Best jellies and jams

Consumer Reports
Bonne Maman and Trader Joe’s have big fruit flavor and big strawberry pieces.

(Photo courtesy bonnemaman.us)

Some inexpensive brands tasted better than pricier ones.

Smucker’s (“bringing you the goodness of jams, jellies, preserves, and smiles”) and Welch’s (“makes the most delicious jams, jellies, and spreads”) are two of the biggest names in jellies and jams. And most of their products did well in our tests. But other brands­—365 Everyday Value grape, Bonne Maman, and Trader Joe’s strawberry—scored at least as high. And Smucker’s Simply Fruit was just OK.

Among the lower-rated products was the priciest one in the bunch. The label on Stonewall Kitchen, $7.05 per jar (31 cents per tablespoon), says, “Whole, sun-ripened, sweet strawberries make our strawberry jam an exceptional American classic bursting with memories of summer.” Not according to our trained tasters, who found a musty off-taste in some of our samples.

MORE AT COnsumer Reports

View photo

.
365 Organic Concord Grape

Grape jellies

The top four all have a strong grape flavor and are quite sweet. Differences weren’t very noticeable. The lower-rated Market Pantry is a looser gel and creates a gummy feeling in the mouth. “Concord,” by the way, simply refers to the type of grape used to make jelly and juice.

(See also: Baking chocolate taste test)


Strawberry jams

Bonne Maman and Trader Joe’s have big fruit flavor and big strawberry pieces; Welch’s strawberry flavor has a hint of grape; Smucker’s Seedless is thicker than most of the tested jams, with a uniform texture; and Smucker’s Low Sugar has some fresh strawberry flavor but is a bit sour and more runny than others. The lower-rated strawberry jams have off-tastes. Archer Farms lost points for a slight medicinal flavor; Polaner and Smucker’s Simply Fruit taste a tad pruney.

Bottom line.

The very good grape jellies taste similar, so choose by price. The very good strawberry jams have slightly different textures. Choose Bonne Maman or Trader Joe’s if you favor strawberry chunks; Smucker’s Seedless if you don’t like seeds. Try Smucker’s Low Sugar if you’re looking to limit sugar. And note that the words “all fruit” or “simply fruit” didn’t guarantee a tastier jam. Our experts also rated the nutrition of each jelly and jam—based on calories, sodium, and sugars—and judged the products good or very good. Polaner All Fruit is the only one with fiber (3 grams).

Copyright © 2006-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • People are freaking out over a photo of Kellyanne Conway in the Oval Office

      Twitter is alive with the sound of outrage after Kellyanne Conway, the counselor to President...

      Business Insider
    • She asked her jailed boyfriend for some heroin advice. Then things turned deadly

      A Florida woman needed advice on cutting the strength of her heroin supply. So she turned to her incarcerated boyfriend. “You’ll figure it out,” Robert Rigby, in jail on drug charges, told Melissa Winings in a phone call. “If you get hit in the head enough times you learn to wear a helmet.” A day later, Winings was arrested, charged with manslaughter. Police say she gave carfentanil to a 34-year-old Sarasota man who then died. Rigby, 42, gave Winings a set of numbers to reduce the potency of her drugs. “Will you do that for me now on, not guesstimate and use those numbers?” Rigby asked. “Yes, baby,” the 25-year-old Nokomis woman said. But in the early hours of Aug. 29, 2016, Sarasota County Sheriff’s

      Miami Herald q
    • George W. Bush Breaks His Silence on the Direction of the Country Under President Trump: ‘I Don’t Like the Racism and Name-Calling’

      For eight years since leaving the White House, George W. Bush has refused to criticize publicly those who succeeded him, saying he didn’t want to make an already tough job any harder for President Obama and, now, President Trump. “I don’t like the racism and I don’t like the name-calling and I don’t like the people feeling alienated,” Bush, 70, tells PEOPLE in an interview for the new issue of the magazine on newsstands Friday. The former president, joined by his wife  Laura, spoke with PEOPLE in the third-floor painting studio of their Dallas home to launch his first art book, Portraits of Courage: A Commander in Chief’s Tribute to America’s Warriors. The collection of portraits of the wounded warriors of America’s war on terror aims to raise awareness and funds for the post-9/11 veterans’ health care and employment programs of the George W. Bush Presidential Center.

      People
    • Tarek El Moussa Loses His Cool on 'Flip or Flop'

      It's been a rough week for "Flip or Flop" stars Tarek and Christina El Moussa as they toured the morning talk shows, opening up about their marital breakup. The post Tarek El Moussa Loses His Cool on 'Flip or Flop' appeared first on Real Estate News & Advice | realtor.com®.

      Realtor.com
    • People Are Not Happy that Casey Affleck Won the Best Actor Oscar

      "Well, that's Hollywood. You can sexually harass and assault your female coworkers and get Best Actor."

