Best pasta sauces

Consumer Reports

View gallery

Plain pasta isn’t exactly full of flavor, so it helps to pair it with a decent sauce. Our trained tasters found three excellent choices among the 20 they tried.


Among the best is Giada De Laurentiis (from Target), just 60 cents per half-cup. It’s balanced and fresh-tasting, with a buttery richness. Also Excellent are Victoria and Mario Batali, though the Batali costs more than twice as much as the De Laurentiis, ounce for ounce. Three sauces are very good, and most of the rest are merely OK; Hunt’s Traditional is only fair. It tastes a bit like tomato paste and is slightly sour, with a soapy, perfumey off-taste.


What’s in a famous name? Although the tested De Laurentiis and Batali sauces score high, Paul Newman’s rates far lower. Well-known store brands including Great Value (Walmart), Trader Giotto’s (Trader Joe’s), Kirkland Signature (Costco), and 365 Everyday Value (Whole Foods) are also middling, with the best of that group, Great Value, also the cheapest, at 22 cents per half-cup.

Brandmates aren’t equally tasty. Although Barilla and Bertolli tomato and basil sauces are very good, the marinara versions are good. Don’t assume that all sauces by a particular manufacturer will be of similar quality.

(Taste test: whole wheat pasta.)


Judged on calories, fats, sodium, sugars, fiber, calcium, and iron, most products earned a score of good. (Newman’s Own includes some iron and fiber, so it squeaks into the very good category for nutrition.) Still, the numbers differ: Calories per half-cup range from 40 to 100; fat from 1 to 7 grams; sodium from 340 to 560 milligrams; and sugars from 2 to 12 grams.

Bottom line

View gallery


Giada De Laurentiis Tomato Basil is a CR Best Buy. Victoria and Mario Batali, runners-up, are pricier but also somewhat lower in calories, fat, and sugars. All three taste as if made with fresh ingredients. Cost is based on approximate retail prices of the containers we bought. Costco’s came in the biggest jar, 32 ounces; Trader Joe’s in the smallest, 18 ounces.


Our tasters also tried Classico Signature Recipes Creamy Alfredo and the same product in a Light version. Regular has 100 calories and 9 grams of fat per serving (a quarter-cup for these sauces); Light shaves off about 40 calories and 4 grams of fat. Both taste mediocre, and neither comes close to a traditional Alfredo sauce. They taste so similar on fettuccine that if you must eat jarred Alfredo sauce, you might as well choose Light and save calories and fat.

View gallery


Copyright © 2006-2012 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Recommended for You

  • Spain under pressure to refuse refuel of Russian warships

    Spain was under pressure Wednesday from its allies to refuse permission for Russian warships headed for the Syrian coast to refuel at one of its ports. Russia's request to allow its ships to stop on Spanish territory "are under review" while Spain weighs input from its allies and Russian authorities, a foreign ministry spokesman told daily newspaper El Pais late Tuesday. Spain's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to requests for information on Wednesday.

  • Woman who pushed husband out of high-rise window found dead in prison

    An Oklahoma woman convicted of second-degree murder for shoving her hubby out of the window of their high-rise apartment was found dead in her prison cell on Monday, officials said. Amber Hilberling, 25, who was serving a 25-year prison sentence for the 2011 death of Joshua Hilberling was officially pronounced dead at 5:33 p.m. at the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud, OK, according to the Oklahoma Department of Corrections. The medical’s examiner’s office will determine Hilberling’s cause of death, but the woman’s parents who spoke exclusively to KTUL-ABC 8, said that medical staff told them that the death was being treated as a suicide, according to the news channel. Hilberling’s stepfather, Bryan Whitlock, who said he spoke to Hilberling the night before, told KTUL that there is “no way” his stepdaughter’s death was a suicide.

    New York Post q
  • Family Heartbroken After 4-Year-Old Is Killed by New Dog Dropped Off Minutes Earlier

    The owner reportedly dropped the dog off less than an hour before the attack.

