Baking chocolate taste test

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best baking chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Ghirardelli)

We tried seven varieties of semisweet baking chocolate, putting each to the test in the same basic brownie recipe. Only three chocolate brands pleased our palates.


Chocolate desserts are tremendously popular, and the quality of chocolate used is extremely important, whether it's cookies, brownies, a cake, or hot fudge sauce you're making.

To compare the merits of commonly available semisweet baking chocolates, we selected seven brands and baked a batch of brownies with each, using the same Ultimate Brownie recipe. This way we could fully assess which brands performed best.

What were we looking for? Baking chocolate that produces a brownie with rich flavor and incredibly moist texture—no bad aftertaste, no chalky dryness. In other words, addictively good results.


Best Baking Chocolate

Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar ($2.70)


Pros: This made for a moist, fudgy brownie. "It has a good chew, and a nice shattering crust that I associate with brownies," stated one editor.

Cons: Had an unappetizing and deceiving dry look.


(See more: Cheddar cheese taste test)


View gallery

.
Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block

(Photo: Courtesy of Callebaut)

First Runner-Up

Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block ($8.99 per pound)

Pros: Tasters liked this chocolate because it made a cakier, lighter brownie. One editor said, "It has the richest chocolate flavor of them all!"

Cons: Most expensive of the bunch.












Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Kraft Brands)

Second Runner-Up

Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate ($2.99)

Pros: "The smell is to die for," stated one editor. All agreed this brownie was so rich that it almost looked and tasted like ganache.

Cons: Some found this brownie too sweet.




View gallery

.
Nói Síríus

(Photo: Courtesy of noi.is/English)

The Other Contenders

Hershey's makes a favorite chocolate for snacking, but when it comes to baking chocolate, this brand produced a pale and bland-tasting brownie. Scharffen Berger's baking chocolate was surprisingly disappointing as well. It made a beautifully dark, fudgy-looking brownie with a smooth top, but the texture was chalky and the taste muddy.

The Dagoba-made brownie had a crumbly texture, and even tasted "powdery," said one tester.

Nói Síríus stood out for its original and simple packaging, though the taste of this brownie came up short: It looked gooey and fudgy—to a fault—yet was missing an oomph of chocolate. All four brands' brownies would have been better with a scoop of ice cream.



Additional Taste Test Details

All seven types of semisweet baking chocolate evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar, Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block, Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate, Hershey's Baking Chocolate, Scharffen Berger's Semisweet Dark Chocolate Baking Bar, Dagoba Organic Semisweet chocolate for baking, Nói Síríus 45 percent Semi-Sweet Pure Icelandic Chocolate.


Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of the same Ultimate Brownie recipe made with seven types of semisweet baking chocolate bars. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).




More at Epicurious:

Top 12 Cold-Weather Soups

Healthy Comfort Recipes for Any Day 

Edible Holiday Gifts to Make vs Buy

Favorite Casserole Recipes

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • People
    • Japan's sex problem is so bad that people are quitting dating and marrying their friends

      The Japanese sex problem has become so desperate that its young population are giving up on dating and are just marrying their friends. A Government survey found 69 per cent of Japanese men and 59 per cent of Japanese women do not have a romantic partner. One Japanese aggregator website has since been awash with stories of how people have simply got married to life-long friends. The country has one of the lowest birth rates in the world, with just 8.4 children being born per 1,000 inhabitants over the last five years. Its population of 127m people is predicted to decrease to 87m by 2060. The survey, carried out by the country’s National Institute of Population and Social Security Research, also

      Business Insider q
    • Obamacare is 'entering a death spiral,' Paul Ryan says

      Ryan and his House GOP colleagues have tried numerous times to repeal the law but were never able to during Obama's tenure.

      CNBC
    • ‘This Is Us’ Fans Shocked by ‘Shocking’ Fall Finale

      On the midseason finale of This Is Us, Toby surprised Kate by flying across the country to declare his love for her during a Christmas party. "I can live without pizza and cookies and potato chips and whatever that brownie thing was that they were serving on the plane," Toby said. "The one thing I cannot live without, is you." After that speech, Toby and Kate snuck away to express their feelings without their clothes on, but when they were done, it was clear something was wrong. Toby was breathing heavily, and then later, he collapsed, presumably from a heart attack. Fans of the show took to Twitter to express their concern for Toby. Destinee Chrystal wrote "I'm going to be so upset if Toby dies. This is the worst cliffhanger ever," and KayKay tweeted "It took me 6 minutes to process that ending. All I know is Toby better be alive on January 10th."

