Costco's Kirkland Pacs top Tide Pods in detergent tests

Consumer Reports

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean Pacs
For as long as we've been testing laundry detergent pods—those convenient, single-use packets—only Tide Pods have cleaned well enough to make our winner's list. But there's a new top pod in our tests of laundry detergents, and it costs about 30 percent less than Tide Pods. The only catch is you'll need a Costco membership to find it. And if you have kids at home, special safety precautions are a must.

MORE AT COnsumer Reports

Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean Pacs, sold exclusively at Costco, scored two points higher than Tide Pods to become our top-rated laundry detergent pod. Both products were very good at tackling grass and ring-around-the-collar in our tough tests, though only the Kirkland was good at removing blood. And Kirkland costs a competitive 14 cents per load, compared with 22 cents per load for the Tide Pods.

The other nine laundry detergent pods in our latest tests didn't do as well. Worst of the bunch was Seventh Generation Natural Laundry Packs Advanced Triple Enzyme, which costs 30 cents per load and managed an overall score of just 35 out of a possible 100.

While the Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean Pacs earn our praise for price and performance, we do have concerns about its packaging. As we've reported over the last year, detergent pods pose a serious safety risk to children, who might mistake the colorful, bite-sized capsules for candy. Since pods became commonplace in early 2012, there have been more than 9,000 incidents of exposure involving children age 5 or younger.

Consumer Reports has called on the industry to develop more child-resistant packaging. Proctor & Gamble, maker of Tide, responded by adding safety latches to its plastic containers and making the transition from transparent to opaque plastic. The grape-colored Kirkland pods, however, are packaged in a see-through plastic tub not unlike the containers pretzels and other snacks come in. And small fingers will have no trouble removing the flimsy plastic lid.

And so, while Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean Pacs is tops for cleaning, Costco should insist on more child resistant packaging. If you have or care for young children, keep all detergents out of their reach. And if a child does ingest a pod, call the poison-control helpline immediately (800-222-1222).

Copyright © 2006-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Trump used an unusual word in the third debate and now everyone is googling it

      Republican nominee Donald Trump is known for some unusual speech patterns.  During the third...

      Business Insider
    • 'I'm the victim,' Iowa teacher who had sex with student says on 'Dr. Phil'

      DES MOINES — A substitute teacher accused of having sex with a 17-year-old high school student in Cedar Rapids claims the student seduced her. Mary Beth Haglin was charged in July with sexual exploitation by a teacher. On Monday, she appeared on Dr. Phil, accusing the student of seducing her and sharing sexy photos with his friends. “Many people see him as the victim and me as the perpetrator. From a psychological standpoint and from every other standpoint, I feel like I am the victim,” Haglin said on the Dr. Phil show, citing the student's intelligence and “elevated vocabulary” as part of the seduction. Haglin pleaded not guilty to sexual exploitation by a school employee. Her trial is set to

      USA Today q
    • Trump’s ‘bombshell’: Europe’s press reacts to final Clinton-Trump face-off

      As Europe tuned into Wednesday night's presidential debate, many agreed on the defining moment of the night – unfortunately for Donald Trump. q
    • EXCLUSIVE: Shania Twain Stuns at CMT Artists of the Year Event, Reveals How She Stays in Incredible Shape

      Shania Twain SLAYS in Nashville, and gets real with ET about her diet.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • DeAngelo Hall appreciates Brian Mitchell's response to Stephen A. Smith on Redskins comments

      The media firestorm surrounding Stephen A. Smith's comments about the Redskins, calling the team "losers" after a few players celebrated a division win last Sunday, seemingly won't die down. That doesn't mean, however, that Redskins legend and CSN/ESPN 980's Brian Mitchell wants it to continue. 

