Best pasta sauces

Consumer Reports

View gallery

.
Plain pasta isn’t exactly full of flavor, so it helps to pair it with a decent sauce. Our trained tasters found three excellent choices among the 20 they tried.

Taste

Among the best is Giada De Laurentiis (from Target), just 60 cents per half-cup. It’s balanced and fresh-tasting, with a buttery richness. Also Excellent are Victoria and Mario Batali, though the Batali costs more than twice as much as the De Laurentiis, ounce for ounce. Three sauces are very good, and most of the rest are merely OK; Hunt’s Traditional is only fair. It tastes a bit like tomato paste and is slightly sour, with a soapy, perfumey off-taste.

MORE AT CONSUMER REPORTS

What’s in a famous name? Although the tested De Laurentiis and Batali sauces score high, Paul Newman’s rates far lower. Well-known store brands including Great Value (Walmart), Trader Giotto’s (Trader Joe’s), Kirkland Signature (Costco), and 365 Everyday Value (Whole Foods) are also middling, with the best of that group, Great Value, also the cheapest, at 22 cents per half-cup.


Brandmates aren’t equally tasty. Although Barilla and Bertolli tomato and basil sauces are very good, the marinara versions are good. Don’t assume that all sauces by a particular manufacturer will be of similar quality.

(Taste test: whole wheat pasta.)

Nutrition

Judged on calories, fats, sodium, sugars, fiber, calcium, and iron, most products earned a score of good. (Newman’s Own includes some iron and fiber, so it squeaks into the very good category for nutrition.) Still, the numbers differ: Calories per half-cup range from 40 to 100; fat from 1 to 7 grams; sodium from 340 to 560 milligrams; and sugars from 2 to 12 grams.

Bottom line

View gallery

.


Giada De Laurentiis Tomato Basil is a CR Best Buy. Victoria and Mario Batali, runners-up, are pricier but also somewhat lower in calories, fat, and sugars. All three taste as if made with fresh ingredients. Cost is based on approximate retail prices of the containers we bought. Costco’s came in the biggest jar, 32 ounces; Trader Joe’s in the smallest, 18 ounces.

Close-up

Our tasters also tried Classico Signature Recipes Creamy Alfredo and the same product in a Light version. Regular has 100 calories and 9 grams of fat per serving (a quarter-cup for these sauces); Light shaves off about 40 calories and 4 grams of fat. Both taste mediocre, and neither comes close to a traditional Alfredo sauce. They taste so similar on fettuccine that if you must eat jarred Alfredo sauce, you might as well choose Light and save calories and fat.

View gallery

.

Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Michael Moore’s Prediction for Trump’s Impeachment Will Depress a Lot of People

      Michael Moore, a political prophet for our modern times, loves to predict things about Donald Trump. He thinks the new U.S. President is going to get everyone killed; he believes Trump will absolutely build a border wall and ban all Muslims. (Lest we forget, Moore also wrote a prescient essay that predicted Trump would win.) Anyhow, Moore is back on the offensive and predicting another pressing matter on the minds of many citizens, specifically, when will Trump get impeached and kicked out of the White House for good? For those looking for an optimistic answer, you’re not going to love his thoughts. “I would say some time in the middle of his second term,” he explained at a Tribeca Film Festival

      Vulture q
    • Serena Williams Hits the Beach Following Pregnancy Announcement -- See the Pic!

      The tennis pro and mom-to-be took to Instagram to share some photos from her idyllic trip.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Aaron Hernandez Left Multiple Suicide Notes: Report

      The notes were written to his fiancée, his daughter and a close prison friend.

      International Business Times
    • The smartphone is eventually going to die — this is Mark Zuckerberg's crazy vision for what comes next

      At this week's Facebook F8 conference in San Jose, Mark Zuckerberg doubled down on his crazy...

      Business Insider
    • Wheaton College mourns freshman killed during track event

      Wheaton College is in mourning after a 19-year-old student was killed in a bizarre accident at a track meet.

      WLS – Chicago
    • Chris Pratt Walk of Fame Photos (8 photos)

      Chris Pratt, Anna Faris Family Photos, Walk of Fame

      People
    • Dear Abby: Husband bought house, I do all the work

      DEAR ABBY: My husband decided to buy a house. I never wanted one and now I’m depressed. I am thankful that my husband provides for the family and puts a roof over our heads, but now that we are in our house, my days are spent doing chores, yard work, and cleaning, cleaning and cleaning. This is why I never wanted the responsibility of a house. I don’t have time for my family because I’m so busy maintaining this house I never wanted. I have been distant from my husband because I secretly despise him for putting me in this position when he knew it wasn’t what I wanted. Am I being selfish? — DON’T WANT THE RESPONSIBILITY DEAR DON’T: Selfish? No. Passive-aggressive, yes. The problem with passive

      Chicago Sun-Times q
    • I Let My Daughter Transition at 4 Years Old — And Have Zero Regrets Today

      Kai did not choose this haircut, but she put on a smile anyway. By the time Kai was 3 1/2 years old, I couldn't ignore it anymore. She was verbalizing that she was a girl at least six times a day. Everything was: "I'm a princess" and "I'm a girl." Every time she'd say something like that, I'd get down on her level and firmly say, "No, you're a boy." It never worked. She would correct me by waiting until I was in the middle of something and unable to chase her around, then run into the room and yell, "I'm a girl!" and run out again. I did everything I could think of to cut off that kind of talk. There were time-outs, so many time-outs. There were spankings and yelling matches and endless prayers.