      Superfan TV
    • The 62 Most Delish Taco Recipes (63 photos)

      Find how to make these creative and totally inspired tacos. From Delish

      Delish
    • The Messy Truth About Van Jones

      They never learn. The grand journalism pooh-bahs at CNN were humiliated this election cycle when WikiLeaks revealed that former CNN contributor and interim DNC chair Donna Brazile had shared a question with the Hillary Clinton campaign in advance of a March Democratic primary town hall debate. According to CNN, "activist anchor" Roland Martin and his production team at CNN's debate partner and identity politics network TV One were responsible for the leak. CNN host Jake Tapper called the episode "very, very troubling" and condemned the breach: "Journalistically, it's horrifying," he told WMAL radio. CNN president Jeff Zucker declared after an internal investigation that the network "would not

      CNS News q
    • It's Not Lea Michele's Swimsuit That'll Catch Your Eye — It's What She's Wearing With It

      A few days after Lea Michele attended Glee costar Becca Tobin's wedding, the actress traded in her Winter coat for a swimsuit. Lea was snapped on the beach wearing a cobalt blue one-piece, but it wasn't the bathing suit that caught our eyes first. It was actually her multicolored sarong, which she expertly tied to her waist. While some accessorize with body chains at the beach, Lea reminded us just how stylish and flattering a sarong can be. The piece served as a breezy, eye-catching skirt as the star posed to show off the side of her leg. Most of us won't be experiencing beach-weather temps for quite a while, but we're still ready to shop some viable, Lea-inspired swim and sarong options — for

      PopSugar q
    • Dana White Explains Why Chuck Liddell and Matt Hughes Were Fired from UFC

      After purchase, it's typical for a number of employee positions and business expenses to be eradicated. UFC president Dana White said that's exactly what's happening within the fight promotion since its sale for $4 billion in July. “When another company takes over another company, it's absolutely normal for them to come in and, especially at the executive level, let guys go at the executive level.

      MMA Weekly
    • TV Host with Breast Cancer Forced to Remove Wig as Part of ‘Horrific’ TSA Body Search

      Denise Albert, the co-founder of The MOMS, is speaking out after what she calls an “horrific” pat down from Transportation Security Administration (TSA) agents at the Los Angeles International Airport on Sunday — all over medication related to her breast cancer treatment. “I don’t know what was different this time but TSA agents aggressively attempted to do a body cavity search in public,” said Albert in the post. “I was TSA precheck and once through the scanner they asked me to take off my shoes.

      People
    • 12 Secrets Costco Shoppers Need to Know

      Stu pendousmat via Wikimedia Commons A Costco membership opens doors, quite literally, to a vast selection of bulk-size groceries and household goods selling at discounted prices. But buying potato chips ...

      Kiplinger
    • 22 heavily armed men post mannequin challenge on Facebook, much to delight of cops

      In the video, they were all clutching firearms of various caliber. Pistols and shotguns hung frozen in the air, their blunt ends aimed at various persons, who remained as still as, well, mannequins. One man was prostrate under the back of a car, as if for cover, the barrel of his shotgun peeking out. Another hid behind a plastic trashcan, flimsy protection if this were a real battle. From one angle, it appeared to be a Madame Tussauds wax museum exhibit — a re-eneacted modern-day gunfight in rural Alabama involving at least 19 guns and 22 young men, frozen in time, scored by the pulsating beat of pounding rap music. It was a version, albeit an edgy and ultimately inadvisable one, of the mannequin

      Washington Post q
    • Lexi Thompson Is Playing from the Same Tees as the Men This Week. Let's Not All Freak Out

      Lexi Thompson is the only woman in the Franklin Templeton Shootout field this week, and she'll play the same tees as the men. Touting this event as some kind of tricked-up Battle of the Sexes would be insulting not only to Thompson's ability but also to the caliber of elite female golfers in general. Thompson finished the 2016 LPGA season second in driving distance at 277.40 yards, which was longer than 26 players' driving distance on the PGA Tour in the 2015-16 season.