      CSN Mid-Atlantic q
    • Kate Gosselin Accuses Ex-Husband Jon of Having an “Inappropriate Relationship” With Daughter Hannah, 12 (EXCLUSIVE)

      Kate Gosselin has gone to the police with some serious accusations against her ex-husband, Jon Gosselin. In addition to allegations that he’s a drug dealer, the mom-of-eight, 41, is claiming that the 39-year-old has an “inappropriate relationship” with their 12-year-old daughter Hannah, In Touch has exclusively learned. Hannah (Photo Credit: Getty Images) In the police report obtained exclusively by In Touch, Kate claimed Jon once “kidnapped” Hannah by taking her from school; Kate told police “that she detects suspicious behavior between Jonathan and their [then] 10-year-old daughter.” An insider tells In Touch the allegations upset Jon. “Jon had no idea at the time that she accused him of having

      In Touch Weekly q
    • Meet Two Women Changing How Female Lifters Are Perceived

      Women like Suzie B. and Katie Crewe not only dominate their gym’s weight rooms, they post addictive videos viewed by thousands of followers, offering fitness routines that are easy to follow along with. Once you follow one of those women, expect your Instagram recommendations to quickly change from avocado toast snaps to videos of intense push-ups, burpees and true lifting, making the three pound weights you sometimes struggle with lifting seem lighter than ever. All take place in an open gym, in the weight room, with large men walking by, and at times, looking confused. The most popular soundtrack is Kanye West’s “Fade,” after the debut of his video with the ultimate fitness inspiration, Teyana Taylor.

      The New York Observer q
    • An 'Iron Man' Cover Is The Latest Example Of Why Pinup Artists Shouldn't Draw Teenagers

      Midtown Comics has pulled the Invincible Iron Man #1 variant cover by J. Scott Williams of Riri Williams out of her Ironheart armor. A quick peek at Midtown Comics site show the variant with a bold “DO NOT USE (Item Canceled)” declaration. Marvel representatives confirmed to me the choice to pull the cover was a joint decision from Marvel and Midtown Comics.

    • Kourtney Kardashian awkwardly 'blanks' TV hosts who ask about Kim

      Kourtney Kardashian had an awkward on-air moment Thursday morning when hosts of an Australian morning program asked how her sister Kim Kardashian is holding up after her robbery ordeal.   The questions was met with bizarre silence, while the reality TV star sat staring off camera, presumably listening to the panicked advice of her publicists.  SEE ALSO: Khloe Kardashian DGAF about Donald Trump calling her a 'piglet' Making matters worse, the connection was dropped. When producers got Kardashian back on the line post-ad break, she explained "we had a bad connection."   "I think she's totally blanking me on that question," said David Campbell, co-host of Today Extra , adding, "She could just say her sister is fine! I mean I think we just said that you know we're very concerned and we were onside and we hoped that everyone's fine, which I still do." According to The Herald Sun , Kourtney insisted that she be re-connected to the show’s host in order to address the question. Once connected, she discussed how the Kardashian klan was feeling after her sister was held at gunpoint during the Paris robbery.  "I think we're all really still shaken up and I just — you know, I think she has a big supportive family and I know that, like, all of the traumatic things that we've been through, you know, we get through them together as a family and that's what family is all about," she said.  While it might not be the most informative response ever uttered, it may have been worth it as an act of "saving face." What's a potential little white lie about a technical glitch between friends, anyway?   Many of us would love to use the old "we just had a bad connection" excuse to get out of conversations IRL, sometimes.   Kim Kardashian West was robbed at gunpoint in Paris

    • Stephen Colbert rips apart Donald Trump for his most shocking answer at the presidential debate

      Stephen Colbert started his live broadcast of CBS's "The Late Show" on Wednesday night with what...

      Business Insider
    • Celebs Scare Up Some Halloween Fun (20 photos)

      It’s October, which means everyone is busy carving pumpkins, loading up on Halloween candy, and preparing to be scared. There’s certainly no shortage of Halloween haunts in L.A., where celebs have already been checking out the frightening festivities at Knott’s Scary Farm, the Los Angeles Haunted Hayride, and Halloween Horror Nights at Universal Studios. Flip through the pics … if you dare!