    Inside Edition
  • You Need To Read These Stories About Marshawn Lynch From His Former Seattle Teammates

    Just watch his episode of Running Wild with Bear Grylls for proof of all of this. The Seattle Times caught up with a few guys on Seattle’s roster and asked for their favorite Marshawn stories. My first week here, we were outside on the field, and I was talking to Justin Forsett.

  • Phil Collins Witnessed Princess Diana’s Affair and 7 More Shocking Revelations From His Memoir

    In his new memoir, 'Not Dead Yet,' Phil Collins shares shocking stories about Princess Diana and Prince Charles, Adele and more — read Us Weekly's top revelations!

    Us Weekly
  • McIlroy's caddie cashes in on FedEx Cup

    SHANGHAI (AP) — Rory McIlroy didn't have to check his bank account to know that his FedEx Cup bonus had been deposited. His caddie, J.P. Fitzgerald, informed him with a text message. "I think his words were, 'A tsunami just hit my bank account, so thank you very much,'" McIlroy said Wednesday on the eve of the HSBC Champions. "J.P. got a nice percentage of that, so I knew at that point it was already there." No payoff is greater than Sunday at East Lake. For the last seven years, the winner of the Tour Championship also has won the FedEx Cup and its $10 million bonus. The player receives $9 million in cash, and $1 million is deferred into a retirement account. McIlroy also earned $1.53 million

    USA Today q
  • 16 Cool Halloween Costume Ideas to Shop Right Now (16 photos)

    Less than a week left until Halloween — and you’re all set with the costume you’ve been carefully planning since August, right? Yeah, neither are we. But that doesn’t mean our only recourse is a running to the nearest Spirit store and grabbing a weirdly expensive, yet cheap-looking prefab costume . The truth is, you can probably build a much better Halloween costume, DIY style. Just grab a few items from your closet, throw in a just-for-Halloween buy or two, and voilà — a custom costume that looks way better than anything in cheapie polyester. To prove it, we asked Polyvore to bring us its best user-generated Halloween sets . Ahead, you’ll find 16 cool costume ideas, that you can click to shop right on Polyvore. Trust us, there’s still plenty of time to look as if you put effort into Halloween (thank God for two-day shipping). Channel the badass heroine of the Netflix original series that's not  "Stranger Things" with this Jessica Jones costume . Is it the most shockingly original costume ever? Definitely not. Do we adore this unusually elegant take on the cat costume – complete with slinky jumpsuit – anyway? For sure.

    Yahoo Style
  • This Girl Was Bullied For Her Skin Color. Now She's A Badass Model.

    Bullies, be gone.  Khoudia Diop is a 19-year-old from Senegal who has faced bullying throughout her life simply because of the color of her skin.  “I was picked on by other kids, when I was a bit younger because [of the darkness] of my skin tone,” she told The Huffington Post. “But this is something that is actually quite normal in Senegal. It’s not a nice feeling and I’ve had to learn to love myself more every day and tune out the negativity, which helps a lot!” (A 2015 survey revealed between 52 and 67 percent of Senegalese women use skin lightening products, Quartz previously reported.) Diop’s story of overcoming bullying and rising to success touched thousands. She’s now aspiring to be a

    The Huffington Post q
  • 'Nothing short of a miracle' how kids survived suicidal bridge fall with dad, police say

    "When the officers found the children -- conscious and alert -- it's nothing short of a miracle, that's for sure," said Captain Christopher Depuyt with the Pequannock Police Department.

    WABC – NY
  • World Series of Poker player lectures another about being a bully

    Poker is generally a quiet game with occasional banter, but Englishman William Kassouf just doesn’t shut up.

