Baking chocolate taste test

Epicurious

View gallery

.
Best baking chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Ghirardelli)

We tried seven varieties of semisweet baking chocolate, putting each to the test in the same basic brownie recipe. Only three chocolate brands pleased our palates.


Chocolate desserts are tremendously popular, and the quality of chocolate used is extremely important, whether it's cookies, brownies, a cake, or hot fudge sauce you're making.

To compare the merits of commonly available semisweet baking chocolates, we selected seven brands and baked a batch of brownies with each, using the same Ultimate Brownie recipe. This way we could fully assess which brands performed best.

What were we looking for? Baking chocolate that produces a brownie with rich flavor and incredibly moist texture—no bad aftertaste, no chalky dryness. In other words, addictively good results.


Best Baking Chocolate

Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar ($2.70)


Pros: This made for a moist, fudgy brownie. "It has a good chew, and a nice shattering crust that I associate with brownies," stated one editor.

Cons: Had an unappetizing and deceiving dry look.


(See more: Cheddar cheese taste test)


View gallery

.
Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block

(Photo: Courtesy of Callebaut)

First Runner-Up

Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block ($8.99 per pound)

Pros: Tasters liked this chocolate because it made a cakier, lighter brownie. One editor said, "It has the richest chocolate flavor of them all!"

Cons: Most expensive of the bunch.












Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate

(Photo: Courtesy of Kraft Brands)

Second Runner-Up

Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate ($2.99)

Pros: "The smell is to die for," stated one editor. All agreed this brownie was so rich that it almost looked and tasted like ganache.

Cons: Some found this brownie too sweet.




View gallery

.
Nói Síríus

(Photo: Courtesy of noi.is/English)

The Other Contenders

Hershey's makes a favorite chocolate for snacking, but when it comes to baking chocolate, this brand produced a pale and bland-tasting brownie. Scharffen Berger's baking chocolate was surprisingly disappointing as well. It made a beautifully dark, fudgy-looking brownie with a smooth top, but the texture was chalky and the taste muddy.

The Dagoba-made brownie had a crumbly texture, and even tasted "powdery," said one tester.

Nói Síríus stood out for its original and simple packaging, though the taste of this brownie came up short: It looked gooey and fudgy—to a fault—yet was missing an oomph of chocolate. All four brands' brownies would have been better with a scoop of ice cream.



Additional Taste Test Details

All seven types of semisweet baking chocolate evaluated are available nationwide in supermarkets or online. Listed from highest to lowest score achieved, they are: Ghirardelli Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bar, Callebaut Semi-Sweet Chocolate Block, Baker's Semi-Sweet All Purpose Baking Chocolate, Hershey's Baking Chocolate, Scharffen Berger's Semisweet Dark Chocolate Baking Bar, Dagoba Organic Semisweet chocolate for baking, Nói Síríus 45 percent Semi-Sweet Pure Icelandic Chocolate.


Methodology: In a blind taste test, judges compared the flavor, consistency, and appearance of the same Ultimate Brownie recipe made with seven types of semisweet baking chocolate bars. Results were ranked using the Epicurious four-fork rating system (four being best).




More at Epicurious:

Top 12 Cold-Weather Soups

Healthy Comfort Recipes for Any Day 

Edible Holiday Gifts to Make vs Buy

Favorite Casserole Recipes

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Aaron Hernandez Left Multiple Suicide Notes: Report

      The notes were written to his fiancée, his daughter and a close prison friend.

      International Business Times
    • Burt Reynolds makes rare public appearance at film festival

      NEW YORK (AP) — Robert De Niro helped Burt Reynolds onto the red carpet for the Tribeca Film Festival premiere of his new movie "Dog Years" Saturday night in New York. It was a rare appearance for the 81-year old actor, who at times struggled to walk.