      Yahoo Celebrity Staff
    • GOP senators aren’t happy that John McCain was probably caught telling the truth

      Dude, you weren’t supposed to say that out loud! On Monday, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) confirmed one of Democrats’ worst fears. If Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton wins the White House, but Republicans keep the Senate, the GOP “will be united against any Supreme Court nominee that Hillary Clinton, if she were president, would put up.” If America wants to have a Supreme Court in five years, in other words, it better elect the same party to the White House and the Senate. Not long after McCain’s comment, however, a new talking point was born. McCain’s own spokesperson said McCain did not actually mean what he said. The senator will “thoroughly examine the record of any Supreme Court

      ThinkProgress q
    • Family Receives Teen's Letter to Himself - 14 Years After His Murder

      Aaron Vickers wrote the letter as part of a high school assignment.

      Inside Edition
    • Redskins players and coaches react to 'disrespectful,' 'out of line' Stephen A. Smith

      As he's known to do, ESPN's Stephen A. Smith ranted about the Redskins, calling the team losers. The fuss started in the immediate moments after the Redskins beat the Eagles last Sunday. Chris Baker and Ricky Jean Franois celebrated the win in the tunnel with cameras rolling, and Smith eventually watched the video.

      CSN Mid-Atlantic q
    • RZA Responds to Azealia Banks in Lengthy Facebook Post


      Pigeons & Planes
    • A WWE Developmental Wrestler Has Been Suspended After Being Arrested On Serious Charges

      There was some pretty unfortunate news to come out of the WWE Performance Center this week, as Terrance Jean-Jacques, a little-known former collegiate wrestler signed to a WWE developmental contract, was arrested on very serious domestic violence charges and was arraigned on Wednesday. As a result of these charges, Jean-Jacques has been suspended by WWE in accordance with company policy on domestic abuse. Terrance Jean-Jacques, 24, of 40 Locke St., who signed a contract with World Wrestling Entertainment in April, was arrested Sunday and arraigned Wednesday on charges of assault and battery, kidnapping, witness intimidation, destruction of property and threatening to commit a crime.

    • Duterte aligns Philippines with China, says U.S. has lost

      By Ben Blanchard BEIJING (Reuters) - Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte announced his "separation" from the United States on Thursday, declaring he had realigned with China as the two agreed to resolve their South China Sea dispute through talks. Duterte made his comments in Beijing, where he is visiting with at least 200 business people to pave the way for what he calls a new commercial alliance as relations with longtime ally Washington deteriorate. "In this venue, your honors, in this venue, I announce my separation from the United States," Duterte told Chinese and Philippine business people, to applause, at a forum in the Great Hall of the People attended by Chinese Vice Premier Zhang Gaoli.

    • Evacuations lifted after 3 crashes on I-95, multiple deaths reported

      An evacuation order was lifted early Thursday morning after a fatal fiery crash involving hazardous materials on Interstate 95 forced some Johnston County residents out of the area. Northbound lanes of I-95 have reopened, while southbound lanes remain closed.

      WTVD – Raleigh/Durham
    • People are raving about the Fox News anchor who moderated the last presidential debate

      Fox News' Chris Wallace emerged as one of the likely winners of the final presidential debate...

      Business Insider
    • Michelle Obama’s State-Dinner Dresses (12 photos)

      By Erika Harwood. Photos via Getty Images. As the Obamas’ time in the White House draws to a close, the president and First Lady are hosting their last state dinner for the prime minster of Italy and his wife. Over the past eight years, Michelle Obama has worn some of the most iconic looks ever seen on a First Lady. Take a look back at the gorgeous gowns Obama has worn for every U.S. state dinner. This story originally appeared on Vanity Fair . More from Vanity Fair: Jackie Kennedy and Michelle Obama: The White House Wardrobes __ What Will Michelle Obama Do After the White House? Film's Sexiest Little Black Dresses Kate Middleton's Best Looks of 2016 Brad Pitt Through the Years The Kardashians' Obsession with Nude

      Vanity Fair