Digital cameras : Buy performance, not megapixels

Consumer Reports

If you look closely at the cameras in recent weekend retail circulars, you might be surprised. A lot boast 14 or even 16 megapixels. Camera makers appear to have injected new life into an old marketing scheme: More megapixels mean a better camera.

Our camera tests have shown for years that cameras with more megapixels don't necessarily produce better images than those with fewer. Under the best of circumstances models with more megapixels can produce images with greater detail, but that's not very important unless you need giant enlargements.

More from ConsumerReports.org: 

E-Book reader prices dropping

Latest tablet computer reviews

Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers or sponsors on Yahoo!

The compact Sony Cyber-shot
features 16.1 Megapixels

A case in point: Cameras with just 10 megapixels are often ranked at or near the top of Consumer Reports' Ratings (available to subscribers) for models with built-in lenses,beating cameras with more megapixels. To achieve such ranking, they had to produce very good images for regular, low-light, and flash photos.

One reason some of those 10-megapixel models performed so well is that they have very good lenses. For the best image quality, a high-quality lens is essential. (Tip: Look at the lens' maximum aperture setting. Those with a setting of f/2 or f/1.8 tend to be of better quality.)

There's another reason not to jump for the camera with the most megapixels. If you use an older computer to store and edit your images, the huge files such a camera produces might be harder to work with and will fill up a memory card faster than files from a camera with modest resolution. Consider a camera with 14 or 16 megapixels if it is rated highly in our tests and you want to make very large prints or do a lot of cropping.

Here's what else our tests have found:

Canon PowerShot SD4000 IS ELPH

Better displays

LCD displays on basic cameras continue to improve, which is why you'll find that most recommended models have at least a 3-inch display with good or very good quality. That's important, because none of the subcompacts or compacts has an optical or electronic viewfinder. You don't have to pay a lot for a very good LCD. The Canon PowerShot SD4000 IS ELPH, $220, has one, though the display on the Leica V-Lux 20, $650, is just OK. If you must have a viewfinder in a basic camera, look for one of the three superzooms that include electronic viewfinders: the Nikon Coolpix P100, Canon PowerShot SX30 IS, or the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ40.

Nikon D5100

Trickle-up attractions

Useful features usually trickle down from advanced cameras to basic ones, but some are actually moving in the opposite direction. For example, the swiveling LCD has moved up to the advanced Panasonic Lumix DMC-G3K and Nikon D5100. That feature, which originated on basic cameras, can be useful for self-portraits, hard-to-reach shots, or photographing children. The same advanced Panasonic Lumix includes a touch screen that lets you control exposure settings on the screen. You can also tap its LCD to set a focus point or snap a photo.

Nikon Coolpix S8000 14.2 Megapixel

Greater zoom on small cameras

Manufacturers are putting impressive zoom lenses on subcompacts without adding much weight or bulk. The Nikon Coolpix S8000 has a 10x zoom and weighs only 6 ounces.

 

Powerful zooms on bigger models

Camera makers are putting very powerful zoom lenses on the larger, bulkier models we call superzooms. The Canon PowerShot SX30 IS has one of the widest zoom ranges we've seen, 35x, which is the 35-mm equivalent of 24 to 840 mm. To get that kind of shooting versatility with an SLR or SLR-like camera, you'd have to buy two or more interchangeable lenses. In the past, superzooms sacrificed image quality for versatility. But that's no longer the case. All the superzooms in the Select Ratings (available to subscribers) have very good image quality, though not quite comparable to an SLR's.

New lens designs

Most models that accept interchangeable lenses still come with the usual 18- to 55-mm zoom. But camera and lens makers do offer more versatile zooms. For instance, Panasonic recently introduced a 45- to 175-mm f/4.0-5.6 telephoto zoom (the 35-mm equivalent of 90 to 350 mm), which has a power-zoom switch on the lens barrel that you can use to zoom smoothly.

