damage skin. Most designer makeup brands are hyper-aware of the problems that low-grade ingredients present and more drugstore brands are starting to follow in their footsteps.

While drugstores offer a greater variety of raw-ingredient products than in the past, department stores and designer names provide the greatest assortment in foundation hues. This fact alone pushes foundations into the splurge zone.

Eyeshadow: Save

While pigmentation plays a big part in choosing whether to opt for designer or drugstore cosmetics, makeup’s spoiling cycle does as well. Eyeshadows are recommended for a maximum lifespan of only three months, meaning that you’re likely to be wasting money on $28 eyeshadow palettes.

Big drugstore brands like L’Oreal, Maybelline, and Revlon have developed affordable eyeshadows with generous pigmenting to help ease the blow on your bank account.

Eyeliner: Save

Eyeliner is known to have a life of only three months, due to its close proximity to the eye’s mucous membranes, which can easily transfer bacteria. Many drugstore names have developed formulas very similar to that of designer cosmetics, so this is another product that consumers can save money on.

Blush: Splurge

Due to its longer shelf-life (one to two years), blush is one of those makeup marvels that women can freely indulge in. Color pigments and quality are also imperative when selecting blush, as it requires a lot of blending upon application.

Lipstick: Save

With so many formulas on the market, from matte finishes to glossy bases, lipstick at a designer quality can easily be found at your local drugstore. Further, this cosmetics product offers the greatest hue variety so finding a great color for less is more than a possibility.

Mascara: Save

Above all, mascara has the shortest lifespan, of only two to three months. Much of its quality degrades due to frequent exposure to air, which causes its formula to dry and crust. Additionally, it often is a breeding ground for bacteria due to its usage near and--if you’ve ever poked yourself with a mascara wand--in the eye area.

With these factors in mind, determining what type of makeup to buy at a department store versus a drugstore is made much simpler.

 

 

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Adam Jones didn't like Orioles farewell gift to David Ortiz

      Orioles’ star Adam Jones presents David Ortiz with a dugout phone, which Ortiz smashed during a game in 2013. The David Ortiz farewell tour was filled with many memorable moments. Prior to his final game at Camden Yards, on Sept. 21, the Orioles rolled out the red carpet, showed highlights of Ortiz mashing home runs against the mutual rival New York Yankees, and then presented him with the actual visitor’s dugout phone he once destroyed during an in-game meltdown.

      Big League Stew
    • Grandmother Finds the Mummified Body of Her Missing Grandson in the Attic 2-Years After He Was Reported Missing | B. Scott

      21-year-old Dyquain Rogers was reported missing on November 1st, 2014. On Wednesday, a mummified body believed to be the young man’s was found in the attic of his grandmother’s home. Investigators believe he committed suicide. via NY Daily News: Relatives of Dyquain Rogers are demanding a complete autopsy after the coroner said the death was likely a suicide, according to GoErie.com. “I don’t believe any of this stuff,” aunt Erica Jeffries-Jordan told the news website. “I want answers.” Rogers was last seen in the same house where he was found, which is also where he lived, Erie County Coroner Lyell Cook told the news website. Rogers was reported missing on Nov. 4, 2014. The body was in the Erie

      B. Scott | lovebscott.com q
    • Inside the Alleged Abduction of California Mom Sherri Papini

      Keith Papini details what happened before his wife was found alive.

      ABC News q
    • 15 Tiny Christmas Trees That Make a Big Imact (16 photos)

      If you live in a small home or just want to add on to your main tree, mini Christmas trees are for you. But don't let their tiny stature fool you — they'll add a super-size dose of Christmas cheer to your home. You'll see. From House Beautiful

      House Beautiful
    • This baby wombat thinks it’s a dog and we don’t have the heart to tell him otherwise

      Marsupials can be so dang cute, like this baby wombat that thinks it’s a dog. We’re no experts on wombat behavior, but…

      Hello Giggles
    • Ask Amy: Grieving family struggles to come together

      Dear Amy: My sister recently died suddenly. My husband does not like my late sister’s husband. My mother invited my sister’s husband to share our holiday dinner. I have a problem with him right now because after 35 years together (she even waited for him while he was in prison for more than a decade), he announced that he had met someone two months after my sister’s death. We all believe he was dating this woman before my sister passed. My mother, brother in-law and I are in grief therapy. Our counselor suggested we do things together that my sister liked, as a form of healing. My mother believes this could be an exercise for healing. My husband refuses to go and has said I am being disloyal

      Washington Post q
    • 50 Cent on Kanye West’s Breakdown: ‘You Could See That Coming’

      While many found Kanye West‘s breakdown and hospitalization shocking, fellow rapper 50 Cent says he actually wasn’t too surprised. “That was interesting because I kind of felt like you could see that coming,” 50 Cent said on the topic during a Watch What Happens Live appearance, Thursday. 50 Cent, 41, appeared on the New York City-filmed Bravo talk show with actress Leah Remini.

