The Best BBQ Sauces

Consumer Reports
From Left to Right: Stubb's Original, Archer Farms
Texas Style (Target), Emeril's Original BAM!B-Q
and Great Value Original (Wal-Mart).

Barbecue sauce might remind you of lazy weekends, but tasting sauces was serious business for our trained panelists.

To recognize the varied flavors they might find, tasters first spent three days sampling everything from a tamarind-flavored soft drink to old herbs, from orange marmalade to liquid smoke. They then tasted each of 10 sauces three ways: straight up, on chicken tenders coated in sauce and broiled, and on chicken thighs cooked with sauce in a slow cooker for at least 4 hours. Ratings were based on the toughest test, how the sauces tasted straight up.

The verdict: Five sauces were Very Good overall.

More from ConsumerReports.org: 

How to choose the right BBQ grill

Fourth of July gear

Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers or sponsors on Yahoo!

Taste

The best sauces all have complex flavors, though they tasted somewhat different, as the ratings below show. Stubb's was tangy; Archer Farms and Great Value were smoky; Emeril's had a hint of cumin and celery-seed flavor; and KC Masterpiece was sweet with a lingering spicy heat.

When cooked with meat, most of the sauces became more mellow, and their flavor improved, but not all were equally versatile. Stubbs, for example, tasted best as a condiment or when basted on meat cooked quickly, since it tends to lose flavor during slow cooking. Archer Farms, Great Value, Emeril's, and KC Masterpiece tasted equally good however they were used.

The rest of the sauces were decent but had drawbacks that included an ashy flavor, a gelatinous texture, or excessive sweetness.

Nutrition

Pour with a light hand. Per 2-tablespoon serving, these sauces have 30 to 70 calories, 4 to 16 grams of sugars, and 100 to 460 milligrams of sodium. The good news: They have no fat.

Bottom line

Check the taste comments for the Very Good sauces and choose one that appeals to you. The top three cost more than 20 cents per serving ($3.22 to $3.99 for a 16- or 18-ounce container), but Walmart's Great Value Original is just 8 cents per serving ($1.20 for 18 ounces). High price doesn't mean high quality: The priciest sauce, Bone Suckin', lacked complexity and was extremely sweet.

Consumer Reports Ratings

Very Good :

Stubb's Original
Tangy, spicy, touch of smoke, thinner than most. Best as end-of-cooking baste or condiment.

Archer Farms Texas Style (Target)
Smoky, spicy with lingering heat and a splash of cider vinegar.

Emeril's Original BAM!B-Q
Cumin and celery-seed flavors. Just a bit sweet, a touch of smoke.

• Great Value Original (Wal-Mart)
Very thick, smoky.

KC Masterpiece Original
Very thick, spicy, smoky and quite sweet with lingering heat.

Good :

Bull's Eye Original
Gelatinous texture, ashy flavor. Better cooked than as a condiment.

Sweet Baby Ray's Original
Very thick, gelatinous, with sweet fruity flavor that becomes even sweeter in slow cooking, and lingering heat.

Bone Suckin' Sauce Thicker Style
Sweetest of all, with a tomatoey, fruity and honey flavor with crunchy bits.

Kraft Original
Very thick and gelatinous with ashy flavor. Better in slow cooking than as dip or baste.

Jack Daniel's Original No. 7 Recipe
Gelatinous. Ashy smoke overwhelms much of the flavor. Cooking doesn't help much.

 

 

Copyright © 2006-2011 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Red Bull heir enjoys jet-set life 4 years after hit-and-run

      BANGKOK (AP) — The Ferrari driver who allegedly slammed into a motorcycle cop, dragged him along the road and then sped away from the mangled body took just hours to find, as investigators followed a trail of brake fluid into the gated estate of one of Thailand's richest families.

      Associated Press
    • Reheating Rice Can Give You Food Poisoning If You Don't Do This

      Although reheating takeout when you're too busy to cook is one of life's great pleasures, leftover rice can actually be scarily bad for you, the NHS say. Because if you didn't already know, you can get a pretty grim case of food poisoning from eating reheated rice; it's not the reheating that causes the problem, but instead the way the rice has been stored after being cooked the first time. So uncooked rice often contains spores (cells capable of reproducing quickly) of Bacillus cereus — a bacteria strand that can cause food poisoning — that can survive when rice is cooked. And if the rice is left standing at room temperature after it's been boiled, the spores can grow into bacteria, which will

      House Beautiful q
    • Entertainment Tonight
    • Trump rails against Hillary Clinton in a late-night tweetstorm amid Russia investigation

      President Donald Trump went on a tweetstorm on Monday night, railing against a bipartisan...

      Business Insider
    • United responds to critics after barring 2 teens for leggings

      United Airlines responded to criticism it received on Sunday after it barred two teenage girls from boarding a flight because they were wearing leggings. The story came to light after Shannon Watts, an activist who witnessed the exchange at an airport in Denver, tweeted about it early Sunday. "A @united gate agent isn’t letting girls in leggings get on flight from Denver to Minneapolis because spandex is not allowed?" she wrote on Twitter.

