Best stuffing mixes

Consumer Reports
Stuffing mixes for Thanksgiving

(Photo: James Worrell)

Find out which packaged stuffing mixes taste best.

For many people, Thanksgiving dinner isn’t complete without stuffing. But it also isn’t complete without the pressure of cooking a huge meal, to say nothing of entertaining Aunt Mavis and Uncle Arnold. As a result, making stuffing from scratch may be a stretch.

To see which packaged stuffings taste best, our trained testers tried 11 and found two very good options. In preparing each product, we followed its stovetop directions. All of the stuffings call for extras: water or broth, butter or margarine, bouillon, and sometimes vegetables. (See our stuffing Ratings and tips for carving a turkey.)

MORE AT COnsumer Reports


The top choices, Pepperidge Farm Herb Seasoned and Pepperidge Farm Cornbread, are flavorful, fresh-tasting, and moist. Their instructions call for chicken broth and sautéed celery and onions, which of course require more work but made them taste fresher than the others.

Mrs. Cubbison’s also called for fresh celery and onions, but those couldn’t hide the dehydrated flavor of the seasonings or the fact that some pieces were dry. Even big names such as Stove Top and Arnold/Oroweat are just OK, with drawbacks including chewy vegetables, crunchy crumbs, overpowering herbs, or the flavor of bouillon instead of fresh broth. (Broth tastes of chicken; bouillon tastes salty and “as if a chicken flew over it,” a taster said.)

Tasters also sampled ready-made Boston Market Fresh Vegetable Stuffing ($4.30, serves two or three), which didn’t wow them. It tasted of chicken broth and dried seasoning and was a bit sweet. Celery pieces were chewy and seemed dried, and too-soft carrot pieces tasted like they’d been frozen.


As prepared, all stuffings scored Good or Fair for nutrition. Saturated fat ranged from 1 to 5 grams and sodium from 230 to 791 milligrams. (The recommended daily limit for most people is 2,300 milligrams.) The Stove Top mixes have the least saturated fat but 1 gram of trans fat. Serving sizes are one-half cup or 1 cup once prepared, but most are close in weight, so you’re getting the same amount of stuffing. (Some are more dense than others.)

You can make stuffing a bit more healthful by using lower-sodium broth, cutting the amount of butter, or adding vegetables and fresh herbs. Bottom line. Both Pepperidge Farm products would be welcome guests at a Thanksgiving dinner. Any stuffing would probably be tastier with real chicken broth or fresh ingredients. Food-safety experts recommend against stuffing the turkey, but if you insist, make sure that you cook stuffing to 165° F.

Tips for carving the bird

You spend hours cooking a turkey, so don’t butcher it when it’s time for slicing. Here are a few pointers from our professionally trained chefs:

Give it a rest.

To keep more juice in the meat, let the bird sit for 15 to 30 minutes after taking it out of the oven.

Use the right tools.

You’ll need a sharp 8-to-10-inch carving knife, stainless-steel tongs, and a cutting board. Hone your knife lightly before carving by sliding the blade up the steel at a 20-degree angle. As you carve, use the tongs to grip the bird while holding it on the cutting board. Don’t use a fork, which pierces the skin and lets tasty juices seep out.

Go against the grain.

Work on one side of the turkey at a time, first removing the legs (separate the thigh from the drumstick by cutting through the joint) and then cutting off the breast meat in one big chunk. Pull a little skin away from the breastbone to see how the grain of the meat runs, and cut 1/4- to 1/2-inch-thick slices across the grain. That helps hold in juices. Slice the thigh meat, but leave drumsticks intact.

Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Recommended for You

  • Mariah Carey’s Rep Confirms Star’s Split From Billionaire Fiance James Packer After Fight in Greece: Read the Statement

    Mariah Carey’s rep confirmed that the star split from her billionaire fiance, James Packer, after a fight in Greece — see the statement

    Us Weekly
  • This photo of a dog with a mouthful of ladybugs is freaking out pet owners

    The photo that Kansas veterinarian Lindsay Mitchell posted to Facebook looked so unreal and disturbing that some who saw it went right to the hoax-busting website Snopes to verify it. But that didn’t stop the photo from being shared more than 53,000 times since it went up last week. Mitchell, of Hoisington, Kan., posted a graphic picture of a dog with a mouthful of Asian lady beetles. Ladybugs aren’t so cute when 30 to 40 of them are stuck to the roof of a dog’s mouth. “This is the second pup I have seen like this today. If your pet is drooling or foaming at the mouth look for these lady bugs. They cause ulcers on the tongue and mouth and have a very painful bite,” she wrote on the Hoisington

    The Charlotte Observer q
  • Kim Kardashian Concierge Reveals New Robbery Details: ‘They Weren’t There for Jewels’

    ET sits down exclusively with the concierge during Kim Kardashian's robbery, who recalls the terrifying events of Oct. 3.

    Entertainment Tonight
  • Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen predicted the election 15 years ago

    It’s a little-known fact, but once upon a time 15 years ago, Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen had a lifestyle magazine. The publication,…

    Hello Giggles
  • Apple's cord situation is completely out of control

    Apple's newest computer, the MacBook Pro, looks pretty great: It's got fast chips, a...