Olympus SP-610UZ

Cameras with 3D

As more electronics manufacturers add a 3D feature to HDTVs, you might expect to find it on many cameras. But 3D is making only modest inroads, mostly in basic cameras. Olympus, Sony and Panasonic have been the most aggressive in adding it to their models. In our Ratings (available to subscribers), just two basic models, Olympus SP-610UZ and Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX9V, and two advanced ones, Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF2K and Lumix DMC-G3K, include 3D. The two advanced models require a special lens for 3D that costs $200.

If you have a 3D-capable TV and would like to try out the budding technology without spending a bundle, consider a basic model first to see if you like it.

Nikon V1

Mirrorless advanced cameras

A big development in cameras this year has been the rise of the SLR-like model, a smaller, lighter competitor that also uses interchangeable lenses.

Sony recently introduced six such models, and Nikon finally joined most other major SLR makers by unveiling two 10-megapixel SLR-like cameras: the Nikon V1 ($900 with kit lens) and Nikon J1 ($650 with kit lens). We haven't tested them yet.

Most of the new SLR-like cameras are more compact than SLRs and include sensors larger than those of basic cameras. As we went to press, Canon didn't offer this type of camera.

 

Copyright © 2006-2011 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • 'Angel of Death' serial killer dies after attack in prison

      TOLEDO, Ohio (AP) — A serial killer known as the "Angel of Death" after he admitted killing three dozen hospital patients in Ohio and Kentucky died Thursday, two days after investigators said he was attacked in prison, Ohio's prisons department said.

      Associated Press
    • Dear Abby: Family thinks ill husband is faking it

      DEAR ABBY: My husband has been sick and unable to work for several years due to a debilitating illness. He has been home taking care of the kids while I have been working full time. We have lost everything because of the financial burden of his illness. I am very grateful to my parents for helping us financially during this tough time. Unfortunately, I believe some of my family think my husband is faking his illness. This is hurtful since they have known him for a long time (we’ve been married 12 years). My sister recently asked him in a rather nasty way why he doesn’t just go get a job, and I’m beginning to think that my parents share her sentiment. He already feels guilty and worthless for

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • An American Airlines co-pilot died during landing, and this is scary

      American Airlines issued a statement yesterday explaining a tragic medical mystery that happened in the cockpit. On Wednesday, an American Airlines co-pilot…

      Hello Giggles
    • Cosmo
    • Drugged-out dog will make you melt right along with him

      Australian golden retriever Oscar had to get minor surgery. This is decidedly bad news, but his post-surgery bliss says otherwise. His owner, Sarah, posted this picture of Oscar on the way home from surgery, while he was still on sedatives, showing that he might have not had too bad a time.  And people could not get enough of it. doggo went under for surgery and now he is DRUGGO pic.twitter.com/ZTJpqapbGq — hot librarian (@smack__that) March 27, 2017 That smile! You can practically see the big doggy spa he's imagining in his head, brought on by whatever the vet used to put him under.  SEE ALSO: Meet the dog who's basically a saint If there was ever a time to use the phrase "blissed out," it's here. The very picture of bliss.  At home, Sarah had help of a feline friend in making sure he got better: @JackLScanlan his lil mate's looking out for him pic.twitter.com/CipxihNeXJ — hot librarian (@smack__that) March 27, 2017 Now, Sarah says that he's recovering just fine. @aimeeclarke he's fine!! Being well looked after pic.twitter.com/6hwub6jCvE — hot librarian (@smack__that) March 28, 2017 Even without the sedatives he's still a pretty peaceful pup. But how is he dealing with all this newfound attention now that he's gone dog viral?? he's hired security to deal with his newfound celebrité pic.twitter.com/lfKlECZe58 — hot librarian (@smack__that) March 30, 2017 Phew. Sleep easy folks, Oscar is taken care of. Perhaps the best part of all this is the follow up: people replying with pictures of their own dogs after surgery. The doggy drowsiness is real.  @smack__that awwww your doggo got much happier drugs than mine!  pic.twitter.com/85cQQn61zh — Nikki (@nikki_isabel) March 27, 2017 DOG TONGUE ALERT: @nikki_isabel @smack__that omg pic.twitter.com/3CwiqXzbex — Sydney Taylor (@stayl0r2) March 28, 2017 All in all, a really adorable corner of the internet. Get well, all you pups! [H/T]: Buzzfeed WATCH: Finally, you can vacuum clean your dog

