Catherine
By Yahoo! Shopping User Aug 9, 2009
Pros: Good graphics, good gameplay
Cons: repetitive levels, minimal relation to other ff games, no character development
The game isn't horrible, but neither is it the best game ever. It has good graphics, and most controls are pretty easy to get used to. The negatives consist of a constant loss of health whenever you step outside of your chalice safety zone (which... happens often since your moogle gets tired), getting cut off from the other locations on your map when you change the element of your chalice (until you unlock the unknown element), very little initial knowledge about the vulnerabilities of the enemies (unless you look it up online), the repetion of levels (though a positive is that new monsters appear when you return, and the old ones get tougher), and the gameboy advanced multi-player (for those who don't have gameboy advance, you'll probably never know what it was like, because i sure didn't). It's hard to level up or gain points when you don't actually know what you have to do to get points. I found it unfair that some of the levels actually take away points for doing things like picking objects or gil up. Having to trim Mog's hair was probably the most ANNOYING and time consuming thing you have to do in the game. I found myself having to drop important items during dungeons because i couldn't carry anymore objects (which bothers me because i'm the kind of person who likes to collect everything and sell what i can). You never know if you actually need a certain object or not until you get the blueprints and scrolls for the objects, and even then it's unknown if you can use the object or not because of your race. Also, there is an unnecessary playthrough when you go through a Miasma stream. For what reason do i have to basically walk SLOWLY in a straight line while i'm playing the game? It serves no purpose other than to get to the other side...slowly and tediously. Positives include good music, fair story line (though the only connection it has to the other FF games is a man named Cecil who lives in Marr's Pass), fair trading system (as long as you don't trade in Leuda as any race other than Selkie), and a fair combat system (until you get frozen, stuck, then beat upon and die instantly). Though the combat is VERY different from the other FF games, it's not too bad. I tend to lean towards the real time battle system anyway. i gave it a 3 out of 5 because, though it had some flaws, for me, the game wasn't too bad at all. It kept me occupied and i found myself trying to finish it, mostly so i could finally understand where the storyline was going (who was the black knight? What was he talking about when he said something stole his memories? Why do the Selkies steal your gil when you talk to them? What are the yellow squigly things on the map that look like people's names written in cursive? How come the miasma has elements, and why do you have to carry such an annoying chalice around?) The game leaves questions unanswered, and tends to have annoying attributes. In all, i'd say buy it, if it's on sale. Bought mine for $7 and i say it was a good investment, but i don't think i would have paid more. Read more Less
Was this review helpful? Yes - No