      Golf
    • Coco Austin and Ice-T Throw Baby Chanel a 1st Birthday Party With Cute Mother-Daughter Outfit Changes

      The couple's baby donned Minnie Mouse and Cinderella-inspired outfits.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Woman shuts down saleswoman who called her $130 engagement ring 'pathetic'

      When it comes to love, it's not about the money. Quinn and Ariel McRae dated for two years before tying the knot. But a saleswoman where the couple bought Ariel's rings tried to put a damper on the festivities by calling the jewelry "pathetic." "My husband doesn't have a lot, neither of us do," McRae explained in a Facebook post about the encounter. "We scrape and scrape to pay bills and put food in our bellies, but after almost 2 years of dating we decided that we couldn't wait anymore, so we didn't." "I wasn't even thinking about rings, I just wanted to marry my best friend," she continued, "But he wouldn't have it. He scraped up just enough money to buy me two matching rings from Pandora." The two headed to the store and picked out a pair of rings they could afford — two rings for $130. SEE ALSO: Little boy proposes to his classmate with his mom's diamond ring McRae was was thrilled to get her rings, and then, the couple encountered a saleswoman. "While we were purchasing my rings... another lady that was working there came over to help the lady selling them to us," she wrote. "She said, 'Y'all, can you believe that some men get these as engagement rings? How pathetic.'" "I watched my now husband's face fall," she continued. Quinn was already upset that he couldn't his fiancé a more expensive ring, so the saleswoman's words crushed him. "He was so upset at the idea of not making me happy enough and of me not wanting to marry him because my rings didn't cost enough money or weren't flashy enough," she explained. "Y'all I would have gotten married to this man if it had been a 25¢ gum ball machine ring" she proudly posted. "When did our nation fall so far to think the only way a man can truly love a woman is if he buys her $3,000+ jewelry and makes a public decree of his affection with said flashy ring?" McRae quickly shot down the pretentious saleswoman, calmly saying, "It isn't the ring that matters, it is the love that goes into buying one that is." "My husband was so afraid of me not wanting him because he couldn't afford a piece of jewelry," she posted. "But here I am though, courthouse married, $130 ring set, the love of my life by my side and happier than I could ever imagine." Looks like this marriage is off to a pretty perfect start. Mashable reached out to McRae for a comment, and will update the story when she replies. BONUS: Tom Hanks photobombed a wedding photoshoot in gym shorts

      Mashable
    • Ukraine offers Trump own jet after Air Force One flap

      Ukraine's main plane maker told US President-elect Donald Trump on Wednesday that he may want to purchase one of its jets after he called Boeing's version of Air Force One too costly. "@realDonaldTrump May be it is better to consider #Antonov aircraft as Air Force One?" the plane maker asked. Trump tweeted on Tuesday that "Boeing is building a brand new 747 Air Force One for future presidents, but costs are out of control, more than $4 billion.

      AFP
    • Theories About What May Have Happened To Sherri Papini

      Shasta County police have so far found no leads that could shed light on the motive behind the California mother's kidnapping.

      International Business Times
    • Becker criticises Djokovic following split

      Novak Djokovic failed to train hard enough and will not regain the top world ranking unless he "puts in the hours", former coach Boris Becker says, after the pair split. Djokovic has won 12 Grand Slam titles -- six under Becker -- but on Tuesday the Serb confirmed rumours that he and the German legend had parted ways after three years together. "He has not spent as much time on the practice court as he should have in the last six months and he knows that," Becker, 49, told Sky Sports News.

      AFP
    • Constant Gym-Goer Ditched Her Cardio Workouts for Powerlifting and Lost 37 Lbs.

      For years, Alice Fields was a cardio queen, who would toil away on the treadmill in the hopes of slimming down. Fields tried this weight loss method unsuccessfully for around five years, and says she “felt trapped in my own body,” until a friend introduced her to powerlifting 18 months ago. “Not only had my strength increased dramatically, but my whole body composition changed.

      People
    • 'Star Wars' Actress Daisy Ridley Would 'Love to See the Look on People's Faces' When They Find Out About Rey

      Daisy Ridley thinks it’s “quite funny” that people keep asking her who Rey’s parents are — and has hinted that it might not be as big a mystery as everyone thinks. In an interview with Time Out London, the Star Wars: The Force Awakens star, who also narrated the documentary The Eagle Huntress (now in theaters), had a surprising take on the question that has been baffling Star Wars fans for the past year. “I thought a lot was answered in The Force Awakens,” Ridley told the magazine.

      Yahoo Movies
    • A Facebook executive says fasting for 15 hours a day changed his life — here's his daily routine

      In 2014, Dan Zigmond, director of analytics at Facebook, lost more than 20 pounds in less than a...

      Business Insider