      Mashable
    • Gordon Ramsay Reveals the 1 Place You Should Never Eat

      Sure, Gordon Ramsay has high standards, but is there really anything he would never eat? Turns out it's more of a place where he would never eat rather than one specific food — and that's on a plane. In an interview with Refinery29, Gordon revealed his feelings about airplane food and why those feelings might be justified. "There's no f*cking way I eat on planes," he said. "I worked for airlines for 10 years, so I know where this food's been and where it goes, and how long it took before it got on board." Yikes. The man has a point — there's no denying that airplane food is not the best. So what's a traveler to do to avoid midflight hunger, according to the world-renowned chef? If you're like

      PopSugar q
    • Dwyane Wade's Baby Momma, To Join Cast Of Basketball Wives LA

      I can still remember the office conversations we had when the world learned that Dwyane Wade had fathered a child with another woman while he and Gabrielle Union were on a break. Dwyane held a press conference calling his son a blessing. Wade’s son Xavier was quickly dubbed the “break baby,” Union was questioned by paparazzi in airports and many of us wondered what we would do in a similar situation. Well, Gabby and Dwyane worked it out, got married and seem to be enjoying their marriage. Afterward, unless you were following Aja Metoyer, Xavier’s mother, we didn’t hear too much more about the little boy. But all of that might be changing now that Xavier’s mother is going to be joining the cast

      MadameNoire q
    • 7 Drugstore Moisturizers That Will Work Wonders for Your Skin

      Instead of spending tons of money on luxury skin care, we suggest using drugstore products that work amazingly well for a reasonable price.

      The Cheat Sheet q
    • Woman Survives Vicious Attack by Her Husband

      The following material contains graphic images that may be disturbing. Parents are advised that these images may not be suitable for young children.

      The Doctors TV
    • Company gets death threats after bidding on border wall

      The Penna Group CEO Michael Evangelista-Ysasaga on his company's bid to work on Trump's wall along the U.S. border with Mexico and immigration reform.

      Fox Business Videos
    • This divorced couple gets together every year to take a family photo with their son (4 photos)

      Adam Dyson and Victoria Baldwin may no longer be married, but they will always be parents. “We are not in love, we don’t always agree, we’re not best friends, sometimes we don’t even like one another. But you know what we are? We are forever connected because of our beautiful, smart, kind, compassionate, funny son,” writes Baldwin in a Facebook post that was shared by Love What Matters . The couple got divorced shortly after their son turned two, and even though they live in completely different states (Baldwin is serving in the military in Alaska while Dyson is ex-military and attending school in South Carolina), they make an effort to get together with their son for a family photo every 12 to 18 months. “Adam and I are not perfect co-parents, but we made a deal when we got divorced, to put our son first and to value the richness that we each bring to his life, for different reasons,” she writes. “We both need to be there, we both deserve quality time and quality memories with him. Neither of us blame one another for the direction our relationship took. We do not place blame on one another, and we certainly don’t place blame in the presence of our son.” ALSO SEE:  When it wouldn’t stop raining, this family did a muddy maternity photoshoot instead The almost-annual family portraits started before the divorce when Baldwin, who was a professional photographer herself, would get photos taken of the her husband and herself. When Bruce came along, Baldwin wanted photos “to capture milestone and the growth of our son.” “There wasn’t a huge discussion about it,” Baldwin tells Yahoo Canada . “I asked Adam if he would like to come, so he could get photos will Bruce as well. He agreed that was a great idea, and we naturally decided a family portrait was part of that session, in addition to our individual photos with Bruce. After our first post-divorce professional photo, we decided to continue it for the foreseeable future.” And so began an adorable tradition, one that Bruce looks forward to. “[Since] our divorce was finalized shortly after his second birthday, Bruce doesn’t have memories of mom and dad being romantic together,” Baldwin says. “He loves it when we are all together!” But Bruce isn’t the only one loving the family portraits, Baldwin’s photos on Facebook received thousands of likes, with hundreds of commenters sharing their own experiences. ALSO SEE: We divorced to save our relationship “Good for you guys! It truly is an act of selflessness to do this for your son! My ex husband and I remain friends and respect each other and get along great. Not only for our four kids, but for us as well!” writes one. “This is so important. Growing up, I had family photos with “both” my families. Everything was kept so separate that it made me feel like two different people,” says another. “We want Bruce to know families don’t have to fit a specific mould to be a family even when things may seem like they are falling apart. We want him to know it’s possible to come back together in a different way, and still have happiness and joy in your heart,” Baldwin says. “The ending of a romantic relationship didn’t mean the ending of a relationship all together, it meant we needed to find a new way to love and parent our son together, just no longer together.  Two homes, twice the love, I always say!” What do you think of Baldwin’s family photos? Let us know by tweeting us @YahooStyleCA .

