Digital Crave

Why DVD Still Makes Sense

Digital Crave

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Is there a certain film that, if you come across it flipping channels randomly, you feel compelled to watch no matter what? Even though you've seen it roughly 34,000 times? Even if it's just the last half hour of the movie? Even if it's on the Spanish language station?

I have a theory about these films — I call them comfort movies. They're familiar and soothing, and you can watch them again and again in the same way that you listen to old favorite records. For instance, anytime The Hunt for Red October is broadcast on basic cable (according to my rough calculations, about once every 9.4 hours), I must watch that movie. It might be a submarine movie thing, because the same happens with Crimson Tide and The Abyss.

Evidently, I find underwater drama soothing, for reasons I probably don't want to know. I suppose I could pay a therapist $120/hour to find out, but I suspect no good news can possibly come of that.

Comfort movies and DVD

I review movies and DVDs for a living, so I have copies of all these films on a shelf somewhere. For me, they really are like old records, and knowing that I have a physical copy of them really is a comfort. Because I've learned the hard way: If you're relying on digital download and on-demand services for your movies these days, you might literally not know what you're missing.

As with music, movies are slowly but surely "going digital." Increasingly viable digital distribution — via iTunes or Netflix or your local cable provider — prompts the question: Why even bother anymore with DVD, or its posh cousin the Blu-ray disc?

Well, I'll tell you. I spend an alarming amount of time watching films and TV series collections on home video, and as such have given this matter an inordinate amount of thought. Here are some of the reasons to stick with DVD and Blu-ray in an increasingly downloadable world....

DVD Extras: Digital versions of movie titles never have the full suite of extras you get on the DVD or Blu-ray. In fact, many don't have any extras at all. This is on purpose, of course — it's one of ways Hollywood is trying to prop up DVD sales and rentals.

For those of us who value the behind-the-scenes details of a movie — the making-of docs, deleted scenes, alternate endings and gag reels — this is a dealbreaker on certain titles.

Some films, particularly historical epics or based-on-a-true-story movies, are genuinely enhanced by extras material which provide factual context in the form of documentaries or expert interviews. For instance, when director Robert Redford's underrated 2010 historical drama The Conspirator came out on DVD, it included a full-length documentary on the Lincoln assassination. Watching them both together made for a fascinating home video double feature.

For blockbuster popcorn movies, particularly effects-heavy action pictures, the extras are sometimes even more interesting than the movie itself. Take Disney's sci-fi reboot Tron: Legacy. Not a great film, but the DVD extras included some amazing behind-the-scenes material on the film's gorgeous art design and terrific music (by legendary electronica duo Daft Punk).

Image and Sound Fidelity: For most movies available via download, particularly older titles, digital copy means a fairly radical dropoff in audio and video specs. The issue is further complicated depending on what device you're transferring the movie to. Digital movies designed to be watched on a portable device necessarily have a smaller file size, which means lower-quality sound and image.

The good news here is that high-definition versions of new movies are becoming more common at the big online retailers like iTunes and Amazon, and many of the on-demand services for the living room TV have HD options now.

Closed Captioning: Due to certain technology issues with digital distribution, you can't always get closed captioning on purchased or rented digital titles. And even when you can, they may not function across various devices. It's a case-by-case situation, usually, and highly vexing if you've come to rely on closed captioning for whatever reason.

Subtitles can be hard to find with on-demand services, too — for instance, if you watch Netflix on your living room TV via a game console or set-top box. (Although thanks to some new initiatives by Netflix, that situation has been improving recently.)

Lending: This might seem obvious, but there's one very simple thing you can do with a DVD or Blu-ray that is ridiculously complicated when dealing with digital media. You can grab that DVD off the shelf and lend it to a friend. I tend to be highly evangelical when it comes to movies I'm really into. I've probably circulated my DVD copy of Martin Scorcese's Hugo to a dozen other parents at my kids' school.

Thanks to the many technical and legal compilations of Digital Rights Management, or DRM, you just can't do that with a digital copy of a movie — or a book or a record, for that matter. This is a ginormous Digital Age dilemma that is still sorting itself out, but meanwhile it means DVD has an advantage when it comes to one of pop culture's most enduring pleasures — sharing movies with friends.

I imagine the day will come when we will all have instant access to high-quality digital movies, with all the extras attached and all the viewing rights included. But that day isn't here yet. When I crave one of my favorite comfort movies, I'm glad I still have my old-fashioned DVD library.

