Baking chocolate taste test

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best baking chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Ghirardelli)

We tried seven varieties of semisweet baking chocolate, putting each to the test in the same basic brownie recipe. Only three chocolate brands pleased our palates.


Chocolate desserts are tremendously popular, and the quality of chocolate used is extremely important, whether it's cookies, brownies, a cake, or hot fudge sauce you're making.

To compare the merits of commonly available semisweet baking chocolates, we selected seven brands and baked a batch of brownies with each, using the same Ultimate Brownie recipe. This way we could fully assess which brands performed best.

What were we looking for? Baking chocolate that produces a brownie with rich flavor and incredibly moist texture—no bad aftertaste, no chalky dryness. In other words, addictively good results.


Best Baking Chocolate

Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar ($2.70)


Pros: This made for a moist, fudgy brownie. "It has a good chew, and a nice shattering crust that I associate with brownies," stated one editor.

Cons: Had an unappetizing and deceiving dry look.


(See more: Cheddar cheese taste test)


View gallery

.
Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block

(Photo: Courtesy of Callebaut)

First Runner-Up

Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block ($8.99 per pound)

Pros: Tasters liked this chocolate because it made a cakier, lighter brownie. One editor said, "It has the richest chocolate flavor of them all!"

Cons: Most expensive of the bunch.












Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Kraft Brands)

Second Runner-Up

Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate ($2.99)

Pros: "The smell is to die for," stated one editor. All agreed this brownie was so rich that it almost looked and tasted like ganache.

Cons: Some found this brownie too sweet.




View gallery

.
Nói Síríus

(Photo: Courtesy of noi.is/English)

The Other Contenders

Hershey's makes a favorite chocolate for snacking, but when it comes to baking chocolate, this brand produced a pale and bland-tasting brownie. Scharffen Berger's baking chocolate was surprisingly disappointing as well. It made a beautifully dark, fudgy-looking brownie with a smooth top, but the texture was chalky and the taste muddy.

The Dagoba-made brownie had a crumbly texture, and even tasted "powdery," said one tester.

Nói Síríus stood out for its original and simple packaging, though the taste of this brownie came up short: It looked gooey and fudgy—to a fault—yet was missing an oomph of chocolate. All four brands' brownies would have been better with a scoop of ice cream.



Additional Taste Test Details

All seven types of semisweet baking chocolate evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar, Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block, Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate, Hershey's Baking Chocolate, Scharffen Berger's Semisweet Dark Chocolate Baking Bar, Dagoba Organic Semisweet chocolate for baking, Nói Síríus 45 percent Semi-Sweet Pure Icelandic Chocolate.


Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of the same Ultimate Brownie recipe made with seven types of semisweet baking chocolate bars. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).




More at Epicurious:

Top 12 Cold-Weather Soups

Healthy Comfort Recipes for Any Day 

Edible Holiday Gifts to Make vs Buy

Favorite Casserole Recipes

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Everything Aaron and Jordan Rodgers Have Said About Their Family Feud

      Quarterback Aaron Rodgers may have led the Green Bay Packers to a narrow victory during Sunday night’s playoff game against the Dallas Cowboys, but his family did not share in the celebration. According to a new interview with The New York Times published Sunday, Ed Rodgers confirmed that he’s not on speaking terms with his son following the 32-year-old NFL star’s rise in popularity. Word of the family’s rift became public knowledge last spring when the quarterback’s younger brother Jordan appeared on JoJo Fletcher‘s season of The Bachelorette.

      People
    • Pictures of Mcdonald's new Big Macs are already sweeping the internet

      People across the country are already stumbling across McDonald's (MCD) all new Big Macs, which were originally unveiled last November and scheduled for an early 2017 launch.  The Grand Mac, which rests on a larger sesame seed bun, is made with two beef patties that weigh in at one-third of a pound compared to a traditional Big Mac, which has two, 1.6-ounce beef patties. Think of this one as a supersized Big Mac. The Mac Jr. is a essentially a single-layer Big Mac, which may be more ideal for the hands of kids (great news, right?).  Each sandwich has the traditional Big Mac sauce.  McDonald's started testing the Grand Mac and Mac Jr. in more than 120 restaurants in the central Ohio and Dallas

      The Street q
    • How Much Money Does the Average American Have in Their Bank Account?