      People
    • Trump targets another company, draws Sanders' criticism

      By Doina Chiacu WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President-elect Donald Trump drew a rebuke from former Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders on Saturday, after turning his attention to another Indiana company planning a move to Mexico. "Rexnord of Indiana is moving to Mexico and rather viciously firing all of its 300 workers. Rexnord Corp , an industrial supplier based in Milwaukee, announced plans in October to move a bearing plant, and its 300 jobs, from Indianapolis to Mexico, employees told the Indianapolis Star at the time.

      Reuters
    • Parents of teen who committed suicide sue school counselor

      Three weeks before 18-year-old Jay Gallagher took his own life, a worried friend who lived in Colorado sent an email to his school counselor at Potomac Falls High in Potomac Falls, Va., telling the counselor that Jay was saying things “with suicidal content,” according to a lawsuit filed in Loudoun County Circuit Court Friday. “He’s usually crying alone in his room because he doesn’t seem to have a good relationship with his parents,” the girl wrote. The counselor, Richard Bader, met with Gallagher, sending the girl a reassuring response: “Talked with him today. Thank you for bringing it to my attention.” But should Bader have notified Gallagher’s parents? That question is at the center of a

      Washington Post q
    • Former ambassador to China reacts to Trump's Taiwan call

      Jon Huntsman weighs in on 'Fox & Friends'

      FOX News Videos
    • Korean riot police use military tactics from ancient Rome

      If you want to see ancient Roman military tactics in practice, you don’t need a time machine. Just watch these Korean riot police use those tactics to stop rioters. Full story at YouTube. More great military stuff.

      Holy Kaw! q
    • Hollywood Reacts With Disgust At ‘Last Tango” Rape Scene Revelations

      Actors and other public figures are responding with outrage at recently surfaced news that Last Tango In Paris director Bernardo Bertolucci, in a three year old video that only came to light this week, confirmed what co-star Maria Schneider has long said about the film’s most controversial moment: the brutal rape scene was shot without her full consent. The scene in question featured Brando’s character raping Schneider’s character using a stick of butter as lubricant. It…

      Deadline
    • Palin Says Trump's Carrier Deal Could Be 'Crony Capitalism'

      Gov. Sarah Palin is expressing concern over Donald Trump's recently announced deal with Carrier.

      ABC News q
    • Drone Footage Captures Devastating Destruction of Tennessee Wildfires

      Footage from an aerial drone operated by Gatlinburg, Tennessee, resident Andrew Duncan, shows the devastation resulting from nearby wildfires. Among the victims of the fires are Jon and Janet Summers, a Memphis couple who was vacationing with their three sons in Gatlinburg when wildfire ripped through the town. “I am sorry to report that at 4:45 pm CST, the Sevier County Sheriff’s department has reported that the Medical Examiner has confirmed that two of the bodies found in North Chalet Village were Jon and Janet Summers,” Jon’s brother, Jim Summers, posted on Facebook Thursday.

      People
    • New details emerge in Joe McKnight shooting and release of shooter

      After hearing criticisms of his office for releasing the man who admitted to shooting former NFL running back Joe McKnight, Jefferson Parish Sheriff Newell Normand held a press conference to reveal some details of the case, including that the man who shot McKnight was in his car when he fired all three shots. McKnight was shot and killed on Thursday afternoon in New Orleans. Authorities said that Ronald Gasser, 54, shot McKnight.

      Shutdown Corner
    • Woman Who Ate ‘Carbs All Day Every Day’ Drops 100 Lbs. After Eliminating Bread from Her Diet

      Kristina Guice had always been “the fat kid in school,” she says, so when the Tucson, Arizona, native got accepted to graduate school across the country in Long Island, New York, she decided this was her opportunity to make a change. Guice, 25, had recently lost a close friend — who had also been her weight loss inspiration — and got accepted to graduate school just two weeks later.

      People
    • Elle
    • 'The Walking Dead': Here's What Happens to Negan in the Comics

      The newest villain in 'The Walking Dead' has been in the comics for a while, so we may have some clue what will happen to Negan next.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • Sasha Obama’s $695 Christmas-Tree-Lighting Coat Just Made It to the Top of Our Wish Lists

      The Obamas had their final Christmas-tree lighting on the Ellipse in President’s Park last night, and of course, the first family showed up in style. While they all looked great, with Barack keeping it simple with a long, black coat, a suit, and a burgundy scarf, and Michelle wearing a black coat with a metallic pattern on the front, we were particularly digging Sasha’s outerwear — a faux-fur deep navy blue Opening Ceremony coat.

      Yahoo Style
    • Colombia Plane Crash Survivor Cried Out for Crew

      He says he survived by curling up in the fetal position.

      ABC News q