Hugo DVD

Case Study: Hugo

The utterly enchanting Hugo, director Martin Scorcese's love letter to cinema and childhood, makes a strong case for DVD/Blu-ray over digital. I like this movie a lot, but my kids absolutely love it, which means it's been in heavy living room rotation for weeks now.

Had we opted for a digital rental of Hugo — via iTunes, say — we would have been able to watch it exactly once, within 30 days of purchase, and would be required to finish the film within 24 hours of pressing play. As parents know, kids just don't tend to operate within such schedules.

The DVD/Blu-ray combo pack also includes five excellent featurettes that explore details of the film's production and elements of cinematic history. For the grown-ups, this stuff is gold, and you can't get the full extras package in any downloadable bundle.

Finally, Hugo is a lush film, both visually and aurally, and with Blu-ray you get maximum home video specs with 1080p high-definition and 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio. Hugo is also one of the very few films to make truly artful use of 3D technology, and the retail package includes a Blu-ray 3D disc for those with the proper home theater setup.

Note: This was written by Glenn McDonald, a Digital Crave contributor.
Check out more tech trends and new at Digital Crave

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Chiefs fans were so sad after playoff loss they left their grills in the parking lot

      Arrowhead Stadium became a hellscape. .@AbbyClopton10 It wasn't! If you look closely in this pic you'll actually see two grills and half a bottle of Jack. Look, they up and left their grills and everything.

      SB Nation q
    • Peta Murgatroyd Bra Selfie Reminds Us Post-Baby Body Expectations Are Ridiculous

      The “post-baby body” obsession has, unfortunately, seemingly taken over our culture. Instead of marveling at the fact that women bring forth life from…

      Hello Giggles
    • Texas teacher who had sex almost daily with 13-year-old student gets 10 years in prison

      A former Texas middle-school teacher who was impregnated by a 13-year-old student has been sentenced to 10 years in prison. Alexandria Vera, 25, was facing up to 30 years behind bars after pleading guilty to aggravated sexual assault of a child in November. She admitted to police that a relationship that started with Instagram messages between her and the boy blossomed into a romance — one that the boy’s family approved of. A judge in the 209th District Court in Houston said during Vera’s sentencing hearing on Friday that he does not believe the former English teacher is a danger to children or a classic pedophile, the Houston Chronicle reported. But Judge Michael McSpadden said he wants to send

      Washington Post q
    • Georgia constituent pens open letter to Rep. John Lewis

      Woman shares her message on 'Fox & Friends'

      FOX News Videos
    • ‘Fame Can Change Things’: Aaron Rodgers’ Family Opens Up About Their Rift

      NFL star Aaron Rodgers’ father Ed Rodgers has opened up in a new interview with The New York Times about his family’s strained relationship with the Green Bay Packers quarterback. “With all the craziness that comes along with the media and the show, it would have been much harder to do it not living together,” Jordan said of moving in together.

      People
    • People are showing off photos of their scratched up Jet Black iPhone 7 handsets

