Lou Reed/John Cale/Nico - Bataclan 72, Vol. 1 (LP)

All Music Guide

After decades of being circulated on inferior sounding bootlegs, the January 1972 reconvergence of Velvet Underground (VU) cofounders Lou Reed (vocals/acoustic guitar), John Cale (guitar/viola/piano/vocals) and Nico (vocals/harmonium) in Paris at Le Bataclan has been committed to CD. A suitably noir mood hangs over them as they stonily amble through VU staples and key entries from their concurrent solo endeavours. They commence with a slow and almost methodical "Waiting For The Man" as Cale offers up a simple piano accompaniment to Reed's casual guitar and lead vocal. Reed aptly describes the bleak torch reading of "Berlin" as his "Barbra Streisand song" before unveiling a profoundly minimalist interpretation. It captures the unnerving mood inescapably defining the city in the wake of WWII. They return to the early VU for an inspired "Black Angel Death Song". Reed's rhythmic chiming guitar incongruously fits beside Cale as he whittles away an austere viola counterpoint. Back briefly to Reed's eponymouslytitled debut for a very Dylanesque delivery of "Wild Child". The reconnection between the duo begins to jell significantly if not audibly throughout an intense "Heroin," immediately recalling what makes the Cale/Reed combo so appealing. Cale seizes the reigns for the melodically and lyrically involved "Ghost Story" from his own Vintage Violence (1970). One rarity is Cale's "Empty Bottles" which he contributed to Jennifer Warren's Jennifer (1972) album. The remainder of teh evening is continued on Le Bataclan '72, Vol. 2 (2005) as Nico finally takes the spotlight for a healthy sampling of her work. She couches a trio of postVU efforts around three of her most memorable sides during her brief time in the band. They saunter into an intimate and warmly received mini set featuring "Femme Fatale", "No One Is There" and "Frozen Warnings" of off Marble Index (1969), as well as "Janitor Of Lunacy" from Desertshore (1970). The show concludes with another trip into the VU on a comparatively optimistic "I'll Be Your Mirror" duly juxtaposed against an edgy and sinister "All Tomorrow's Parties". While fans and pundits hopefully proclaimed the performance as The Velvets reformation, alas it would not be so. Le Bataclan '72, Vol.1 (2005) as well as its subsequent instalment Le Bataclan '72, Vol. 2 (2005) are highly listenable and should be considered as essential for anyone whose interests have at any point been piqued by the Velvet Underground or its primary constituents: John Cale, Lou Reed and/or Nico.

- Lindsay Planer, All Music Guide