      Good Morning America
    • Homeowner’s son kills three would-be burglars with AR-15

      Three would-be robbers were shot and killed Monday when an Oklahoma homeowner’s son opened fire on them with an AR-15, authorities said. Wagoner County sheriff’s deputies were called to the home in Broken Arrow, southeast of Tulsa at around 12:30 p.m. local time. When they arrived, they found the three dead suspects and two uninjured residents. Sheriff’s spokesman Deputy Nick Mahoney said the suspects enetered the home through a glass back door with the intent to burglarize it. It was not immediately clear why they picked that home. Mahoney said the suspects encountered the homeowner’s 19-year-old son, who opened fire after an exchange of words. Two of the suspects died in the home’s kitchen

      New York Post q
    • Reality Contestants Abandoned in Wilderness After Show Is Canceled

      Last week, the 10 contestants who hadn't quit the show emerged from the 600 acre estate where it was filmed to discover what had happened in the last year, including Brexit, Donald Trump becoming president, and the cancellation of their show.  Being canceled wasn't even Eden's only issue. By September 2016, a third of the contestants had decided to leave, saying they were too hungry, or had been bullied by other contestants, or just that the show was not what they thought it was going to be. (For instance, at one point, some of the men were forming a plan called "Operation C--t" to get the women off the show.) 

      E! Online q
    • Kristin Cavallari Shows Off Her Bikini Body on Vacation with Husband Jay Cutler

      Kristin Cavallari and Jay Cutler jetted off to Mexico for a romantic getaway

      People
    • No One Told These Guys Their Show Was Canceled

      "Hey, guys, guess what? So this isn't gonna air and also Donald Trump is president now!"

      Cosmopolitan
    • The Street q
    • BREAKING: Visual evidence Undertaker doesn’t actually appear out of nowhere

      This is from Raw in Philadelphia tonight: @ryansatin :) pic.twitter.com/3uDxggp01m— MeepMoop™Guy (@VincentMichaels) March 28, 2017 This changes everything. What does the world even mean?

      Cageside Seats q
    • Eminem’s daughter Hailie is all grown up, because time is the weirdest

      If you came of age in the late ’90s or early-aughts, then you heard an Eminem song or two (or 50) in…

      Hello Giggles
    • Baby on Board! 12 Boy Band Members Who Are Reporting for Daddy Duty (12 photos)

      Liam Payne, Louis Tomlinson: Boy Band Members with Babies

      People
    • Here’s a Map of the Sanctuary Cities Jeff Sessions Has Threatened with Funding Losses

      Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced in a press conference Monday that the U.S. government planned actions—most notably the pulling of federal funds—against so-called sanctuary cities and states for undocumented immigrants. The attorney general was reaffirming a longstanding position for the administration of President Donald Trump. In the news conference, Sessions painted a picture of violent criminals on the loose, stating that "countless Americans would be alive today" if it weren't for sanctuary cities and states.

      Newsweek
    • People are freaking out that United told women they couldn't wear leggings on a flight — here's what really happened

      United Airlines refused to let two women board a flight on Sunday because they were wearing...

      Business Insider
    • Reality Show Set in Wilderness Canceled, But No One Tells Contestants for Months

      LONDON – The contestants of a British reality show that marooned them in the wilderness for a year as a social experiment have returned to civilization – only to discover the series was canceled several months ago and no one bothered to tell them. The Channel 4 program, “Eden,” assembled 23 men and women and dispatched... Read more »

      Variety
    • Brad Pitt, Sandra Bullock Are Reportedly Dating

      There are new rumors suggesting that Brad Pitt and Sandra Bullock could be dating.

      International Business Times
    • NASA just captured a photo of Jupiter that you won’t believe is real

      NASA has managed to capture some pretty stunning photos of all the cool stuff they've spotted over the years, and rarely does it fail to amaze. There's images of planet surfaces, the rings of Saturn, and even black holes flying through space totally unchecked . Rarely, however, does a photo look so unreal that at first glance you'd be likely to mistake it for a work of Earthling art. A new photo captured by NASA's Juno spacecraft falls into that category, and oh what a sight it is. The image, originally taken by Juno's "JunoCam" camera, was taken in early February and shows Jupiter's ever-swirling mass of storm clouds from an altitude of roughly 9,000 miles. The storms which continually rock the planet take on a milky appearance when captured up close, and a citizen scientist named Roman Tkachenko took the liberty of enhancing the photo's colors to bring out even more of the defining lines and edges. The Juno craft, packed with all kinds of fancy monitoring equipment, made its fifth flyby of the planet on Monday, which is also the fourth "science orbit," which is the name they give the flybys when all the instruments on board are up and running. The craft's next flyby won't happen until late May 2017, so it's a rare and exciting event when one of these close passes goes by without a hitch. The craft's data is currently being sent to Earth where researchers will continue to mine it for precious information about our solar system's most intimidating planet.

      BGR News
    • Video evidence shows LaVar Ball is worse at basketball than you could ever imagine

      Lonzo Ball must have gotten his basketball genes from his mother. Famous dad LaVar Ball has been telling anyone who’ll listen that he would beat Michael Jordan in a game of 1-on-1. Men lie, women lie, ball don’t — well, now that we have video of LaVar playing, we can safely say that this Ball did lie.

      SB Nation q
    • Sean Hannity Blasts His CBS Interview With Ted Koppel as ‘Fake Edited News’

      Sean Hannity took to Twitter to fire back at a segment on “CBS Sunday Morning,” in which veteran TV journalist Ted Koppel told the Fox News host that he is “bad for America.” Hannity blasted the interview that ran as “fake ‘edited’ news.”

      The Wrap