      Yahoo Canada Style
    • 'Angel of Death' Donald Harvey critical after savage prison beating

      A notorious serial killer known as the "Angel of Death" is in a critical condition after being beaten up in his Ohio prison cell, according to authorities. Donald Harvey killed at least three dozen people while working as a nurse's aide in the 1970s and 80s.

      International Business Times
    • Dallas-based first officer dies after collapsing on American Airlines flight from DFW | American Airlines

      A Dallas-based American Airlines first officer died Wednesday after collapsing in the cockpit during a flight. Flight 1353 from DFW International Airport was preparing to land Wednesday afternoon in Albuquerque when the captain declared a medical emergency, the Albuquerque Journal reported.  Medics quickly boarded the plane but were unable to revive the first officer, WFAA-TV (Channel 8) reported.  The first officer has been identified as William "Mike" Grubbs. "American Airlines is deeply saddened by Grubbs's death," American Airlines spokeswoman Polly Tracey said. "We are taking care of first officer Grubbs' family and colleagues, and our thoughts and prayers are with them them during this

      Dallas Morning News q
    • Silicon Valley billionaire used to crash meetings with co-founders of Google

      Top investor Chris Sacca shares his best career tip in Tim Ferriss’ book, “Tools of Titans.”

      CNBC q
    • Love, Marriage – and Babies! How the Property Brothers Finally Settled Down – and Why They Still Live Together

      The Property Brothers Jonathan Scott and Drew Scott stay connected. As the stars of HGTV’s most popular series, Property Brothers, Drew and Jonathan Scott, 38, have spinoff shows, a bestselling book (their second, It Takes Two: Our Story, comes out Sept. 5), their own production company and a collection of furniture and decor. “This is the most humbling, unexpected, fantastic place to be in my life,” Jonathan tells PEOPLE of his relationship with girlfriend, Jacinta Kuznetsov, 28, a development producer at Scott Entertainment.

      People
    • How to lose friends and 'exfoliate' people — Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner, is caught between 2 worlds, and his friends are cutting ties

      Signing up to carry out Donald Trump's vision of America has come at a cost to many of the...

      Business Insider
    • The New England Patriots

      The New England Patriots have a fairly lengthy history of bending the NFL's rules. Here's a look at the 4 biggest scandals in Patriots history.

      The Cheat Sheet q 32 min ago
    • Dog owner fatally mauled by Staffordshire bull terrier while he was being 'interviewed for BBC documentary'

      A dog owner mauled to death by his Staffordshire bull terrier was allegedly being interviewed by the BBC when the horrific attack took place. The man’s cause of death was recorded as hypovolemic shock and damage to the airway – with the injuries said to be consistent with a dog bite. The dog remains in secure kennels after being seized by police – who have since confirmed that the animal is not prohibited under the Dangerous Dogs Act.

      Yahoo News UK
    • 911 Call Released in 'Make My Day' Home Invasion Killings

      Three teens are dead, and a 21-year-old woman has been arrested.

      Inside Edition
    • Maksim Chmerkovskiy Undergoes Surgery to Get 'Un-Broken' Following Calf Injury

      Maksim Chmerkovskiy Undergoes Surgery to Get 'Un-Broken'

      People