    Sporting News
  • Dreaded Polar Vortex May Be Shifting

    The polar vortex in recent years has brought the kind of miserable cold to northern states that made it hard to breathe outside. We’re probably in for more of the same. That’s the finding of a new study published yesterday in the journal Nature that finds that as the Arctic warms, it is shifting the polar vortex to Europe. That in turn will bring more bursts of frigid cold to North America. Those temperature drops could lead to miserable days in February and March, the research finds. Conversely, those drops in temperature could offset some of global warming’s effect in those regions, said Martyn Chipperfield, professor of atmospheric chemistry at the University of Leeds and a co-author of the

    Scientific American q
  • EXCLUSIVE: 'This Is Us' Star Milo Ventimiglia on the Devastating Jack Reveal: 'Now Comes All the Speculation'

    The star of NBC's breakout hit talks to ET about Tuesday's brutal revelation and what it means for the show.

    Entertainment Tonight
  • Teen Girls Arrested After Video of Assault on Man, 62, Appears on Facebook

    Two girls, one 14 and one 15, are accused of assaulting a 62-year-old man who told them to get off his lawn.

    Inside Edition
  • Michael Bloomberg nails the 'greatest conundrum' America faces today

    Former New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg attempted to explain the sentiment of Donald Trump’s supporters, noting that many would be “flipping hamburgers” after they lose their jobs to technology. “One thing that has to be said here is Donald Trump really does represent 40% to 45% of this country. Indeed, this explains why manufacturing activity is up even as manufacturing jobs falter.

    Yahoo Finance
  • The Cubs were so bad in Game 1 that Cleveland police are worried

    The Chicago Cubs turned in a disappointing performance during their 6-0 loss to the Cleveland Indians in Game 1 of the World Series. Corey Kluber and the Indians’ big, bad bullpen completely dominated Chicago’s bats, giving up just seven hits over nine shutout innings. While that would normally be good news to the people of Cleveland, one local group seemed a bit concerned about the Cubs’ offensive struggles in Game 1.

    Big League Stew
  • A leaked alternate version of the Season 7 “Walking Dead” premiere shows an even MORE tragic death

    Spoilers ahead for the Season 7 premiere of The Walking Dead. If you’ve watched it already (and if you haven’t, stop reading…

    Hello Giggles
  • A Redskins Coach Exposed His Wiener To Fans When He Whipped It Out To Pee On The Sideline

    One Redskins coach, however, decided to go full Nick Novak and pee on the sideline during Washington’s game on Sunday against Detroit. Ben Kotwica, Washington’s special teams coordinator, grabbed a cup, walked away from the action, and went to the bathroom. If you’d like to see the uncensored picture, Deadspin has your back.

  • Don’t vote for Hillary Clinton because you have to—vote for her because she’s a true progressive

    I have a confession: I voted for Clinton in the primaries. To clarify — I consider myself to the left of Sanders on nearly all domestic issues, and I lean heavily towards non-intervention in foreign affairs, particularly in the Middle East. I voted for Clinton not to preserve the center-left establishment, but because I believe she’s the…

    Quartz q
  • Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal open up about Novak Djokovic's recent struggles in tennis

    Sporting legends Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal have opened up about Novak Djokovic's recent run of poor form in tennis, admitting that while the Serb is "going through a crisis" they feel that the sport is less important as compared to what life has to offer. The number one ranked player in the world Djokovic, recently revealed that loss of desire and love for the sport was behind his struggles following his incredible success on court at the beginning of the season. Federer and Nadal who have experienced ups and downs in their careers understand what the Serb is going through but have revealed that life is more important than the sport.

    International Business Times UK q
  • Man Dies of Flesh-Eating Bacteria from Ocean: What Is Vibrio Vulnificus?

    A man in Maryland died just days after he developed a rare infection from a type of flesh-eating bacteria that live in ocean water. The man, Michael Funk, 67, had a cut on his leg that came into contact with the salty water in a bay near his home in Ocean City, according to Nature World News. The cut allowed a type of bacteria called Vibrio vulnificus to enter his bloodstream.