      Curious as to whether you're keeping up with the Joneses? Here's how much the average American has in their bank account and savings account.

      The Cheat Sheet q 9 min ago
    • 'Nature at its best:' Giant gator spotted at Florida nature center

      Floridians have seen their share of giant alligators, but usually not like this.

      WPVI – Philadelphia
    • Pakistani mother sentenced to death for daughter's 'honour killing'

      A mother who murdered her own daughter and set her alight for marrying the man of her choice has been sentenced to death, officials said Tuesday, in a case that had revolted many in Pakistan. Zeenat Bibi, aged 16, was doused with kerosene and set alight in June last year in Pakistan's teeming cultural capital Lahore, a little over a week after she wed 20-year-old motorcycle mechanic Hasan Khan against her family's wishes. A judge in an anti-terror court in Lahore sentenced her mother Perveen Bibi to death on murder and terrorism charges, prosecutor Mian Mohammad Tufail told AFP.

      AFP
    • Mayor quits golf club as members try to block Obama's entry

      The local mayor and member of the exclusive Maryland country club whose members are preemptively trying to keep President Obama out over his stance on Israel announced that he was dropping out over the controversy. Jeffrey Slavin, the mayor of the Montgomery County town of  Somerset, said he could no longer belong to a community at Woodmont Country Club with such “intolerance,” The New York Post reported. The Washington Post reported that some members of the historically Jewish club were bothered by Obama’s recent decision not to vote on a U.N. resolution criticizing Israeli settlements. “[President Obama] has created a situation in the world where Israel’s very existence is weakened and possibly

      Fox News q
    • Aly Raisman and Simone Biles Are Redefining the 2017 SI Swimsuit Issue

      After stunning the world at the Rio Olympics last Summer, gold-medal gymnasts Aly Raisman and Simone Biles are back and better than ever, continuing their pursuit of blowing our minds, this time on the cover of the 2017 Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue. The girls are taking the modeling world by storm, and we think they are the perfect candidates for this year's famed issue. "Aly and Simone represent all that is beautiful and strong and inspiring in women today," said MJ Day, SI Swimsuit Issue editor. "Women that are not only elite athletes, that are captivating and impressive in their own professional accomplishments (lots and lots of Olympic gold medals between them), but strikingly sexy and

      PopSugar q
    • Authorities: Trooper was shot by driver who caused rollover

      PHOENIX (AP) — An Arizona state trooper who was beaten and shot while responding to a traffic collision on Interstate 10 was attacked by a Mexican man who was responsible for the one-vehicle rollover, authorities said.

      Associated Press
    • Massive Alligator Strolls Casually Past Florida Tourists

      Video shows the gator without a care in the world.

      Inside Edition
    • Aaron Rodgers Hasn't Spoken to His Family in 2 Years, Father Confirms

      In a New York Times story about the family rift, the NFL star's dad, Ed Rodgers, said the family hasn't spoken to the Green Bay quarterback since the end of 2014. The public first became aware of a rift in the Rodgers family when Aaron's younger brother, Jordan, appeared as a contestant on ABC's reality show "The Bachelorette" last summer. Before Jordan brought the show's star JoJo Fletcher to his Chico, California, hometown to meet his family, he told her that Aaron would not be there, explaining that he had chosen to distance himself from his family.