    Business Insider
  • Angry grizzly bear charges couple twice; what they did possibly saved their lives

    John and Lisa Vandenbos were scouting for fishing spots along the Lamar River in Yellowstone National Park on Saturday when they spotted an adult grizzly bear feeding on a partially consumed carcass. The grizzly bear was obviously surprised and was in no mood to share in its bounty, so it immediately charged the couple, coming to within 9 feet, according to Yellowstone National Park spokeswoman Morgan Warthin. Fortunately, the couple from Bozeman, Montana, were prepared and both quickly discharged their bear spray. “The bear initially left,” Warthin wrote. “When attempting to charge the couple again, it ran into the original cloud of bear spray. Upon making contact with the cloud, the bear retreated q
  • Donald Trump’s March to Loserland Is Only Beginning

    Donald Trump’s march to Loserland is only just beginning. His real pain starts the day after Election Day. As they say in his native Queens, what goes around comes around. And come it will. Accelerated business losses. A continent-wide clamoring to remove his miasmic moniker from buildings. Multiple looming lawsuits, two of them fraud actions arising from Trump University, one of those before federal Judge Gonzalo Curiel in San Diego, whom he suggested was biased because of his ethnicity. Trump will also face revelatory depositions should he follow through on threats to sue the 11 women who have recently accused him of sexual transgressions. He might remember his deposition during his 1990 divorce

    The Daily Beast q
  • Tomb of Christ opened for the first time in centuries

    Researchers have uncovered the original surface of what is traditionally considered the tomb of Jesus Christ in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem. The tomb's surface had been covered by a thick layer of marble, according to an exclusive by National Geographic. "The marble covering of the tomb has been pulled back, and we were surprised by the amount of fill material beneath it," said Fredrik Hiebert, archaeologist-in-residence at the National Geographic Society working at the site.

    International Business Times UK q
  • Russell Wilson's injuries are even worse than we thought

    First, on the knee injury, Wilson told Seattle media he wasn’t supposed to play for four weeks. Wilson, with the help of a live-in therapist, never missed a game. Wilson has a pectoral injury he’s dealing with.

    Shutdown Corner
  • Mariah Carey 'dumped' by billionaire fiance James Packer but keeping $10m engagement ring

    The fairytale may be over for Mariah Carey and her fiance James Packer with reports claiming the couple have split. The Australian businessman is alleged to have ended his 10-month engagement to the US pop star due to her extravagant spending in the midst of their wedding preparations. Packer, 48, proposed to Carey, 46, in January 2016 after almost a year of dating and presented the Grammy-winning singer with a $10m (£8.1m) engagement ring which he is reportedly allowing her to keep.

    International Business Times ONC UK q
  • The Best Gifts for Adventure Travelers (15 photos)

    Whether youre hiking up Everest or through the local national park , there is so much to experience while venturing through unknown terraina pointyour beloved summit-seeking friend has reminded you a million times. This holiday season givethe adventurers in your lifesomething they can use on their journeybackpacks, sleeping bags, and growlersand a promise to jointhem on an adventure later in the year. This year, Travel + Leisure is offering its most comprehensive gift guide ever. The goal? Make sure you can find the perfect present for everyone (yes, evenyour mother-in-law ) on your list. Below, our picks for outdoor enthusiasts:

  • 'American Idol's' Taylor Hicks: I thought I was going to die

    Taylor Hicks says he's lucky to be alive. The season 5 "American Idol" winner told TMZ he thought he was going to die on Wednesday when an engine on the private plane he was on stopped working. "Two of the pistons blew, oil went everywhere, and the engine stopped, and the rotor blade just stopped in mid-air." Hicks told TMZ of his terrifying ordeal. "I just thought to myself, 'What can you do?' Because you're absolutely helpless in this situation because we lost a complete engine." Hicks said he remembered the important points in his life. “My life, and all of our lives kind of flashed before our eyes a little,” he said. Thankfully, the pilot of the twin-engine plane was able to land safely despite

    Fox News q
  • VIDEO: Man pistol whips scary clown prankster in California

    A video showing a man dressed as a clown scaring random people in Northern California has gone viral after one man pistol whipped the prankster.

    KABC – Los Angeles
  • Charlie Sheen Jumps Back Into 'Major League' Indians Uniform for World Series

    Sheen might be the most famous Cleveland Indian to have never played in an actual game, and he made his World Series alliance clear prior to Game 2.

    Entertainment Tonight
  • ‘I Went Back to Him, to the Home I Feared I Might Die In’

    The last thing that I remember before falling down the stairs was my husband’s hand wrapped so tightly around my throat that the edges of my vision had begun to turn black, and my desperately clawing at his face in an attempt to do anything needed to get away.

    Yahoo Beauty
  • TRUMP: 'We should just cancel the election and give it to Trump'

    Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump on Thursday claimed that Hillary Clinton's policies...

    Business Insider
  • The significance of what Daenerys Targaryen is wearing in this Season 7 leaked photo is INSANE

    Leaked photos from the set of Game of Thrones just keep on coming and with them? Game of Thrones Season 7 spoilers! With these…

    Hello Giggles
  • Michael Massee, Actor Who Accidentally Killed Brandon Lee During Filming of 'The Crow,' Dies at 61

    Michael Massee, the actor who unfortunately will forever be known as the man who accidentally shot and killed Brandon Lee on the set of the 1994 film The Crow, has died. Massee’s death was first announced by actor Anthony Delon and confirmed to The Hollywood Reporter by a representative of his agent at Greene & Associates in Los Angeles. In just his second movie appearance, Massee was playing a character known as Funboy when he fired a revolver that had been improperly prepared by crew members at Brandon Lee, the son of famed martial arts star Bruce Lee.

    The Hollywood Reporter
  • What Will Happen to Mariah Carey’s Ring from James Packer?

    If the news of Mariah Carey’s split from James Packer is permanent, there are some very important custody arrangements to work out. Who gets to take the jet to her children’s sports games and performances?

  • 11 Scary-Easy Halloween Cupcakes (34 photos)

    Don't stop there, delight little ghouls with ridiculously awesome Halloween cakes , celebrate day of the dead or and just enjoy a pumpkin that's really a cake —all in our collection of fun Halloween party recipes . From Delish