      Look, we're just going to go ahead and say it: the Jet Black iPhone 7 and the Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus are the most gorgeous smartphones that have ever been created. This is not open to debate. It's a fact. There's simply nothing else like the sleek glossy finish of Apple's Jet Black iPhones, which reflects just the right amount of light to appear as though the glass face of the phone wraps straight around to the back of the device. It's stunning, but there's a pretty big caveat to that bold statement we made. The Jet Black iPhone 7 and the Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus are the most gorgeous smartphones that have ever been created... for about 3 minutes after you first remove one from the box. After that, Apple's Jet Black finish starts to scratch and scuff like crazy, and it's also a magnet for grease and grime. Apple didn't exactly admit how delicate its Jet Black finish is when it unveiled the iPhone 7 and iPhone 7 Plus last September, but it did post a disclaimer on its website. Here's that disclaimer in full: The high-gloss finish of the jet black iPhone 7 is achieved through a precision nine-step anodization and polishing process. Its surface is equally as hard as other anodized Apple products; however, its high shine may show fine micro-abrasions with use. If you are concerned about this, we suggest you use one of the many cases available to protect your iPhone. Translation: the Jet Black finish on the iPhone 7 and iPhone 7 Plus is going to scratch. A lot. We've shown you what happens to the Jet Black iPhone finish in a couple of different posts. One showed a Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus after three months , and another showed a Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus after just two months . Both of those posts were scary for potential Jet Black iPhone owners, and now there are even more examples of what Apple's sleek new iPhone finish looks like with normal wear and tear. A post on Reddit from over the weekend asked people to share what their Jet Black iPhones look like now that they've been used. Several people complied, and the photos they shared give us a good idea of what happens to Jet Black iPhones when they're in your hands as opposed to being featured in photos on Apple's website. Reddit user KateWalls shared the highest-quality photos in the thread, and you can see plenty of fine scratching on her Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus — which is only two weeks old. She does note that in person, the scratches are more visible on the antenna bands than they are on the aluminum housing. Here are a couple of examples from her post: There's definitely plenty of scratching there but as you can see, it's much more visible at certain angles to the light. Another user named ctsikh posted one photo of his Jet Black iPhone 7, and you can clearly see some scratching. You can also see how much grease and dirt the Jet Black finish picks up — remember my tweet showing a Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus that had been handled by customers in an Apple store? Yeah. https://twitter.com/zacharye/status/778223454935982080 If those photos don't scare you, this one from Redditor polygonarsenal definitely will: He used a filter to accentuate the scratches, which look downright terrible. This is pretty much the stuff nightmares are made of. There are a bunch more photos in the thread on Reddit , so definitely check them out.

      BGR News
    • Jessica Alba threw a pajama party with a bunch of celebrity friends, and everyone’s PJ game was on point

      If there’s one thing we love, it’s celebs. And if there’s two things we love, it’s pajama parties. Needless to say, a…

      Hello Giggles
    • Dear Democrats: Nobody Cares About Your Feelings

      Democrats have lost three of the last four federal elections—2010, 2014 and 2016—in large part because they are still clinging to the comforting but false notion that voters punish bad behavior. More than two months after the stunning defeat of Hillary Clinton, there seems to be no evidence that Democrats have learned anything. They continue to harp on whatever makes Trump look “unpresidential,” and while there is unquestionably plenty of material there, it is also clear that there aren’t enough voters who care about such things to swing an election. If there were, Trump would not have prevailed. Clinton won the popular vote, and she won it decisively, by nearly three million ballots. That brings

      The New York Observer q
    • Boston reporter gives obnoxious Steelers fan huge shove after he dives into live shot

      In the latest example of unruly fans thinking it’s hilarious to interrupt a reporter’s live shot comes this moment from 7 News Boston sports anchor Joe Amorosino: The drama began when a man wearing a Steelers hat dove into the shot, and yelled ‘Steelers’. Amorosino, not hesitating, shoved him out of the shot and continued on with his report, which he concluded: “Bring those Steelers into New England next week for that knucklehead and they’ll do the same thing to him.”

      For The Win q
    • How to enable the ‘dark mode’ feature hiding in your iPhone browser right now

      Apple's iOS 10 software is packed full of new features. In fact, there are so many new features that it's impossible to remember them all, which is why we often publish collections of lesser-known tips and tricks. A perfect example is this collection of 5 iPhone features only power users know about  — we always want to help people get the most out of their smartphones. When iOS 10 was first released as a closed beta last summer during WWDC 2016, developers instantly began picking it apart. In doing so, they stumbled upon a fantastic looking "dark mode" feature hiding inside iOS . The good news is it was there. The bad news, as we all know, is that it wasn't enabled when iOS 10 was finally released in September. Rumors suggest that a new " theater mode " might be introduced in iOS 10.3, but nothing has been confirmed at this point. What you might not know, however, is that there's already a dark mode feature hidden inside your iPhone browser. Night Shift is a nifty new feature Apple introduced in iOS 10 that reduces the amount of blue light emitted by an iPhone or iPad display at night. It theoretically helps users sleep better, but it doesn't do anything to make text more visible in low light situations. For that, you need "dark mode," which switches things up and makes the background black with light colored text. Dark mode is available in many third-party iOS apps and even a handful of first-party apps. Sadly, however, there's no system-wide dark mode feature for the time being. That said, there's actually a special dark mode in Safari that most people don't know about, and it'll let you read just about any article on the web in light text on a black background. Here's how to enable it: 1) First, load any article in Safari (if you're reading this Safari on an iPhone or iPad, you're good to go). 2) Tap the reader mode icon in the left corner of the URL bar. You'll then see something that looks like this: 3) Tap the "aA" icon in the right corner of the URL bar and you'll get a drop down menu that looks like this: 4) Tap the black circle all the way to the right in the top row of the drop down menu. Presto — you've just enabled dark mode in Safari: Here's what your screen will look like once you start scrolling around: In-line pictures will still display normally, but the rest of the page will be dark, as pictured above. It's not the system-wide dark mode we've all been waiting for, but people spend a tremendous amount of time reading in Safari, so this should be a big improvement at night.