      Associated Press
    • Michael Moore’s Prediction for Trump’s Impeachment Will Depress a Lot of People

      Michael Moore, a political prophet for our modern times, loves to predict things about Donald Trump. He thinks the new U.S. President is going to get everyone killed; he believes Trump will absolutely build a border wall and ban all Muslims. (Lest we forget, Moore also wrote a prescient essay that predicted Trump would win.) Anyhow, Moore is back on the offensive and predicting another pressing matter on the minds of many citizens, specifically, when will Trump get impeached and kicked out of the White House for good? For those looking for an optimistic answer, you’re not going to love his thoughts. “I would say some time in the middle of his second term,” he explained at a Tribeca Film Festival

      Vulture q
    • Eating disorder survivor bares her stomach rolls on Instagram as part of recovery

      Clare has posted a slew of revealing belly snaps to her Instagram account since joining. An eating disorder survivor has taken to Instagram to courageously bare her stomach rolls, as part of her commitment toward recovery and self-love. Clare, known as Becoming Body Positive on Instagram, has posted a slew of revealing belly snaps to her account since joining in December 2016.

      Yahoo Canada Style
    • Nintendo’s NES Classic will be available at Best Buy stores tomorrow morning

      The NES Classic is officially discontinued, and Nintendo has said that the final shipments of the mini-console are reaching stores this month. Best Buy has announced that the NES Classic Edition will be available at its stores (not online) at start of business tomorrow. A Best Buy spokesperson said that the NES Classic will be sold on a first-come, first-served basis.

      The Verge q
    • I Let My Daughter Transition at 4 Years Old — And Have Zero Regrets Today

      Kai did not choose this haircut, but she put on a smile anyway. By the time Kai was 3 1/2 years old, I couldn't ignore it anymore. She was verbalizing that she was a girl at least six times a day. Everything was: "I'm a princess" and "I'm a girl." Every time she'd say something like that, I'd get down on her level and firmly say, "No, you're a boy." It never worked. She would correct me by waiting until I was in the middle of something and unable to chase her around, then run into the room and yell, "I'm a girl!" and run out again. I did everything I could think of to cut off that kind of talk. There were time-outs, so many time-outs. There were spankings and yelling matches and endless prayers.

      ELLE q
    • Illinois college student killed in freak accident during track and field meet

      WHEATON, Ill. –  A college student was killed on Saturday during a track and field meet in suburban Chicago. Friends gathered at a vigil at Wheaton College in Wheaton, Ill.  said the student was named Ethan Roser.  They said Roser was killed during a track and field event hosted by Wheaton College on Saturday afternoon. Witnesses said Roser was hit in the head with a "hammer," which is a heavy metal ball attached to a thin wire. In men's events, the hammer weighs 16 pounds. In women's, it weighs almost 9 pounds. It is not clear which type of hammer was involved in the tragic accident. Friends said that Roser was a freshman on the soccer team. He was volunteering at the meet.

      Fox News q
    • Ariel Winter gave the LBD a sparkly, sheer update, and we’re obsessed

      Honestly, it is hard to keep up with all of Ariel Winter’s looks. She is constantly serving glam and making us all…

      Hello Giggles
    • Ron Howard, Henry Winkler Mourn Death of ‘Happy Days’ Costar Erin Moran

      “OH Erin… now you will finally have the peace you wanted so badly here on earth …Rest In It serenely now.. too soon,” tweeted Henry Winkler, who most know as The Fonz. Moran’s big brother on the show, Ron Howard, also expressed his grief over her passing, writing, “Such sad sad news.

      The Wrap
    • Man who made his living killing African wildlife gets eaten by African wildlife

