Katharine McPhee - Katharine McPhee (CD)

All Music Guide

From the beginning of the series' fifth season, Katharine McPhee seemed like the ideal American Idol: a dropdead gorgeous brunette, she was certainly telegenic and she also had a powerhouse voice, equally impressive on a slowburning, showstopping “Somewhere Over The Rainbow” as on a lively cover of KT Tunstall's “Black Horse and a Cherry Tree.” Most importantly, Katharine was the first American Idol finalist since the premiere season to seem to appeal directly to the show's core audience of predominantly female preteens and adolescents, the first since Kelly Clarkson to possess a crucial blend of young, fresh looks, pop sensibility and wholesome sexiness. All the pieces seemed to be in place for McPhee to take home the crown but she got steamrolled by the Soul Patrol, as the world's youngest Baby Boomer, the prematurely grey Taylor Hicks won the competition by appealing to the other AmIdol core audience the adults that grew up on the pop of the '60s, '70s and '80s and were wondering w...here all that good music went. Taylor's debut record appealed precisely to that audience, which freed runnerup Katharine to deliver an album that appealed to younger listenersÂ…at least in theory. In practice, it took a bit of effort to get all involved with McPhee's debut album to agree to this principle. According to several prerelease interviews, the singer approached her producers and label midway through production requesting that the album sound younger; specifically, she wanted the music to have a stronger RB and modern pop influence, so it would sound contemporary which, in turn, would give her a greater chance of establishing herself as an artist outside the confines of American Idol and as Kelly Clarkson proved with her two albums, this could result in greater success both in the short term and in the long run. Read more Less