      BGR News
    • Christmas price tag feels like holiday snub

      Dear Amy: My 17-year-old daughter and I are still trying to recover from a Christmas snub. In our family, we draw names and have a $50 budget. My daughter's cousin drew her name and had purchased the item my daughter wanted, but he bought a smaller size than she wears and the gift cost about $30. She is upset that he didn't spend the designated amount. This also happened on Christmas Day with her aunt and grandmother, who both went under budget with their gifts to her, but over budget with their gifts to other nieces. We don't want to seem ungrateful and would like your thoughts on what to do about this, if anything. How can this be addressed? Dear Mom: Your daughter responded to a gift by (first)

      Chicago Tribune q
    • San Diego Moving Companies Are Refusing To Help The Chargers Move To L.A.

      The Chargers are leaving San Diego for Los Angeles. As is the case when sports teams relocate, fans are mad. It’s understandable you’re angry and feel betrayed, but this should be a lesson for everyone all over the world — sports teams are nothing more than corporate entities out to take your money.

      UPROXX
    • Gisele Bündchen and Tom Brady Cuddle Up at Boston Park Following Patriots Win

      The retired model and her quarterback husband were spotted for the first time together in months, appearing very much in love while watching a hockey game at a Boston park over the weekend. Brady, 39, whose team took home a victory on Saturday night, kept a tight squeeze on his wife while wearing a fur-trimmed Canada Goose parka and a black cap.

      People
    • Rogue One's reshoots show how Disney saved the first standalone Star Wars movie

      Now that Rogue One: A Star Wars Story has been out in theaters for a month, the veil of secrecy has been lifted and we’ve learned quite a lot about about how the film came together. Disney put an enormous amount of effort into Rogue One, bringing in writer and director Tony Gilroy in June to help fix up the film by writing new dialogue and directing some additional scenes, earning a screenplay credit for the film and a reportedly hefty $5 million paycheck for his efforts. Gareth Edwards appears to have taken an unorthodox approach to filming Rogue One.

      The Verge q
    • 5 Totally Brilliant Netflix Series You Should Be Watching (5 photos)

      You're all queued up for a Netflix-and-chill night, but what to watch? You could turn on Friends for the 10943284th time. Or you could (gasp!) watch something new. There are, of course, the Netflix gold-standard series: House of Cards, Orange Is the New Black, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, The Crown. But assuming you've already watched all those, we have you covered: These five series gems will make you glad you have a Netflix account/your roommate's password. VIDEO: The 20 Best TV Shows of 2016 Happy streaming!

      InStyle
    • Aaron Rodgers' Father Gets Candid About Their Estrangement: 'Fame Can Change Things'

      Ed Rodgers spoke with the 'New York Times' about his son's rift with the family.

      Entertainment Tonight
    • The Latest: Trump promises health insurance for all

      WASHINGTON (AP) — The Latest on President-elect Donald Trump (all times EST):

      Associated Press
    • Chargers admit mistake, drop new LA logo after criticism

      The Chargers have dropped their new LA logo, which bore an uncanny resemblance to that of the Los Angeles Dodgers.

      Omnisport
    • Ciara Posts Family Picture After Cheeky Move From Ex Future

      Singer Ciara just clapped back at her ex, Future, after the latter showed up during her husband Russell Wilson's game.

      International Business Times
    • Dad's Heartbreak: Girl He Raised as His Own Was Really Kidnapped as a Newborn

      One father's joy was another father's heartbreak, after Charles Manigo learned that the girl he raised and believed to be his own daughter for 18 years was really another man's child. Alexis Kelly," Manigo said. But what Manigo didn't know was that his former girlfriend, Gloria Williams, had allegedly snatched the girl from a maternity ward, and lied when she told him she'd given birth to the baby when he was away.

      Good Morning America