Consumer Reports Picks the Best Cup o' Brew

Consumer Reports

Folgers, Maxwell House, and Starbucks are America's best-selling ground coffees. But all three were iced by Eight O'Clock Colombian coffee in our taste tests. As for Starbucks, it didn't even place among the top regular coffees and trailed among decafs.

View photo

.
Photo: Courtesy
of Eight O'Clock Coffee

Our tests of 19 coffees also show that some of the best cost the least. At about $6 per pound, Eight O'Clock costs less than half the price of Gloria Jean's, Peet's, and other more expensive brands.

Like your joe without all the caffeine? Dunkin' Donuts and Millstone were the front runners among the decafs. But Folgers Gourmet Selection Lively Colombian came in close behind and costs up to $3 less per pound. But even the best decaffeinated coffees couldn't match the best regular brews in our taste tests.

What we tasted
Our coffee experts focused on 100 percent Colombian — a best-selling bean — for regular coffee. Most of our decaffeinated coffees are a blend of different beans.

What makes a great cup of Colombian? Lots of aroma and flavor, some floral notes and fruitiness, a touch of bitterness, and enough body to provide a feeling of fullness in the mouth. Woody, papery, or burnt tastes are off-notes.

Weeks of sipping and swirling confirmed that even 100 percent Colombian coffee and its Juan Valdez logo don't guarantee quality. Our trained testers unearthed other surprises:

Still so-so after all these years
Chock full o'Nuts and Maxwell House have pushed coffee that's "heavenly" and "good to the last drop" since 1932 and 1907, respectively. But off-notes, little complexity, and, for Chock full o' Nuts, variable quality put both behind Eight O'Clock.

When boutique isn't better
Midwest-based Caribou and Kickapoo beat an array of larger players among regular coffees. But Bucks County Coffee, from Langhorne, Penn., tasted only OK, and Peet's, from Berkeley, Calif., was burnt and bitter, despite costing $14 per pound. Peet's, Archer Farms, and Kickapoo also varied from batch to batch.

Caffeine differences
None of our decaffeinated coffees had more than 5 milligrams of caffeine per 6-ounce serving. But among regular coffees, Caribou and Bucks County had roughly four times the caffeine (195 milligrams) of some of the lowest-level brews. Medical experts say up to 600 milligrams per day is probably safe for most and can help keep you alert. But heart patients and women who are pregnant or nursing should stay below 200 milligrams, which might mean sidestepping those brands among the caffeinated coffees we tested.

How to choose
Several of our top coffees could save you $25 to $70 per year over pricier brands even if you drank just one 6-ounce cup per day. Here's what else to think about:

Consider how you take it
Coffees judged very good taste fine black. Milk and sugar can improve a mediocre coffee, but not even cream is likely to help the lowest-scoring decafs.

Choose a good coffeemaker
The best coffeemakers from our January report reached the 195º to 205º F required to get the best from the beans and avoid a weak or bitter brew. A top Michael Graves model costs just $40.

Consider grinding for fresher flavor
Even the best pre-ground coffee can't beat the best fresh-ground when it comes to taste. One top grinder from our January report, the Mr. Coffee IDS77, costs only $20.

Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers on Yahoo!

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Katie Holmes’ hair transformation is the best cut we’ve seen so far this spring

      ‘Tis the season for spring haircuts! When the weather gets warm again, we love to trade our long locks for something light and airy….

      Hello Giggles
    • Rabbit set to be world's biggest dies on United Airlines flight in fresh PR disaster

      United Airlines has confirmed they are investigating reports that a giant rabbit died while travelling to Chicago on one of its transatlantic flight. Simon, a three-foot continental rabbit, was reportedly travelling from Heathrow to Chicago’s O’Hare Airport after the 10-month old bunny was purchased by a celebrity owner. ‘The client who bought Simon is very famous.

      Yahoo News UK
    • How a Mom's Fitbit Led Police to Charge Her Husband with Her Murder

      How a Mom's Fitbit Led Police to Charge Her Husband with Her Murder

      People
    • Can You Spot The Snake In This Photo?

      If you can, you have better eyes than most

      Esquire
    • ESPN will cut 100 on-air personalities today

      ESPN is cutting 100 on-air personalities, and more than 100 employees in total. It's a result of rising programming costs and falling subscriber numbers. Here are the full details of the layoffs.

      Yahoo Finance
    • Tarek El Moussa Just Revealed What Pushed Him to File For Divorce and It Might Shock You

      When Tarek El Moussa filed for divorce from wife and HGTV partner in crime Christina El Moussa in December 2016, we had a lot of questions, and now, he's telling all. Tarek recently sat down with Us Weekly to talk about what caused his split, as well as that shocking incident where Christina called the cops on her then-husband in May of last year. "It was a gradual thing over time," the Flip or Flop star said when asked about what went wrong in his marriage. "We were both very busy people with health issues and kids. We didn't fight, we just grew apart." He explained that his battle with cancer took a toll on their relationship, as well as Christina's fertility issues and their miscarriage after

      PopSugar q
    • Amazon’s $96 sound bar is so good it doesn’t need a separate subwoofer