      ELLE q
    • Flight Attendant Gets Real About the Rash of Passenger Protests Against Airlines

      With so much turmoil being documented lately between flight crews and passengers, one flight attendant is standing up for his profession.

      Yahoo Beauty
    • Australia, New Zealand hit back at North Korea threat

      Australia and New Zealand stiffened their rhetoric against North Korea Sunday after the isolated state threatened Canberra with a nuclear strike, urging it to think twice before "blindly and zealously toeing the US line". The move comes as US Vice President Mike Pence wraps up an Asia tour, which has included visits to South Korea, Japan and Australia partly to reassure allies amid fears that Pyongyang may be readying for a sixth nuclear test. "If Australia persists in following the US' moves to isolate and stifle North Korea... this will be a suicidal act," a North Korean foreign ministry spokesman said after Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop called the hermit state a "serious threat".

      AFP
    • Team that made Stephon Marbury a god no longer wants him

      Beijing has honored him with a statue, museum, stamp and play. But no longer with a contract. The Beijing Ducks agreed to terminate their pact with Stephon Marbury this weekend, making the 40-year-old former Knick and Net a free agent. Marbury had one more year left on his deal — after which he said he would retire — but disagreements about his role and salary caused the rift. Marbury, who resuscitated his basketball career in the Chinese Basketball Association after falling out of the NBA in 2009, released a statement to his legions of overseas fans, saying he always will be a “Beijinger” and thanking them for giving him a “second life.” Marbury, from Coney Island and a fixture on very bad Knicks

      New York Post q
    • Aaron Hernandez's Connecticut hometown prepares for funeral

      Family and friends of Aaron Hernandez will say their farewells to the former NFL player during a private funeral in his hometown. Services are scheduled for 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. Monday for the former New England Patriots tight end, who was found hanged in his cell in a maximum-security prison in Massachusetts last Wednesday. Hernandez was serving a life sentence for the 2013 murder of semi-pro football player Odin Lloyd, who was dating the sister of Hernandez's fiancee, and he had just been acquitted of murder charges in the shooting deaths of two men in Boston in 2012.

      The Associated Press
    • Burt Reynolds makes rare public appearance at film festival

      NEW YORK (AP) — Robert De Niro helped Burt Reynolds onto the red carpet for the Tribeca Film Festival premiere of his new movie "Dog Years" Saturday night in New York. It was a rare appearance for the 81-year old actor, who at times struggled to walk.

      Associated Press
    • From First to Worst: This Fast-Casual Restaurant Now Ranks Last in Customer Loyalty

      It's hard to go from hero to zero, but this fast casual restaurant managed to do it in just two years.

      Motley Fool q
    • Conjoined Twins Refuse to Be Separated Despite Doctor's Warnings

      Conjoined Twins Refuse to Be Separated Despite Doctor's Warnings

      People
    • Report: Hawks' Dennis Schroder asked John Wall to work out with him after NBA Playoffs

      John Wall and Dennis Schroder have had some intense battles over the years and some beef, as well. Currently, they are locked in a competitive playoff series that saw Wall dunk on Schroder, then stare him down. Schroder, though, has at times been very complimentary of Wall over the years and, according to reporters in Atlanta, Schroder would like to train with Wall in the offseason. It is relatively common for players on different teams to work out together over the summer and it sounds like Schroder would like to have that type of relationship with the Wizards All-Star.

      Comcast SportsNet Mid Atlantic q
    • Milestone man Messi puts on sensational Clasico display

      By Rik Sharma MADRID (Reuters) - Lionel Messi delivered a majestic Clasico display to silence the Santiago Bernabeu as the Argentine scored his 500th Barcelona goal to snatch a thrilling 3-2 win at Real Madrid on Sunday. Messi scored twice with his stunning second strike settling a pulsating clash in the last minute of stoppage time, drawing Barcelona level with Madrid on 75 points at the top of La Liga, although Los Blancos have a game in hand. The stand-out player in a magnificent match, Messi was a nightmare for Real Madrid whose captain Sergio Ramos was sent off for a hasty two-footed lunge at the Argentine while Casemiro was lucky to avoid red for repeated fouls on the No. 10.

      Reuters
    • North Korea 'ready to sink' US aircraft carrier Carl Vinson

      The US has warned North Korea against destabilising the region any further after the official newspaper of the government's Workers' Party said that Pyongyang was ready to sink a US aircraft carrier heading towards the peninsula. The newspaper likened the USS Carl Vinson - which has been ordered by US President Donald Trump to sail to the Korean peninsula following North Korea's recent failed missile tests - to a "gross animal".

      International Business Times