      Scott Van Zyl made his living taking wealthy clients on "safaris" for the sole purpose of bringing home trophies like leopards, zebras, wildebeests and even lions. Now, investigators in Zimbabwe believe that Van Zyl ended up on the wrong end of the predator-prey relationship, and DNA tests have confirmed that he was attacked, killed, and eaten by crocodiles while on a hunting trip. Van Zyl, who ran SS Pro Safaris, offered specials for hunters to spend a week or more on his hunting lands which border nature preserves, with the promise of killing up to seven different species for $9,000. He also offered other hunting expeditions with targets like elephants and giraffes, though specifics for those, including prices, aren't listed on the company's site. Photos of clients holding the bodies of several rare species are posted on Van Zyl's site, along with the motto "Stop whining, go hunting." The circumstances surrounding his death are spotty, but reports suggest that Van Zyl and a second hunter and a pack of dogs. The two men split up, choosing to travel on foot alone, but when the dogs returned to the base camp without Van Zyl, his companion knew something was wrong. His footprints were tracked to a riverbank where searchers found his backpack as well as several large Nile crocodiles. Authorities killed the crocs after getting clearance to do so and subsequently discovered human remains inside the stomach of one of them. Tests of the remains matched Van Zyl. The incident is just one of a handful of fatal crocodile attacks tallied so far in 2017 alone.

      BGR News
    • District attorney: Aaron Hernandez left multiple suicide notes in jail cell

      In the hours after Aaron Hernandez committed suicide Wednesday , authorities in Massachusetts said that the former Patriots tight end didn't leave any type of note before killing himself. However, after further investigation, it turns out that's not the case.  Worcester County district attorney Joseph D. Early Jr. revealed this week that Hernandez actually left three suicide notes and a bible in the prison cell where he was found dead.  In a statement, Early also noted that Hernandez's death at the Souza-Baranowski Correction Center had officially been ruled a suicide and that the cause of death was asphyxia by hanging.  Hernandez's lawyer, Jose Baez, and former agent, Brian Murphy, had both

      CBS Sports q
    • Conjoined Twins Refuse to Be Separated Despite Doctor's Warnings

      Conjoined Twins Refuse to Be Separated Despite Doctor's Warnings

      People
    • 2 major new polls show Trump will conclude his first 100 days as the least popular president in modern history

      President Donald Trump set another record low approval rating as he concludes his first 100 days...

      Business Insider
    • American Airlines apologizes for onboard clash over stroller

      American Airlines on Saturday apologized to a female passenger and suspended an employee after a video showing an onboard clash over a baby stroller went viral, in the latest embarassment for a U.S. carrier over how it treated a customer. The clip, posted to Facebook on Friday by a bystander on the flight, shows a woman in tears with a young child in her arms, and a man emerging from his seat to confront a male flight attendant. Facebook user Surain Adyanthaya, who put the video on his page, said in his post that the flight attendant had forcefully taken the stroller from the woman, hitting her with it and just missing her child.

      Reuters
    • Dowd: New poll is 'good news, bad news, really bad news' for Trump

      The Powerhouse Roundtable debates President Trump's progress as we approach 100 days in office.

      ABC News Videos
    • CNN Anchor Alisyn Camerota Says She Was Sexually Harassed by Roger Ailes

      “Yes, Roger Ailes did sexually harass me,” Camerota said on CNN's 'Reliable Sources.'

      The Hollywood Reporter
    • The Wizards of Waverly Place Cast: Where Are They Now? (6 photos)

      The Wizards of Waverly Place Cast: Where Are They Now?

      People
    • Ron Howard Reacts To Erin Moran's Death

      Erin Moran died in Indiana on Saturday at the age of 56.

      International Business Times
    • Australia, New Zealand hit back at North Korea threat

      Australia and New Zealand stiffened their rhetoric against North Korea Sunday after the isolated state threatened Canberra with a nuclear strike, urging it to think twice before "blindly and zealously toeing the US line". The move comes as US Vice President Mike Pence wraps up an Asia tour, which has included visits to South Korea, Japan and Australia partly to reassure allies amid fears that Pyongyang may be readying for a sixth nuclear test. "If Australia persists in following the US' moves to isolate and stifle North Korea... this will be a suicidal act," a North Korean foreign ministry spokesman said after Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop called the hermit state a "serious threat".

      AFP
    • Man Attacked by 2 Dogs While Trying to Protect His Jack Russell Terrier

      A caught-on-video attack by two dogs on Catalina Island this week left a Huntington Beach man in the hospital and his Jack Russell terrier seriously injured.

      Tribune