      Good Morning America
    • Last Night’s Look: Love It or Leave It? 1/16/2017 (13 photos)

      See the best red carpet looks from this week

      People
    • Adriana Lima Hits Patriots Game ... Joins Insanely Hot Group of Wives & GFs (PHOTOS)

      Julian Edelman's quasi-girlfriend, Adriana Lima, attended her first Patriots playoffs game this weekend ... and fit right in with the ridiculously good lookin' group of W.A.G.s.  First, the Edelman-Lima situation (or EdeLima) ... our sources tell us they're still dating but it's more casual than serious.  As one source put, "When they can see each other, they do. But it's not very often." Still, they're tight enough that she went to the Pats vs. Texans game at Foxborough this weekend ... joining other wives and girlfriends like Kristen Rorie (Tyler Gaffney's GF), Ciera Liguori (D.J. Foster's GF), Camille Kostek (Gronk's GF) and Siggi Bennett (Martellus Bennett's wife).  And that doesn't even

      TMZ q
    • Peta Murgatroyd Bra Selfie Reminds Us Post-Baby Body Expectations Are Ridiculous

      The “post-baby body” obsession has, unfortunately, seemingly taken over our culture. Instead of marveling at the fact that women bring forth life from…

      Hello Giggles
    • Connecticut Politician Arrested for Groping a Woman After a Disagreement

      Connecticut Republican politician Christopher von Keyserling was having a political disagreement with a female colleague when the unnamed 57-year-old woman said to him that we’re living in a “a new world,” politically speaking. To that, the 71-year-old member of the representative town meeting and an outspoken commentator on town affairs allegedly responded, “I love this new world, I no longer have to be politically correct,” according to an arrest warrant, says Time.

      Yahoo Style
    • Guatemala says US can't deport millions of migrants

      The United States "doesn't have the luxury" of deporting millions of undocumented migrants as President-elect Donald Trump has threatened, Guatemala's president argued Monday. "Economically, the United States doesn't have the luxury of throwing out 12 million inhabitants or people who are on its territory without papers given that they produce, consume and contribute to GDP growth in that country," President Jimmy Morales told Guatemalan radio station Emisoras Unidas. Trump, who takes over from Barack Obama on Friday with a Republican legislative majority, has sent chills through nearby Latin American countries, including Guatemala, with his repeated vows to expel millions of migrants without residency papers.

      AFP
    • Tom Brady Responded To Antonio Brown Posting Mike Tomlin's 'A**holes' Speech On Facebook

      Only historians will ever be able to properly place Antonio Brown’s Facebook Live video into proper context. Well, Steelers coach Mike Tomlin was the victim of Brown’s odd choice, and now the world knows his secret — he doesn’t like the Patriots, who are the Steelers’ opponent in the AFC Championship Game this Sunday.

      UPROXX
    • Kourtney Kardashian Steps Out with Justin Bieber — But ‘Is Still Serious About Making Things Work with Scott’: Source

      Kourtney Kardashian may have been spotted hitting the town with ex-fling Justin Bieber over the weekend — but the two are now just friends, a source tells PEOPLE. Bieber and Kardashian stopped by West Hollywood hotspot The Peppermint Club on Saturday night, shortly after the reality star left a birthday celebration for Jessica Alba‘s husband Cash Warren. According to a Kardashian source, she and Bieber “hung out together with friends, but didn’t spend the night together.

      People
    • America’s Average IRA Balance Is Anemic: How Do You Stack Up?

      The average retirement account ended 2016 with a lackluster balance, judging by Fidelity Investments’ latest quarterly analysis of individual retirement accounts and 401(k) accounts. Fidelity administers investment accounts that are collectively worth more than $5 trillion. The average balance in IRAs administered by Fidelity was $94,100.

      Money Talks News
    • Aaron Rodgers’s Family Finally Speaks Out About Estrangement

      On last season’s The Bachelorette, viewers were let in on Rodgers family secrets. Winner Jordan Rodgers is the younger brother of NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers. Jordan let his now fiancé, JoJo Fletcher, in on the fact that Aaron has not spoken to their family in years.

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • Ciara Posts Family Picture After Cheeky Move From Ex Future

      Singer Ciara just clapped back at her ex, Future, after the latter showed up during her husband Russell Wilson's game.

      International Business Times