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Can You Guess Which Country Has the World's Largest Oil Reserves? (Hint: It's Not Saudi Arabia) -- The Motley Fool

      For decades, the oil market has been dominated by Saudi Arabia, because it not only produced the most oil on a daily basis but also controlled the most oil underground. Those oil resources, known as reserves, gave the country leverage because it could ramp its output up or down to respond to market conditions. It often used that advantage to keep oil prices at a level of its choosing by putting pressure on other members of OPEC to follow its lead. That said, there's a new kid it town that, thanks to advances in drilling technology, now has more reserves than the Saudis. That surprising newcomer is none other than the United States of America, which, according to one estimate, has the world's

      The Motley Fool q
    • Falcons receiver blames Lady Gaga's halftime show for part in Super Bowl collapse

      The Atlanta Falcons blew a 28-3 lead in Super Bowl 51 before losing to the New England Patriots in overtime. It was a game that many sports fans will never forget. You also may remember that the Falcons went into the locker room at half up 21-3 with all the momentum. Then, the halftime show happened. The Super Bowl halftime show, which featured Lady Gaga, made for a 30-minute halftime compared to the 12-minute intermission in the regular season. Falcons wide receiver Mohamed Sanu said the long layoff contributed to the epic Super Bowl meltdown. Sanu said on NFL Network’s Good Morning Football on Friday when asked about the halftime show’s negative effect: “It definitely did. Because usually,

      For The Win q
    • Chrissy Teigen Hilariously Responds to Falling Asleep at the Oscars!

      There was plenty of excitement and drama going on at last night’s Oscars to keep us all entertained, but that didn’t stop Chrissy Teigen from taking a little nap.

      Clevver News
    • Trump says he would have handled administration leaks differently than Sean Spicer

      President Donald Trump said Tuesday that he would have handled leaks in his administration...

      Business Insider
    • ‘Cash me outside’ girl is a bi-coastal menace to America

      The teen notorious for her “cash me outside” remark on the “Dr. Phil” show has found herself in the middle of trouble again. Police are investigating a brawl involving Danielle Bregoli, 13, and three others early on Sunday morning outside of a bar in Lake Worth, Florida. Bregoli, who made headlines earlier this month for a Spirit Airlines altercation, was caught on camera exchanging words with another female bar patron in a video shared to YouTube. According to the post, the woman had suggested that Bregoli was out past her curfew. In response, one of Bregoli’s friends hurled ice cream at the woman and then made a break for it. The food fight led to more altercations that were not seen on the

      New York Post q
    • Here’s the exact moment Emma Stone realized “La La Land” *didn’t* win Best Picture

      By now you’ve heard the stories about the Best Picture snafu at the 2017 Academy Awards. Presenter Warren Beatty was handed the…

      Hello Giggles
    • China reacts with anger, threats after South Korean missile defense decision

      Chinese state media have reacted with anger and boycott threats after the board of an affiliate of South Korea's Lotte Group approved a land swap with the government that allows authorities to deploy a U.S. missile defense system. The government decided last year to deploy the U.S. Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system, in response to the North Korean missile threat, on land that is part of a golf course owned by Lotte in the Seongju region, southeast of Seoul. The board of unlisted Lotte International Co Ltd approved the deal with the government on Monday.

      Reuters
    • EXCLUSIVE: Matt Damon Blames Oscars Flub on Host Jimmy Kimmel: 'They Got What They Paid For'

      As expected, the men continued to feud at the Academy Awards.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Brie Larson Hates Giving Casey Affleck Awards

      Actress has had to do it twice this season - and has not look thrilled

      Esquire
    • Ryan Gosling's Oscars date wasn't Eva Mendes (8 photos)

      When Ryan Gosling showed up at the 2017 Academy Awards — fans around the world were quick to notice the Canadian heartthrob wasn’t with his gorgeous wife, Eva Mendes. Nope. Instead, he was spotted with a beaming blonde in a stunning gold gown. Wondering who his +1 was? Gosling attended the awards show alongside his older sister, Mandi, who is a producer. And turns out, it’s not the first time she’s joined him on the red carpet. Take a look through the gallery to see all the times Ryan’s big sis has joined him on the red carpet, and let us know what you think by tweeting @ YahooStyleCA .

      Yahoo Canada Style
    • This is how badly the Washington Redskins have financially botched things with Kirk Cousins

      If the journey to the next Kirk Cousins contract were a car ride, the Washington Redskins would have sideswiped every parked vehicle on the street by now. The Redskins have internal problems. On Wednesday, he is due – and from all accounts from league sources, about to receive – a franchise tag that will amount to a one-year deal for $23.94 million in 2017.

      Yahoo Sports
    • Another beloved “Game of Thrones” character has died in real life

      Terrible news from the world of Westeros: Neil Fingleton, who played Mag the Mighty on Game of Thrones, died at the age…

      Hello Giggles
    • White House responds to father of Navy SEAL killed in Yemen raid

      White House press secretary Sean Spicer on Monday responded to the father of US Navy SEAL Chief...

      Business Insider
    • Best Oscars Quotes 2017 (11 photos)

      The most memorable words from film's biggest night

      People