      It used to be that if you wanted to add decent sound to your TV, you need to spend upwards of $1,000 on a surround sound system. The the home audio market got much more competitive, and prices began to fall. Things really took a turn when companies began launching sound bars, which cost less to make and didn't require users to run cables all over their homes. Fast-forward to today, and you can get a solid sound bar with a wireless subwoofer for between $200 and $300. And then there's the AmazonBasics 2.1 Channel Bluetooth Sound Bar with Built-In Subwoofer , a 4-star rated home audio solution that costs less than $100. The nifty design builds the sub right into the sound bar itself, delivering great sound, a compact design, and the easiest possible installation. Here are a few more details from the product page: 31.5-inch sound bar with built-in subwoofer enhances home-audio systems (not compatible with universal or TV remotes) Bluetooth technology v2.1 + EDR with A2DP & AVRCP for seamless streaming from various devices Full-range stereo speakers; up to 92 dB (2.1 channels) 4-piece 2-inch round frame; mid- to high-range drivers; 4-by-2.7-inch sub-range driver; 2-piece passive radiator 3 sound modes: Standard, News, and Movie; remote control and wall-mount hardware included; measures 31.5 by 3.2 by 3.5 inches (W x H x D)

      BGR News
    • High School Student Dies After Being Punched at Party

      An 18-year-old high school student in Illinois who was about the graduate died after police say he was hit during an incident at a party Saturday night.

      Tribune
    • America's Ugliest College Campuses (13 photos)

      These college campuses emphasize brains over beauty.

      Travel+Leisure
    • Caitlyn Jenner kept rudely interrupting Kelly Ripa on ‘Live’

      It’s “Live with . . . Caitlyn!” On Tuesday morning’s “Live with Kelly” show, Caitlyn Jenner was a guest — and possibly one of the rudest ever. Jenner, who appeared to promote her memoir, “The Secrets of My Life,” continuously cut off Kelly Ripa and guest co-host, John Leguizamo. At one point, Jenner even turned the tables on Ripa, asking when she first identified as a female. “Just think about that,” she said, pointing her manicured finger at Ripa. “When did you know you were a girl?” Jenner then made Leguizamo her target, asking him how he enjoyed dressing in drag in the 1995 comedy, “To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar.” The painful 15-minute interview consisted of endless, self-congratulatory

      New York Post q
    • US Navy fires warning flare at Iran vessel in Persian Gulf

      DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — A U.S. Navy guided-missile destroyer fired a warning flare toward an Iranian Revolutionary Guard vessel coming near it in the Persian Gulf, an American official said on Wednesday, the latest tense naval encounter between the two countries.

      Associated Press
    • Your drive to Yosemite just got easier. Storm-damaged road to Yosemite Valley set to reopen

      Yosemite visitors, no need to follow detours anymore. The southern entrance and road leading to Yosemite Valley will reopen 5 a.m. Monday. A stretch of Big Oak Flat Road had been impassable for two months because of a landslide, forcing travelers to take a 22-mile detour to get to places such as the Majestic Yosemite Hotel and Half Dome Village, a park announcement said Tuesday. Visitors may still encounter traffic delays along Big Oak Flat Road, which connects to State Route 120. One-lane closures may be in effect, and the road will close 7 p.m. to 5 a.m. for several days as crews shore up repairs. The road had been shut from Crane Flat Campground to the Foresta area since mid-February, forcing

      Los Angeles Times q
    • Esquire
    • Longtime NFL reporter Ed Werder laid off by ESPN

      One of ESPN’s most experienced NFL reporters is out, effective immediately. Ed Werder, who has a strong reputation for covering football and particularly the Cowboys, has been let go, he said on Twitter this morning. “After 17 years reporting on NFL, I’ve been informed that I’m being laid off by ESPN effective immediately. I have…

      NBC Sports: ProFootballTalk q
    • 'Devastated' Chris Soules Speaks Out After Arrest for Allegedly Leaving the Scene of Deadly Crash

      Devastated Chris Soules Speaks Out After Arrest for Allegedly Leaving Scene of Deadly Crash

      People
    • ‘Happy Days’ Star Erin Moran’s Husband Pens Heartbreaking Letter Chronicling Her Cancer Battle

      In the aftermath of former “Happy Days” star Erin Moran’s shocking death this past weekend, rumors have begun to circulate regarding the nature of the actress’ untimely passing. Her co-star Scott Baio added fuel to the fire by saying that he was less than shocked about the news during an interview on “The Bernie and Sid... Read more »

      Variety
    • New Video Shows United Passenger Before Dragging Incident

      A security officer asserted that Dr. David Dao "refused to leave" his seat and "folded his arms tightly,” but his attorney calls the description “utter nonsense.”

      Yahoo View
    • Whoops, Mark Hamill might have accidentally revealed Rey’s parentage…back in the ’80s

      Mrk Hamill is at it again! Well, he was, back in the 80s. Apparently, his interview techniques haven’t changed too much because…

      Hello Giggles
    • Man threw girlfriend's autistic twins, 4, into bitterly cold sea while high

      A Boston man is accused of throwing his girlfriend's four-year-old autistic twins into bitterly cold water at a beach on Monday (24 April) while high on heroin. Mikel Anthony Hilerio, 29, of Roxbury, has been charged with two counts of recklessly endangering a child. A police report described the state of the children after troopers were called to the scene by witnesses.

      International Business Times